From: Jed Rothwell
* You proposed a preposterous theory that different super-nova produce elements different isotopic ratios. This is not a theory. It is known fact. It is not my proposal. It is seen every day in cosmology. Every supernova is different and even in any one, like the one that preceded our sun, after the initial coalescence of elements, isotopes were redistributed among the planets according to mass, and the isotopic composition of elements varies slightly from planet to planet. EVEN IN OUR SOLAR SYSTEM. To suggest earth could have a "universal" ratio of isotopes is beyond preposterous since it is not even the same between planets !!! * Anyone reviewing the astronomical data on isotopes, going back to the 1940s, would know that is wrong. You must have gone absolutely NUTS. You are so completely wrong that you must have no understanding of this subject at all. What data? I challenge you to present a single piece of real evidence for Universal isotope ratios. * So far you have added the most misinformation and mistaken information to this particular subject, but I am not sick with laughter. You should be sick with embarrassment! . and to look like such a uneducated and yet vocal proponent - for this field of LENR. I am ashamed, for the entire field, that you are so misinformed on this important point, and not just that - so stubbornly misinformed. This casts a shadow over everything you have said about Rossi. Jones