Den mån 4 okt. 2021 kl 15:57 skrev Mark Phippard <markp...@gmail.com>:
> On Sun, Oct 3, 2021 at 7:17 PM Sean McBride <s...@rogue-research.com> > wrote: > > > On Sun, 3 Oct 2021 09:07:04 -0400, Mark Phippard said: > > > > >Homebrew and MacPorts are both listed. > > > > I saw that, but I thought they required Xcode... > > > > >Honestly once those projects > > >supported SVN it kind of removed all of the incentive to publish a > > >package. That is why we stopped providing one from CollabNet and > > >removed our listing from that page. I would guess it had to do with > > >why WanDisco stopped too. > > > > I see. Do you agree Wandisco's should be removed from the website > listing at this point? > > If they no longer intend to provide newer versions then yes I think it > should be removed. I would prefer someone else do it though simply > because I used to work for a competitor of WanDisco and would not want > anyone there to think that was a motive. I tried to remove any > CollabNet package from this page that we were no longer maintaining, > such as when we stopped providing new binaries for OSX and Solaris. I don't pretend to know anything about Macos, but WANdisco is providing Subversion 1.10.6 for Mac OS 10.9. Is that version of Mac OS supported by Fink/Homebrew/MacPorts? If not, then I think it is reasonable to keep the link - at least until 1.10 is EOL (or we find a client side security issue in 1.10, there was a CVE fix in 1.10.7 but only server side). By the way, the situation for Linux and Windows is just the same so we should make the same decision for all platforms. Checking further, CollabNet is providing packages for 1.12.2. That one is for sure EOL. I downloaded and installed Subversion Edge 5.2.4, which seems to contain Apache HTTP Server 2.4.39 and Subversion 1.8.19. It is not evident to me if CollabNet is providing any Subversion services in any other product. Cornerstone was last updated 2019-12-31 so it is based on either 1.13.0 or 1.10.6 if they used the lastest version on the time of release. As for VersionsApp it seems current and active and I can't see any reason not including it. If "only providing outdated versions" is a reason for de-listing then sadly both CollabNet and WANdisco should go (at least when 1.10 is EOL). I can edit the website but I'd appreciate if anyone else in PMC would give their opinion on policy. Kind regards Daniel Sahlberg
