Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-02-02 Thread Gregory Youngblood
The problems you had with the x8dtn, did the affect the x8dtn+-o that you know of, or just the -6? I'm thinking of building a system around this due to the PCI-X so I can use the AOC-SAT2-MV8. Any thoughts? Thanks. -- This message posted from opensolaris.org

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-02-01 Thread Mark Nipper
On 31 Jan 2010, Jacob Ritorto wrote: I spent *so* many hours looking for that firmware.� Would you please post the link?� Did the firmware dl you found come with fcode? Running blade 2000 here (SPARC). Well, I can't say for sure it's the right firmware for your device. I

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-02-01 Thread Mark Bennett
I did see that and confirmed the support has made it into the 130 release I'm testing with. However, the WD10EARS does not expose 4k sectors to the outside world, so it is not identified as supporting it. Correct alignment, to ensure best performance of the internal translation, seems to be

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-02-01 Thread Mark Bennett
The WD10EARS disks don't work well. I had too many issues with timeouts that disappeared when replacing them with ST32000542AS drives. My next challenge is to get the LSI 3081 to boot off the disk I want it to, and then to get multipath functional. Has anyone else had issues with the LSI IT

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-31 Thread Mark Bennett
Update: For the WD10EARS, the blocks appear to be aligned on the 4k boundary when zfs uses the whole disk (whole disk as EFI partition). Part TagFlag First Sector Size Last Sector 0usrwm256 931.51Gb 1953508750 calc

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-31 Thread Kjetil Torgrim Homme
Mark Bennett mark.benn...@public.co.nz writes: Update: For the WD10EARS, the blocks appear to be aligned on the 4k boundary when zfs uses the whole disk (whole disk as EFI partition). Part TagFlag First Sector Size Last Sector 0usrwm

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-31 Thread Richard Elling
See also PSARC 2008/769 which considers 4 KB blocks for the entire OS in a phased approach. http://arc.opensolaris.org/caselog/PSARC/2008/769/inception.materials/design_doc -- richard ___ zfs-discuss mailing list zfs-discuss@opensolaris.org

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-31 Thread Jacob Ritorto
Hey Mark, I spent *so* many hours looking for that firmware. Would you please post the link? Did the firmware dl you found come with fcode? Running blade 2000 here (SPARC). Thx Jake On Jan 26, 2010 11:52 AM, Mark Nipper ni...@bitgnome.net wrote: It may depend on the firmware you're

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-30 Thread Ed Fang
I do not know if this has anything to do with some of the problems you're seeing. however, there is definitely an issue using /some/ LSI controllers on Supermicro boards. I just rencetly had an issue with using LSI3442 (the next gen over the 1068E chipset) on a Supermicro MB (X8DTN-6).

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-30 Thread Mark Bennett
I'm looking into the alignment implications for the WD10EARS disks. It may explain my issues. I seem to recall boot issues in some of the LSI release notes affecting other boot devices. I think it takes over boot responsibility. I've encountered this sort of issue over the years with many scsi

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-28 Thread Tonmaus
Thanks for your answer. I asked primarily because of the mpt timeout issues I saw on the list. Hi Arnaud, I am looking into the LSI SAS 3081 as well. My current understanding with mpt issues is that the sticky part of these problems is rather related to multipath features, that is using

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-28 Thread James C. McPherson
On 28/01/10 09:36 PM, Tonmaus wrote: Thanks for your answer. I asked primarily because of the mpt timeout issues I saw on the list. Hi Arnaud, I am looking into the LSI SAS 3081 as well. My current understanding with mpt issues is that the sticky part of these problems is rather related to

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-28 Thread Tonmaus
Hi James I do not think that you are reading the data correctly. The issues that we have seen via this list and storage-discuss have implicated downrev firmware on cards, and the various different disk drives that people choose to attach to those cards. Thanks for pointing that out. I

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-28 Thread Mark Bennett
My experience was different again. I have the same timeout issues with both the LSI and Supermicro cards in IT mode. IR mode on the Supermicro card didn't solve the problem, but seems to have reduced it . Server has 1 x 16 bay chassis and 1 x 24 bay chassis (both use expander) test pool has 24 x

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-28 Thread Simon Breden
Are you using the latest IT mode firmware? (1.26.00 I think, listed above and without checking mine using AOC-USAS-L8i which uses same controller) Also, I noticed you're using 'EARS' series drives. Again, I'm not sure if the WD10EARS drives suffer from a problem mentioned in these posts, but it

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-28 Thread Simon Breden
Are you using the latest IT mode firmware? (1.26.00 I think, listed above and without checking mine using AOC-USAS-L8i which uses same controller) Also, I noticed you're using 'EARS' series drives. Again, I'm not sure if the WD10EARS drives suffer from a problem mentioned in these posts, but it

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-28 Thread Mark Grant
Also, I noticed you're using 'EARS' series drives. Again, I'm not sure if the WD10EARS drives suffer from a problem mentioned in these posts, but it might be worth looking into -- especially the last link: Aren't the EARS drives the first ones using 4k sectors? Does OpenSolaris support that

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-26 Thread Mark Nipper
It may depend on the firmware you're running. We've got a SAS1068E based card in Dell R710 at the moment, connected to an external SAS JBOD, and we did have problems with the as shipped firmware. Well, I may have misspoke. I just spent a good portion of yesterday upgrading to the latest

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-25 Thread Mark Nipper
As in they work without any possibility of mpt timeout issues? I'm at my wits end with a machine right now that has an integrated 1068E and is dying almost hourly at this point. If I could spend three hundred dollars or so and have my problems magically go away, I'd love to pull the trigger

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-25 Thread Tristan Ball
It may depend on the firmware you're running. We've got a SAS1068E based card in Dell R710 at the moment, connected to an external SAS JBOD, and we did have problems with the as shipped firmware. However we've upgraded that, and _so far_ haven't had further issues. I didn't do the upgrade

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-12 Thread Arnaud Brand
 : james.mcpher...@sun.com [mailto:james.mcpher...@sun.com] De la part de James C. McPherson Envoyé : lundi 11 janvier 2010 23:05 À : Arnaud Brand Cc : zfs-discuss@opensolaris.org Objet : Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ? On 11/01/10 11:57 PM, Arnaud Brand wrote: According

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-11 Thread Maurice Volaski
According to various posts the LSI SAS3081E-R seems to work well with OpenSolaris. But I've got pretty chilled-out from my recent problems with Areca-1680's. Could anyone please confirm that the LSI SAS3081E-R works well ? Is hotplug supported ? It works well in Solaris 10 including

Re: [zfs-discuss] Is LSI SAS3081E-R suitable for a ZFS NAS ?

2010-01-11 Thread James C. McPherson
On 11/01/10 11:57 PM, Arnaud Brand wrote: According to various posts the LSI SAS3081E-R seems to work well with OpenSolaris. But I've got pretty chilled-out from my recent problems with Areca-1680's. Could anyone please confirm that the LSI SAS3081E-R works well ? Is hotplug supported ?