Re: If T-Test can not be applied

2002-02-22 Thread EugeneGall
1 of a stream: 16.9 17 15.8 17.1 18.7 18 mean = 17.25 variance = 0.995 Portion 2 18.3 18.5 mean = 18.4 variance = 0.02 The SPSS unequal variance t-test gives a 2-tailed P of 0.037, but the equal variance t produces a two-tailed P of 0.174 An exact test is possible with these data, as there are o

Re: How to test whether f(X,Y)=f(X)f(Y) is true??

2002-02-21 Thread Rich Ulrich
of the > varriable does dependent on the other variable in some kind of pattern, is > just that there are not lineraly dependent, hence the almost zero > correlation coeffiicent. So, I am just wonder whether any kind of tests that > I could use to test dependency between 2 varaib

Re: How to test whether f(X,Y)=f(X)f(Y) is true??

2002-02-21 Thread Vadim and Oxana Marmer
There is a test based on nonparametric density estimates. You can estimate joint and marginal densities by nonparametric methods and then test if f(x,y)=f(x)f(y). You can find some details and references in Pagan & Ullah "Nonparametric Econometrics". On Wed, 20 Feb 2002, Chia

Re: How to test whether f(X,Y)=f(X)f(Y) is true??

2002-02-20 Thread Chia C Chong
> > > If you find that they are uncorrelated and you have a reason to believe > > > that they may be not independent anyway then you can look for more > > > advanced tests. > > > > Can you give some examples of more advanced tests that can be used to test > &

Re: How to test whether f(X,Y)=f(X)f(Y) is true??

2002-02-20 Thread Glen Barnett
Linda <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]... > Hi! > > I have some experimental data collected and can be grouped into 2 > variables, X and Y. One is the dependent variable (Y) and the other is > an independent variable (

Re: How to test whether f(X,Y)=f(X)f(Y) is true??

2002-02-20 Thread Rich Ulrich
t; advanced tests. > > Can you give some examples of more advanced tests that can be used to test > the depedency of data when there these data are uncorrelated?? You can check for an obvious non-linear (say quadratic) fit. WHAT is your 'reason to believe that they may be not indepe

Re: How to test whether f(X,Y)=f(X)f(Y) is true??

2002-02-20 Thread Chia C Chong
question. > If you find that they are uncorrelated and you have a reason to believe > that they may be not independent anyway then you can look for more > advanced tests. Can you give some examples of more advanced tests that can be used to test the depedency of data when there these data a

Re: How to test whether f(X,Y)=f(X)f(Y) is true??

2002-02-20 Thread Vadim and Oxana Marmer
more advanced tests. On 20 Feb 2002, Linda wrote: > Hi! > > I have some experimental data collected and can be grouped into 2 > variables, X and Y. One is the dependent variable (Y) and the other is > an independent variable (X). What test shall I made to check whether > there can be e

How to test whether f(X,Y)=f(X)f(Y) is true??

2002-02-20 Thread Linda
Hi! I have some experimental data collected and can be grouped into 2 variables, X and Y. One is the dependent variable (Y) and the other is an independent variable (X). What test shall I made to check whether there can be expressed as independent or not?? Thanks.. Linda

Re: If T-Test can not be applied

2002-02-16 Thread Herman Rubin
are significantly different from each other or not. One of the >two underlying assumption to calculate the T-Test is not given (Variances >are assumed to be NOT equally distributed; but data is normally >distributed). What kind of (non?)parametric-test does exist - instead of the >T-Test

Re: If T-Test can not be applied

2002-02-15 Thread Rich Ulrich
a > whether they are significantly different from each other or not. One of the > two underlying assumption to calculate the T-Test is not given (Variances > are assumed to be NOT equally distributed; but data is normally > distributed). What kind of (non?)parametric-test does exist - i

Re: If T-Test can not be applied

2002-02-15 Thread Art Kendall
rical sets of data > whether they are significantly different from each other or not. One of the > two underlying assumption to calculate the T-Test is not given (Variances > are assumed to be NOT equally distributed; but data is normally > distributed). What kind of (non?)parametric-test d

Re: If T-Test can not be applied

2002-02-15 Thread William B. Ware
Excuse the bad grammar or typo noted below... It's been a "long morning" already, and it's still not 9 am... :) Bill On Fri, 15 Feb 2002, William B. Ware wrote: > What are your samples sizes? If there are equal or nearly so, the t-test

Re: If T-Test can not be applied

2002-02-15 Thread William B. Ware
What are your samples sizes? If there are equal or nearly so, the t-test is robust with regard to unequal variances. On the other hand, you could just read the part of the output that reports results for "equal variances not assumed." You might also consider using a nonparametric

Re: If T-Test can not be applied

2002-02-14 Thread JJ Diamond
umerical sets of data > whether they are significantly different from each other or not. One of the > two underlying assumption to calculate the T-Test is not given (Variances > are assumed to be NOT equally distributed; but data is normally > distributed). What kind of (non?)parametric-test

Re: If T-Test can not be applied

2002-02-14 Thread Dennis Roberts
data >whether they are significantly different from each other or not. One of the >two underlying assumption to calculate the T-Test is not given (Variances >are assumed to be NOT equally distributed; but data is normally >distributed). What kind of (non?)parametric-test does exist - in

If T-Test can not be applied

2002-02-14 Thread Matthias
Hello, would be nice if someone can give me some advice with regard to the following problem: I would like to compare the means of two independent numerical sets of data whether they are significantly different from each other or not. One of the two underlying assumption to calculate the T-Test

Re: F-test

2002-02-14 Thread Dennis Roberts
can you bit a bit more specific here? f tests AND t tests are used for a variety of things give us some context and perhaps we can help at a minimum of course, one is calling for using a test that involves looking at the F distribution for critical values ... the other calls for using a t

F-test

2002-02-14 Thread Jan
The question is how do I see the difference when it's asked for an f-test or a t-test? Jan = Instructions for joining and leaving this list, remarks about the problem of INAPPROPRIATE MESSAGES, and archives are availab

Re: test differences between proportions

2002-02-13 Thread Glen Barnett
Rich Ulrich wrote: > > On Mon, 11 Feb 2002 13:56:46 +0100, "nikolov" > <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > hello, > > > > i want to test the difference between two proportions. The problem is that > > some elements of these proportions are de

Re: Ansari-Bradley dispersion test.

2002-02-13 Thread kjetil halvorsen
Hola! For a more robust test, which not assumes equal centers, use the fligner-Killeen test. Kjetil Halvorsen Glen Barnett wrote: > > Rich Ulrich <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message > [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]... > > On Sat, 09 Feb 2002 16:5

Re: test differences between proportions

2002-02-11 Thread David Duffy
nikolov <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > i want to test the difference between two proportions. The problem is that > some elements of these proportions are dependent (i can not isolate them). > That is, the t-statistics does not work. How could i do? Do other kind of > tests exis

test differences between proportions

2002-02-11 Thread nikolov
hello, i want to test the difference between two proportions. The problem is that some elements of these proportions are dependent (i can not isolate them). That is, the t-statistics does not work. How could i do? Do other kind of tests exist? Is there a book or a paper on the subject? Thank

Re: Ansari-Bradley dispersion test.

2002-02-10 Thread Glen Barnett
Rich Ulrich <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]... > On Sat, 09 Feb 2002 16:59:34 GMT, Johannes Fichtinger > <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Dear NG! > > I have been searching for a description of the Ans

Re: Ansari-Bradley dispersion test.

2002-02-10 Thread Rich Ulrich
On Sat, 09 Feb 2002 16:59:34 GMT, Johannes Fichtinger <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Dear NG! > I have been searching for a description of the Ansari-Bradley dispersion test up to >now for > analysing a psychological research. I am searching for a description of this t

Ansari-Bradley dispersion test.

2002-02-09 Thread Johannes Fichtinger
Dear NG! I have been searching for a description of the Ansari-Bradley dispersion test up to now for analysing a psychological research. I am searching for a description of this test, specially a description how to use the test. Please, can you tell me, how to use the test, or show me a link

Re: How to test f(X , Y)=f(X)f(Y)

2002-01-30 Thread Bruno Monastero
"Linda" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]... > I have 1000 observations of 2 RVs from an experiments. X is the > independent variable and Y is the dependent variable. How do I perform > the test whether the following s

Re: How to test f(X , Y)=f(X)f(Y)

2002-01-28 Thread Glen Barnett
Linda <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]... > I have 1000 observations of 2 RVs from an experiments. X is the > independent variable and Y is the dependent variable. How do I perform > the test whether the following statement is

Re: How to test f(X , Y)=f(X)f(Y)

2002-01-28 Thread JJ Diamond
likelihoods. so the chisquare test of independence or even a linear correlation ala pearson come to mind. does this help? [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Linda) wrote in message news:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>... > I have 1000 observations of 2 RVs from an experiments. X is the > independent variable

How to test f(X , Y)=f(X)f(Y)

2002-01-28 Thread Linda
I have 1000 observations of 2 RVs from an experiments. X is the independent variable and Y is the dependent variable. How do I perform the test whether the following statement is true or not?? f(X,Y)=f(X)f(Y) Linda

Re: Non Parametric Unit Root Test

2002-01-24 Thread Vadim and Oxana Marmer
eatment is in Tanaka "Time Series Analysis". On 22 Jan 2002, Maand M wrote: > Hi: > > I would like to know where can I read more about Non > Parametric Unit Root Test for uniform distribution. > Any book or paper on it? &g

Re: Unique Root Test - Statistics

2002-01-22 Thread Glen Barnett
Shakti Sankhla <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]... > Hi All: > > This is basically not a SAS problem but I believe that many of the list > members could help. > > I am looking for information on Statistical topic call

Unique Root Test - Statistics

2002-01-22 Thread Shakti Sankhla
Hi All: This is basically not a SAS problem but I believe that many of the list members could help. I am looking for information on Statistical topic called Unique Root Test. Any help will be welcomed. Thanks Shakti -- Posted via Mailgate.ORG Server - http://www.Mailgate.ORG

Re: test

2002-01-19 Thread janne
What is it you wonder about? pingzhao Hu wrote: = Instructions for joining and leaving this list, remarks about the problem of INAPPROPRIATE MESSAGES, and archives are available at http://jse.stat.ncsu.edu/

Dunnett's test

2002-01-08 Thread David Jensen
Could someone please help me with a problem I just can't seem to solve. I can get Dunnett's test results output listing using Proc GLM in SAS but I cannot get the p-value for the test so that I can output it to a dataset. I cannot find anything in any SAS documentation that shows

Test -- please ignore

2001-12-31 Thread E. Jacquelin Dietz
This is just a test -- please ignore! Jackie Dietz

Re: How ro perform 'Runs Test'??

2001-12-28 Thread Kjetilh Halvorsen
wrote in message >> news:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>... >> > > I am using nonlinear regression method to find the best parameters >> > > for my data. I came across a term called "runs test" from the >> > > Internet. It mentioned that this is to deter

Re: How ro perform "Runs Test"??

2001-12-27 Thread Rich Ulrich
L PROTECTED]>... > > > I am using nonlinear regression method to find the best parameters for > > > my data. I came across a term called "runs test" from the Internet. It > > > mentioned that this is to determines whether my data is differ > > > sig

Re: analysis of criterion test data

2001-12-24 Thread Donald Burrill
On 24 Dec 2001, Carol Burris wrote: > I am a doctoral student who wants to use student performance on a > criterion test, a state Regents exam, as a dependent variable in a > quasi-experimental study. The effects of previous achievement can be > controlled for using a standardiz

analysis of criterion test data

2001-12-24 Thread Carol Burris
I am a doctoral student who wants to use student performance on a criterion test, a state Regents exam, as a dependent variable in a quasi-experimental study. The effects of previous achievement can be controlled for using a standardized test, the Iowa test of Basic skills. What kind of an

Re: How ro perform "Runs Test"??

2001-12-23 Thread Jim Snow
"Glen" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]... > [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Chia C Chong) wrote in message news:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>... > > I am using nonlinear regression method to find the best parameters for > > my

Re: How ro perform "Runs Test"??

2001-12-20 Thread Glen
[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Chia C Chong) wrote in message news:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>... > I am using nonlinear regression method to find the best parameters for > my data. I came across a term called "runs test" from the Internet. It > mentioned that this is to determines

How ro perform "Runs Test"??

2001-12-19 Thread Chia C Chong
I am using nonlinear regression method to find the best parameters for my data. I came across a term called "runs test" from the Internet. It mentioned that this is to determines whether my data is differ significantly from the equation model I select for the nonlinear regression. C

test-ignore

2001-12-10 Thread Jim Snow
test please ignore = Instructions for joining and leaving this list and remarks about the problem of INAPPROPRIATE MESSAGES are available at http://jse.stat.ncsu.edu/ =

Re: What usually should be done with missing values when I am conducting a t test or other tests?

2001-12-07 Thread Rich Ulrich
On Fri, 07 Dec 2001 04:59:46 GMT, Richard J Burke <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > jenny wrote: > > > What should I do with the missing values in my data. I ned to perform > > a t test of two samples to test the mean difference between them. > > > > How s

Re: What usually should be done with missing values when I am conducting a t test or other tests?

2001-12-02 Thread Glen
[EMAIL PROTECTED] (jenny) wrote in message news:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>... > What should I do with the missing values in my data. I ned to perform > a t test of two samples to test the mean difference between them. > > How should I handle them in S-Plus or SAS? It depends on

What usually should be done with missing values when I am conducting a t test or other tests?

2001-12-01 Thread jenny
What should I do with the missing values in my data. I ned to perform a t test of two samples to test the mean difference between them. How should I handle them in S-Plus or SAS? Thanks. JJ = Instructions for joining and leaving

Re: which test to use

2001-11-28 Thread Niko Tiliopoulos
Dear Kathy, You slightly confuse me with all that detail, but if what I get is right, and that is that you have two continuous variables (one IV & one DV), then why don't you use a simple regression analysis? Is there something I overlooked or does this appear to solve your query? Best Niko Til

Re: Good book about non-parametric statistical hypothesis test

2001-11-03 Thread EugeneGall
Hollander, M. and D. A. Wolfe. 1999. Nonparametric Statistical Methods, 2nd edition. John Wiley & Sons, New York. 787 p. {Encyclopedic, but not as easy to read as many of the others cited. The notes on each test provide good discussions and references to recent adva

Re: Can I Use Wilcoxon Rank Sum Test for Correlated & Clustered Data??

2001-11-02 Thread Robert J. MacG. Dawson
le plot (Q-Q plot) and trying to the fit both A and B with > some theoretical distributions (all distributions avaiable in Matlab!!). > Again, none of the distributions seem can descibe then completely. Then I > was trying to perform the Wilcoxon Rank Sum test. From the data, it see

Re: Can I Use Wilcoxon Rank Sum Test for Correlated & Clustered Data??

2001-11-01 Thread Donald Burrill
would tell you? > and trying to the fit both A and B with some theoretical distributions > (all distributions avaiable in Matlab!!). Again, none of the > distributions seem can descibe then completely. Then I was trying to > perform the Wilcoxon Rank Sum test. What hypothesis w

Re: Can I Use Wilcoxon Rank Sum Test for Correlated & Clustered Data??

2001-11-01 Thread Glen
gt; uniform etc via visualisation. Hence, I proceeded to plot the > Quantile-Quantile plot (Q-Q plot) and trying to the fit both A and B with > some theoretical distributions (all distributions avaiable in Matlab!!). > Again, none of the distributions seem can descibe then completely. Then

Re: Can I Use Wilcoxon Rank Sum Test for Correlated & Clustered Data??

2001-11-01 Thread Glen
Are all the questions you post related to the same problem? Why not let us in on what you're actually doing, so we have more of a clue how to answer your questions? Glen = Instructions for joining and leaving this list and remarks

Re: Good book about non-parametric statistical hypothesis test

2001-11-01 Thread Glen
"Chia C Chong" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message news:<9rrv0e$4hk$[EMAIL PROTECTED]>... > Does anyone know any good reference book about non-parametric statistical > hypothesis test?? > > Thanks > > CCC Read more than one. Here are some that

Re: Good book about non-parametric statistical hypothesis test

2001-11-01 Thread Jonsey
Try "Practical Nonparametric Statistics" by W.J. Conover "Chia C Chong" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message 9rrv0e$4hk$[EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:9rrv0e$4hk$[EMAIL PROTECTED]... > Does anyone know any good reference book about non-parametric statistical >

Re: Good book about non-parametric statistical hypothesis test

2001-11-01 Thread Michael Dewey
On Thu, 1 Nov 2001 17:00:31 -, "Chia C Chong" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: :Does anyone know any good reference book about non-parametric statistical :hypothesis test?? : :Thanks : :CCC : : Try any one of @BOOK{leach79, author = {Leach, C}, year = 1979, title =

Good book about non-parametric statistical hypothesis test

2001-11-01 Thread Chia C Chong
Does anyone know any good reference book about non-parametric statistical hypothesis test?? Thanks CCC = Instructions for joining and leaving this list and remarks about the problem of INAPPROPRIATE MESSAGES are available

EWMA Vs Linear Average, Chi Square Test, & False Positives.

2001-10-31 Thread Vinay A. Mahadik
Hi, I have a basic question that I just couldn't find an answer for. I want to measure the % error introduced by using EWMA as against a linear average for a *stationary* random process (not necessarily Normal) over a given (long/short term) time window: I am using the Chi Squared tes

spss sg test comparing changes in two groups

2001-10-30 Thread linda mcguigan
HI I am working in SPSS10. I have two groups research/ control with pre and post data for each group. I want to use a sig test to check whether any difference in progress between pre and post data between research group and control is a sig difference. Currently I have the all data in four

test

2001-10-19 Thread Aftab H
test - Original Message - From: Wouter Duyck To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2001 1:47 PM Subject: ANOVA by items Dear all :-)Suppose i have a factorial design with two between-subject factors (onefactor A of 3 levels and one factor B of 2

Re: Logistic Regression vs Chi Square test in the following scenario

2001-10-02 Thread Rich Ulrich
e a p value from a F statstic? Or should I be using a chisquare > test? It is a 2x2 table. Logistic regression has nothing to offer: there is no risk of 'over-fitting' the binary prediction, so it would only give you ancillary statistics that are irrelevant. And it offers a

RE: Logistic Regression vs Chi Square test in the following scenario

2001-10-02 Thread Simon, Steve, PhD
Title: RE: Logistic Regression vs Chi Square test in the following scenario Nick writes: >Let's say I have two variables: y is the dependent variable, x is the >independent variable. Both variables are binary and discrete. > >I want to see if there is a relation between

Logistic Regression vs Chi Square test in the following scenario

2001-10-01 Thread Nick
is a relation between x and y. Is it possible to use logistic regression analysis in this case and generate a p value from a F statstic? Or should I be using a chisquare test? Thanks, Nick = Instructions for joining and leaving this

Re: 2x2 tables in epi. Why Fisher test?

2001-05-11 Thread robert . nemeth
Dear Ronald, as far as I understand, the preference (dominance) of Fisher's test has a historical/computational background. It was quite cumbersome to calculate the probabilities for different margins by hand (huge number of tables) and, therefore, as long as the computers were not able

Re: One tailed vs. Two tailed test

2001-03-13 Thread Alan McLean
eal effects are ever null. A > one-tailed p value, for a normally distributed statistic, does have a > real meaning, as I pointed out. But precision of > estimation--confidence limits--is paramount. Hypothesis testing is > passe. > ... The only use for

bad test items (long)

2001-01-30 Thread dennis roberts
t for sure ... C is not good ... and D can't be proved to be correct none of the choices is correct ... C is probably the BEST choice but still not a good one this might be a good question for assessing an inappropriate objective ... or, an inappro

Re: trivariate normality test statistic

2001-01-23 Thread Herman Rubin
In article <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, gus gassmann <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >Wendy wrote: >> Hi, >> I'm looking for a test statistic for trivariate normality. Does anybody know >> such a test-statistic, respectively a book/website where I can find one ? &g

Re: trivariate normality test statistic

2001-01-23 Thread Herman Rubin
In article <tDza6.239027$[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Wendy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >Hi, >I'm looking for a test statistic for trivariate normality. Does anybody know >such a test-statistic, respectively a book/website where I can find one ? I can give you lots of test sta

Re: trivariate normality test statistic

2001-01-22 Thread gus gassmann
Wendy wrote: > Hi, > > I'm looking for a test statistic for trivariate normality. Does anybody know > such a test-statistic, respectively a book/website where I can find one ? > > Thanks ! > > Wendy If you transform the components to independence (using the Chol

trivariate normality test statistic

2001-01-21 Thread Wendy
Hi, I'm looking for a test statistic for trivariate normality. Does anybody know such a test-statistic, respectively a book/website where I can find one ? Thanks ! Wendy = Instructions for joining and leaving this lis

Help needed with Anderson-Darling Test

2001-01-20 Thread Veeral Patel
Hi I have been conducting goodness of fit tests using A-D tests and one thing i forgot to do beforehand was to find out if A-D tables of critical values exist. I have read one book from D'Agostino and Stephens(1986) they outline distribution specific A-D test critical values which re

F-test; H0: ß0=0; ß1=1 interpreting results; siognificance level; company valuation; final thesis

2001-01-12 Thread TomZ
h the slope of 1 and an intercept of 0. I construct 2 models 1. MV = ß0+ß1pred + err or ln(MV) = lnß0+ß1ln(pred) + err 2. MV = pred +err or ln (MV) = ln (pred) to test the null hypostesis if ß0 = 0 and ß1 = 1 as this is what I expect. I

Re: Smoothing, F-test, and Degrees of Freedom

2001-01-12 Thread TomZ
Hi, I would say that the degrees of freedom do not change whan you smooth the data or change it ina any other way. you could for example LN the data to get rid of the long tails in a distribution and use then an F-test. I guess what you do withthe data is indepandent from the test you conduct

RE: Bland and Altman Test

2001-01-10 Thread Dale Glaser
: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject:Re: Bland and Altman Test On 1 Jan 2001 09:00:27 -0800, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > Dear list members > > I have a reference to the Bland-Altman test. > > Bland J.M and Altman D.G (1986) Statistical methods for assessing agreement > betw

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2001-01-10 Thread Alf Breull
Of course, it's of strong advantage to use computers as reference tools, however, exactly the same tools are frequently used 'against' patients because of well-known dependencies within countries related health systems etc. Also, the doctor's final word again is a matter of his view, education an

Re: Bland and Altman Test

2001-01-10 Thread Rich Ulrich
On 1 Jan 2001 09:00:27 -0800, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > Dear list members > > I have a reference to the Bland-Altman test. > > Bland J.M and Altman D.G (1986) Statistical methods for assessing agreement > between two methods of clinical measurement., Lancet, i, 307-10. >

Smoothing, F-test, and Degrees of Freedom

2001-01-08 Thread Jimc10
I am using non-linear regression to fit electophysiological data (current vs t) to exponential equations. I am using an F-test on the residual sum of squares to determine how many components are required. A typical trace will have several thousand points. Question: If I use an adjacent average

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2001-01-08 Thread Rich Ulrich
On Fri, 05 Jan 2001 10:44:13 +, "P.G.Hamer" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Rich Ulrich wrote: > > > Computers do better than experts in making medical > > diagnoses when the correct answer has to be from a narrow set. > > I think that some of the early systems also were better than humans > a

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2001-01-05 Thread Alf Breull
On Thu, 04 Jan 2001 14:42:02 -0500, Rich Ulrich <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >alf> >> The problem is not the existence of literature, the problem is the >> content. > [ snip, ... essentially 'cite the good literature, in great detail' ] Not exactly -- I was asking for 'the good literature' in the

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2001-01-05 Thread P.G.Hamer
Rich Ulrich wrote: > Computers do better than experts in making medical > diagnoses when the correct answer has to be from a narrow set. I think that some of the early systems also were better than humans at identifying the possibility of unusual diagnoses. AFAIR it took the humans to reach a fi

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2001-01-04 Thread Rich Ulrich
uot; The paradigm that has worked well is: comparing the correlations between raters (several skilled humans plus one computer program). This is not my area, but as I understand it, the computers do well when the criterion can be narrowly defined. (And, if the criterion won't change.) Computers

Bland and Altman Test

2001-01-01 Thread RCKnodt
Dear list members I have a reference to the Bland-Altman test. Bland J.M and Altman D.G (1986) Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement., Lancet, i, 307-10. I am not able to travel to any university at the present time (slight health problems

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2000-12-31 Thread Peter Russell
; CANADA > http://www.uwinnipeg.ca/~clark > > > > > > > What kind of statistical methods are used in screening job applicants?

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2000-12-30 Thread Alfred Breull
ne or other publication in the context of comparisons between clinical judgment and actuarial predictions, whcih (1) is published in an indexed journal; (2) has a correct translation between scientific hypothesis and actually tested statistical hypothesis; (3) shows the correct statistical test

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2000-12-29 Thread Rich Ulrich
> 'demostrably valid' one or other day, scientific publication or > period. - for instance, what is supposed to mean? - that some idiot could offer pseudo stat- reasons for something, and that is exactly how Jim's note looks to you? - If you meant that, please read better

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2000-12-29 Thread Alf Breull
ly valid' one or other day, scientific publication or period. Coming from test psychology, you would hesitate because reliability and validity coefficents, usually, suffer from 'regression to the middle', are too low for individual prognosis, explanantion (in the meaning of Hemp

Re: psychologist analyze thyself (was: psych test for Statistics)

2000-12-28 Thread jim clark
Hi On 27 Dec 2000, Jeff Rasmussen wrote: > >scores, but not in aggregating them). In general, human judgment > >does not fare all that well relative to actuarial (i.e., > >statistical) methods. Interesting that someone posting to a > >statistical newsgroup would advocate the non-statistical ap

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2000-12-28 Thread jim clark
ellectual, interests, personality, ... > Do people who apply for a faculty position at your department have to > take such a psychological test too? The literature I mentioned is critical of the fact that psychologists themselves do not follow practices suggested by the empirical literat

Re: psychologist analyze thyself (was: psych test for Statistics)

2000-12-27 Thread Jeff Rasmussen
Rich, You're right, I forgot to mention the biases! I'm on sabbatical so I must have forgotten (or repressed) that rather salient feature. >By the big ones: sex, race, social class, age, ethnicity. >By more subtle ones: >wealth, body language, speech accents, shopping habits. >And if you don't

Re: How to test whether the deviation is a constant?

2000-12-27 Thread Bob Hayden
yyou are quite sure it makes sense. A better and more general approach might be to use regression and test beta-0=0 and/or beta-1=1. _ | |Robert W. Hayden | | Work: Department of Mathematics / |Plymouth State College MSC#29

Re: psychologist analyze thyself (was: psych test for Statistics)

2000-12-27 Thread Rich Ulrich
On 27 Dec 2000 08:18:11 -0800, [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Jeff Rasmussen) wrote: < ... > Jeff > ' When I'm on such committees I do a rank ordering based on whatever actuarial data is available and know that doing otherwise is just mucking around with error. Most other faculty haruspicate via predictors

Re: How to test whether the deviation is a constant?

2000-12-27 Thread Rich Ulrich
separately posted to sci.stat.consult, sci.stat.edu On Mon, 25 Dec 2000 17:51:14 +0800, Wen-Feng Hsiao <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Dear all, > > Paired t-test helps us to exam whether the paired samples (or the same > samples) respond differently between two treatments. T

psychologist analyze thyself (was: psych test for Statistics)

2000-12-27 Thread Jeff Rasmussen
> >There is a considerable literature on clinical judgment (i.e., >interview and human judgement) vs. actuarial predictions (i.e., >predictions from demonstrably valid regression equations ... >human judgment _might_ be used in producing individual predictor >scores, but not in aggregating them).

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2000-12-27 Thread T.S. Lim
innipeg, Manitoba R3B 2E9 [EMAIL PROTECTED] > CANADA http://www.uwinnipeg.ca/~clark > What kind of statistical methods are used in screening job applicants? Do people who apply for a faculty positi

Re: How to test whether the deviation is a constant?

2000-12-26 Thread Jerrold Zar
Yes, you can perform a paired t-test by hypothesizing a constant, C, in H0: mu1 - mu2 = C, but whether or not C = 0 does not necessarily have anything to do with distribution shape. Jerrold H. Zar Northern Illinois University == >>> Wen-Feng Hsiao <[EMAIL PR

Re: How to test whether the deviation is a constant?

2000-12-26 Thread Jerrold Zar
>>> Wen-Feng Hsiao <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> 12/26/00 08:14PM >>> Dear all, Paired t-test allows us to exam whether the paired samples (or the same samples) respond differently between two treatments. The null hypothesis is H0: mu1=mu2 or mu1-mu2=0. Could this be

How to test whether the deviation is a constant?

2000-12-26 Thread Wen-Feng Hsiao
Dear all, Paired t-test allows us to exam whether the paired samples (or the same samples) respond differently between two treatments. The null hypothesis is H0: mu1=mu2 or mu1-mu2=0. Could this be extended to test a null hypothesis with H0: mu1-mu2=C, where C is a constant, but unknown. My

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2000-12-26 Thread jim clark
Hi On Tue, 26 Dec 2000, John Uebersax wrote: > IMHO, psychological tests in this case should not substitute for a > thorough interview and human judgment. > > Just my .02 worth. There is a considerable literature on clinical judgment (i.e., interview and human judgement) vs. actuarial predictio

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2000-12-26 Thread Henry
On Sat, 23 Dec 2000 02:15:54 GMT, T.S. Lim <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >I was wondering if it's a common practice in Statistics to require job >applicants to take a psychological test. At the MS/PhD level (in the >US), I don't think it's common. However, some compani

Re: OT: psychological test for recruitment in Statistics

2000-12-26 Thread John Uebersax
I've never heard of any statistician position requiring a psychological test. Even when I worked at the RAND Corporation, where the position involved some degree of defense-related research, it was not required. (Frankly, if a firm required such a test, I would take that as a sign that it i

  1   2   >