in theory yes, I have reached mapbox several times of clients of theirs that are not complying with ODbL or to their terms of service. they either stop replying, doesn't get fixed (Strava example) or gets fix after sending 9 emails during two months. this last example was regarding Livestream, a Vimeo company that even replied to me stating they weren't using OSM (when they were using Mapbox Street tiles without the reasonable calculated Mapbox logo, so I assume they were premium clients or whatever they call it at mapbox. had to explain that that doesn't not entitle them not to attribute OSM. his has been shared on other threads on mailing lists.
As Kathleen mentioned on other topics, including this one, it's their client responsibility for the lack of attribution not mapbox. end result of all this, no ones fault and everything remains the same. On Thu, 31 Oct 2019, 11:43 Jeffrey Friedl, <jfri...@yahoo.com> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > do a search for Strava on social media images, on twitter as examples: > > > > https://twitter.com/MissJKirby/status/1189164486252515333?s=09 > > Ah, I see, I thought you were referencing a screenshot from the app, but > that > seems to be an image made explicitly for posting on Twitter. One imagines > that > Strava hasn't built a map renderer just to make Twitter images, so > probably the > images are sourced from somewhere (Mapbox, Google, etc.). If the > underlying > data originates from OSM, someone indeed should be putting the attribution. > > > following your mindset, we should blame the map provider (Mapbox) and > not the company that uses the maps. > > I don't know that it's a "mindset". The person using OSM data has the > responsibility to attribute, no? > > If Mapbox is not putting attributions, it would be a surprise. Can you > show a specific example where > Mapbox is providing OSM-derived maps without attribution? (If it's not > apparent from the example > that it's Mapbox providing OSM-derived maps, please be sure to cite your > evidence that that's what > we're seeing). > > Jeffrey > > >
_______________________________________________ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
