-----Original Message-----
From: Stephen A. Lawrence 

> they *succeeded* in their replication, *and* they looked at the published
data, *and* they found a mundane explanation for the apparent excess heat,
*and* they showed that the mundane explanation fully accounted for the
results of their *successful* replication.... That's completely different
from the claim that 95 failures to replicate "disprove" the claims of one
successful scientist...


.... Yes - and that scenario is not even close to what actually happened !

.... especially when you consider the entirety of the evidence of the Italian
work, after 1992 with Ni-potassium. Did you actually read any of the papers,
Stephen? I think not, or at least not carefully. Check out the chart about
2/3 of the way down Steve's article: 

http://www.newenergytimes.com/v2/news/2008/NET29-8dd54geg.shtml#pf

That looks closer to proof than disproof.

The CERN groups response is really a joke in my opinion, let alone
"disproof". They admit up front that they lack critical information from the
Piantelli-Focardi  paper. Perhaps these were essential details which were
responsible for a failure to replicate anything. How can anyone in the right
mind claim *successful replication* when there is the kind of up-front
admission that they don't have a clue? An how could later commentators fail
to take into account the subsequent and far better work that followed?

Please read the papers Steve mentioned, before expressing a non-sensical
opinion based on a second hand report on an early paper, which was itself
not accurate. Even if doubts are raised about the calorimetry in a single
early paper (and JR is correct on that) they are were made irrelevant 3
years later - or about the "interpretation of data", that is a long, long
way from "disproof." Especially with 20/20 hindsight, and the better results
that followed.

For instance in later papers using Ni (1997-99), gammas, tritium and
neutrons were documented. Tritium is radioactive and extremely hard to
rationalize away as mundane, when it is found. Are you saying that someone
could replicate tritium- and then find a mundane explanation of it? Of
course not, so why would you believe that the one early and confused null
experiment was a "replication" at all - or was "successful" as you call it,
since it was admittedly different - or why would you believe that one
cursory re-interpretation of data trumps another more thorough POV; or that
in suggesting BUT NOT PROVING a mundane way that it could have happened, but
didn't, that everything is suddenly disproved ? Especially in the light of
what came later?

This is beyond bizarre - to suggest anything close to "disproof" is absurd.
It smacks of an attempted smear-job on Piantelli. But why?

It is almost as if the Yanks are getting caught up in someone else's
professional rivalry thing in Europe. Too bad. The later Piantelli work
seems quite good to me.

Jones


Reply via email to