Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-07 Thread sebb
On 07/06/07, Henning Schmiedehausen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: On Wed, 2007-06-06 at 19:13 +0100, sebb wrote: > On 06/06/07, Roland Weber <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > sebb wrote: > > > s/branch/tag/g surely? > > > > Eh... CVS tag = SVN branch? Whatever, the things that are > > No, CVS tag = SV

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-06 Thread Henning Schmiedehausen
On Wed, 2007-06-06 at 19:13 +0100, sebb wrote: > On 06/06/07, Roland Weber <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > sebb wrote: > > > s/branch/tag/g surely? > > > > Eh... CVS tag = SVN branch? Whatever, the things that are > > No, CVS tag = SVN tag No. SVN tag == SVN branch == shallow directory copy. The

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-06 Thread Henning Schmiedehausen
This is my personal model for this stuff. YMMV trunk ---+ main development --- | release branch branches/JCS_1_3 | + --- tag tags/JCS_1_3_RC1 | + --- tag tags/JCS_1_3_RC2

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-06 Thread Roland Weber
Hi Sebastian, > So a release can be developed in a branch or the trunk; before the > release is finally built the current files should be copied to a > subdirectory of tags. > > The tags subdirectory should not be updated once created. The branch was the correct term. You copy trunk into a branc

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-06 Thread sebb
On 06/06/07, Roland Weber <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: sebb wrote: > s/branch/tag/g surely? Eh... CVS tag = SVN branch? Whatever, the things that are No, CVS tag = SVN tag not trunk and from which you can get a named historic version (=revision?) of what used to be in trunk :-) In SVN, ther

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-06 Thread Roland Weber
sebb wrote: > s/branch/tag/g surely? Eh... CVS tag = SVN branch? Whatever, the things that are not trunk and from which you can get a named historic version (=revision?) of what used to be in trunk :-) It's called "level" in CMVC, and I just don't want to spend my time on learning a separate voc

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-06 Thread sebb
On 06/06/07, Roland Weber <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hi Thomas, >> If you changed the release files manually, you >> should commit those changes to SVN and give Sebastian some time to >> change his vote. > > We were voting on the artifacts on people.apache.org/~tv/jcs/, not on > SVN. This is at

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-06 Thread Roland Weber
Hi Thomas, >> If you changed the release files manually, you >> should commit those changes to SVN and give Sebastian some time to >> change his vote. > > We were voting on the artifacts on people.apache.org/~tv/jcs/, not on > SVN. This is at least what I understood the release-then-vote-policy >

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-03 Thread Rahul Akolkar
On 6/3/07, Martin van den Bemt <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Agreed. though that page probably needs a bit of a reality check.. The problem is when someone does a -1 with reasoning, people tend to stop voting until that vote is switched to a +1 and if that vote is switched to a +1 and there are en

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-03 Thread Martin van den Bemt
Agreed. though that page probably needs a bit of a reality check.. The problem is when someone does a -1 with reasoning, people tend to stop voting until that vote is switched to a +1 and if that vote is switched to a +1 and there are enough votes, people that stopped voting will keep silent. H

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-03 Thread Will Glass-Husain
Martin, Actually, that's not true. Releases cannot be vetoed by a -1. See http://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html If there's a majority approval and at least 3 +1 PMC votes, than it's up to the release manager to decide whether or not to release. He can decide to table the vote based on

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-03 Thread Martin van den Bemt
Rony is a PMC member.. However the -1 of Sebb (which is binding and blocking) is still there (unless I missed his +1).. Added Rony to the jakarta-pmc authorization file (thanx for spotting this).. Mvgr, Martin Thomas Vandahl wrote: > Hi Roland, > > Roland Weber wrote: >> Hi Thomas, >> >>> I cou

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-03 Thread Thomas Vandahl
Hi Roland, Roland Weber wrote: > Hi Thomas, > >> I could not find any information about whether Rony Flatscher is a >> member of the PMC > > In the committers-only SVN module is a file board/committee-info.txt > which lists the PMCs of all Apache projects. It's (supposed to be ;-) > the authorit

Re: Result: [VOTE] Release JCS 1.3

2007-06-03 Thread Roland Weber
Hi Thomas, > I could not find any information about whether Rony Flatscher is a > member of the PMC In the committers-only SVN module is a file board/committee-info.txt which lists the PMCs of all Apache projects. It's (supposed to be ;-) the authoritative source. Rony Flatscher is listed there a