[LUTE] Re: clip-on strobe tuner with 1/6 MT

2011-02-08 Thread Anthony Hind
David Should I understand that for the moment it is not programmable? How about the diapason, is that variable? Do the "sweetened tunings" include those that may interest us, 6th comma, etc? Perhaps, you have not looked into this? I temporarily mislaid my ST-122 strobe tuner and have had t

[LUTE] couperin lecons

2011-02-08 Thread hera caius
I was trying to find the complete score for Couperin s Lecons de tenebre...on the net. Does anybody knows a place where I can find it in pdf or other format? Thanks. -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: couperin lecons

2011-02-08 Thread hera caius
--- On Tue, 2/8/11, hera caius wrote: From: hera caius Subject: couperin lecons To: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Date: Tuesday, February 8, 2011, 2:34 PM I was trying to find the complete score for Couperin s Lecons de tenebre...on the net. Does anybody knows a place wher

[LUTE] Re: clip-on strobe tuner with 1/6 MT

2011-02-08 Thread David van Ooijen
On 8 February 2011 12:10, Anthony Hind wrote: >     Should I understand that for the moment it is not programmable? How about > the diapason, is that variable? > Do the "sweetened tunings" include those that may interest us, 6th comma, etc? > Perhaps, you have not looked into this? The website ha

[LUTE] Re: clip-on strobe tuner with 1/6 MT

2011-02-08 Thread Martin Shepherd
By "diapason" II think Anthony meant pitch standard. I looked at the Peterson website and it seems to say that it can be varied from 404 to 460 or something - not a wide enough range from some of us who wish all "early" music could be in 392. But a tempting machine, nevertheless... Best wish

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Anthony Hind
Dear Ed, Martyn, and All, As you lecture on this painting, and until now, I have only given it an admirative, but casual look, may I formulate a few questions about the significance of the stringing and the fretting, about which you may be able to enlighten me? The fretting appears to

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Roman Turovsky
Anthony, the lute denotes FAMILIAL HARMONY, and the broken string denotes that that familial harmony was disrupted by a death. And the fretting is equally tempered, just like it was (and should be) in real life. RT - Original Message - From: "Anthony Hind" To: "Ed Durbrow" ; "Mart

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread David van Ooijen
On 8 February 2011 15:35, Anthony Hind wrote: > Dear Ed, Martyn, and All, > >      As you lecture on this painting, and until now, I have only given  it an Read John North The Ambassadors' Secret - Holbein and the world of the Reniassance to know all (and more) about the symbolism in this parti

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Lex van Sante
I think there is a mixup between fret-spacing and fret thickness. Frets being of equal thickness may well mean that this particular lute had a high action which temporarily can be corrected by tying frets of equal diameter. The frets of this lute do not seem to be placed at the 6th comma meanto

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Roman Turovsky
Those temperaments were and are for masochists. RT - Original Message - From: "Lex van Sante" To: "lute mailing list list" Sent: Tuesday, February 08, 2011 9:59 AM Subject: [LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project I think there is a mixup between fret-spacing and fret thickness. Fr

[LUTE] Re: oogle Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Anthony Hind
Yes, I agree that high action could be compensated for by equal thickness frets (and this could also be considered as a less than ideal set-up); but if that is the answer to my question, why would the strings have been fixed so high in relation to the bridge holes. Wouldn't that be counter to th

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Lex van Sante
Not all of them were and are. A 6th comma meantone temperament upon g on a Renaissancelute tunes to g' is quite pleasant to the ear, well my ear at least. I find that when I just tune my lute to the sound I want to hear it ends up being in this temperament. Cheers, Lex Op 8 feb 2011, om 16:12 h

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Anthony Hind
Roman I was not talking about equal temperament versus 4th or 6th comma, but equal fret thickness. I agree with Lex that this could be to compensate for high action, but then why the high positionining of the strings? Regards Anthony - Message d'origine De : Roman Turovsky

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Roman Turovsky
It can also be really insufferable, when it renders minor 3rds too wide. RT From: "Lex van Sante" To: "lute mailing list list" Sent: Tuesday, February 08, 2011 10:17 AM Subject: [LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project Not all of them were and are. A 6th comma meantone temperament upon g on

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Anthony Hind
Yes, I read many of these excellent papers, that I hadn't read until now. The symbolism appears so sophisticated that clearly a badly strung lute could also have been expected to have been recognised as such, by such equally sophisticated viewers, and be part of that symbolism; but there are many

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Anthony Hind
I have been using 6th comma on my Baroque lute, in spite of warnings from many that it should sound dischordant, and it hasn't (at least not to my ears, or to those of my lutenist visitors. Anthony - Message d'origine De : Lex van Sante À : lute mailing list list Envoyé le : Mar 8

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Lex van Sante
Minor thirds were regarded as more or less dissonant anyway, and maybe the so called Elisabethan Melancholy was to be expressed using insufferable minor thirds. LvS Op 8 feb 2011, om 16:21 heeft Roman Turovsky het volgende geschreven: > It can also be really insufferable, when it renders > min

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Lex van Sante
I really find the baroque lute and its music more picky in this respect than the renaissancelute and music. LvS Op 8 feb 2011, om 16:25 heeft Anthony Hind het volgende geschreven: > I have been using 6th comma on my Baroque lute, in spite of warnings from > many > that it should sound dischor

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Roman Turovsky
That's why we have so much music in minor keys, n'est ce pas? I for one can't stand half-ass minor thirds. RT - Original Message - From: "Lex van Sante" To: "lute mailing list list" Sent: Tuesday, February 08, 2011 10:28 AM Subject: [LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project Minor th

[LUTE] thirds - was gadget talk

2011-02-08 Thread David van Ooijen
Pure is what the ears would percieve as most in tune, if not tainted by one temperament or the other. Pure minor third = 315.6 cents 1/4 comma minor third = 304.9 cents 1/6 comma minor third = 310.3 cents ET minor third = 300 cents Pure major third = 386.3 cents 1/4 comma MT major third = 386.3 c

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Lex van Sante
I'm sorry to hear that, because it means going to early music concerts must be a torment for you in most cases. Lvs Op 8 feb 2011, om 16:33 heeft Roman Turovsky het volgende geschreven: > That's why we have so much music in minor keys, n'est ce pas? > I for one can't stand half-ass minor thir

[LUTE] Re: clip-on strobe tuner with 1/6 MT

2011-02-08 Thread Mjos & Larson
The unit sounds appealing to me, too. Although I also perform on modern guitars, on early instruments I play 98% of the time in 1/6 comma MT at A415. So the unit's pitch and MT settings sound ideal. I have been concerned whether the clamp would open wide enough for easy attachment to a lute pegbo

[LUTE] Re: Holbein painting [Google Art project] frets and bridge

2011-02-08 Thread Martyn Hodgson
My earlier response to Anthony: Anthony Sorry to delay answering - I will reply to this but if you're in a rush then send it off. I need to spend proper time studying the picture. At a glance you're right, the fretting does look all the same diameter! Trying to think why th

[LUTE] Re: clip-on strobe tuner with 1/6 MT

2011-02-08 Thread David van Ooijen
On 8 February 2011 17:04, Mjos & Larson wrote: > I have been concerned whether the clamp would open wide enough for > easy attachment to a lute pegbox or theorbo extension (no problem on The clamps of the cable-and-clamp (Korg/no name/Seiko) fits. The clamp of the Korg clip-on fits. > the machin

[LUTE] "Strobe" tuners.

2011-02-08 Thread Herbert Ward
I have an old Peterson mechanical-wheel strobe tuner. It is big, heavy, expensive, and must be plugged into the wall for power. But it works much better than any battery-powered tuner, including those which have "strobe" in their names. To get on or off this list see list information at http:

[LUTE] Barbetta - Novae tabulae / Il terctio libro (1582)

2011-02-08 Thread Reinier de Valk
Dear all, Does anyone happen to have a copy of Giulio Cesare Barbetta's 1582 Novae tabulae or Il terctio libro? Parts of the copy (in pdf) that I have are hardly legible, and I need to double check. I'm looking only for pieces 39 (Martin menoit) and 40 (Il nest plaisir). Any

[LUTE] Re: clip-on strobe tuner with 1/6 MT

2011-02-08 Thread Herbert Ward
A mechanical-wheel strobe tuner has several advantages over the battery-powered "strobe" tuners that I've seen. By showing multiple octaves (four or five of them) simulataneously, it gives you an instant, easy-to-see, and unambiguous indication of whether a string is false. Since it has no digit

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Martin Shepherd
Dear Anthony and All, Just a few points which may be of interest: Anthony, I think there's no need to look for any imperfections in the lute beyond the broken string, the symbolism of which would have been perfectly clear to anyone, unlike some of the other (possible) imperfections you mentio

[LUTE] Re: thirds - was gadget talk

2011-02-08 Thread wikla
David, that was a clever answer! Enjoyable! ;-) Arto On Tue, 8 Feb 2011 16:47:49 +0100, David van Ooijen wrote: > Pure is what the ears would percieve as most in tune, if not tainted > by one temperament or the other. > > Pure minor third = 315.6 cents > 1/4 comma minor third = 304.9 cents >

[LUTE] Google art project

2011-02-08 Thread Martin Shepherd
Just one further thought about the string thicknesses - the 6th course is about twice the thickness of the third, which implies more or less equal tension stringing, and the octaves are quite thin, which also suggests a reasonable amount of tension on the thickest strings (because with low tens

[LUTE] Re: Holbein painting [Google Art project] frets and bridge

2011-02-08 Thread Anthony Hind
Thanks Martyn, I should have given you more time to think about this. "At a glance you're right, the fretting does look all the same diameter! Trying to think why this may be my speculation (and that's all it is!) is : if the neck had pulled up this might have been done so as to reduc

[LUTE] Vivaldi Double Cello Concerto RV 531

2011-02-08 Thread David Tayler
For those wishing to dive into continuo, the slow movement of the concerto for two cellos in G Minor is an excellent piece to work on, and it lies really well on the lute, archlute or theorbo. http://youtu.be/BWDFshDDJ3I?hd=1 dt To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.c

[LUTE] Re: Vivaldi Double Cello Concerto RV 531

2011-02-08 Thread wikla
Dive into the _listening_ of continuo? Any link to the written music? Beautiful, though. ;-) Thanks! Arto On Tue, 08 Feb 2011 10:23:56 -0800, David Tayler wrote: > For those wishing to dive into continuo, the slow movement of the > concerto for two cellos in G Minor is an excellent piece to w

[LUTE] Re: couperin lecons

2011-02-08 Thread Eleanor Smith
Having been looking for a copy myself this week - there are plenty of music shops selling editions of the Leçons ... but no free edition that I've found yet. Good luck! Elly --- On Tue, 2/8/11, hera caius wrote: From: hera caius Subject: couperin lecons To: lute@cs.d

[LUTE] Re: [off list] Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread demery
>> For example, it seems to have been established that some of the >> instruments are >> >> misaligned, as possible symbols of impending chaos, or aligned to the >> date of >> Good Friday 1533. >> >> "But cleaning of the picture has established that each one of the >> instruments >> to the right of

[LUTE] Re: Vivaldi Double Cello Concerto RV 531

2011-02-08 Thread Bernd Haegemann
Dive into the _listening_ of continuo? Any link to the written music? That is already the 2. dan of Continuo: no numbers + no notes :-)= To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: clip-on strobe tuner with 1/6 MT

2011-02-08 Thread Leonard Williams
In my post regarding this tuner, I had mistakenly reported some specs that are for the full size version. Sorry! Regards, Leonard Williams On 2/8/11 7:42 AM, "David van Ooijen" wrote: > On 8 February 2011 12:10, Anthony Hind wrote: >>     Should I understand that for the moment it is not prog

[LUTE] Re: Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Alexander Batov
Hi Martin, I can't really see any reasons for putting the nut in a sloped rebate, can you? He must have got something wrong in otherwise such a perfect painting ... :) The other feature that I'm sure was remarked upon before is the rather pronounced fluting of the ribs (some other paintings

[LUTE] lute for young beginner

2011-02-08 Thread Stuart Walsh
A friend's daughter has suddenly decided she wants to play the lute. She has found this, surprisingly inexpensive, instrument: http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=330522967196&ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT Presumably it's made in the Far East (as reckoned from here in UK). There wa

[LUTE] Re: Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Martin Shepherd
Hi Alexander, Yes, the ribs here seem to stay fluted even as they go over the block, but in general old lutes seem to have developed the fluting after they were taken off the mould. I glue my paper linings in wet, and find that when they shrink they tend to pull the ribs into a fluted shape,

[LUTE] Re: thirds - was gadget talk

2011-02-08 Thread David van Ooijen
On 8 February 2011 18:51, wikla wrote: > David, > > that was a clever answer! Enjoyable!  ;-) Perhaps, but with a typo. |-( It's the ET _major_ third that's 400 cents, obviously. David - way past bed time > > Arto > > On Tue, 8 Feb 2011 16:47:49 +0100, David van Ooijen > wrote: >> Pure is wha

[LUTE] Re: Vivaldi Double Cello Concerto RV 531

2011-02-08 Thread Edward Martin
Very nice, David. I played continuo on that piece at least 2 times in the past, and it is gorgeous. ed At 12:23 PM 2/8/2011, David Tayler wrote: >For those wishing to dive into continuo, the slow movement of the >concerto for two cellos in G Minor is an excellent piece to work on, >and it lies

[LUTE] Re: Google Art project

2011-02-08 Thread Alexander Batov
Thank you, Martin. I know perfectly well the distortion effect you are describing (both from my own experience and old lutes) but the fluting that is caused by paper lining re-enforcement of the joints doesn't quite appear so consistent and pronounced as it looks on some of the paintings. Or

[LUTE] Re: thirds - was gadget talk

2011-02-08 Thread wikla
Dear all, isn't it funny: you tend to read, what you think is written. It is happy, if also the writer thought as the reader - as is the case here... ;) Nice example of this phenomenon is scrambling the letters: "Acncriodg to a reserchaer at Crdgaimbe Ueisnrvity, it dsoen't mtetar in waht o