Hi Chris >quite true keith. you've touched on some points i've been meaning to bring >to bring to bear on this discussion. hopefully i'll find some time to >contribute more. > >robert, i was trying to draw you into the discussion as a thought exercise >(the thing about the whales). this very question was put to me many years >back,
And to me - or rather it was me that put the question. >and it proved to be very transformational. no, i'm not trying to >"guru" you. but i do like to share it when the opportunity presents itself. Here's what you said: >>then there's the whales. we know their ancestors were land dwellers. in >>other words, sea creatures gave rise to land creatures, and some of them >>chose to return to the sea. >>why would they do that? this is a serious question. after all, you're >>giving up an awful lot. Are they? I reckon they've got it pretty good. I'm a bit envious. The way they live in the sea reminds me of the way later Paleolithic Man lived on the land. Those were the good old days, I think. You said they "chose" to return to the sea, and I guess they did, though it's hard to say just why - because they like it that way, or maybe the land-dolphins, whatever they were - or perhaps their not-dolphin corporate dolphinhoods - screwed the land up somehow (nuked it?) and the sea was their only refuge. Who knows, if they're that bright maybe they geo-engineered themselves into sea creatures rather than evolving or devolving or whatever. I once wrote a three-page article about dolphins for New Scientist. It's not that relevant to this discussion, but it's here, if you're interested: " Lessons from a deadly disease of dolphins - Attempts to save captive dolphins dying from a bizarre disease known as malleiodosis have paved the way for an effective vaccine for humans", Keith Addison, New Scientist, Nov 17, 1983 http://snipurl.com/27wmeh Those particular captive dolphins, by the way, had been rescued from the annual dolphin slaughter at Taiji in Japan, the subject of "The Cove". In 1983. Anyway, the article was mainly based on interviews with two major scientists. Among other things, I asked them whether dolphins developed their big brains before or after returning to the sea. "Before." So then it could well have been a conscious decision. Best Keith >>think about it. _______________________________________________ Biofuel mailing list Biofuel@sustainablelists.org http://sustainablelists.org/mailman/listinfo/sustainablelorgbiofuel Biofuel at Journey to Forever: http://journeytoforever.org/biofuel.html Search the combined Biofuel and Biofuels-biz list archives (70,000 messages): http://www.mail-archive.com/biofuel@sustainablelists.org/
