Thanks Timm. This is valuable feedback. Nevertheless - can you point to any advantage JSF has over Wicket? Anything at all?
Thanks Timm Helbig wrote: > > Hi, > > I did one Project with JSF and two with Wicket. > > By far Wicket is much easier to handle, (nearly) everything works as > supposed, > which is not true for JSF, especially when it comes to external Libraries > like Trinidad or other UI Extension Libraries. > > One other thing which is important for me is the Productivity. And this > is > much higher with Wicket than with JSF. > > The Community support is suberb with Wicket, and somewhat difficult when > you > check the JSF Forums, but this depends on the Manufactor of the Library > you > use. > > I don't want to slash JSF here, but I find it is miles away from a usable > Product. For me it looks more like a prototype of what could be possible. > Just check what happened from 1.1 to 1.2, and you see, that even Sun > seemed > to face this. > > Regards, > Timm > > Am Mittwoch, 6. August 2008 11:13:53 schrieb nlif: >> Hi all, >> >> We are in the process of selecting a web-framework, and although I am in >> favor of Wicket, I was asked to provide an objective comparison of Wicket >> with JSF. I have developed a few small apps in Wicket, but I admit I am >> not >> very familiar with JSF. Prior to posting here, I googled a bit, and found >> a >> few forum-threads and blog posts on this topic, but most are from 1-2 >> years >> ago and in framework years, this may be considered obsolete. >> >> Although this is the Wicket forum, I expect there are people here who >> also >> used (or at least evaluated) JSF at some point, so I'd be happy if folks >> here could share their experience. If anyone can point me to useful links >> that would be great too. >> >> I really am not trying to provoke a flame war, just to gather >> information. >> >> In your opinion, what are Wicket strengths? What are JSF's ? (even if >> you're a Wicket fan, surely there's something ;) >> >> I would be interested to hear people thoughts regarding the fact the JSF >> is >> a standard, while Wicket is not. How important is that to you? In what >> ways >> do you think this matters (if at all)? >> >> Also, supposedly JSF has a larger selection of 3rd party components >> compared to Wicket. Is this true? how often do you find yourself rolling >> your own components and how hard is it to do so in Wicket (and I mean >> non-trivial-good-looking-Ajax-enabled stuff). >> >> Many thanks in advance. > > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > > -- View this message in context: http://www.nabble.com/Comparing-JSF-and-Wicket-tp18847208p18864975.html Sent from the Wicket - User mailing list archive at Nabble.com. --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
