[LUTE] Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Stewart McCoy
Dear Roman, The paper is indeed interesting, although I cannot be sure who wrote it. In the paper, you are referred to as Roman Turovsky-Savchuk. Is this really your full name? If so, is your choice of the name Sautscheck for your own compositions, derived from the last part of your name? A few

[LUTE] Re: Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread David Tayler
There were the wax tablets, but it seems likely that there were multiple systems for compositions. Sketches on paper show, obviously, that paper was used for sketches. These systems could have been used in combination Surely the keyboard was used by many composers Dowland most likely composed for

[LUTE] Re: dyeing/loading

2008-06-08 Thread Anthony Hind
Le 7 juin 08 à 21:02, Martin Shepherd a écrit : Dear Jaroslaw, I agree with everything you say - but my problem has always been that (a) I wanted to know how the old guys really did it and (b) I didn't like any of the options that were available. I admit that (a) is not necessarily

[LUTE] Re: Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Donatella Galletti
Stewart, I expect Roman will answer properly, but Sautscheck is the surname of his grand mother. I saw a tomb with this name on it in Prague, in the cemetery of important persons, apparently it's a common name. In Italian all this ( wondering about the hidden meanings of it etc) is called

[LUTE] Re: Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Roman Turovsky
From: Stewart McCoy [EMAIL PROTECTED] Dear Roman, The paper is indeed interesting, although I cannot be sure who wrote it. One Dan Hill, a violinist. In the paper, you are referred to as Roman Turovsky-Savchuk. Is this really your full name? If so, is your choice of the name Sautscheck for

[LUTE] Re: Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Roman Turovsky
From: Stewart McCoy [EMAIL PROTECTED] Dear Roman, The paper is indeed interesting, although I cannot be sure who wrote it. One Dan Hill, a violinist. In the paper, you are referred to as Roman Turovsky-Savchuk. Is this really your full name? If so, is your choice of the name Sautscheck for

[LUTE] Re: Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Mathias Rösel
Roman Turovsky [EMAIL PROTECTED] schrieb: A few years ago, I told a friend about your compositions for lute, and how you used the pseudonym Sautscheck. He was much amused. He is a retired lecturer in German, and so is familiar with the German language. He said that Sautscheck has certain

[LUTE] Re: Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Donatella Galletti
- Original Message - From: Mathias Rösel [EMAIL PROTECTED] Roman Turovsky [EMAIL PROTECTED] schrieb: A few years ago, I told a friend about your compositions for lute, and how you used the pseudonym Sautscheck. He was much amused. He is a retired lecturer in German, and so is

[LUTE] Re: dyeing/loading

2008-06-08 Thread Anthony Hind
Damian I suppose you do know the work of Partizio Barbieri, and I assume you do not agree with his findings about Roman and Neapolitan gut string ropes. Patrizio Barbieri: Roman and Neapolitan gut strings, 1550-1590, GSJ, May 2006, pp 176-7. PB appears to have shown that roped

[LUTE] Re: [LUTE] Re: Double headed 12c/loaded/Demi-filé

2008-06-08 Thread Jarosław Lipski
Hi Martyn, I just talked to Mimmo. He explained that the tension of 0.9 till 1.2 Kg came out from mathematical calculations made by Ephraim Segerman considering the bridge holes of surviving lutes. He calculated some 1.2 till 1.5 Kg. but this was made considered the density of a low twist gut

[LUTE] new POM - oops

2008-06-08 Thread Martin Shepherd
Sorry I forgot to say, the new Piece of the Month is in the usual place: www.luteshop.co.uk/month/pieceofthemonth.htm I also forgot to apologize for the lack of an MP3 for the second piece - I just felt it was too much of a handful to play on 9c, when it's written for 10. Martin To get

[LUTE] Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Stewart McCoy
Dear Donatella, Thanks for your message. I'm afraid I made the same old mistake of mixing up the various lists. Roman's message was to the Baroque Lute Net, and I accidentally replied to the Lute Net. His original message was: An interesting paper from Cambridge-

[LUTE] Re: [LUTE] Re: [LUTE] Re: Double headed 12c/load ed/Demi-filé

2008-06-08 Thread Anthony Hind
Jaroslaw and Martyn I believe the difference in calculation comes from Martyn using a stiffish high twist (rather than a rope). This can possibly be pushed through quite a narrow hole, where a flexible rope would not go through. Mimmo is taking the calculation for a rope diameter as being

[LUTE] Re: [LUTE] Re: [LUTE] Re: Double headed 12c/load ed/Demi-filé

2008-06-08 Thread Anthony Hind
Oh I may have misunderstood. I thought Segerman's calculations were with a rope, but if they were with a low twist then the results Mimmo and Segerman mention include Martyn's results at between 1,2kg and 1,5kg, Martyn is just at the higher side of this calculation. It remains that the

[LUTE] Re: medieval plectrum, how to make?

2008-06-08 Thread EUGENE BRAIG IV
- Original Message - From: howard posner [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Saturday, June 7, 2008 8:39 pm Subject: [LUTE] Re: medieval plectrum, how to make? To: lute-cs.dartmouth.edu lute@cs.dartmouth.edu On Jun 6, 2008, at 5:37 AM, Eugene C. Braig IV wrote: My

[LUTE] Re: new POM - oops

2008-06-08 Thread adS
Dear Martin, on your web page you say: Altogether it appears in nine sources Well, I have: Source Page/No.Title in source Schele 64/1 Corante Mercurij A[nn]o 1615. Schele 87/2 Courante Aegidius 99rCourante Basel F.IX.53 11r-12r Courante 402211v/3 [Cou]rant

[LUTE] Re: [LUTE] Re: [LUTE] Re: Double headed 12c/ loaded/Demi-filé

2008-06-08 Thread Martyn Hodgson
--- On Sun, 8/6/08, Anthony Hind [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: Anthony Hind [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [LUTE] Re: [LUTE] Re: Double headed 12c/loaded/Demi-filé To: Jarosław Lipski [EMAIL PROTECTED], Martyn Hodgson [EMAIL PROTECTED], lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Net lute@cs.dartmouth.edu

[LUTE] Palestrina's lute (was Musical Crimes etc)

2008-06-08 Thread howard posner
On Jun 8, 2008, at 3:03 AM, Stewart McCoy wrote: I have a vague memory of hearing that Palestrina had a lute handy when composing. If you google palestrina lute mass into google (without the quotes) you should pull up a page of Jessie Ann Owens' The composer at work from Amazon that

[LUTE] Re: [LUTE] Re: [LUTE] Re: [LUTE] Re: Double head ed 12c/loaded/Demi-filé

2008-06-08 Thread Anthony Hind
Thanks Martyn for these precisions. It seems a fair point to say that technique has to adapt to a string type. Indeed loaded strings also call for a change in technique. I have found that even with the loaded string on my 7c, very much as people have been saying of low tension strings, I

[LUTE] Re: dyeing/loading

2008-06-08 Thread damian dlugolecki
Hi Anthony, I don't know Patrizio Barbieri's article. I will look it up and read it. But the fact that there was an industry of ropemaking in every port city, and nearly every large city, is not evidence that this technology extended to the art of making music strings from lamb gut. I

[LUTE] Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Stewart McCoy
Dear Roman, Saying that I could not be sure who wrote the paper, was meant as a joke, since the paper is about dodgy attributions. It is clearly by Daniel Hill. I have contacted my German lecturer friend by email, who has kindly replied at once to explain what he had meant. He writes, Sau is the

[LUTE] Palestrina's lute (was Musical Crimes etc)

2008-06-08 Thread Stewart McCoy
Dear Howard, Many thanks indeed. The Amazon site gives a lot of detail about Palestrina, and confirms that he used the lute while composing. Jessie Owens' book certainly looks a good read. Best wishes, Stewart. -Original Message- From: howard posner [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: 08

[LUTE] Re: Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Mathias Rösel
He suggests that the -tscheck part of Sautscheck might be derived from the German word for Czech. He was looking at the word from a purely etymological point of view. Please excuse my rude wording, but that is pure non-sense (in the very sense of the word) because there are no bridges from

[LUTE] Re: Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Gernot Hilger
Let me assure that the mere Sautscheck word evokes no pejorative undertones at all to me although the Sau- prefix is pretty common here and means just what Stewart says. It is not very rude, though. Can be used talking to your mother-in-law without any risk. Sautscheck merely sounds

[LUTE] Re: Palestrina's lute (was Musical Crimes etc)

2008-06-08 Thread howard posner
On Jun 8, 2008, at 2:46 PM, Stewart McCoy wrote: The Amazon site gives a lot of detail about Palestrina, and confirms that he used the lute while composing. Jessie Owens' book certainly looks a good read. I was mistaken in saying it was an Amazon site, BTW. It's Google Book Search. -- To

[LUTE] Re: Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Roman Turovsky
I have contacted my German lecturer friend by email, who has kindly replied at once to explain what he had meant. He writes, Sau is the German for sow (as in female pig), but is used frequently as a (fairly rude) prefix to indicate a pejorative, e.g. Sauwetter (what we have been getting up to the

[LUTE] Re: Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Roman Turovsky
From: Mathias Rösel [EMAIL PROTECTED] Besides, the modifying use of the prefix sau- is fairly confined to the estates of Bavaria, btw not always pejorative (saugut, saugeil). Most other parts of German speaking countries use Arsch- or Scheisz- instead (arschkalt, Scheiszwetter, both pretty

[LUTE] Re: Musical Crimes: Forgery, Deceit, and Socio-Hermeneutics

2008-06-08 Thread Roman Turovsky
Stewart, You might be happy to know that your neologism has been recorded: http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=sautscheckerei RT - Original Message - From: Stewart McCoy [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Lute Net lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Sunday, June 08, 2008 5:38 PM Subject:

[LUTE] Re: dyeing/loading

2008-06-08 Thread damian dlugolecki
Hi Anthony Stringmakers use machines to add torsion to strings as they dry. There are illustrations of these in Bachmann, Alberto 'Encyclopedia of the Violin' 1925. But they are not the same as the machines used to make rope. I don't know what more evidence you don't need. Here is