Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-10-14 Thread Patrick Moore
It was not as big a feature as we had hoped; merely a sidebar to a bike review where Jan briefly tried MKS Urban pedals with half clips and didn't like them. His earlier blog post had let us hope that they were going to do a study. Study or not, I have to say that I agree with Jan, to the point

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-10-14 Thread Rod Holland
Oops, did miss it. It was a short sidebar to a review, "MKS Rinko Pedals". Best summary is last paragraph: Retentionless pedals work great on flat roads. Uphills, especially short > rises, are easier when your feet are firmly attached to the pedals. As some of the folks on this thread have

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-10-14 Thread Rod Holland
Just scanned the tables of contents for the Summer and Autumn issues, and didn't see it. Maybe I missed it. rod On Tuesday, October 13, 2015 at 2:18:13 PM UTC-4, George Schick wrote: > > Now that Summer is long past, does anyone who subscribes to BQ have a > synopsis of what they found out

RE: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-10-14 Thread Allingham II, Thomas J
"My summation is this : there is nothing to gain or lose regardless of any choice" Lack of any consequence to any decision might provide a disincentive to give any thought to the decision itself. Is this really what you meant to say? From: rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-10-14 Thread ascpgh
Jan's point rang very true for me too. All data aside, my adult cycling experience grew out of self-conducted recovery from an injury that made my connection to the bike less Mark Cavendish or Keirin racers, more about how to manage my altered proprioception and all-around poise that came

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-10-14 Thread Edwin W
> > As I ride without retention, I think of myself JUST like this guy! > https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ud5T5I4XcA Riding free, Edwin > > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-10-14 Thread Garth
As always of course , everyone decides for themselves ! Just because "j. doe" says it is so does not make it so . I ride up all sorts of short steep hills over hill and dale in Crocs for goodness sakes . . .. which are essentially foam . Crocs slides even, not the clog style with the

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-10-13 Thread George Schick
Now that Summer is long past, does anyone who subscribes to BQ have a synopsis of what they found out about pedal retention usefulness that they'd like to share? On Friday, May 15, 2015 at 9:23:53 AM UTC-5, Patrick Moore wrote: > > Doubtless of interest to RBW listers. Quoted from the Compass

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-07-16 Thread Patrick Moore
This just in: from the VO blog. Obviously rigorous, high and pure science. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CNedIJBZpgMfeature=youtu.be Seriously, if not exactly rigorous or pure, still interesting. (The rigor is at the level of the BQ observations: anecdotal, but still informative.) For my own

RE: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-13 Thread olofstroh
Steve wrote (and Patrick more added some interesting comments): Let's face it: those who like flat pedals - pedals without retention devices - aren't after performance gains that can be measured objectively. They're after comfort and convenience. Some riders can make them work quite

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-13 Thread Matthew J
Improper content reported. On Saturday, June 13, 2015 at 5:28:04 AM UTC-5, Ron Mc wrote: actually, this thread went to the toilet long ago, and Steve, you and Matthew J filled it On Friday, June 12, 2015 at 4:47:07 PM UTC-5, Steve Palincsar wrote: I'm surprised this discussion has had

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-13 Thread Ron Mc
actually, this thread went to the toilet long ago, and Steve, you and Matthew J filled it On Friday, June 12, 2015 at 4:47:07 PM UTC-5, Steve Palincsar wrote: I'm surprised this discussion has had so much staying power. It's a relatively trivial issue, as far as I'm concerned. -- You

RE: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-13 Thread olofstroh
Out for two hours this morning, tried to observe what I did. Found that I do lift my foot so that there is no pressure on the pedal, but foot still in kontakt with the pedal. On the flats and on the hills. Must be an automatic brain thing. And first time this year in only a t-shirt and shorts!

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-13 Thread Steve Palincsar
On 06/13/2015 02:56 AM, olofst...@gmail.com wrote: I started to ride intensively at age 5 and have never stopped (now 72). Didn´t meet retention until over 30. I´m a natural spinner and rides both roads and trails. On flat rubber pedals, never got enamoured by retention. This comes very

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Edwin W
It's a relatively trivial issue, as far as I'm concerned. Now that has never limited a thread, has it? Cheerfully, Edwin On Friday, June 12, 2015 at 4:47:07 PM UTC-5, Steve Palincsar wrote: On 06/12/2015 05:33 PM, Edwin W wrote: I think that Jan does a great job of disclosing and being

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Steve Palincsar
On 06/12/2015 05:33 PM, Edwin W wrote: I think that Jan does a great job of disclosing and being honest in reviews AND having a business that runs on a certain kind of biking introduces a bias.. which is why he should disclose! It is impossible to measure this bias, we all have to work out in

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Edwin W
I think that Jan does a great job of disclosing and being honest in reviews AND having a business that runs on a certain kind of biking introduces a bias.. which is why he should disclose! It is impossible to measure this bias, we all have to work out in our mind how much he is biased. In my

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Steve Palincsar
On 06/12/2015 05:49 PM, Edwin W wrote: It's a relatively trivial issue, as far as I'm concerned. Now that has never limited a thread, has it? Well, that's certainly true. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Patrick Moore
Steve: Although I am someone who hasn't used non-retention pedals since 1970 (that's a wee bit hyperbolic but largely true) I have to weigh in for the other side and say that I, personally, have heard too much from riders with enough experience and certainly enough power output about the joys of

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Kellie
Hahaha... made me  On Saturday, May 16, 2015 at 8:02:47 AM UTC-7, Rod Holland wrote: Anne, Sounds like the guy forgot to unclip his mouth from his Y chromosome... That causes any number of accidents... rod On Saturday, May 16, 2015 at 10:09:13 AM UTC-4, Anne Paulson wrote: Is

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Patrick Moore
It's really a question of torque, not power. Like an old 20 hp tractor that can climb a wall (if it is using clipless pedals). On Thu, Jun 11, 2015 at 7:05 PM, Benz, Sunnyvale, CA benzouy...@gmail.com wrote: I'm a little late to this discussion, but can you please reconcile your claim about

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Ron Mc
Clayton, I don't think your head should have been bitten off. It was a reasonable interrogatory. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Steve Palincsar
On 06/11/2015 10:14 PM, 'clayton bailey' via RBW Owners Bunch wrote: Does he not own Rene Herse? And sell his own randoneur frames? I thought he did. H. You are wrong. He owns the Rene Herse name, but licenses it to Mike Kone of Boulder Bicycles for the Herse bicycle line. Clayton

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Jan Heine
It's totally normal to be skeptical when a magazine also has a sister company that sells bicycle components... However, the reason Compass exists is because we at Bicycle Quarterly wanted to put our research into practice and make the parts that we want to ride on our own bikes. We cannot tell

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread 'clayton bailey' via RBW Owners Bunch
Jan, I apologize. I did not mean to offend anyone, and was totally mistaken about your connection to Rene Herse. Your connection to them in my mind, somehow became your brand, that you sold. However I stand by my brake comments. I had intense brake judder on my Specialized Crux, and it was

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Mark Parker
I thought the whole debate was that for unracers flat pedals are fine. From what I have read of his exploits, it doesn't surprise me that Jan gains some efficiency from being attached to the pedal. I don't think I do. I certainly fall into the unracer camp and will keep on doing what I have

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Matthew J
It's totally normal to be skeptical when a magazine also has a sister company that sells bicycle components... However, the reason Compass exists is because we at Bicycle Quarterly wanted to put our research into practice and make the parts that we want to ride on our own bikes. We cannot

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Deacon Patrick
Just imagine how I made the real Patrick feel when I joined! Grin. With abandon, Patrick (who sometimes likes to look like the real Patrick by adding a long description to my signature just to mess with him. Grin.) On Friday, June 12, 2015 at 10:59:26 AM UTC-6, Clayton.sf wrote: Now we have

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Clayton.sf
Now we have two claytons! Will have to change my handle ;-) Clayton Scott SF, CA -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Matthew J
Does he not own Rene Herse? And sell his own randoneur frames? I thought he did. H. Well, you are going to have to H a little bit longer and harder. While Jan owns the name and sells components with it, Rene Herse branded randonneur frames are made and sold by Mike Kone and Mark

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Matthew J
But its cool to bite Jan's head off for something he does not do. On Friday, June 12, 2015 at 8:49:06 AM UTC-5, Ron Mc wrote: Clayton, I don't think your head should have been bitten off. It was a reasonable interrogatory. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-12 Thread Jan Heine
Clayton, No apologies necessary. You are right that a lot of brake judder can be cured with toe-in adjustment. However, on these carbon forks, even the most extreme toe-in doesn't solve the problem - we tried everything (including toe-out, different pads, etc.). On our first long ride on that

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread Richard
You said it Patrick, the ability to move ones feet while riding is a huge benefit. Even slight movements make a big difference. I don't get BQ's opening the lid analogy, nor do I understand this statement When my feet are firmly attached to the pedals, I may not actually pull up, but I am

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread Philip Williamson
Boat shoes would probably be fine. I rode in Ralph Lauren fake All-Stars high-top sneakers today, with thin wool socks. VP-001s with pins. What BMX pedals are you getting? I have a pair of silver VP-001s coming for the Ross C-Line makeover, but I'd like to upgrade another bike as well from

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread John
Patrick, 5-10 sneakers have been my favorites for years. I save a bunch of dough buying the close out models from the 5-10 web site at http://shopfiveten.com/C-44/Bike I especially like the ones with the sticky rubber soles because they grip even better when the pedals soles get wet. John

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread Patrick Moore
Richard: thanks. You pushed me over the edge. I plan to try flatties on the Fargo, but next month or so, since I've just dropped huge on my car, roof, hvac, cleaning, etc. Vaughn at Stevie's recommended some polycarbonate pedals list $22 that he says are fine and used by the BMX periti. So

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread Richard
Patrick, I think you'll love flatties. Plastic ones will do, just make sure they have pins on the flats. Your feet will never slip, even when wet. You really don't need special shoes for platforms. For hot summer days I ride in sandals, and sneakers in the cooler months. Try to find ones with a

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread Ron Mc
there is no question with platform pedals you give up pull with a high-rev spin up hills. But for me, the advantages of foot placement flexibility along with instant ingress and egress more than make up for it. If you're grunting on a 70-inch gear, you should stand up anyway and lose the

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread bertin753
I pull up especially when I'm grunting up a hill at very low cadence, which of course means standing and hauling on the bar. I'll see how much torque I lose with clipless-less-ness. Need closed shoes because of dirt and pebbles. Will look at 5-10 and also atGoodwill. Sent from my iPhone

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread Benz, Sunnyvale, CA
I'm a little late to this discussion, but can you please reconcile your claim about the lack of ability to put out power with BMX sprinting? These guys generate in excess of 1000 watts and don't have clipless pedals. They seem to be able to put down plenty of watts with very modest body weight.

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread 'clayton bailey' via RBW Owners Bunch
Does he not own Rene Herse? And sell his own randoneur frames? I thought he did. H. Clayton On Thursday, June 11, 2015 6:55 PM, Steve Palincsar palin...@his.com wrote: On 06/11/2015 11:38 AM, 'Clayton' via RBW Owners Bunch wrote (speaking of Jan Heine): He seemed infer

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread Steve Palincsar
On 06/11/2015 11:38 AM, 'Clayton' via RBW Owners Bunch wrote (speaking of Jan Heine): He seemed infer that judder in plastic bikes is incurable, but I think *he was just putting on a sales spin for his bikes.* What bikes would those be? Jan doesn't sell bikes at all. -- You received this

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread 'clayton bailey' via RBW Owners Bunch
Patrick, one of my favorite shoes I used back in my toe clip days, are skate shoes. They have grippy soles, padded toes and tongues and you can find them cheap at Payless or Target. However, currently my faves are 510s paired with big mountain bike pinned flats. They stick so well, that with a

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread 'Clayton' via RBW Owners Bunch
After riding clipless and toe clips since 1987, I wanted my spin to be more efficient, so I spent 3-1/2 years perfecting my spin, by pedaling a stationary bike, one legged on slippery flat pedals. The only time I have found clipless to be an advantage is when you need the extra horse

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-11 Thread John
I was disappointed in the piece. It just sounded like Jan's personal preference and that he needed more practice pedaling flat pedals to have an opinion worth sharing. I love 5-10 Sneakers the Riv Grip King pedals better than riding on VP Thin Gripsters or Vice pedals, but is that really

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-09 Thread Patrick Moore
I wonder if no-retention works best if you pedal small gears at a highish cadence, rather than if you mash. Can anyone comment on this? -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-09 Thread Deacon Patrick
I have no idea, Patrick. I ride the steep in SS but not with the weight you're talking about. And don't know how much I'd notice the ability to lift up on the rear pedal. With abandon, Patrick On Tuesday, June 9, 2015 at 1:56:20 PM UTC-6, Patrick Moore wrote: I shall have to try it. But what

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-09 Thread Deacon Patrick
Retention free works high or low cadence for me. When I read Jan's jar lid example, I thought Uh, pedal/handlebar does the same thing so I personally suspect less difference in efficiency than retention vs. body weight only. I'm not limited to my body weight on the downstroke when pulling up

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-09 Thread Garth
It makes zero difference to me :) I ride on the flats, sometime spinning sometimes mashing. Up the ubiquitous 20 something percent climbs , both seated and standing , makes no difference to me . I wonder how I put up with riding rock hard boards called cycling shoes for so long . My feet

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-09 Thread Garth
Of course after the test it was agreed that for racing, clipless is more practical and safe , with the violent efforts and all. So again, whatever suits your style :) -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-09 Thread Patrick Moore
I shall have to try it. But what about *really* steep hills? I find that I not only pull down on the bar, but pull up on the pedal. Would losing the last be a handicap? I mean such occasions as grunting a 40 lb load up a very steep 1/4 to 1/2 mile hill up the side of a mesa in a 70 gear. Again,

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-09 Thread Patrick Moore
Deacon: thanks. To turn the question around (for everyone): what are the *advantages* of riding no retention? I discount the reason given as no need for special shoes since I certainly wouldn't be cycling fixed or off road no-retention in Bass Weejuns on Tony Lamas or, for that matter, in Sperry

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-09 Thread Patrick Moore
And I am not secretly and snidely asserting that retention is better*. If no retention is proved to be more efficient, I'll drop my Keos and SPDs in a NY minute. But I *am* skeptical, since cycling and its related technology is after all very mature, and foot retention dates back well over 100

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-08 Thread Garth
Just Ride . . . . . and keep smiling Patrick Moore :-) -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to rbw-owners-bunch+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com. To

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-08 Thread Clayton.sf
Riding flats well after years of clip less is not something that happens over night. Different technique is needed and that comes with regular use. Quickly jumping on flats for a ride and drawing conclusions is likely too hasty an approach. Clayton Scott SF, CA -- You received this message

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-08 Thread Steve Palincsar
On 06/08/2015 12:02 PM, Garth wrote: What is everyone expecting ? Stating the obvious , whatever one chooses to use for pedals , let alone anything , they'll seek and find justification from wherever they can get it to support their choice, or they make up their own evidence . *No

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-08 Thread Garth
Just Ride . . . and Smile :) On Monday, June 8, 2015 at 12:23:37 PM UTC-4, Patrick Moore wrote: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-refuting_idea On Mon, Jun 8, 2015 at 10:02 AM, Garth gart...@gmail.com javascript: wrote: What is everyone expecting ? Stating the obvious , whatever

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-08 Thread Jan Heine
There seems to be a misunderstanding. We never advertised it as a study. I wrote in a blog comment that we tested some pedals with and without retention. I am sorry this was misunderstood as purporting to have done a scientific study, and then reported here as such. The article and test never

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-08 Thread Patrick Moore
Why haven't I received my copy??? I want it!! I had hoped this article reported a scientific study, but even if it don't, it will be interesting to read others' experiences on the matter. Me, riding fixed or, when using gears, not using them a great deal, I find that I do pull up hard on hills

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-08 Thread Ron Mc
From this distance, I'm still in awe of Anne's bike. But I had one of the best chats with a couple of roadies at yesterday's halfway stop that I can ever remember. These guys had followed me on my upright for 8 miles before they gained momentum to pass. As we came out of the creek bottom

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-08 Thread 'Mojo' via RBW Owners Bunch
I too was disappointed with the study. By study I thought Jan meant a scientific study where a hypotheses was rigorously tested with a repeatable methodology that would refine the hypothesis. Instead it was subjective with non-repeatable observations of how Jan reacted to a system that was

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-08 Thread Garth
What is everyone expecting ? Stating the obvious , whatever one chooses to use for pedals , let alone anything , they'll seek and find justification from wherever they can get it to support their choice, or they make up their own evidence . *No scientific study is or can be Absolutely

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-08 Thread Patrick Moore
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-refuting_idea On Mon, Jun 8, 2015 at 10:02 AM, Garth garth...@gmail.com wrote: What is everyone expecting ? Stating the obvious , whatever one chooses to use for pedals , let alone anything , they'll seek and find justification from wherever they can get

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-07 Thread Brian Hefferan
I like the two hands opening a jar lid analogy. Is power output really limited by the rider's body weight when using platform pedals, though? It seems that by pulling hard on the handlebars in rhythm with the pedal stroke, some of that force of can be added to the downward leg thrust. The arms

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-03 Thread Jayme Frye
Received my summer issue of BQ. I am disappointed with the published test. Not that the test does not support my position but that it was a seat-of-the-pants test. I was expecting/hoping for power outputs, VO2 charts, lactate threshold kinds of data. This is what I would expect from the BQ

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-06-03 Thread Jan Heine
I am sorry that there was a misperception that we did a detailed study of pedal retention. We tested a few pedals, both with and without retention, and the results were interesting. Whether a more rigorous study is needed when the results are so clear is another matter. To cite an even more

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-22 Thread Jack K
To illustrate what I find odd in Mike's post (below) I'll suggest the following modification of it. To be clear, this is suggested merely to illustrate a point and possibly foster useful discussion. On the lugged steel wannabe retro grouches... I see at least a dozen a day. I live in an aging

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-19 Thread Mike Shaljian
Perhaps Hanlon's Razor applies to this sticky situation: Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Matthew J
What's being debated is gender-based knowledge. Off topic for the list, no doubt, but mansplaining is definitely a well-documented phenomena. And while there certainly may be anecdotal counter narratives* of womansplaining, I find it incredibly hard to believe such activity comes anywhere

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Steve Palincsar
On 05/18/2015 11:13 AM, Anne Paulson wrote: On the other hand, some bikes are clearly chosen. If I see someone touring on a generic Surly Long Haul Trucker, well, that's a pretty common bike to tour on. But if I see someone touring on a singlespeed 'cross bike, I'm going to figure they chose to

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Will
That's true. But when I walked the babies I didn't think the advice that I received was ill-intentioned, nor did I get into a gender wrangle with it (or post to a use-group). I listened and hoped to learn something. Mostly I didn't (learn anything). But the point is: gender knowledge isn't

[RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Dave Redmon
The main reason I use straps with flat pedals is to retain control of the pedal when I come to a stop. When it comes time to go, I raise my foot and the pedal rises with it. It's quick, reliable and I avoid nicks and bruises to my shins. My pedals are MKS Tourists, which allow use of Power

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Anne Paulson
I don't want to get into an argument about whether a guy of my age would have gotten the same comments about clipless pedals. Maybe, maybe not. And I certainly believe that the comments were well-intentioned. But Will, I think you're missing the point. It's not about the cost of the item; it's

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Matthew J
It might simply be that the young man believed that clip-in pedals were more efficient. Whatever the rider thought, it was none of his business. On point - I tour with half clips and don't wear cycle specific clothing when touring. Two years back on a couple day tour from LaCrosse, Wi to

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Patrick Moore
Yanking the thread back to retentionless, Vaughn, the you 20-something mechanic as Stevie's says he rides nothing but platforms (what *is* the proper term for pedals with grippy flats but no clip mech? Non-no-clips?) and feels fully confident bombing at 35 mph down very rough tracks. He also says

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Patrick Moore
I think the incident was a huge opportunity for a magnificent put-down, something along the lines of, Joe Blow of Surly and I conferred about this build, and we both agreed with Tom Ritchey and Keith Bontrager that flat pedals work best for this setup. I must say it works for me; my last 3 customs

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Will
I dunno about this. I remember walking the babies in a backpack and stroller. It never failed that women (never men) would give unsolicited advice on things. Socks needed to be pulled up, hats needed adjusting, sun screen, and so forth. I never made it a gender issue. And I never thought

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Steve Palincsar
On 05/18/2015 01:24 PM, Mike Schiller wrote: ...of course we all must realize that the most well researched, carefully chosen, and costly bike/stroller may not be the best choice for a person/use. The person on their $5000+ carbon bike most likely feels that they made an informed decision

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Mike Schiller
...of course we all must realize that the most well researched, carefully chosen, and costly bike/stroller may not be the best choice for a person/use. The person on their $5000+ carbon bike most likely feels that they made an informed decision even though they would be more comfortable on

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Will
Anne, I think we agree. I watch folks on the bikepaths here riding $5K bikes. Yes... they went to the LBS and many of them got hosed. I had a young person give me the business last month. She was on an Orbea with all the go-fast bits. I was on my Atlantis (with fenders). She wanted to know

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Matthew J
Mansplaining is not well documented Google pulls up thousands of articles on the subject, many from respected outlets. I do not think bikes and strollers lack philosophical equivalence. Both are transport devices. Something is lost in translation here. -- You received this message

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Will
No and no. Mansplaining is not well documented... and it is exactly why I used the stroller example. Women are quite capable of gender indifference in giving advice. I do not think bikes and strollers lack philosophical equivalence. Both are transport devices. My point is: despite having

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Will
sigh On Monday, May 18, 2015 at 11:48:18 AM UTC-5, Matthew J wrote: Mansplaining is not well documented Google pulls up thousands of articles on the subject, many from respected outlets. I do not think bikes and strollers lack philosophical equivalence. Both are transport devices.

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Garth
On Monday, May 18, 2015 at 10:05:09 AM UTC-4, Matthew J wrote: It might simply be that the young man believed that clip-in pedals were more efficient. Whatever the rider thought, it was none of his business. Ultimately . . . . What someone else think of me is none of* my* business

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread cyclotour...@gmail.com
#interruptershaming On Monday, May 18, 2015 at 2:49:05 PM UTC-7, Mike Schiller wrote: Huh? I didn't say I ride an upright bike. On all 3 of my low trail custom's I have drop bars a inch or so below the saddle. I was referring to Mr P. On the carbon wannabe racers... I see at least a

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Mike Schiller
Huh? I didn't say I ride an upright bike. On all 3 of my low trail custom's I have drop bars a inch or so below the saddle. I was referring to Mr P. On the carbon wannabe racers... I see at least a dozen a day. I live along the coast in SoCal and they ride their bikes up and down all day

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Patrick Moore
Garth: what *I* think of you is very much your business! Over and out. For now. Patrick playing the age'd fool in ABQ, NM. On Mon, May 18, 2015 at 12:08 PM, Garth garth...@gmail.com wrote: On Monday, May 18, 2015 at 10:05:09 AM UTC-4, Matthew J wrote: It might simply be that the young

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Brewster Fong
On Monday, May 18, 2015 at 11:03:00 AM UTC-7, Steve Palincsar wrote: On 05/18/2015 01:24 PM, Mike Schiller wrote: ...of course we all must realize that the most well researched, carefully chosen, and costly bike/stroller may not be the best choice for a person/use. The person on

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Steve Palincsar
On 05/18/2015 04:42 PM, Brewster Fong wrote: On Monday, May 18, 2015 at 11:03:00 AM UTC-7, Steve Palincsar wrote: On 05/18/2015 01:24 PM, Mike Schiller wrote: ...of course we all must realize that the most well researched, carefully chosen, and costly bike/stroller may not be

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread John
Anne, I think my little cousin would have the best response in this situation: Talk to the hand! And I think Mr. Twain has the best advice for situations like this: “Never argue with stupid people, they will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience.” John On Saturday,

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-18 Thread Brewster Fong
On Monday, May 18, 2015 at 1:51:41 PM UTC-7, Steve Palincsar wrote: On 05/18/2015 04:42 PM, Brewster Fong wrote: On Monday, May 18, 2015 at 11:03:00 AM UTC-7, Steve Palincsar wrote: On 05/18/2015 01:24 PM, Mike Schiller wrote: ...of course we all must realize that the most well

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-17 Thread Anne Paulson
The belt drive is fantastic. The Thudbuster seat post is no longer on the bike. It turns out that with the small size of the bike and the big wheels, there is not enough room to use a bikepacking seatbag, so I installed a Nitto R10 rack. The R10 attaches to the seat post (look at the bike and tell

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-17 Thread Liesl
Anne (and Deacon Patrick), I think these kinds of comments and suggestions-- even though men get them too -- can be very gendered. I think a good way to think of it is: do women repeatedly and persistently receive and experience comments on a whole range of mechanical/engineering activities

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-17 Thread Mike Schiller
Anne, sounds like you have found a solution to carrying gear in the rear, but a few bag makers can produce small bikepacking seatbags. I had one made by Greg at Boulder Bags that will fit a french fit bike. It fits my summer sleeping bag and a bivy/tarp.

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-17 Thread Anne Paulson
Revelate makes smaller bikepacking seatbags-- but not small enough to fit my bike. And in any case, I don't want a tiny little bag, because I want to carry stuff in it. I'm not really a fan of bikepacking seatbags: they don't hold very much, they're hard to pack and unpack, and whatever you want

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-17 Thread Andrew Marchant-Shapiro
As I said in another forum apropos of something else--when people start explaining to you why you're doing something wrong and that something has no consequences for them one way or the other, you're into the land of religion. Avoid. On Saturday, May 16, 2015 at 10:09:13 AM UTC-4, Anne

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-17 Thread Tom Harrop
What a bike! How is the belt drive? Can't believe anyone would look at that and only be able to come up with you should ride clipless... -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-16 Thread Anne Paulson
Is this mansplaining, or does this happen to you, too: I was out riding my Surly Krampus on some fire roads that are, to be honest, too steep for me. So I was doing a lot of walking. But that's OK, I don't mind walking. At the top, I came upon three guys who had ridden up the other side, the

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-16 Thread Derek Simmons
It was NOT because you didn't share genders with the those other riders; it was because you didn't have the same gear and the same bike worldview--and they would have gone off on any one riding your rig, not because the rider was different, but because the ride was. On Sat, May 16, 2015 at 10:09

Re: [RBW] Re: BQ to publish study of pedal retention usefulness in Summer issue

2015-05-16 Thread Eric Norris
Speaking as a rider who uses clipless pedals and shoes, I certainly appreciate this, and I'm sure that riders of flat pedals will extend this courtesy to me. Same goes, I would hope, for Lycra vs loose shorts, jersey vs non-jersey, bar height, etc., etc. We all put a lot of thought into where

  1   2   >