I think that the water pressure would most certainly play a factor. I also
think the system configuration would play a big deal. I would think that in
certain situations the low pressure could win out, even with the extra
filling of dead end pipe. 
Since the Victaulic valves have a set pressure rating (on @ 13psi, off
@18psi), if you had a lot of water pressure, you would still just have the
18psi of air. On a 'standard' dry valve, with the greater water supply, you
would need greater air pressure. And that while the higher air pressure
would reduce the amount of water that would fill the branch lines (and other
dead end pipe), it would also mean that the extra air would need to get out
through the Inspectors test valve prior to water. I could envision a
situation where you have high water pressure, and where the DV is located a
long way from you area of protection, when the low pressure DPV would work
best. (since in this situation the dead end pipe volume would be
representing a smaller part of the system volume than a system with the DPV
located immediately next to the area of protection, and therefore the amount
of 'extra filling' of pipe is minimized by the air pressure factor). In this
situation, with the higher pressure type DPV, you would still have to expel
all the air in the main bulk main which at the higher pressure, would take
longer.

"To release 30% of the air trough the ITC takes approximately the same
amount of time in low and high air pressure systems.
The pressure follows an e-function along the time-axis."

My understanding from the Tyco white Paper, is that this does not follow a
e-function the time axis, but rather is dictated by the supply pressure,
amount of dead-end pipe being compressed, test orifice size.... My
understanding would be if you had no dead end pipe (just for the discussion
on the theory involved, see figure 11 of the white paper), the low pressure
would be better, since with the high air pressure, all the air in the main
will have to leave through the ITV. At some point the higher air pressure is
going to release enough pressure as to be comparable to where the low
pressure system was initially. From that moment, they are going to take the
same amount of time. Therefore the extra time for the air pressure to go
from the 'high air pressure' to 'low pressure' would be just that, extra
time. (again, for this example the volume of dead end pipe is minimized and
therefore little additional 'filling' of pipe is involved). At what point
the volume of dead end pipe, leading to increased time for filling of dead
ends would seem to be the sweet spot:).  

Seems to be too many factors for me to feel comfortable with making any
concrete conclusions about a general preference of low versus high pressure
DPVs. I'd imagine using the FDT program on a regular probably gives you the
ability to draw conclusions by looking at the system configuration and water
supply.    


Thank you all for your insight on the matter. Certainly opens up a new line
of thinking for me. 


Ah the quest for the sweet spot:)    

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected]
[mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of å... ....
Sent: Monday, June 22, 2009 9:55 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Slow responding dry pipe valves

would not the pressure from the water, rather than the air, determinemore
accurately what is happening during water-filling-and-air-purging?

if water is coming in at 7psig, ignoring the complications of filling dead
ends,
and velocity pressure vs normal pressure, and the expanding boundary marked
by the front of the water wave as it fills the pipe...

if water is coming in a 7 psig, will it not trap air in the branches at
close
to 7psig?  thus air is compressed 7: 1 in low pressure and compressed 7:2
in high-pressure systems.  This suggest that roughly double the amount
of water is needed to fill branches in low pressure systems than the amount
of water needed to fill branches in high pressure systems.  That might
explain
some of why the high pressure systems deliver water quicker,

although it does not explain the sweet spot.

scot deal
excelsior fire engineering




> For example: with a water pressure of 7 bar (100 psi)
> a low air pressure systems may trip at 1 bar (14 psi) and the standby
> pressure is 1.4 bar (20 psi),
> a high air pressure system may trip at 2 bar (28 psi) and the standby
> pressure is 2.8 bar (40 psi).
>
> So there is hardly any difference until the valve has tripped.
> After the valve has tripped, it is another situation:
> Water at a pressure of 7 bar (100 psi) is trying to fill-up a pipe
> system with a remaining amount of air in it that is different for
> both types of systems:
> remaining pressure in a low air pressure system: 1 bar (14 psi),
> remaining pressure in a high air pressure system: 2 bar (28 psi).
>
>
>
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
For Technical Assistance, send an email to: [email protected]

To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[email protected]
(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)

_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
For Technical Assistance, send an email to: [email protected]

To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[email protected]
(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)

Reply via email to