Dave- This may come as some surprise to you, and seems counter-intuitive BUT- A HIGHER AIR PRESSURE IN THE SYSTEM CAN RESULT IN A FASTER WATER DELIVERY TIME. There are several variables within the equation of what it takes to get water to the ITC.
Instead of summarizing them here, I'm simply going to point you to James' G's White Paper on Performnace of Dry Pipe Systems which I'm sure you can find on Tyco's website. I will back up my surprising (to some) intro by stating that when we've done water delivery calcs, the results were at first counter-intuitive almost every time! But realize that beyond the time it takes to TRIP the system, there is TRANSIT time that's ignored by those going toward lower and lower supervisory air settings. While that lowers compressor size and refill times, it also means that when the water enters the system, much more of it is diverted from its course toward the ITC (or flowing heads) and goes up each branchline to equalize pressure. If you have 500 GPM diverted into filling pipe not in the path, that's the time (the time it takes to introduce 500 Gal) you'll lose toward getting water to the ITC. The right Quick Opening Device will trip the system quicker regardless of the pressure since its looking at RATE of decrease. Then, when water enters the system, if the air pressure is higher than you'd have expected, there is less water diverted and the vast majority of it heads for the ITC. Any non-believers simply have to watch the "video" replay of the FDT calcs to illustrate and light the light bulb of Aha! for them. Once a couple of scenarios of high and low pressure are run, it becomes more and more obvious that reduction of one variable (supervisory pressure) to an extreme while focusing on one component of water delivery (Trip Time) can have a greater offsetting NEGATIVE impact on the second component (Transit Time). Its not as apparent when doing a simple 1/2" ITC flow, but if you've seen a calc run with 4 k17's open, there's not much holding back the forward inrush of water as lots of air can get out of four K17 orifi. Read the White Paper. See the Video. Be the water, and do good works. Class dismissed. glc -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Dave Phelan Sent: Thursday, October 25, 2007 7:55 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Supervisory Alarm - Low Air Thanks for the information - I will be adjusting my field acceptance testing procedures now to include this requirement. I see the problem as being a gap between the sprinkler installer and alarm tech / electrician. Even if the sprinkler tech puts in the proper switch with double contacts to be code compliant it then falls to the alarm contractor to know the requirement and properly pick up boths sets of contacts for both high and low pressure supervision. I guess the way to handle this up front on plan review is to specifically cite the requirement on the drawings instead of the typical 'low air supervisory device' notation. In talking to some contractors on the matter there is an opinion that high air monitoring isnt all so important but looking at things through my AHJ-fire colored glasses Im well aware of the negative impact on water delivery time a system with excessive pressure can have. I recently had the cooperation of a contractor during the acceptance testing process and after we trip tested the system at the design pressures we had a water delivery time of 53 seconds. We then refilled the system and increased air pressure 5 and 9 psi above the design pressure. At 5 psi above the water delivery was just about 1:45 but at 9 psi over the water delivery was just over 3 minutes. Im sure we've all seen one or more test video burns in our time and the thought of delaying water delivery nearly three times over is not only unacceptable but plain dangerous. Funny thing though, now that I have a better education - even at 9psi excess pressure the supervisory alarm might not have sounded. Even though 13 & 25 only specify testing of the LOW air supervisory device I'd like to offer that since the sprinkler industry knows better and is educated that we make it a point to test for high air during our semi-annual inspections and should the switch not be properly wired by the alarm contractor we note it as an exception and notify the owners to have it corrected. I'm pretty sure that the alarm contractor isnt going to fiddle with the air filling device to simulate this test so its most likely not connected or even being done. Opinion time over - work day begins. Dave, An AHJ in NJ _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field) _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)
