As we all know, a water flow tests automatically picks up the other  
demands on the system.  The problem is when a loop is being installed  
to feed multiple planned buildings on one site.  My first point is  
that it is the EOR's (ok, the sub- engineer) job to size the site main  
and to tell the contractor the available water supply to be used.   
WHEN the contractor accepts the role of defining the water supply for  
their sprinkler system from a facility loop that is yet to be  
installed (getting dangerously close to performing the E word and  
arguable outside the scope of 13R), how can they not include the  
domestic impact on that loop?  The challenge is defining that volume.   
Why would one take the demand for one building then multiple it by the  
number of buildings. Sure it SOUNDS logical but it's insane (as shown  
by Eric's example).  Having noticed that as the size of the building  
increases, the volume for the individual units goes down and for  
really large buildings there is a huge difference.  Wouldn't it seem  
appropriate to treat all the other building in the entire complex as  
one big building and define the volume that way?

Roland

On Dec 2, 2009, at 5:32 AM, Eric Tysinger wrote:

> These are all valid points that can be or maybe should be  
> considered, however none of these requirements are in any codebooks.  
> The original question was what exactly is the requirement as stated  
> by NFPA 13R. It gives diagrams for specific examples of preferred  
> and acceptable arrangements for water supply connections. It also  
> uses one of these diagrams to show an example of a shared connection  
> between a fire and domestic line.
>
> We did a 52 building, multi-family site a year or so back. The site  
> was actually planned for 104 buildings. Each building had  
> approximately 100gpm domestic allowance. So what I am gathering for  
> these posts is that I should have accounted for 104000 gpm? Even at  
> the number of buildings we actually did it would have been 5200gpm.  
> I'm sorry but this really sounds way off and definitely not covered  
> by 13R.
>
> Thanks,
> Eric Tysinger CET

_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
[email protected]
http://fireball.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum

For Technical Assistance, send an email to: [email protected]

To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[email protected]
(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)

Reply via email to