Stephen wrote:
> Frank, > > before I begin my commentary on your "authoritative" analysis of cs > products, I thought I'd just remind you of [what all of us can appreciate, > objectively] the definition of a fanatic. It is: "one who has lost sight of > his objective ....but redoubles his efforts." [attributed to an anonymous > Frenchman] > > For it seems that you have lost sight of the purpose of all our efforts -- > the baseline efficacy of CS materials, and how to get there. This principal > issue is one you never address. I have to tell you: it is the primary > something that drives our efforts here. I think we have a handle on that in > our lab; we often do comparative bacteriology so as to make such > determinations. You presuppose that in vitro tests have some relevance to what colloidal silver does in the body. It clearly does not. In the body there are chloride ions that render silver ions into silver chloride that has no known antibacterial properties. If one were really interested in testing efficacy, the tests would be conducted in a solution whose chemical components closely simulate blood serum. > Having spoken with one of the scientists at Malvern Instruments today, it > was made quite clear to me that the Zetasizer is NOT intended for particle > characterization, only size distribution and for "bulk analysis" at that! > .....ie. for distribution of particles of greater size than those found in a > fine colloid. The machine may be spec'd down to 2nm at the small end, but > he [the scientist] was reluctant to say how near that end it can accurately > get..... Please provide the name of the Malvern scientist you spoke with. If there are 2 nm particles in the colloid, the Zetasizer has no problem finding them. I have prepared a sample colloid having such particles and have run the size distribution plot to demonstrate it. See the plot at: http://www.silver-colloids.com/Misc/Smalltest.html > Furthermore, he opined that TEM is a very useful complement -- how did he > put it? "a valuable supplement" -- to the Zetasizer, esp. for particle > characterization AND measurement of nanometer sized particles, and for all > such particles that are visible by TEM but may NOT be to a Zetasizer. The > Malvern instrument does not present itself as for Particle Characterization. A TEM is useful to observer small particles ONLY in solutions that do not have a high ionic content. For solutions with high ionic content (like most silver colloids), the formation of compounds during sample preparation creates a such vast number of particles of the compound that any meaningful observation of the original particles is improbable. More information on this is found on the I suspect that you failed to mention to the Malvern scientist that your solutions were highly ionic. > As happens often with colloids that contain very small particles, > 'particulate' configurations that appear to be spherical 'semi-agglomerates' > may present such a face to laser diffraction that they are taken for > particles when, in fact, they are not! .... This in clear juxtaposition to > the oceans of tiny particles that are just too small for the Zetasizer to > even 'see'. Though the semi-agglomerates may be actually comprised of the > same discrete particles that are similar to those circulating freely, the > Zetasizer sees ONLY the semi-agglomerates and takes them for giant > particles, while we see the discrete particles within them by TEM. > Exceptionally fine colloids [and the micrographs of them, such as those on > our website], are endowed with particles in the nanometer sized class, or > less, But these don't even show up on your printout as part of the > distribution curve! Because the Zetasizer cannot see them at all! You claim such particles exist. In my opinion, what your TEM images show is silver oxide particles formed when the water was evaporated from a solution containing a high concentration of silver ions. What the images prove, is that large quantities of silver compounds are formed when the water is evaporated from a highly ionic solution, and these particles can be observed on a TEM. > So, then, the oceans of tiny particles that are characteristic of a fine > colloid are the same that are seen in such spherical semi-agglomerates. That > they are drawn together, upon close examination and yet remain distinct, > still repelling each other ....is an interesting phenomenon. They appear > only just able to resist the attractive force drawing them into such > spherical configurations by so remaining distinct. But the Zetasizer cannot > see or make this distinction. > > The Zetasizer cannot distinguish the discrete particles because they are too > small for it, just like the oceans of free particles. So it says the > distribution only includes the phantom image you are taking literally to > mean they are particles of such and such size. Were these actual particles > of the magnitude your machine describes, the 'solution' harboring them would > have the characteristic colors appropriate to those large sizes -- namely > yellow to red to green. Distinguishing discrete particles is of no importance. What is important is determining the particle size distribution in the aggregate, which is the task for which the Zetasizer was designed. > As well, the Malvern scientist could not assure me absolutely that there is > no magnetic energy created by the machine, and we already know that the > finer the colloid, the more magnetic fields impact it..... > > I'm sorry, Frank, the analyses you present on your website -- of commercial > products -- just doesn't 'cut it'. We've also looked at the other cs > products you've "analysed", and find your similar FAILURES with them as > well. And, really, if you reflect upon it, you just can't suggest there are > micron-sized particles in those colloids! First of all, because you could > almost see them with the naked eye, or at least with a laser -- as they > would look like huge arc-lit sparklets in a laser beam. Which is patently > not so! And there would also be color ....which there is not! If you can see micron sized particles with the naked eye, you have the best eyes on earth, not to mention being able to see bacteria cells without a microscope. What looks "like huge arc-lit sparklets in a laser beam" is not micron sized particles, but very large aggregated particles that will soon settle out. > Furthermore, I do not doubt that the CSPro product has been characterized by > other TEM labs and is in possession of very different results than those you > have tendered for the size and distribution of its particles. I'm sure the > other 'analyses' will support my contention that there are alot of 2nm to > 5nm particles in iot, NONE of which you show. And the giant particles your > analysis describes -- 500nm -- do not exist except as the semi-agglomerates > previously described -- which your machine cannot discern. Yes, there are > particles in the 30 to 85nm range and they do show up, in quantity, and on > your size distribution, but the overall analysis is faulty AND clearly > lacking in comprehensiveness. Again, TEM images of highly ionic solutions are not usable for determining the size of particles in the original solution. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. In our opinion, our test suite provides the most objective evaluation of the physical properties of the colloids available anywhere. > With respect to the other cs product, your machine again misses the 2nm to > 5nm particles that are very present. And the gross sizes you describe are > once again those ephemeras, the semi-agglomerates. > Stephen See the Smalltest plot described above that demonstrates 2 nm particles are easily detectable. As I see it, your complaints center around the fact that our scientific equipment does not confirm the claims you make for your product. You claim to have nanometer size particles that the Zetasizer is unable to see, however, it is able to see the nanometer size particles in the smalltest colloid sample without a problem. This may have more to do with unsubstantiated claims than faulty scientific measurements. We perform a uniform set of measurements in an exact and repeatable way on all the products tested in order to determine the physical properties of the colloidal solutions in an objective fashion. The overwhelming majority of the feedback we are getting on the product analysis is positive. Those visiting our site have expressed their opinion that this type of objective analysis of greatly appreciated and long overdue. Over time we hope to test every available commercial product. frank key -- The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver. To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: [email protected] -or- [email protected] with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line. To post, address your message to: [email protected] Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>

