Am 09/apr/2013 um 16:17 schrieb Steve Bennett <stevag...@gmail.com>:
> On Mon, Apr 8, 2013 at 2:53 AM, Dave Sutter <sut...@intransix.com> wrote:
>> Creating another instance of the OSM database and server is a very
>> good idea. I would propose we make the purpose of this database to
>> allow people post ANY geo data that is NOT part of the base map. It
>> would be an open database for general GIS data.
>>
>> Some examples of random things people could do with this database:
>> - The high resolution imagery outlines discussed in this thread
>> - Migratory patterns of birds (I can't find the post where someone was
>> requesting where to do this...)
>> - GPS tracking for running, hiking, cycling and other recreation,
>> similar to Strava or MapMyRun (see
>> http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/OpenSportMap)
>> - GIS Management for operations like Haiti OSM team
>
> There are very many use cases for GIS data that is useful to OSM but
> doesn't meet the current OSM criteria. Perhaps so many that one
> database wouldn't be enough. Some that come to mind:
> - everything that fails the "on the ground" test (flight paths,
> boundaries, designations, etc)
> - statistical/population/demographic data
> - project metadata like "the zzz team is working within this boundary area"
> - subjective data (preferred cycle routes)
> - historical data (explorers' routes, defunct bus routes, demolished
> buildings...)
>
> Probably some of these already have good homes (OpenAviatianMap?).
>
there is also historic OSM (right now mainly ML).
Still, some of what you exclude is already in OSM: boundaries, designations,
population data, demolished buildings...), and IMHO there is also room for
this, like for start_dates, Wikipedia links, ancient cultures, place names
etc.,
The on the ground rule shouldn't mean to exclude information that is publicly
available but maybe isn't visible staring on the ground itself.
cheers,
Martin
_______________________________________________
talk mailing list
talk@openstreetmap.org
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
