Hi Eric, I'm not up to speed with your emails. The LENR+ type of activities is still something that if proper tests are done and affirmative, will be much more interesting, this is clear. But I would like to keep the discussion to the original FP experiment.
> I think this would be an interesting test to whether there is a possible > isotope effect. But there's evidence that LENR is seen in light water/light > hydrogen systems as well. So if the test concerns the *existence* of LENR, > rather than a parameter that affects it, I think another control should be > sought out. > To decide here one need to have a clue about, P(FP-effect | water) and P(FP-effect | heavy water) There is a reason why heavy water is typically used so I would assume that the effect seen is much stronger (more frequent, higher energy) then when water is used. If the frequencies are the same, I would guess that we could measure the strength to a number and use that in stead in a test. The FP effect itself for a skeptic does not necessary equate to a nuclear effect. It having an isotopic effect would be quite a strong indication that there is a nuclear effect or am I wrong? Else wouldn't it be so interesting that people would take notice of this field? Cheers!
