RE: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-06 Thread John Horner
When it comes to Flash, I think we make a mistake in thinking of it as a web format. It isn't. It's an animation format, which can be used in all kinds of ways -- freestanding applications, kiosks, mobile phones and yes, web pages. So, is the site using Flash for things like navigation, which are

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-05 Thread Christian Montoya
On 2/6/07, Jermayn Parker <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Well, that's nice. So, I'm curious -- the site has both a photo (jpeg) > of the hotel exterior and a (Flash-embedded) image of one of the rooms, > so what's the problem? So one flash embedded image and a photo of the hotel exterior is

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-05 Thread Jermayn Parker
Well, that's nice. So, I'm curious -- the site has both a photo (jpeg) of the hotel exterior and a (Flash-embedded) image of one of the rooms, so what's the problem? So one flash embedded image and a photo of the hotel exterior is going to give you a good feel about what the hotel is all ab

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-05 Thread Hassan Schroeder
Jermayn Parker wrote: > If your in the hotel business and advertising for a brand new hotel, you > need to sell your business and entice people away from their current > 'fav' hotels to yours. Do you think not having any photos and just a > nice flashy home page will do that? I know for a FACT tha

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-05 Thread Jermayn Parker
Ok I guess your having a dig at me but I will humour you If your in the hotel business and advertising for a brand new hotel, you need to sell your business and entice people away from their current 'fav' hotels to yours. Do you think not having any photos and just a nice flashy home page will do

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-05 Thread Hassan Schroeder
Jermayn Parker wrote: > Photos of what the rooms look like would be one obvious example of what > would make this website a bit more credible. Wow. Lack of room photos equates to: > a useless uninformative site and apart from the home page it is > ugly and bare as naked bones. :: not to mention

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-05 Thread Jermayn Parker
Photos of what the rooms look like would be one obvious example of what would make this website a bit more credible. On 2/6/07, Hassan Schroeder <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Jermayn Parker wrote: > Your explanation makes sense but as a designer who also dabbles in seo, > would not it be your r

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-05 Thread Hassan Schroeder
Jermayn Parker wrote: > Your explanation makes sense but as a designer who also dabbles in seo, > would not it be your right to 'suggest' and sell the importance of > descent content?? The internet is a place were you find useful or > useless information. It is not primely a gallery of art like thi

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-05 Thread Jermayn Parker
Your explanation makes sense but as a designer who also dabbles in seo, would not it be your right to 'suggest' and sell the importance of descent content?? The internet is a place were you find useful or useless information. It is not primely a gallery of art like this website. also you look at

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-05 Thread Barney Carroll
Jermayn Parker wrote: It is not that good... Yes it may load quick but it is a useless uninformative site and apart from the home page it is ugly and bare as naked bones. Lets hope that the designer does not win any awards That's all down to inevitable site content though. The designer has d

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-03 Thread Jermayn Parker
It is not that good... Yes it may load quick but it is a useless uninformative site and apart from the home page it is ugly and bare as naked bones. Lets hope that the designer does not win any awards On 2/3/07, Matthew Smith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> A great example of Faust in practi

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread Matthew Smith
A great example of Faust in practice: http://www.ivyhotel.com/ Bravo! I took a quick (and only quick) look in Lynx and got a meaningful site. I think that this could be a first. And also a last, as this example neatly takes away any excuse for a primarily Flash-based site to be inaccessi

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread miden
On Fri, 2007-02-02 at 17:01 -0500, Christian Montoya wrote: > On 2/2/07, Mark Harris <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > miden wrote: > > > Interesting letter on "The Register" WRT accessiblity: > > > > > > "...it's very hard to see why the tiny amount of forethought website > > > authors could show tow

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread Rob O'Rourke
Christian Montoya wrote: On 2/2/07, Mark Harris <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: miden wrote: > Interesting letter on "The Register" WRT accessiblity: > > "...it's very hard to see why the tiny amount of forethought website > authors could show toward accessibility in the very beginning is so > terrib

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread Terrence Wood
On 3/02/2007, at 10:28 AM, Mark Harris wrote: [accessibility should be] a factor that influences your design choices from the beginning Absolutely. Design is, after all, about creating functional purpose not merely aesthetic pleasure. kind regards Terrence Wood. **

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread Christian Montoya
On 2/2/07, Mark Harris <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: miden wrote: > Interesting letter on "The Register" WRT accessiblity: > > "...it's very hard to see why the tiny amount of forethought website > authors could show toward accessibility in the very beginning is so > terribly absent." > > http://www

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread Mark Harris
miden wrote: Interesting letter on "The Register" WRT accessiblity: "...it's very hard to see why the tiny amount of forethought website authors could show toward accessibility in the very beginning is so terribly absent." http://www.theregister.co.uk/2007/02/02/letters_0202/ And that's real

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread miden
On Fri, 2007-02-02 at 16:37 +, Rob O'Rourke wrote: > True, I'm starting to realise that more and more now as the works piling > up =$ > Still, at least the world of corporate merchandise e-commerce is a > little more accessible now =] > > Interesting letter on "The Register" WRT accessibl

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread Rob O'Rourke
Sunday John wrote: Yea, I agree with your comment. Contents that is available through xml for flash improves performance. Also given the user a choice to switch to version of site is good idea to meet end users viewing experience. Like I said, all still boils down to the project goal, target aud

RE: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread Sunday John
client. Sunday John Web Developer www.isslng.com -Original Message- From: listdad@webstandardsgroup.org [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Rob O'Rourke Sent: Friday, February 02, 2007 3:08 PM To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Subject: Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;) Sunday

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread Barney Carroll
Now that's what I'm talking about. When everything is available as raw XML and you've got XSLT, you're in flexible heaven. Rob O'Rourke wrote: Not necessarily, check out what Dan Cederholm wrote about his work on MTV.com [1], they have a fully flash site that runs from a server-side generated

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread Rob O'Rourke
Sunday John wrote: Funny enough, website development depends on your site goal, target audience and client's want. If your site demands that you use a flash (if it's a major communication) then you have to use flash. Sunday John Web Developer www.isslng.com Not necessarily, check out w

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread Barney Carroll
Milosz, those sites are incredibly flash-intensive. Without flash, they fail. With flash and a slow connection (or even processor), they run badly. I'm afraid any objective source would give those low marks for accessibility. But they are entirely based on style - there is no real substance in

RE: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread Sunday John
m: listdad@webstandardsgroup.org [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Barney Carroll Sent: Friday, February 02, 2007 12:08 PM To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Subject: Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;) Matthew Smith wrote: > tolerate screen motion? (A bit off-topic, I know, but I believe that &g

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-02 Thread Barney Carroll
Matthew Smith wrote: tolerate screen motion? (A bit off-topic, I know, but I believe that accessibility/standards doesn't stop at the content, but extends to software and OS.) Not liking fancy animations does not make you an accessibility advocate. Apparently everyone hates flash, but for

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Christian Montoya
On 2/1/07, Noah <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Interesting how people today still either get Picasso or they don't. Says a lot about the timelessness of the work... Well, list-admin said we have to get back on topic, so I'm still wondering if Milosz will share his definition of "accessible." Othe

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Noah
Interesting how people today still either get Picasso or they don't. Says a lot about the timelessness of the work... Noah PerthWebDesigns.com Quoting Jermayn Parker <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: some of it makes sense (like self portraits etc) but a lot of his  sculptures and other stuf

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Jermayn Parker
some of it makes sense (like self portraits etc) but a lot of his sculptures and other stuff doesnt, it went agaisnt the grain of normal painting etc of his era >>> [EMAIL PROTECTED] 2/02/2007 10:14:18 am >>> On 2/1/07, Jermayn Parker <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > You look at people like Piac

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Tim
Picasso's art did make sense, that is why he is famous now. Simple lines. If Picasso were making webpages they would all be accessible. This comparison of genius with self indulgent art for arts sake is annoying. Tim On 02/02/2007, at 1:05 PM, Jermayn Parker wrote: You look at people like

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Christian Montoya
On 2/1/07, Jermayn Parker <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: You look at people like Piacoso and his art made no sense and it was popular and so are these types of website, make no sense but are popular (myspace another example) I have no idea what you are talking about. Picasso's art makes total sen

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Jermayn Parker
You look at people like Piacoso and his art made no sense and it was popular and so are these types of website, make no sense but are popular (myspace another example) >>> [EMAIL PROTECTED] 2/02/2007 9:56:49 am >>> Why would you want to create such an image gallery for navigation, no rollove

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Tim
Why would you want to create such an image gallery for navigation, no rollover titles, no idea where each link goes, uses a lot of images for a text based navigation system, maybe it is art but not much else. Tim On 02/02/2007, at 6:00 AM, <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Christian Montoya

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread JDR @ Home
- Original Message - From: jonnysoco To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Sent: Thursday, February 01, 2007 6:11 PM Subject: Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;) http://jrgraphix.net/research/flash_dock.php Awesome! Thank you. Jeff

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Susie Gardner-Brown
Oh yes. You can choose to have the icons bigger or smaller, and the animation on or off. And the animation relates to the size of the icons - smaller icons = smaller animation. You can also have them not visible at all until you put your cursor right at the bottom of the screen (or wherever the do

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Hassan Schroeder
Matthew Smith wrote: > Ah, that's what a Mac dock looks like; haven't seen a Mac for about > eight years. Eeeew! The animation nearly made me seasick ;-) Do Macs > have a means of turning the animation off for those (like me) who cannot > tolerate screen motion? Yes. And you can adjust the d

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Matthew Smith
Quoth jonnysoco at 02/02/07 09:41... http://jrgraphix.net/research/flash_dock.php Ah, that's what a Mac dock looks like; haven't seen a Mac for about eight years. Eeeew! The animation nearly made me seasick ;-) Do Macs have a means of turning the animation off for those (like me) who cann

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread jonnysoco
http://jrgraphix.net/research/flash_dock.php On 2/1/07, Susie Gardner-Brown <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: On 2/2/07 5:00 AM, "[EMAIL PROTECTED]" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> > At the bottom of this site: http://www.mandchou.com/ - there is an image > gallery in Flash used for navigation.

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Susie Gardner-Brown
On 2/2/07 5:00 AM, "[EMAIL PROTECTED]" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> > At the bottom of this site: http://www.mandchou.com/ - there is an image > gallery in Flash used for navigation. Can someone point me to a tutorial for > creating this? > > -- > Thanks! > > Jeff No idea but you might tr

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Gunlaug Sørtun
Milosz A. Lodowski - New Media Designer wrote: Christian in your opinion - those sites are inaccessible... without any argues I cannot agree so that's why I've asked... I define 'accessible' as "be given access". In normal terms that means that if one access-point is closed to particular visito

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Tee G. Peng
On Feb 1, 2007, at 12:06 PM, Rob O'Rourke wrote: Accessibility is making a site available and usable to the widest possible audience, on as many user agents as possible. A lot of the sites you've picked are pure flash, while these can be made somewhat accessible (e.g. making the text sel

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread miden
Milosz - Your site's opening page took almost three minutes to load on a dialup connection... b'bye. I gave up trying to view sites after three successive 'you need flash' notices... b'bye. Judging by what I (finally) saw on your opening page I would guess that the listed pages are quite beautifu

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Rob O'Rourke
Milosz A. Lodowski - New Media Designer wrote: Christian in your opinion - those sites are inaccessible... without any argues I cannot agree so that's why I've asked... Accessibility is making a site available and usable to the widest possible audience, on as many user agents as possible. A

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Milosz A. Lodowski - New Media Designer
eu - Be my Guest! Mobile contact: +44 079.23.388.905 (UK) Ice - e-Motional Design Expert www.e-motionaldesign.com - Original Message - From: "Christian Montoya" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Thursday, February 01, 2007 7:20 PM Subject: Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility -

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Christian Montoya
On 2/1/07, Milosz A. Lodowski - New Media Designer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: How do you define "accessible" ? pure text ? Not fair. You picked these sites, so you have to define your criteria. The ball is in your court to answer that question. -- -- Christian Montoya christianmontoya.net .. d

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread jdreid
Christian Montoya <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On 2/1/07, Milosz A. Lodowski - New Media Designer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I'd like to present you the list of best100 e-motional designs, > > we're waiting for your opinions about our idea and choice ;) > > > > http://www.e-motionaldesig

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Milosz A. Lodowski - New Media Designer
EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Thursday, February 01, 2007 6:45 PM Subject: Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;) Milosz A. Lodowski - New Media Designer wrote: I'd like to present you the list of best100 e-motional designs, we're waiting for your opinions about our idea and

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Milosz A. Lodowski - New Media Designer
nal Design Expert www.e-motionaldesign.com - Original Message - From: "Christian Montoya" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Thursday, February 01, 2007 6:36 PM Subject: Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;) On 2/1/07, Milosz A. Lodowski - New Media Designer <[EMAIL

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Designer
Milosz A. Lodowski - New Media Designer wrote: I'd like to present you the list of best100 e-motional designs, we're waiting for your opinions about our idea and choice ;) http://www.e-motionaldesign.com/blog/100-the-best-e-motional-websites-part-1-of-4/ Best Wishes Milosz A. Lodowski Art Di

Re: [WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Christian Montoya
On 2/1/07, Milosz A. Lodowski - New Media Designer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I'd like to present you the list of best100 e-motional designs, we're waiting for your opinions about our idea and choice ;) http://www.e-motionaldesign.com/blog/100-the-best-e-motional-websites-part-1-of-4/ So, a bu

[WSG] Art and accessibility - my opinion ;)

2007-02-01 Thread Milosz A. Lodowski - New Media Designer
I'd like to present you the list of best100 e-motional designs, we're waiting for your opinions about our idea and choice ;) http://www.e-motionaldesign.com/blog/100-the-best-e-motional-websites-part-1-of-4/ Best Wishes Milosz A. Lodowski Art Director IceAge Design Squadron Be our Ally, Hire our