a.ashfield <a.ashfi...@verizon.net> wrote: It is not worth my time to determine the time sequence. I didn't think > Murray was allowed in the plant until after the test . . . >
You are wrong about that. In any case, many other people were in the plant, and they asked the same questions. > . . . and I expect Penon knew he was hostile by then. > Penon's opinion of Murray is irrelevant! Penon was being paid to provide information and to answer questions. He had a contractual obligation to answer whether he thought people were nice or naughty. > So even if he didn't know of the pending court case he probably didn't > feel inclined to answer a third party's request for info. > Third party?!? What are you talking about? Murray worked for I.H. That is abundantly clear from the Answer, and from Exhibit 19. In it, Vaughn wrote: "Also, I would like to introduce you to one of our new team members, Joe Murray." Have you done your homework on this? Have you read the documents? - Jed
