[LUTE] Re: lute tasting, was Greenwich festival

2009-11-14 Thread Nedmast2
I agree with your advocation of blind testing, David. Having been involved with audio and audiophiles for many years, I've never agreed with the view that blind testing is not useful in evaluating audio components. Most, if not all, of us, overestimate our ability to remain dispass

[LUTE] lute tasting, was Greenwich festival

2009-11-14 Thread David Tayler
Although I'm sure the LSA is a terrific event, and kudos for having the pros weigh in, their are several events in Europe that are also very good. Also, some European makers don't ravel to the USA very often. Of course the best tasting event is is in our music studio, where we hook up two $3000

[LUTE] Re: Greenwich festival

2009-11-14 Thread Nancy Carlin
For those of you into comparing lutes, the best event is the LSA's Lute Tasting. This is always a part of the festivities at our seminar at Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland, Ohio - end of June in 2010. Last time there were 2 sessions - one for renaissance and one for bar

[LUTE] Re: Greenwich festival

2009-11-14 Thread Jarosław Lipski
David, Speaking from the point of view of someone who has on occasion organized one of these things, noise is a big problem that the presenters choose to ignore. The "softies" have to form a group, ask for a separate room, and have breakout rooms. This is true , however on this occasion it co

[LUTE] Re: Greenwich festival

2009-11-14 Thread Jaroslaw Lipski
I agree about economical issues, however it doesn't seem to explain everything. Why harpsichord makers could show their instruments? Why gamba makers could show what they produce? I doubt if anyone would actually buy any of these instruments during the exhibition. Even Kingham cases where rep

[LUTE] Re: Greenwich festival -quick snaps and atmos

2009-11-14 Thread Monica Hall
Very nice - thanks for posting them! monica - Original Message - From: "Stuart Walsh" Cc: Sent: Saturday, November 14, 2009 5:35 PM Subject: [LUTE] Re: Greenwich festival -quick snaps and atmos Here are some quick photos (forgot even to colour correct them) of the exhibition and t

[LUTE] Re: Greenwich festival

2009-11-14 Thread Christopher Stetson
Hear! Hear! -Chris. >>> David Tayler 11/14/2009 1:42 PM >>> Speaking from the point of view of someone who has on occasion organized one of these things, noise is a big problem that the presenters choose to ignore. The "softies" have to form a group, ask for a separate room,

[LUTE] Re: Greenwich festival

2009-11-14 Thread David Tayler
Speaking from the point of view of someone who has on occasion organized one of these things, noise is a big problem that the presenters choose to ignore. The "softies" have to form a group, ask for a separate room, and have breakout rooms. What then happens is the facilities people start charg

[LUTE] Re: Greenwich festival

2009-11-14 Thread Christopher Stetson
All that Dana says, as usual, is true, but it's also true that even at it's beginning there was not much of a lute presence at the BEMF exhibition. I was there as an employee, moving in Hubbard Harpsichords and manning the booth. Of course, I don't have total recall, but I remember

[LUTE] Re: Greenwich festival -quick snaps and atmos

2009-11-14 Thread Stuart Walsh
Here are some quick photos (forgot even to colour correct them) of the exhibition and the Lute Society table! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VRaGYtf1t4c Stuart To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: Greenwich festival

2009-11-14 Thread demery
Unfortunatly, there are some harsh economic realities involved in renting a table at events like the BEMF. You have to man the table, staff doing so need accommodation and food, and are not producing work in your shop. If your shop is selling smaller instruments such as recorders and bagpipes yo

[LUTE] Re: Greenwich festival

2009-11-14 Thread chriswilke
Jaroslaw, It was the same at the Boston Early Music Festival Exposition. The Lute Society of America had a stand with info and some recordings. There were lots of other instruments to see and try: viols, recorders, harpsichords, etc. Lute-wise, all I could find was a single very, very ba

[LUTE] Re: Greenwich festival

2009-11-14 Thread Jaroslaw Lipski
Yes, it is. I've been there yesterday. There was only Lute Society stand, Mimmo Peruffo's and one lute maker (David van Edwards pupil) displaying student lutes. It would be a good opportunity to try Mimmo's loaded gut basses except there was a terrible constant noise of the bagpipes being pla

[LUTE] Re: Mr Strange Gregory hitts J. Whitfield

2009-11-14 Thread Stuart Walsh
Stewart McCoy wrote: Dear Stuart, "Mr Strangs Gregery hitts" is in only one source - Cambridge University Library, Dd.2.11. There might well be a bar missing from the first strain, but it is impossible to be sure what the missing notes are or where they should be. The attribution to John Whitfi