Jones Beene wrote:
The CERN groups response is really a joke in my opinion, let alone
"disproof". They admit up front that they lack critical information from the
Piantelli-Focardi paper. Perhaps these were essential details which were
responsible for a failure to replicate anything.
They succeeded in replicating the Ni loading effect and excess heat
effect. The missing information may be related to other aspects of
the work that you mentioned, but they had enough information to load
the Ni, observe the apparent excess heat, and show that it is not
excess heat. Based on my knowledge of gas calorimeters (Mizuno,
Biberian), this does not surprise me.
They did not have enough information to load the Ni often, or easily,
but they did succeed in loading it a few times, and that's enough to
prove the point.
How can anyone in the right mind claim *successful replication* when
there is the kind of up-front admission that they don't have a clue?
They don't need a clue. They got the gadget to do what Focardi
described and they showed it does not mean what Focardi thought it meant.
An how could later commentators fail to take into account the
subsequent and far better work that followed?
I do not think it was far better. It would be far better with an
envelope calorimeter of some sort. A gas calorimeter is a can of
worms and it will not produce convincing results in my opinion. As I
said, I have even seen a reversal which should be solid Second-law
proof of heat, and yet the other methods of measuring heat used at
the same time showed nothing. Who knows what to make of that? It
tells me you should try another approach.
Beene discusses some of their other results:
For instance in later papers using Ni (1997-99), gammas, tritium and
neutrons were documented. Tritium is radioactive and extremely hard
to rationalize away as mundane, when it is found. Are you saying
that someone could replicate tritium- and then find a mundane
explanation of it? . . .
This has nothing to do with the calorimetry, which remains iffy at best.
I have not looked closely at the gammas, tritium or neutrons because
I don't know much about them. I would note that people have often
screwed up these measurements as well. I know calorimetry, and this
kind of calorimetry does not work and should not be used unless you
have no choice. I wouldn't trust their other results until they get
this one squared away.
The later Piantelli work seems quite good to me.
Then I suggest you try calibrating a gas calorimeter, and learn some
of the many ways it will confound and deceive you.
Frankly, I cannot understand why so many people devote years of
effort and vast sums of money to these experiments, and yet they use
half-baked, unreliable, primitive calorimetry! It is not that hard to
do an adequate job of calorimetry. You don't need to approach the SRI
standard of excellence. It is a waste of time doing any other part of
the experiment, such as looking for tritium, if you cannot be sure
you have excess heat. I mentioned a long, sad list of people with bad
calorimetry: Patterson, Miley, Bush & Eagleton, Stringham . . . It
seems especially endemic in light water and non-Pd studies. These
people wasted their time and other people's money -- MY MONEY in some
cases! Lousy instruments, wrong instruments, no calibration, on and on!!!
Of course there has been unforgivably sloppy calorimetry in Pd-D
studies as well, notably Arata. When I complained about this to
Talbot Chubb he said "Arata and Zhang have been slaving away for a
year. They have had no time to calibrate." I told Talbot that's nuts.
It is also wrong: A&Z have three highly competent PhDs sent by the
government of the PRC doing whatever they ask. One of them could
calibrate properly in a few days. (And you can be darn sure there is
a replication back in the PRC that is properly calibrated! They are
not spending hundreds of thousands a year on this without checking it out.)
Naturally, when I raised questions about Arata's calorimetry he blew
me away. He gets furiously angry with anyone who questions any aspect
of his work. He is not a good experimentalist, to say the least. A
brilliant scientist, but he should not be in the lab using circa 1935
ridiculous calorimetry with $500,000 worth of the best instruments
money can buy. Nuts, nuts, nuts. I am glad that others are now
replicating this experiment. Arata -- in the Grand Tradition of
Patterson and Piantelli -- is upset by this, and he is trying to
derail these replications.
- Jed