Jones Beene wrote:
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Stephen A. Lawrence 
> 

Whoops -- You lifted the following quote from its context:  You snipped
the part where I said, "The claim Jed made was *not* that they failed to
replicate; it was that..."

Consequently, you've made it sound like I claimed the following
statements to be true.  I did not.  I claimed that they constituted
Jed's argument.  I did not say he was correct.  In fact, I don't know if
he's correct, and have never claimed otherwise; that was not my point,
as I reiterate, below.

>> they *succeeded* in their replication, *and* they looked at the published
> data, *and* they found a mundane explanation for the apparent excess heat,
> *and* they showed that the mundane explanation fully accounted for the
> results of their *successful* replication.... That's completely different
> from the claim that 95 failures to replicate "disprove" the claims of one
> successful scientist...
> 
> 
> .... Yes - and that scenario is not even close to what actually happened !
> 
> .... especially when you consider the entirety of the evidence of the Italian
> work, after 1992 with Ni-potassium. Did you actually read any of the papers,
> Stephen? 

No, and I never said I had.  And again, that wasn't my point.  I was not
commenting on the papers!  I was merely trying to point out that the
"failure to replicate doesn't disprove positive results" argument had
*nothing* *to* *do* with Jed's original post.

Perhaps he's wrong, but attacking him for representing failure to
replicate as proof of original incorrect results is pointless.  He
didn't do that.


> Please read the papers Steve mentioned, before expressing a non-sensical
> opinion based on a second hand report on an early paper, which was itself
> not accurate.

And please don't put words in my mouth, eh?

I didn't say "Jed's right about this!"

I actually said, "Jed didn't say failure to replicate proved the
original results wrong!".

And I enlarged a bit on that last point.

What I said was neither nonsensical nor incorrect; nor was it based on
the content of the papers, as I thought was obvious.  But perhaps that
wasn't obvious to everyone, and I should have made it clearer.


Reply via email to