Jones Beene wrote:
It really is as simple as this: Radioactivity = Credibility. Transmutation = Credibility.
Credibility to scientists. Who needs 'em? Most of them are bought and paid for by the DoE. As Stan Szpak says, scientists believe whatever you pay them to believe.
Excess Heat = Controversy
Excess heat = technology. Something useful for mankind. Something highly profitable. That means the public will be interested and if we can overcome the academic politics it means hundreds of billions of dollars in funding. Tritium, transmutations and neutrons have no market value and they will attract the attention of few academic scientists at most -- the ones who are not in the DoE's pocket.
If transmutations can be scaled up and made to produce commercially valuable stuff such as gold I will become interested in it. Until then, I really don't give a damn about it, except insofar as it might be a useful clue that helps a theorist figure out how cold fusion works. That would be good, if the theory helps guide research to make practical progress. The theory itself would be of no more interest to me, personally, than an out of date programming guide to an obsolete version of C++ not installed on my computer. Someone may need it, but not me. I have strictly utilitarian goals.
If it could be shown conclusively that cold fusion can never be scaled up, and can never become a practical source of energy, I would drop it immediately. I would not spend 5 more minutes on the subject. I have absolutely no interest whatever in neutrons and tritium . . . Fortunately, all the evidence points in the other direction, indicating that it can be scaled up and it will be useful, if only we learn how to control it.
- Jed

