Re: [hlds_linux] Rumour: VALVe bullying server plugin developers

2005-05-21 Thread Clayton Macleod
heh. You re-read the thread. I'm following it just fine, sorry you're having trouble. Anyways, you said "Cutting down the ability for folks to create cheats around the new valve engine?" What exactly does removing the menu API that everyone was using do to curtail cheating? And how exactly was lea

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Clayton Macleod
Eric should take his own advice. On 5/21/05, Brian J. holmes <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Not sure if that comment was directed at me or not, but I didn't make > the statement, I was quoting someone else from the hlcoders list after > Steven H. asked where it was documented. I never disputed the

RE: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Brian J. holmes
Not sure if that comment was directed at me or not, but I didn't make the statement, I was quoting someone else from the hlcoders list after Steven H. asked where it was documented. I never disputed the use of the term hack. -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTEC

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Eric (Deacon)
In a bold display of creativity, Brian J. holmes wrote: A "hack" is a funny thing to call a user message nicely documented in cl_dll/menu.cpp. A set of functionality existed for a particular, obscure purpose. To use that functionality in going way above and beyond its intended use--indeed, it

Re: [hlds_linux] Rumour: VALVe bullying server plugin developers

2005-05-21 Thread Britt Priddy \(PZ\)
That made alot of sense. Please explain. Re-read the thread. - Original Message - From: "Clayton Macleod" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Saturday, May 21, 2005 6:47 PM Subject: Re: [hlds_linux] Rumour: VALVe bullying server plugin developers I fail to see how providing menus that a

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Andrew Forsberg
[snip] I've said it a million times before but in my opinion the huge half-life mod community and the huge server admin community are what has made, and will continue to make, half-life as successful as it is. All I'm asking is some common courtesy from valve in response to those two groups wa

RE: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Brian J. holmes
I did in fact read the whole thread my point is that, as a server admin, using a plugin that is restrained to only having the esc menu system available is quite simply a pain in the ass. As a server admin I want an in game menu for my admin plugin, and I think that echoes the wants of a great numb

Re: [hlds_linux] Rumour: VALVe bullying server plugin developers

2005-05-21 Thread Clayton Macleod
I fail to see how providing menus that aren't cumbersome has anything to do with cheating. On 5/21/05, Britt Priddy (PZ) <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Fear that mods are better than the actual games provided by Valve? > OR > Cutting down the ability for folks to create cheats around the new valve >

[hlds_linux] Plugins - Where to start

2005-05-21 Thread Geoffrey McRae
Hi, I am looking to develop some basic administration plugins for CS:Source, can anybody point me in the correct direction to start? Tutorials... etc would be great. I have a background in development so I dont need somthing that teaches the language, I just want to know the basics of a HL2 plugi

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Andrew Forsberg
People keep claiming this "other" method is documented so where is said documentation? Note: I havent looked for it myself I haven't either but this is directly quoted from the hlcoders list: A "hack" is a funny thing to call a user message nicely documented in cl_dll/menu.cpp. Well, if

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Simon Garner
On 22/05/2005 6:38 a.m., Brian J. holmes wrote: What needs to happen in my opinion is that Valve needs to respond to the needs and wants of the server admin community by extending their menu API t allow for in-game menu's and further they need to at the very least provide complete changelogs for

RE: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Brian J. holmes
>People keep claiming this "other" method is documented so where is said >documentation? >Note: I havent looked for it myself I haven't either but this is directly quoted from the hlcoders list: A "hack" is a funny thing to call a user message nicely documented in cl_dll/menu.cpp. ~dvander

Re: [hlds_linux] Rumour: VALVe bullying server plugin developers

2005-05-21 Thread Britt Priddy \(PZ\)
Fear that mods are better than the actual games provided by Valve? OR Cutting down the ability for folks to create cheats around the new valve engine? - Original Message - From: "Michael McKoy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Friday, May 20, 2005 2:37 PM Subject: Re: [hlds_linux] Rumour

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Daniel
Just to sum up this thread: Whingers: die valve die die Valve: sorry we are just trying to help, work with us. Whingers: die piggie piggie die die Every sensible person on this earth + m0gley: You whingers are idiots. People need not read anything else said in this monumental waste of time threa

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread apophis
On 5/21/05, Steven Hartland <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Sounds sensible but from what I have read this has already been offered. > People just need to talk about it and come up with some requirements to > provide a supportable API. Requirements: Work exactly like the menus that are being removed.

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Steven Hartland
- Original Message - From: "Brian J. holmes" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> The facts as I see them are: 1) Valve included a documented and supported plugin interface allowing for a menu system requiring the user to press escape and use a mouse to access. 2) Valve also included a documented but n

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Eric (Deacon)
In a bold display of creativity, Brian J. holmes wrote: What needs to happen in my opinion is that Valve needs to respond to the needs and wants of the server admin community by extending their menu API t allow for in-game menu's See, I think that's reasonable. -- Eric (the Deacon remix)

RE: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Brian J. holmes
So I'm going to weigh in here from a server admin perspective. Personally, it seems to me the thrust of this debate so far has revolved around petty complaints of semantics and name calling. The facts as I see them are: 1) Valve included a documented and supported plugin interface allowing for

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Eric (Deacon)
In a bold display of creativity, Frash wrote: A fact is that VALVe does this all to maintain control. I doubt that, honestly, but even if it's true, it's certainly reasonable. Basically, it's like someone driving across a public park to avoid having to go around and getting pissed when the cit

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Eric (Deacon)
In a bold display of creativity, Rash wrote: Trust me guys, VALVe will revert it. They have to, or nobody will take them serious anymore. Just FYI, as an ardent pedant, it's difficult for me to take anyone seriously who says things like "take them serious anymore." Serious is an adjective. Se

[hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Frash
I admit my previous posts were a bit too whiney and even offensive at some points, so ill try again. A fact is that VALVe does this all to maintain control. There is a big chance plugins like NeoTF and WC3 are simply impossible because VALVe does not like them. We are forced to use a menu that req

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread m0gely
Frash wrote: Trust me guys, VALVe will revert it. Whoa there! Talk about backing someone (big) into a corner! Alfred said two things that stuck out to me, one of which it seems a bunch of coders are ignoring all together. For one, Alfred said that Valve would not be held hostage by plugin d

Re: [hlds_linux] Rumour: VALVe bullying server plugin developers

2005-05-21 Thread m0gely
Steven Hartland wrote: Fact is if you use undocumented "hacks" they there is no reason to complain when said things stop working. If you where using the documented menu methods then this problem wouldn't have occurred and if changes where made said API Im sure notice would be given. I'm still t

Re: [hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Steven Hartland
- Original Message - From: "Frash" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> @ Steve: Get your facts straight or stay out of this discussion please. Which fact do you believe I stated wrongly that its not a documented API if so I quote: Alfred Reynolds wrote: They are using an undocumented hack to display

[hlds_linux] VALVe getting critism from 3 sides for blocking the "fancy menu hack"

2005-05-21 Thread Frash
Trust me guys, VALVe will revert it. They have to, or nobody will take them serious anymore. First the admins started complaining their plugins doesnt work. Then the coders started complaining (HLCoders). Now even the players are complaining (See Steam forums). I dont even have to link it, but its

Re: [hlds_linux] Rumour: VALVe bullying server plugin developers

2005-05-21 Thread Roc
Funny fact, you go to such sites as Mani's and you here all sorts of complaints against valve when Mani knew of said "hack" and was warned! Stop blaming valve :) Steven Hartland wrote: Fact is if you use undocumented "hacks" they there is no reason to complain when said things stop working. If

Re: [hlds_linux] Rumour: VALVe bullying server plugin developers

2005-05-21 Thread Roc
True, very well said ;) Regards Steven Hartland wrote: Fact is if you use undocumented "hacks" they there is no reason to complain when said things stop working. If you where using the documented menu methods then this problem wouldn't have occurred and if changes where made said API Im sure no

Re: [hlds_linux] Rumour: VALVe bullying server plugin developers

2005-05-21 Thread Steven Hartland
Fact is if you use undocumented "hacks" they there is no reason to complain when said things stop working. If you where using the documented menu methods then this problem wouldn't have occurred and if changes where made said API Im sure notice would be given. Steve / K - Original Message