From: Jed Rothwell Do you realize how silly you are sounding on every incremental try - with this nonsense?
* I know how improbable this is. I know it just as well as you do. So do E&K. However, unlike you, we will wait to see what the data reveals. No matter how improbable it may seem, it cannot be 100% ruled out by theory, only by experiment. You say that's nonsense but people such as Kullander and I call it science. If that were true, then why did no Kullander say up front, "yes I know that copper can migrate easily, that the patent clearly states "nickel in a copper tube" and that we found the isotope distribution was completely natural" <insert Jon Stewart sly grin > . and the great Dr Kullander continues: "yet even so, we decided to issue the headline that this proves a nuclear source for the reaction - for the reason that we want this be true, and lacking real proof, we kinda threw it in there.." * we are not idiots or senile; we just have a different world-view than you do. On that point we are in full agreement. Jones
