Re: MD: Re: Recording speeds

2001-06-17 Thread Eric Woudenberg, Minidisc.org Editor


Stainless Steel Rat [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

 
 * Stuart Howlette [EMAIL PROTECTED]  on Fri, 15 Jun 2001
 | Not a mention of high speed,
 
 Ahem.  The context of this discussion is, paraphrased, moving music from
 computers to MD equipment faster than S/PDIF.  S/PDIF doesn't do that
 (obviously :).  AES/EBU doesn't do that.  TTL doesn't do that (maybe it
 could, but that would be very ugly).  IR controllers don't do that.  PCx
 controllers don't do that.  Line out doesn't do that.
 
 The -- singular -- standard for this is IEEE 1394.

I'm missing something, why can't USB do that? In the realm of PC to
Solid State MP3 player connectivity at least, USB is certainly the
standard.

Rick
-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



MD: Two ideas on MD PC related products

2001-06-17 Thread G der


  Why doesn't sony seem to be considering to make a MD
Drive for the home PC ? Don't you think that would be
nice ? For both recording and playing purposes... I
think this may be told a thousand times but i'm not
thinking the storage issue, it's just about music..
I've got my CD-RW for storage and that works pretty
fine =)
  The other issue (product, service whatever you call
it) is a one related to the above one. If we have some
technology called ATRAC3, why can't we store our music
in ATRAC3 files on our computers just like MP3's and
sharetrade the songs in MiniDisc format ? So then we
can maybe  even able to upload them through our
MiniDisc recorders or MD Drives... ??? I think that
would be nice to have a ATRAC3 player (WinAtr  haha)
and some (.ac3) or (.atr) files on my HDD

  See ya, thanx
  Please reply with your own ideas =)


__
Do You Yahoo!?
Spot the hottest trends in music, movies, and more.
http://buzz.yahoo.com/
-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Two ideas on MD PC related products

2001-06-17 Thread Dave Hooper


   Why doesn't sony seem to be considering to make a MD
 Drive for the home PC ? Don't you think that would be
 nice ? For both recording and playing purposes... I
 think this may be told a thousand times but i'm not
 thinking the storage issue, it's just about music..
 I've got my CD-RW for storage and that works pretty
 fine =)

You can already get them, but they record at 1x speed and are not a data
transport device, just a music transport device (e.g. you cannot read the
ATRAC / ATRAC3 files digitially off of the minidisc, you can only read off
the audio data.  The reason for this product decision has historically been
copyright paranoia, e.g. SDMI)

   The other issue (product, service whatever you call
 it) is a one related to the above one. If we have some
 technology called ATRAC3, why can't we store our music
 in ATRAC3 files on our computers just like MP3's and
 sharetrade the songs in MiniDisc format ? So then we
 can maybe  even able to upload them through our
 MiniDisc recorders or MD Drives... ??? I think that
 would be nice to have a ATRAC3 player (WinAtr  haha)
 and some (.ac3) or (.atr) files on my HDD

You can already get ATRAC3 files.  I've seen compressors that compress to
ATRAC3 format instead of MP3 or MP3pro, for example.  And likewise players.
I think you can even play these files back using plugins for WinAmp.
The one thing you cannot do is upload the digital ATRAC3 data to your
minidisc.  If you want to record the files onto your minidisc, you NEED to
play the atrac files using your favourite player and hook the output of your
soundcard (preferably opticial digital out if you have it) into your
minidisc, or if you have an internal minidisc recorder in your pc, set it to
record the output of the soundcard...

Sony used to have an internal PC  **data** deck.  It was one of their really
early MD products.  Total pity you can't get it any more (maybe try Ebay but
I doubt anyone that has one would consider parting with it for any amount of
money! )   :)

Dave

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



MD: Marking tracks on MZ-R900

2001-06-17 Thread Tim Pitman


I'm trying to add track marks to a recording on my MZ-R900, and would like
to know how to do it accurately.  Currently I press pause when it gets to
the right spot, then tarck-mark.  Is there a better way?



-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Re: Recording speeds

2001-06-17 Thread Stuart Howlette


Did anyone actually receive my apology or did it just dissapear off the face
of the earth?

--
Stuart Howlette
There are many questions in life, but is the right answer only correct
because the majority believe in it?
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.liquid2k.com/stuh84/
http://www.liquid2k.com/stuh84/personal/
--

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Marking tracks on MZ-R900

2001-06-17 Thread Dave Hooper


Probably not, but you don't say how you originally recorded the material.
If it's a copy of a CD, with a compatible CD player with opticial digital
out, you can set the player to Sync and it will put the track marks in
exactly the right places using the track information in the SPDIF signal.
Cool huh?

Otherwise, for example if it's a live recording which you later want to
split into tracks, you'll have to go with the pause-then-track-mark method.

- Original Message -

 I'm trying to add track marks to a recording on my MZ-R900, and would like
 to know how to do it accurately.  Currently I press pause when it gets to
 the right spot, then tarck-mark.  Is there a better way?


-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Re: Recording speeds

2001-06-17 Thread Ask Bjoern Hansen


On Sun, 17 Jun 2001, Eric Woudenberg, Minidisc.org Editor wrote:

[...]
  The -- singular -- standard for this is IEEE 1394.
 
 I'm missing something, why can't USB do that? In the realm of PC to
 Solid State MP3 player connectivity at least, USB is certainly the
 standard.

USB is really slow. I'm too tired to quite figure out what 4x
recording speed would require, but I could imagine that it'd be more
than USB can give.


 - ask

-- 
ask bjoern hansen, http://ask.netcetera.dk/   !try; do();


-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Marking tracks on MZ-R900

2001-06-17 Thread Dave Hooper


 Probably not, but you don't say how you originally recorded the material.
 If it's a copy of a CD, with a compatible CD player with opticial digital
 out, you can set the player to Sync and it will put the track marks in
 exactly the right places using the track information in the SPDIF signal.

Duh, I meant set the MZR900 to Sync record.  You set the CD player to 'play'
:)

Dave

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Re: Recording speeds

2001-06-17 Thread Marc Britten


it probably can, but Firewire has all of the stuff in place. but then again so do USB 
CD-R's

its probably a bit different going to solid state MP3 players since all your doing is 
dumping a file, here you would need to turn the mp3 audio into a viable digital 
source(like the PCLink or Xitel stuff does through sound card type api's) then the 
digital source goes into the MD player which converts it to ATRAC and writes it to 
disc.

marc

On Sun, Jun 17, 2001 at 05:51:01AM -0400, Eric Woudenberg, Minidisc.org Editor wrote:
 
  The -- singular -- standard for this is IEEE 1394.
 
 I'm missing something, why can't USB do that? In the realm of PC to
 Solid State MP3 player connectivity at least, USB is certainly the
 standard.
-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Two ideas on MD PC related products

2001-06-17 Thread Mike Lastucka


   Why doesn't sony seem to be considering to make a MD
Drive for the home PC ? Don't you think that would be
nice ? For both recording and playing purposes... I
think this may be told a thousand times but i'm not
thinking the storage issue, it's just about music..
I've got my CD-RW for storage and that works pretty
fine =)

Demand, of course, would play a big part in not having one out already.  MD 
is still a niche market, in my opinion.  There's also the issue with MD data 
drives not being able to play MD audio.


---
Mike Lastucka, B. Tech
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://sites.netscape.net/element5/
2048 bit DH 0x16DC15CD

_
Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Marking tracks on MZ-R900

2001-06-17 Thread Mike Lastucka


I'm trying to add track marks to a recording on my MZ-R900, and would like
to know how to do it accurately.  Currently I press pause when it gets to
the right spot, then tarck-mark.  Is there a better way?

Beyond setting automatic marking (every five minutes, or at any 2 sec 
pause), you're doing them the best way that *I* know how.


---
Mike Lastucka, B. Tech
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://sites.netscape.net/element5/
2048 bit DH 0x16DC15CD

_
Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



RE: MD: Marking tracks on MZ-R900

2001-06-17 Thread Danny-K



  ===
  = NB: Over 50% of this message is QUOTED, please  =
  = be more selective when quoting text =
  ===

 I'm trying to add track marks to a recording on my MZ-R900, and
 would like
 to know how to do it accurately.  Currently I press pause when it gets to
 the right spot, then tarck-mark.  Is there a better way?

 Beyond setting automatic marking (every five minutes, or at any 2 sec
 pause), you're doing them the best way that *I* know how.


Are you guys saying that the R900 (which seems to be top of the line right
now) doesn't have a simple track mark button?  Good god.

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Recording speeds

2001-06-17 Thread Stainless Steel Rat


* Stuart Howlette [EMAIL PROTECTED]  on Sun, 17 Jun 2001
| Did anyone actually receive my apology or did it just dissapear off the face
| of the earth?

I saw it.
Twice, actually.
-- 
Rat [EMAIL PROTECTED]\ Caution: Happy Fun Ball may suddenly
Minion of Nathan - Nathan says Hi! \ accelerate to dangerous speeds.
PGP Key: at a key server near you!  \ 
-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Marking tracks on MZ-R900

2001-06-17 Thread Dave Hooper


  Currently I press pause when it gets to
  the right spot, then tarck-mark.  Is there a better way?
 

 Are you guys saying that the R900 (which seems to be top of the line right
 now) doesn't have a simple track mark button?  Good god.


No... read it again.  He presses pause, then presses the track-mark button.
So we can presume the R900 has one of these.

Dave

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Recording speeds

2001-06-17 Thread Stainless Steel Rat


* Marc Britten [EMAIL PROTECTED]  on Sun, 17 Jun 2001
| it probably can, but Firewire has all of the stuff in place. but then
| again so do USB CD-R's

USB CD-R/W is a SCSI hack.  That is, the driver and drive pretent to be
SCSI devices.  USB was never intended to be used for this sort of thing.
It is a low speed bus, like Apple's ADB, intended for keyboards, mice,
tablets, sticks, possibly modems, printers, and other low-bandwidth
devices.  Using it for fast devices like disks and scanners and network
adaptors was not intended but is allowed for.  4x-6x is the absolute
maximum that USB CD-R/W can maintain, and that is if the writer is the only
thing on the bus.  Even a mouse on the same bus can drop that to 1x-2x,
assuming it can keep up at all.

IEEE 1394 was designed from the ground up to be a cheap, fast bus for high
speed data transfer, primarilly disk I/O, with the intention for multimedia
applications like digital audio and video recorders.

USB 1.1's absolute maximum throughput of 11Mbps vs IEEE 1394's current
400Mbps.
-- 
Rat [EMAIL PROTECTED]\ Warning: pregnant women, the elderly, and
Minion of Nathan - Nathan says Hi! \ children under 10 should avoid prolonged
PGP Key: at a key server near you!  \ exposure to Happy Fun Ball.
-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



RE: MD: Marking tracks on MZ-R900

2001-06-17 Thread Richard Lang


 Are you guys saying that the R900 (which seems to be top of the line
right
 now) doesn't have a simple track mark button?  Good god.

 No... read it again.  He presses pause, then presses the track-mark
button.
 So we can presume the R900 has one of these.

Wasn't the point that the R900 would be expected to be capable of completing
a track-mark operation by only pressing ONE button (whatever it may be
called)?  

Pause + Track-Mark = 2 buttons.

Without ever having used an R900 or R90 I would certainly expect that if you
wanted to insert a track mark you would just use one button.  

Is the pause function to allow for a rehearsal (like the home MD decks)
when you're inserting marks in an existing recording or something?

Richard Lang
Senior Solicitor

Duncan Cotterill
Christchurch, New Zealand

email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
tel: (++64)-3-379-2430  fax: (++64)-3-379-7097
http://www.duncancotterill.com

___PLEASE NOTE: ___
This communication contains information that is confidential and which may be subject 
to legal privilege or subject to copyright.  If you are not the intended recipient, 
you must not use, distribute or copy the contents of this communication.  If you have 
received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by reply e-mail, 
facsimile or collect telephone call to +64 3 379 2430 and destroy the original.  We 
virus scan all e-mails and electronic media but are not responsible for any virus or 
alternation.
-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Recording speeds

2001-06-17 Thread Marc Britten


On Sun, Jun 17, 2001 at 03:10:00PM -0400, Stainless Steel Rat wrote:
 
 * Marc Britten [EMAIL PROTECTED]  on Sun, 17 Jun 2001
 | it probably can, but Firewire has all of the stuff in place. but then
 | again so do USB CD-R's
 
 USB CD-R/W is a SCSI hack.  That is, the driver and drive pretent to be
 SCSI devices.  USB was never intended to be used for this sort of thing.

so are IDE CD-r/w's haven't stopped them from taking over the market.

I didn't say it was a good think i'm just saying you might be able to do it.
 
 IEEE 1394 was designed from the ground up to be a cheap, fast bus for high
 speed data transfer, primarilly disk I/O, with the intention for multimedia
 applications like digital audio and video recorders.

like i said, firewire has all of the stuff in place to do stuff like that.

 USB 1.1's absolute maximum throughput of 11Mbps vs IEEE 1394's current
 400Mbps.

thank you i know, i program USB communications for a living
(among other protocols)(no firewire)
-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



MD: Sony doesn't seem to have a portable MP3 player

2001-06-17 Thread las


Before this post I did a little research to see if I could find a Sony MP3
player similar to a Rio.  From my research, I have found that Sony doesn't
seem to make an actual MP3 player.

They make a music clip that requires you to convert MP3 files to ATRAC3.  I
actually went back to the community page to see what they were talking about
when they said ATRAC3.  I don't feel so bad because it was listed in the FAQ.

If you are highly knowledgeable about all forms of ATRAC skip this section:

-

ATRAC3, as most of you probably know (but I'm sure there are some people on
the list new to MD-and even though I have been involved with MD for a long
time, I really didn't read about the nomenclature when MDLP came out) is the
form of ATRAC used in MDLP.

Again, most you know that it is incompatible with previous ATRAC schemes
(that much I knew).  But all MDLP units have the ability to play ATRAC1 and
ATRAC1 version R making it backwards compatible.

Before I gone on to talk about Sony's clip, I thought that an explanation of
ATRAC types might be of use to people on the list new to MD.  What we call
ATRAC 1 (notice the space between the C and the 1) is really ATRAC1 version
1.0 ATRAC 2 is ATRAC1 version 2.0 and so on.  Then there is ATRAC1 Version R
(which it seems to me could have been called ATRAC1 version 6).

I find this interesting.  There was an ATRAC2 which was never used in any
product!

-

Anyway Sony's MP3 player isn't really an MP3 player at all!  It's an ATRAC3
player.  In order to download MP3 files from your computer to the Clip, you
must first use Sony software and convert them from MP3 to ATRAC3.

My whole point when I first started looking to see if Sony made an MP3
player, was based on a theory of mine that Sony does not encourage MP3 since
it is now in the record business.  Remember this is the same company that
went to court to fight for the individual's right to make home recordings.

I think that somewhere along the line the music industry is going to have to
come to the realization that the internet has changed the rules and some
kind of provisions are going to have to be make for the legal downloading of
copyrighted material.

Larry


-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Recording speeds

2001-06-17 Thread las


Marc Britten wrote:


  IEEE 1394 was designed from the ground up to be a cheap, fast bus for high
  speed data transfer, primarilly disk I/O, with the intention for multimedia
  applications like digital audio and video recorders.


USB and firewire were established around the same time.  It took a long time for
USB to catch on.  I find it over rated.  I hooked my printer up to USB, rather
than using the parallel port thinking I was going to see an increase in
performance.  To me it seems like it takes even longer before the printer starts
printing using USB than it did with the parallel port.

My question is this, does firewire have to be limited to video and audio devices?

Please don't reply if you don't really know but only think you know.

Thanks,
Larry

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



MD: More on the Sony Clip and ATRAC3vs MP3

2001-06-17 Thread las


The follow is a quote from a review of the Sony Clip:

The player holds 60 MB of music at a time, which translates to about 60
minutes at 128 kbps of MP3 music or 80 minutes of
 ATRAC3 music at 105 kbps

Assuming that the difference between 128 and 105 does not produce a
detectable difference in the quality of the sound, it seems that ATRAC3 or
MDLP is actually a more efficient way of storing music files.

All you have to do is have an MD recorder that will, in addition to standard
PCM, accept ATRAC3 like the stick does and Sony could be in the selling
music over the internet business while once again promoting the MD (don't
hold your breath, as I mention below).

I know that for data a standard 74 minute MD holds about 110 MB.  This is
considerably more than the 64 MB of solid state memory that comes with the
Clip.  The memory on the clip is not upgradable.

Sony could use a device that uses their new Stick memory. but the unit
would have to be bigger than the Clip.

But Sony licenses many companies to make blank MDs.  As long as they do not
do this with the stick, they seem to be making a lot more money per unit
selling sticks than they do MDs (so why would Sony even want to encourage
MD?)

One last question for anyone who knows about memory.  Aren't the Stick, Flash
Card and Smart Media all using basically the same memory with a different
size plastic cases and pin configurations?

If my above statement is correct and at most there are only minor changes to
the configuration of the actually memory chip, it would seem to me that Sony
could not be granted a patent for the chip itself only a copyright for the
plastic case.

From my background in Pharmacy I know that in order to try and continue to
hold on to as much of the market share of a drug as possible, many drug
companies copyright a unique design for the capsule or tablet.

While a patent only last 17 years, a copyright is very long.  If you are used
to getting medication that looks a certain way (unfortunately senior citizens
are a large target for this) psychologically many people feel that a pill
that looks different will not be as effective.

In addition drug companies often release their own generic versions of their
drug shortly before the patent runs out.  This offers them several
advantages.  It establishes a buying pattern among wholesalers so that they
buy the generic from the original manufacture.

Second, since the drug company holds the copyright of the design, their
generic can look exactly the same as the original (except that if the
brand name tablet contains the name on it, they leave it off-otherwise they
have not created a generic, but only started to sell their brand name at a
cheaper price.

Drugs are often like blank mini discs.  Sony's ES blanks are no better than
their standard blanks.  Any variation is more in the batch than the type of
blank.  Many times the generic drug is actually made by the same company as
the original or a different but just as large (if not larger) and just as
respected (if not more) company than the original.

Larry





-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Recording speeds

2001-06-17 Thread Stainless Steel Rat


* las [EMAIL PROTECTED]  on Sun, 17 Jun 2001
| My question is this, does firewire have to be limited to video and audio
| devices?

No.  IEEE 1394 (remember, Firewire is an Apple trademark for one
implementation of IEEE 1394) is a low cost, high speed replacement for SCSI
in the small market (home and small business).  Anything that can be done
over SCSI can hypothetically be done over IEEE 1394, as well as some other
clever hacks like TCP/IP over IEEE 1394 (which actually isn't a new idea,
as DEC has been doing that sort of thing for years).

Its utility in the A/V arena is that it is cheap and fast.  Cheap is
obvious.  Fast is that it is more than fast enough to do realtime audio and
video transmission at full bandwidth for editing and such.
-- 
Rat [EMAIL PROTECTED]\ Caution: Happy Fun Ball may suddenly
Minion of Nathan - Nathan says Hi! \ accelerate to dangerous speeds.
PGP Key: at a key server near you!  \ 
-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



MD: Sony MZ-R700DPC

2001-06-17 Thread David Fincher


I dropped by Target today and picked up the 700, as someone on this list 
had earlier promised it would be there.  They had the 500 advertised at 
$149 and the 700 at $199.  It rang up for $249, but the display said $199, 
so I challenged them to look at it and they corrected it.  What was even 
cooler is that you can get a Target card and take an additional 10% off of 
your purchase.  So if you want to buy one (or more) and get one of their 
cards, the cost comes out to $180 plus tax.

I must say that I am very impressed with the quality of the unit, and 
surprised with how much the salesman knew about the unit.  He was able to 
explain to me the difference between the 700 and 500 (which I already 
knew), and seemed genuinely excited about the products.  Maybe it was a 
fluke, but I think he could convince a questioning customer to choose MD 
over MP3.  The only thing I didn't like about it was that they only had the 
green one in stock (and my kids argued over whether it's green or 
yellow).  One more cute thing:  My two year old heard me talking about it 
to my wife, and she saw it and said, I like your mickeydix player, 
Daddy.  So there you go, score one for youth appeal.  Now I just need some 
Hello Kitty md's for her to see.

Anyway, I have just a couple of questions about the unit for those of you 
who have one.

1.  It comes with the Sony Ni-Cad battery.  I have been using NiMh AA cells 
in my other Sony equipment (R-30 and EP-11), but not charging them within 
the units.  I'm curious if it would be okay to charge an NiMh within the 
700.  My charger puts out 1.5V at 50-80 Ma, and is rated OK for Ni-cad or 
NiMh.  I don't want to take a risk, but I'd rather use the NiMh cells and 
save the Sony one in case I resell this later.

2.  The book specifically says do not use other Sony remotes from other MD 
units.  Specifically, p. 20 says, To prevent recorder malfunction, do not 
use a remote control that was supplied with another Sony portable MD 
model.  I have a lipstick remote (MZ-R35) from the EP-11 that has LCD 
readout which I would like to use.  However, I'm not interested in causing 
a recorder malfunction.  I'm not encouraging anyone on the list to damage 
their unit, but I thought some of you may have tried this by now.

Thanks for your help.

David Fincher
-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



MD: Record Level Control for Minidisc from Sound Professionals

2001-06-17 Thread Peter Brown


 === The original message was multipart MIME===
 === All non-text parts (attachments) have been removed ===

recorders, camcorders and other recorders that can't adjust recording =
levels on=20
the fly (while recording). BR- Utilizes high quality Alps slider=20
controls./FONT/DIV
DIVFONT size=3D2/FONTnbsp;/DIV
DIVFONT size=3D2Peter/FONT/FONT/DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2/FONTnbsp;/DIV/BODY/HTML

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



MD: Record Level Control for Minidisc from Sound Professionals

2001-06-17 Thread Peter Brown


 === The original message was multipart MIME===
 === All non-text parts (attachments) have been removed ===

recorders, camcorders and other recorders that can't adjust recording =
levels on=20
the fly (while recording). BR- Utilizes high quality Alps slider=20
controls./FONT/DIV
DIVFONT size=3D2/FONTnbsp;/DIV
DIVFONT size=3D2Peter/FONT/FONT/DIV
DIVFONT face=3DArial size=3D2/FONTnbsp;/DIV/BODY/HTML

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Recording speeds

2001-06-17 Thread Marc Britten



  ===
  = NB: Over 50% of this message is QUOTED, please  =
  = be more selective when quoting text =
  ===

i'm just replying to the USB bit.

the main advantage i believe USB to have over older connection models is supplied 
power, no more ugly wall warts for the Printer/scanner/etc

On Sun, Jun 17, 2001 at 07:22:11PM -0400, las wrote:
 
 Marc Britten wrote:
 
 
 USB and firewire were established around the same time.  It took a long time for
 USB to catch on.  I find it over rated.  I hooked my printer up to USB, rather
 than using the parallel port thinking I was going to see an increase in
 performance.  To me it seems like it takes even longer before the printer starts
 printing using USB than it did with the parallel port.
-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: More on the Sony Clip and ATRAC3vs MP3

2001-06-17 Thread Marc Britten


the answer to your question is yes.

a quote from an article from www.asiaweek.com(with an interesting looking mp3 player 
on it)
http://www.asiaweek.com/asiaweek/technology/2000/0428/cover3.html


The secret of the success of the floppy (and the CD and video cassette as well) was 
universality. But the market for flash memory cards is fragmented between several 
competing formats. Sony's purple, chewing gum-sized Memory Stick is perhaps the best 
known to consumers, but Panasonic and Toshiba are trying to rally the industry around 
their competing SD (Secure Digital) card. Other formats include the wafer-thin 
SmartMedia cards used in MP3 players and Olympus and FujiFilm's digital cameras, and 
the thicker, matchbook-sized CompactFlash cards favored by Kodak, Nikon and Canon. All 
four are mutually incompatible, so it's no good trying to jam the card from your Nikon 
camera into Sony's Cyberframe.



On Sun, Jun 17, 2001 at 08:03:04PM -0400, las wrote:
 
 the configuration of the actually memory chip, it would seem to me that Sony
 could not be granted a patent for the chip itself only a copyright for the
 plastic case.
 
-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Sony MZ-R700DPC

2001-06-17 Thread Richard Rudie


David Fincher wrote:
 I have a lipstick remote (MZ-R35) from the EP-11 that has LCD
readout
 which I would like to use.  However, I'm not interested in causing a
 recorder malfunction.  I'm not encouraging anyone on the list to
 damage their unit, but I thought some of you may have tried this by
now.

I tried the remote from a friend's MZ-R50 with my R700. It controlled
the unit fine (play, pause, skip, etc.), but the LCD display was
completely inactive. I was surprised; the MZ-G750 has its LCD-and-radio
remote, and I had expected that the R700 and G750 were basically
interchangable except for the remote and the AM/FM scribed on the
G750's case.


   2
 [)  [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 |\  http://rsquared.firest0rm.org/

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



RE: MD: md-l-mimedigest V3 #50

2001-06-17 Thread Adam Terri Noto


-Original Message-
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]
Sent: Sunday, June 17, 2001 6:42 PM
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: md-l-mimedigest V3 #50



-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



RE: MD: Marking tracks on MZ-R900

2001-06-17 Thread Mike Lastucka


  I'm trying to add track marks to a recording on my MZ-R900, and
  would like
  to know how to do it accurately.  Currently I press pause when it gets 
to
  the right spot, then tarck-mark.  Is there a better way?
 
  Beyond setting automatic marking (every five minutes, or at any 2 sec
  pause), you're doing them the best way that *I* know how.
 

Are you guys saying that the R900 (which seems to be top of the line right
now) doesn't have a simple track mark button?  Good god.

Read his first post. :)  In other words, yes, there is a track mark button.  
Why the hell would you think they wouldn't have a track mark button?  *takes 
away your crack pipe*.


---
Mike Lastucka, B. Tech
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://sites.netscape.net/element5/
2048 bit DH 0x16DC15CD

_
Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



RE: MD: Marking tracks on MZ-R900

2001-06-17 Thread Mike Lastucka


Wasn't the point that the R900 would be expected to be capable of 
completing
a track-mark operation by only pressing ONE button (whatever it may be
called)?

Pause + Track-Mark = 2 buttons.

Actually you can do either; press it once to create your track mark, or hit 
pause and hit the track mark for peace of mind that you're making the mark 
RIGHT where you want it to be.


---
Mike Lastucka, B. Tech
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://sites.netscape.net/element5/
2048 bit DH 0x16DC15CD

_
Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



RE: MD: md-l-digest V3 #50

2001-06-17 Thread Howard Chu


re: USB and power: USB only supplies 5V @ 500mA max per device. Fine for
keyboards and mice, but nowhere near enough to run a printer or scanner, so
forget that issue.
Firewire also has dedicated power lines, but there's no practical use for
them either. Sony dropped those two lines on their i.Link because they knew
that most devices will need to be self-powered in order to be useful.

Someone quoted USB max throughput 11Mbps vs Firewire 400Mbps. That should be
12 for USB; you might as well compare rated spec to rated spec even if
actual observed
throughput is less in both cases.

Both USB and Firewire talk to storage devices (discs, etc.) using serially
encapsulated SCSI commands.

Aside from speed limitations, the USB design is inferior to Firewire because
it is all master-slave oriented; it requires a host CPU to initiate all
transactions on the bus. (Moreover, it is an Intel-originated spec, and
everything they produce is designed purely to make you buy more Intel
CPUs...) You can only get the full rated USB speed if your CPU is idle
enough to poll all the attached USB devices on a consistent schedule.
Essentially, your host computer must operate in realtime. In practice, the
primary Intel OSes (i.e., Windows!) are completely incapable of realtime
operation. Using USB to transfer realtime audio or video on a Windows PC
inevitably results in dropouts and glitches.

On the other hand, Firewire is a peer-to-peer design, and peripherals don't
have to wait for some master to poll them before they're allowed to send
or receive data. As such, Firewire systems tend to run perfectly glitch-free
no matter what any attached PCs are doing. Even with USB 2.0's 480Mbps bus
bandwidth, 400Mbps Firewire will still deliver superior performance.

re: MD-Data drives vs MD-Audio: MD-Data drives can play audio discs, no
problem. They have always been able to do so, whoever told you otherwise was
wrong. They just can't read the discs in raw digital form and give you the
data as a file. (yet...)

re: data transfer rates... 44.1khz 16bit stereo requires 1.44Mbps bandwidth,
well within the capability of USB. Yet today's applications seldom get a
clean transfer because of USB's dependence on the host CPU which I mentioned
above.

In a Linux system you may be able to overcome some of the timing problems,
but overall it's better to reserve USB for keyboards, mice, and other
low-intensity uses and use Firewire when performance and latency really
count.

Raw capacity of a standard 74-minute MD is about 150MB. It's not the most
convenient thing in the world, but you can of course convert your music to
ATRAC3 format and store it on MD-Data discs. You need to keep a computer
handy for playback...

  -- Howard Chu
  Chief Architect, Symas Corp.   Director, Highland Sun
  http://www.symas.com   http://highlandsun.com/hyc


-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



MD: MD and Cassette Walkmans.

2001-06-17 Thread Churchill, Guy


When was the last time someone on this m-list purchased
a Cassette walkman ?   Are they still very popular ?
They are still on the shelves but I don't know anyone
who has bought one in the last 3 years.  Perhaps
parents still buy them for their kids? shrug

I bought one in 1990 (the smallest Panasonic available
at the time ... cost $400 AUD) .. it lasted 3 years 
and after 5-6 trips to the repair agent they declared
the motor was cactus and not available as a spare part.
Bummer

The next thing I bought was a MZR-3 .. cost $1200 AUD
One trip to the repair agent in year 2000 ($150), and 
it still works.

Never looked at a tape walkman again.

L8R  GC



-Original Message-
From: Neil [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]

But that may also be it's downfall, too. Cassette walkmans came down in
price, once higher-end portable audio became available.

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Re: Recording speeds

2001-06-17 Thread Eric Woudenberg, Minidisc.org Editor


Marc Britten [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

 
 it probably can, but Firewire has all of the stuff in place. but
 then again so do USB CD-R's
 
 its probably a bit different going to solid state MP3 players since
 all your doing is dumping a file, here you would need to turn the
 mp3 audio into a viable digital source(like the PCLink or Xitel
 stuff does through sound card type api's) then the digital source
 goes into the MD player which converts it to ATRAC and writes it to
 disc.

Sorry, I was assuming (as with the Sony MDS-LSA1), that it was to be
ATRAC data flowing over the link. In this case, existing USB drivers
and components that transport 44.1khz 16bit PCM data would do equally
well transporting ATRAC1 at up to 4.8x realtime and ATRAC3 at up to
~20x realtime -- probably limited by MD drive write speed in any case.
(This means that a 5 minute LP4 song download could be done in some 15
seconds!).

So -- I like firewire too, but how does it do as a keyboard and mouse
interface?

Rick

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



MD: MiniDisc Weekly News for 17 June 2001

2001-06-17 Thread MiniDisc Community Pages Weekly News


MiniDisc Community Pages News for 11 June 2001

 o  Xitel provides info on their [1]MD-Port DG2 and Mike Paulus finds 
   [2]Macintosh user reports of experiences with the device under MacOS 
   X.

  [1] http://www.xitel.com/products_dg2.htm
  [2] http://www.xlr8yourmac.com/audio/xitel_dg2_usb_digital.html


 o Tim Yocum completes a [3]review of the Aiwa AM-HX55 MD portable MD 
   player. 

  [3] http://www.yocum.org/minidisc/hx-55


MiniDisc Community Pages News for 12 June 2001

 o  Michael Lane spots an interesting [1] USA Today article on 
   Minidisc's comeback. 

  [1] http://www.usatoday.com/life/cyber/tech/review/2001-06-11-minidisc.htm


 o Robert Mindenhall sends in an MD footnote: The Toronto Star mentions 
   Minidisc in its annual Achievement Awards ``Best audio recording 
   technology: MiniDisc, due to its editing capabilities and 
   portability.'' (See the [2]entire article [2MB PDF]).

  [2] http://www.minidisc.org/torontostar.pdf


 o John Rolt finds the handsomely styled [3]Sanyo MDC 3300 boombox, 
   available from Dixon's (UK) for 180. The unit has a builtin 
   microphone and appears to be the same as the [4]Sanyo PH-MD9 sold in 
   Japan.

  [3] http://194.125.145.43/uk/product.asp?id=359
  [4] http://www.minidisc.org/part_Sanyo_PH-MD9.html


 o Luis Dodero notes several [5]Minidisc product reviews at Ciao.com

  [5] http://www.uk.ciao.com/ciao.php?Pid=1,2,23,533


 o The MD Portal (Singapore) gets a new domain name and server: 
   [6]MDPortal.net. 

  [6] http://www.mdportal.net


MiniDisc Community Pages News for 13 June 2001

 o  Superfi (UK) hosts a ton of high-res MD gear photos: Denon 
   [1]DMD-M1000 [2]DMD-6.5 [3]DMD-F100 [4]DMD-M30, Sony [5]MDS-JA333ES 
   [6]MDS-JA555ES [7]MDS-JB940QS [8]MDS-JE330 [9]MZ-E300 [10]MZ-E500 
   [11]MZ-E900 [12]MZ-G750 [13]MZ-R500 [14]MZ-R700 [15]MZ-R900, and 
   Yamaha [16]MDX596 

  [1] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=305
  [2] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=514
  [3] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=515
  [4] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=592
  [5] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=720
  [6] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=721
  [7] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=370
  [8] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=438
  [9] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=557
  [10] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=558
  [11] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=499
  [12] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=556
  [13] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=500
  [14] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=456
  [15] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=427
  [16] http://www.superfi.co.uk/moreinfo.cfm?Product_ID=723


MiniDisc Community Pages News for 14 June 2001

 o  Stand Back! Mike Paulus finds Archos' updated [1]Jukebox HD-MP3 
   Recorder  Player with S/PDIF and line in, real-time 160kbps MP3 
   encoding, USB I/O for drag and drop track handling, and 6GB capacity 
   (there's a [2]20 gig version in the works). The 350gram, US$350 unit 
   will play 10 hours on a full charge and is slated for June 21 
   shipment.

  [1] http://www.archos.com/products/product_500201.html
  [2] http://www.archos.com/products/product_550005.html


 o Gustavo Gallina points us toward the [3]Alpine MDM-7741 in-dash MD 
   receiver.

  [3] 
http://ecominet2.alpine-usa.com:/pls/admn/item_info1a?p_item_name=MDM-7741p_category=10p_subcategory=40p_main=10p_more=y


MiniDisc Community Pages News for 15 June 2001

 o  Panasonic Party T-Station finds a small photo and brief info on 
   [1]Panasonic's SR-MJ220 MDLP recorder. Panasonic's [2]Japanese MD 
   page sports photos and info for their non-MDLP [3]MDX50 and [4]MDX70 
   boomboxes (both Japanese FM band only), the latter (an 
   AM/FM/CD/MD/Cassette unit), running on AC as well as D-cells 
   (battery life: 4hr (MD playback), 3.5hr (CD-MD recording), 5.5hr 
   (Radio-MD recording)(?)) 

  [1] http://www.hat-in.com/japanese/j-syo-sj-mr220.htm
  [2] http://www.panasonic.co.jp/avc/audio/web/index.html
  [3] http://www.panasonic.co.jp/avc/audio/web/pick_up/mdx50/mdx50.html
  [4] http://www.panasonic.co.jp/avc/audio/web/pick_up/mdx70/mdx70.html


MiniDisc Community Pages News for 16 June 2001

 o George Styles releases [1]RIP MDS-PC3 (v0.2b), a free alternative to 
   Sony's M-Crew software that offers improved MP3 file handling.

  [1] 
http://www.ripnet.co.uk/pagetemplate.php?pagecontent=freeware.phpprogdir=ripmdspc3


 o James Brooks points out Kenwood USA's [2]KMD-D400 in-dash 3MD 
   changer; it can be coupled with any Kenwood head unit that has 
   changer control.

  [2] http://www.kenwoodusa.com/product/product.jsp?productType=35productId=438


MiniDisc Community Pages 

Re: MD: Sony doesn't seem to have a portable MP3 player

2001-06-17 Thread Dave Kimmel


 Before this post I did a little research to see if I could find a Sony MP3
 player similar to a Rio.  From my research, I have found that Sony doesn't
 seem to make an actual MP3 player.

This is true, to the extent that they don't make an MP3 walkman-style
device.  However, they do make an MP3 player.  The Sony CDX-MP450X is a
car AM/FM/CD/MP3 player.  It plays MP3 files that are burned onto a CD-R
or CD-RW, along with audio CDs and the radio.  Unlike the music clip, it
requires no special software apart from a CD burning program and something
to make/get MP3s with.

 My whole point when I first started looking to see if Sony made an MP3
 player, was based on a theory of mine that Sony does not encourage MP3 since
 it is now in the record business.  Remember this is the same company that
 went to court to fight for the individual's right to make home recordings.

I'm not sure how the existance of this car deck affects your theory.
Since they have the technology and the willingness to build a _mobile_ MP3
player, I have to wonder why they aren't building a _portable_ MP3 player.

-- Dave Kimmel
   [EMAIL PROTECTED]
   ICQ: 5615049

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: MD and Cassette Walkmans.

2001-06-17 Thread Shawn Lin


Churchill, Guy wrote:
 
 When was the last time someone on this m-list purchased
 a Cassette walkman ?   Are they still very popular ?

More popular than I'd like.  I notice many minisystems and boomboxes
still have that archaic medium.

 They are still on the shelves but I don't know anyone
 who has bought one in the last 3 years.  Perhaps
 parents still buy them for their kids? shrug

Me neither.

[snip]
 Never looked at a tape walkman again.

I haven't looked at anything that plays cassettes again.
I have loaned out, sold, donated, and given away all my cassette
equipment.
MD HAS replaced cassette in all my audio systems.  I don't have cassette
in my car, I don't have it in my house, I don't have it at all. :) 
However, I can play MD (and CD) everywhere I go.

However, what I feel is much more archaic than cassette is VHS.  I
absolutely can't stand VHS' size, bulk, and inconvenience.  Not to
mention the physical complexity which leads to reliability problems (I
think most people have experienced a VCR chewing up a tape at least
once).  After using DVD, it makes one wonder how VHS survived so long. 
I wish DVD were a recordable+rewriteable media from the beginning
though, like MD is.  I don't know what DVD-R or DVD-RW is going to be
like since I can't afford it, but I feel as though it could end up being
a hack like CD-R/RW is.

Shawn
-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: MD and Cassette Walkmans.

2001-06-17 Thread las


Shawn Lin wrote:



 However, what I feel is much more archaic than cassette is VHS.  I
 absolutely can't stand VHS' size, bulk, and inconvenience.  Not to
 mention the physical complexity which leads to reliability problems (I
 think most people have experienced a VCR chewing up a tape at least
 once).  After using DVD, it makes one wonder how VHS survived so long.
 I wish DVD were a recordable+rewriteable media from the beginning
 though, like MD is.  I don't know what DVD-R or DVD-RW is going to be
 like since I can't afford it, but I feel as though it could end up being
 a hack like CD-R/RW is.

 Shawn

Shawn,
Until someone comes out with a reasonably priced DVD recorder, that will
allow you to make DVDs of your favorite TV shows, etc. and sell the blanks
for just a few dollars, we still need VHS.  This TiVo and Ultimate TV are a
joke because you fill up the space and that's the end of it.

So if you really think about it, we still need VHS far more than we need
cassettes.  Also, unlike VHS recorders, DVD players do not have RF outputs.
You'd be surprised how many people there are who still have TV sets that do
not have video and audio inputs.

I was in a Wal Mart one day and spoke to a woman who had just gotten a DVD
player.  Except she had no way to use it with her RF in only TV.  She was
told that she was going to have to buy an expensive converter.  She had left
by the time that it occurred to me that all she needed was to plug her DVD
player into her video recorder.  When she pressed play on the DVD player
with the recorder set to line in, the output would go through the VCRs RF
output.

Shawn you have to realize that you are light years ahead of the average
person when it comes to this kind of stuff.  Once they started making TVs
that could often last over 20 years and at the same time keep talking about
digital TV signals being forced on us, people don't what to replace their
old TV that is still working OK.

A few years ago I went to visit my father in law.  He was all concerned
about digital TVs being forced on him.  He was worried that his TVs would
either be no good or he would have to buy expensive converters.  This was a
man who was about 80 years old at the time.

Well, sadly we lost my father in law last December, but we still don't have
digital TV signals forced on us.  They have been talking about HDTV in the
US for about 20 years.

A TV from 1950 with a cable converter attached could play every channel your
cable company provides (alas, it would be a black and white picture).  It
takes America 30 years to agree on a standard, so once America gets a
standard that catches on, unlike the Japanese, they are slow to change.

You still see as many if not more models of cassette car units than CDs.
And even a mini unit like Sharp's MD-C2 which has a 3 CD and 3 MD changer
still has a cassette deck in it.  The money would have been better spent
putting in a more powerful amp or a little better quality speakers.

But you are starting to see less and less phono inputs on these units (there
is none on the MD-C2).  Interestingly higher end receivers ($600 to $900 and
up) still have phono inputs.  I guess their thinking is that so called
audiophiles are going to purchase these units and may still have an
expensive turntable and their vinyl collection??

Larry

-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: Re: Recording speeds

2001-06-17 Thread las



  ===
  = NB: Over 50% of this message is QUOTED, please  =
  = be more selective when quoting text =
  ===

Eric Woudenberg, Minidisc.org Editor wrote:

 Marc Britten [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

 
  it probably can, but Firewire has all of the stuff in place. but
  then again so do USB CD-R's
 
  its probably a bit different going to solid state MP3 players since
  all your doing is dumping a file, here you would need to turn the
  mp3 audio into a viable digital source(like the PCLink or Xitel
  stuff does through sound card type api's) then the digital source
  goes into the MD player which converts it to ATRAC and writes it to
  disc.

 Sorry, I was assuming (as with the Sony MDS-LSA1), that it was to be
 ATRAC data flowing over the link. In this case, existing USB drivers
 and components that transport 44.1khz 16bit PCM data would do equally
 well transporting ATRAC1 at up to 4.8x realtime and ATRAC3 at up to
 ~20x realtime -- probably limited by MD drive write speed in any case.
 (This means that a 5 minute LP4 song download could be done in some 15
 seconds!).

Just what is the audio signal that the USB port puts out?  Or is it
hardware dependent?  I had a digital Xitel that I returned because it
could not constantly stream.  But it seemed to me that if it did work any
audio that I played on my computer, regardless of the format would be
converted to optical PCM.



-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



RE: MD: MD and Cassette Walkmans.

2001-06-17 Thread Churchill, Guy


-Original Message-
From: las [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]

 I was in a Wal Mart one day and spoke to a woman who had just gotten a DVD
 player.  Except she had no way to use it with her RF in only TV.  She was
 told that she was going to have to buy an expensive converter.  She had
left
 by the time that it occurred to me that all she needed was to plug her DVD
 player into her video recorder.  When she pressed play on the DVD player
 with the recorder set to line in, the output would go through the VCRs RF
 output.

Except I believe Macrovision should kick in and mess the picture up 
(light and dark fades).  Or is this only present on composite video
inputs?


L8R  GC






-
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
unsubscribe to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: MD: MD and Cassette Walkmans.

2001-06-17 Thread Shawn Lin


las wrote:
 
 Shawn Lin wrote:
 
  However, what I feel is much more archaic than cassette is VHS.  I
  absolutely can't stand VHS' size, bulk, and inconvenience.  Not to
  mention the physical complexity which leads to reliability problems (I
  think most people have experienced a VCR chewing up a tape at least
  once).  After using DVD, it makes one wonder how VHS survived so long.
  I wish DVD were a recordable+rewriteable media from the beginning
  though, like MD is.  I don't know what DVD-R or DVD-RW is going to be
  like since I can't afford it, but I feel as though it could end up being
  a hack like CD-R/RW is.
 
  Shawn
 
 Shawn,
 Until someone comes out with a reasonably priced DVD recorder, that will
 allow you to make DVDs of your favorite TV shows, etc. and sell the blanks
 for just a few dollars, we still need VHS.  This TiVo and Ultimate TV are a
 joke because you fill up the space and that's the end of it.
 
 So if you really think about it, we still need VHS far more than we need
 cassettes.  Also, unlike VHS recorders, DVD players do not have RF outputs.
 You'd be surprised how many people there are who still have TV sets that do
 not have video and audio inputs.

Oh yeah, I definitely know this.  I was more wishing aloud that DVD was
originally a rewriteable media from the very beginning.  I'll bet if
that were the case, we'd have inexpensive DVD recorders by now.  I'm
pretty sure once they got a tuner into a DVD recorder, they'd throw in
the RF output.  Right now I still have to use VHS to record TV shows and
such, but the format is just so inconvenient, I can't help but wonder
why DVD-Video wasn't rewriteable in the very beginning.  It would have
completely replaced the VCR.

 I was in a Wal Mart one day and spoke to a woman who had just gotten a DVD
 player.  Except she had no way to use it with her RF in only TV.  She was
 told that she was going to have to buy an expensive converter.  She had left
 by the time that it occurred to me that all she needed was to plug her DVD
 player into her video recorder.  When she pressed play on the DVD player
 with the recorder set to line in, the output would go through the VCRs RF
 output.

This won't work with most VCR's due to Macrovision.  This is analog copy
protection that hides in the blanking signal, most TV's are immune to
it.  However, it causes a constant light/dark transition of the picture,
geometry distortion, and color distortion through most VCR's. 
Basically, it makes the movie unwatchable.  Macrovision was designed to
prevent copying of commercial videos (VHS and DVD) to an analog VCR. 
Since Macrovision is generated by the Video DAC in the DVD player, there
are hacks out there for many DVD players.  In fact, that's why Apex DVD
players are so popular... they're built around a computer DVD-ROM drive
so they're relatively easy to hack.

 Shawn you have to realize that you are light years ahead of the average
 person when it comes to this kind of stuff.  Once they started making TVs
 that could often last over 20 years and at the same time keep talking about
 digital TV signals being forced on us, people don't what to replace their
 old TV that is still working OK.

Heheh, don't be so sure, I'm using antique TV's!  My Sony KV-25XBR is
about 18-years old, although it looks a lot younger than it is, and my
27 Sony is an old silver one with fake woodgrain sides from the 80's,
probably 15-years old.  I've also got an old 19 Sony probably 20 years
old or so, back before OSD's (this one's got an LED readout).  They'll
have to do until I can afford to replace them all with Vega's.  I would
certainly LOVE to be light years ahead of the average person though.  I
feel the same way about these new flat panel displays I've been seeing. 
I wouldn't mind one bit if CRT's were totally replaced by inexpensive
flat panel displays in the future.  I can't wait till flat panel screens
are affordable and then I can replace all my bulky CRT's.  The bulk and
weight of a CRT TV or monitor is something I'm definitely not going to
miss.

 A few years ago I went to visit my father in law.  He was all concerned
 about digital TVs being forced on him.  He was worried that his TVs would
 either be no good or he would have to buy expensive converters.  This was a
 man who was about 80 years old at the time.

My only concern would be, how the heck am I gonna get rid of my old
TV?  It weighs 150 lbs and I can't exactly sell it on Ebay.  Maybe by
then I'll get lucky and my TV's will be worth something on the Antiques
Road Show.

 A TV from 1950 with a cable converter attached could play every channel your
 cable company provides (alas, it would be a black and white picture).  It
 takes America 30 years to agree on a standard, so once America gets a
 standard that catches on, unlike the Japanese, they are slow to change.

Yes, that's true.  Crazy to think one of those old 1950's TVs with the
huge wooden cabinet, rattan speaker grille, and small, virtually