Hi Jan, I would answer András exactly the oposite :-) I would like to understand and ask you something.
Would you see any problem if he had a Apache Httpd configured as reverse proxy (no PHP in it) in front of Solr just to restrict user access to only the Solritas's URL? This way Solr would not be directly exposed and he would not need to develop a PHP site/application. Maybe a Varnish layer would be even better as he has 1.000.000+ pageviews a day. Again, no PHP in this scenario. What's your opinion about both solutions? Thanks in advance, ---- Marcelo Carvalho Fernandes +55 21 8272-7970 +55 21 2205-2786 On Sun, May 6, 2012 at 7:42 PM, Jan Høydahl <jan....@cominvent.com> wrote: > Hi, > > Solritas (Velocity Response Writer) is NOT intended for production use. > The simple reason, apart from that it is not production grade quality, is > that it requires direct access to the Solr instance, as it is simply a > response writer. You MUST use a separate front end layer above Solr and > never expose Solr directly to the world. So you should feel totally > comfortable continuing to use Solr over HTTP from PHP! > > -- > Jan Høydahl, search solution architect > Cominvent AS - www.cominvent.com > Solr Training - www.solrtraining.com > > On 6. mai 2012, at 14:02, András Bártházi wrote: > > > Hi, > > > > We're currently evaluating Solr as a Sphinx replacement. Our site has > > 1.000.000+ pageviews a day, it's a real estate search engine. The > > development is almost done, and it seems to be working fine, however some > > of my colleagues come with the idea that we're using it wrong. We're > using > > it as a service from PHP/Symfony. > > > > They think we should use Solritas as a frontend, so site visitors will > > directly use it, so no PHP will be involved, so it will be use much less > > infrastructure. One of them said that even mobile.de using it that way > (I > > have found no clue about it at all). > > > > Do you think is it a good idea? > > > > Do you know services using Solritas as a frontend on a public site? > > > > My personal opinion is that using Solritas in production is a very bad > idea > > for us, but have not so much experience with Solr yet, and Solritas > > documentation is far from a detailed, up-to-date one, so don't really > know > > what is it really usable for. > > > > Thanks, > > Andras > >
