Re: Milan Rai on UN occupation of Iraq

2004-03-28 Thread Chris Doss
The opinion polls in Chechnya show (rebel leader) Aslan Maskhadov and (pro-Moscow Chechen president) Aslan Kadyrov as being viewed with about equally phenomenal levels of dislike. Maskhadov has an about 1% approval rating. It's rough being a warlord. :) As I recall the polls showed more

Computer outsourcing to Russia.

2004-03-28 Thread Chris Doss
1) I don't know how the hell Tahoo is going to compete with Yandex.ru and Rambler.ru, which are entrenched in the Russian market and giant. 2) I don't get how computers are a luxury in Russia. Most everybody I know has one. Hell, you can use one in an Internet cafe in Moscow for $1 an hour,

Re: Milan Rai on UN occupation of Iraq

2004-03-28 Thread Louis Proyect
Chris Doss wrote: The opinion polls in Chechnya show (rebel leader) Aslan Maskhadov and (pro-Moscow Chechen president) Aslan Kadyrov as being viewed with about equally phenomenal levels of dislike. Maskhadov has an about 1% approval rating. It's rough being a warlord. :) Is this an endorsement of

Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Louis Proyect
NY Newsday, March 28, 2004 How your job may go abroad BY JAMES T. MADORE AND PRADNYA JOSHI Staff Writer The Bank of New York plans to send 250 technology jobs from Manhattan and elsewhere in the country to India. The accounting firm Marcum Kliegman LLP, with offices in Woodbury and Manhattan, is

Consolidating control

2004-03-28 Thread Marvin Gandall
The US has taken steps to ensure it controls Iraq through its future army even after it formally transfers political sovereignty to a civilian government, reports todays Washington Post. The Post says the US is creating an Iraqi defence department modelled on the Pentagon, and is presently

A Green Party mayor

2004-03-28 Thread Louis Proyect
NY Times, March 28, 2004 Mayor With a Mission By ROBERT SULLIVAN Jason West, the mayor of the little Hudson Valley village of New Paltz who married 25 gay couples last month before receiving a court injunction to stop, has been thinking about gay marriage for a long time. In fact, immediately

Re: Milan Rai on UN occupation of Iraq

2004-03-28 Thread Chris Doss
Incidentally there is an interview with Kadyrov right here (edited by moi): http://www.untimely-thoughts.com/index.html?cat=Aug%202,%202003type=3art=138. As far as I know it is the only time he has ever been interviewed by a Westerner. It is pre-2003 election.

Re: Milan Rai on UN occupation of Iraq

2004-03-28 Thread Chris Doss
You mean on the part of the Chechen population? Hard to say. My impression is that the majority of the population is very tired of being caught in a cross-fire bewteen trigger-happy, panicky Russian conscripts and jihadi nutballs and will accept anything that will get them out of the situation.

Re: Milan Rai on UN occupation of Iraq

2004-03-28 Thread Louis Proyect
Chris Doss wrote: You mean on the part of the Chechen population? Hard to say. My impression is that the majority of the population is very tired of being caught in a cross-fire bewteen trigger-happy, panicky Russian conscripts and jihadi nutballs and will accept anything that will get them out of

new elite in UK

2004-03-28 Thread Chris Burford
Wealthy individuals and corporations no longer need representatives in Parliament or government to safeguard their interests and swing votes. A few rich men sit in the Commons, including Archie Norman, the former chairman of Asda supermarkets, and Michael Ancram, heir to the Marquess of Lothian,

Re: Computer outsourcing to Russia.

2004-03-28 Thread joanna bujes
C'mon Chris, it's you who taught me that Moscow isn't Russia. Different living standards, different access to technology, etc. Joanna Chris Doss wrote: 1) I don't know how the hell Tahoo is going to compete with Yandex.ru and Rambler.ru, which are entrenched in the Russian market and giant. 2)

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread joanna bujes
Some experts see benefits being derived from outsourcing. Exporting routinized jobs such as programming can lower costs for companies and give them the cash to invest in higher-skilled, more innovative jobs in the United States. _ This is such a joke. I won't even comment about

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Devine, James
is it possible that a lot of the out-sourcing is a substitute for importing skilled workers (under the special visas whose name I've forgotten) to do the work here? Jim D. -Original Message- From: joanna bujes [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sun 3/28/2004 9:44

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Doug Henwood
joanna bujes wrote: More interesting is the thesis that outsourcing is profitable for hi-tech companies. I wonder how they figure out that profit. The very large hi tech company I work for has outsourced a number of projects to India and China. I know first hand that the results of this

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread joanna bujes
Glad to hear it. If I told you the actual details of these disasters, you would not believe it...plus it would take a lot of time. The truth is they don't have a clue on how to manage intellectual labor. They try to do it as it were an assembly line. Doesn't work. Offsourcing Hi-tech means

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Doug Henwood
joanna bujes wrote: The efficacy of the capitalist model is more myth than fact. Compared to what? It's hard to argue with its capacity to grow, innovate, and produce cheaper commodities over the centuries - at a high social and ecological cost, for sure, but I don't think you can win the

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Anthony D'Costa
Not really. Initially the H1 and L1 visas facilitated the temporary and some permanent import of skilled workers. This was pre-Y2K era on-site work. The work was largely low-end--maintenance, debugging, some nominal systems integration. Physical presence was vital. Now with learning and

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread jjlassen
joanna bujes wrote: The truth is they don't have a clue on how to manage intellectual labor. They try to do it as it were an assembly line. Doesn't work. Offsourcing Hi- tech means managing intellectual labor accross great geographical, cultural, and sometimes linguistic divides. Not what I would

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Ted Winslow
Doug Henwood wrote: Compared to what? It's hard to argue with its capacity to grow, innovate, and produce cheaper commodities over the centuries - at a high social and ecological cost, for sure, but I don't think you can win the efficiency argument from the left. It has to be on other grounds.

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread joanna bujes
Doug Henwood wrote: Compared to what? It's hard to argue with its capacity to grow, innovate, and produce cheaper commodities over the centuries - at a high social and ecological cost, for sure, but I don't think you can win the efficiency argument from the left. It has to be on other grounds. I

Re: Job loss

2004-03-28 Thread dmschanoes
Compared to what? It's hard to argue with its capacity to grow,innovate, and produce cheaper commodities over the centuries - at ahigh social and ecological cost, for sure, but I don't think you canwin the "efficiency" argument from the left. It has to be on othergrounds.

classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread Craven, Jim
Title: Message I ask my students what "Omission is often the greatest lie" means. I ask them if they are just picking up a book for the first time, written by an author with whom they are unfamiliar, how do you get a sense of that the author's ideological biases and rhetorical intentions

Re: classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread Craven, Jim
-Original Message- From: PEN-L list [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of joanna bujes Sent: Sunday, March 28, 2004 12:30 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [PEN-L] classroom exercise So you're punishing your students because most economic text books are biased? If I were your

Re: classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread Craven, Jim
So you're punishing your students because most economic text books are biased? If I were your student, I'd be pissed at you. Joanna Response Jim C: All texts are biased; the only persons not biased (having preferences for certain outcomes, priorities etc) are those in comas and/or without

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Michael Perelman
The current explanation that job flight this response to improved technology races to questions for me. Virtually every economics textbook I have seen dismisses the idea that new technology can destroy jobs. The most reputable counterargument came from David Ricardo in the 19th-century. Few

Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread Craven, Jim
Title: Message Tomorrow, when I go back to the classroom, as I have done on other occasions, each of my classes will be told that during the course of the term, there will be four key lectures whose content will most definitely be covered on exams. These lectures will be total bullshit:

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Doug Henwood
Michael Perelman wrote: Supposedly, new technology lowers prices, which spurs new demand, which reemploy as the workers. I'm not saying I accept this argument, but I have not seen many economists eating crow. Several centuries of capitalist history are on the side of the non-crow-eaters, no? I

one more classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread Craven, Jim
Title: Message I give my students the famous quote from Lenin (that's Vladimir not John) :"When it comes time to hang the last capitalist, he is probably the one who sold the rope." I ask what that means. Eventually, with some probing, they get the idea that what Lenin meant through his

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread dmschanoes
Supposedly, new technology lowers prices, which spurs new demand, which reemploy as the workers. I'm not saying I accept this argument, but I have not seen many economists eating crow. ___- That's Panglossian political economy. The destruction or creation of jobs is not a

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread jjlassen
Hi Michael, I think the jury's still out on this one. In certain national contexts (usually advanced capitalist ones), the economists are probably not eating crow. (Basso's work shows that working-time is increasing in advanced capitalism) At the global scale, (the only proper level to examine

Re: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread joanna bujes
That's fucked. You have all the power and you're using it to humiliate your students. Great. Joanna Craven, Jim wrote: Tomorrow, when I go back to the classroom, as I have done on other occasions, each of my classes will be told that during the course of the term, there will be four key lectures

Re: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread Michael Perelman
cool it. On Sun, Mar 28, 2004 at 02:04:52PM -0800, joanna bujes wrote: That's fucked. You have all the power and you're using it to humiliate your students. Great. Joanna Craven, Jim wrote: Tomorrow, when I go back to the classroom, as I have done on other occasions, each of my classes

Re: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread Craven, Jim
That's fucked. You have all the power and you're using it to humiliate your students. Great. Joanna Response: I can see from your previous comments ( So you're punishing your students because most economic text books are biased? If I were your student, I'd be pissed at you. Joanna) that you are

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Michael Perelman
That is the standard answer in the economic literature. What would have happened in the post-World War II American economy without the federal government to prop up the job market? On Sun, Mar 28, 2004 at 04:09:23PM -0500, Doug Henwood wrote: Michael Perelman wrote: Supposedly, new

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Doug Henwood
Michael Perelman wrote: That is the standard answer in the economic literature. What would have happened in the post-World War II American economy without the federal government to prop up the job market? It's always some prop, isn't it? This idea that capitalism would have failed 10, 40, 100,

Re: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread joanna bujes
My apologies, I thought you did not tell the students that some of the lectures were bullshit. Joanna Craven, Jim wrote: That's fucked. You have all the power and you're using it to humiliate your students. Great. Joanna Response: I can see from your previous comments ( So you're punishing your

Re: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread Craven, Jim
Thank you. All of my exercises are designed to reward and teach those who take an active interest in their education and to weed out--and deny rewards to--those who don't. On another list, someone made the following comment followed by my response. Please note that I am actually diminishing my

Re: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread MICHAEL YATES
I visited Jim Craven's classes (huge classes, and he has to teach a lot of them to make ends meet) last December. The students were curious and asked me good questions. They had an obvious affection for Jim and he for them (Students wanted to see him after class, and he seemed overly

Re: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread joanna bujes
Certainly, I believe every word you say. His reaction to my misunderstanding however spoke volumes too. Joanna MICHAEL YATES wrote: I visited Jim Craven's classes (huge classes, and he has to teach a lot of them to make ends meet) last December. The students were curious and asked me good

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread ravi
Doug Henwood wrote: joanna bujes wrote: More interesting is the thesis that outsourcing is profitable for hi-tech companies. I wonder how they figure out that profit. The very large hi tech company I work for has outsourced a number of projects to India and China. I know first hand that the

Re: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread Louis Proyect
I visited Jim Craven's classes (huge classes, and he has to teach a lot of them to make ends meet) last December. The students were curious and asked me good questions. Michael Yates A couple of years ago when I was on the phone with Jim a lot discussing Blackfoot and related issues, I often

Re: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread Craven, Jim
Certainly, I believe every word you say. His reaction to my misunderstanding however spoke volumes too. Joanna Yes, it is a kind of Blackfoot thing. When attacked, and it is clear that the attack comes from someone not having properly read and understood that which they were attacking, then the

Re: Milan Rai on UN occupation of Iraq

2004-03-28 Thread Sabri Oncu
Since you clearly don't want to read the actual poll, let me supply some highlights for you. These results don't sound like they're coming from people too terrified to speak their minds. Doug Here is one input from one of those from that part of the world, who is not terrified to speak his

Re: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread MICHAEL YATES
While Zizek's behavior is reprehensible, especially given that his teaching duties are almost certainly minimal, it is not uncommon that when teachers get burned out, they start to take short cuts. These are often indirectly encouraged by the administration which cuts funding for teaching,

Final response: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread Craven, Jim
Title: Message While Zizek's behavior is reprehensible, especially given that his teaching duties are almost certainly minimal, it is not uncommon that when teachers get burned out, they start to take short cuts. These are often indirectly encouraged by the administration which

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread joanna bujes
ravi wrote: i am not an expert on the matter, so this is just my opinion: i believe the above effect is temporary. programming is not difficult and it is well suited for outsourcing. those going through outsourcing disaster will learn from their mistakes... already, i know of many fellow indians

Swans March 29, 2004

2004-03-28 Thread Louis Proyect
http://www.swans.com/ March 29, 2004 -- In this issue: Note from the Editor:The new Iraqi Constitution was heralded as a great achievement just a couple of weeks ago but they forgot their own Bill of Rights. So, the Coalition Provisional Authority, which represents the best democratic

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Louis Proyect
Yeah, that's an incredible salary. I know some top flight programmers with eons of experience...none of whom make more than 130,000. Joanna The article is probably bullshit. It reminds me of those articles about auto workers who make that kind of money, or other skilled blue-collar workers. It

Fundrace.org

2004-03-28 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
http://www.fundrace.org/ -- Yoshie * Bring Them Home Now! http://www.bringthemhomenow.org/ * Calendars of Events in Columbus: http://sif.org.ohio-state.edu/calendar.html, http://www.freepress.org/calendar.php, http://www.cpanews.org/ * Student International Forum: http://sif.org.ohio-state.edu/ *

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Waistline2
In a message dated 3/28/2004 3:28:28 PM Central Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: That's Panglossian political economy. The destruction or creation ofjobs is not a technical function, but a social one. The expulsion oflabor power from the production process is essential to

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread joanna bujes
You're saying that writing a program or creating a software product in three different countries is no different than creating a pre-fabricated house in three different countries: the roof in the US, the window frames in China, and the walls in India. I think though that fitting a pre-fabricated

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread dmschanoes
The great, sort of, and humbling, definitely, thing about a market economy is that it puts a dollar sign alongside all endeavors and makes them equivalent in that great democracy of the world market where lawyers, guns, and money make sure your vote counts because they're doing the counting. So

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread ravi
joanna bujes wrote: You're saying that writing a program or creating a software product in three different countries is no different than creating a pre-fabricated house in three different countries: the roof in the US, the window frames in China, and the walls in India. I think though that

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread Louis Proyect
Ravi wrote: in some cases, this complexity is willful... take the current obsession with XML and building layers and layers on top of it. Sounds like the project I'm working on, which combines websphere, XML, Struts, java and javascript. It has taken me a year to figure out how all the pieces fit

Re: Job flight

2004-03-28 Thread joanna bujes
ravi wrote: come on now. its not about your job against my job, and i am not trying to defend indian programmers or some such identity group. if i do go back, i hope i will be more empowered to participate in the real world, rather than have to sit in a cube and write uninspiring software. No,

Commendante Fidel

2004-03-28 Thread paul phillips
Just finished watching the two hour documentary on CBC Newsworld by Oliver Stone on El Commendante, Fidel Castro, which I understand was commissioned by HBO but censored in the United States because it was not critical of Castro. (It has been subtitled, Lunch with Fidel). Actually, it was very

Re: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread paul phillips
While Michael is undoubtedly right, university administrations reward those who do research and slight teaching. But that is no excuse for teachers to neglect their moral responsibility to teach properly and to serve their students. I think Jim was once a student of mine and I hope he never

Re: Another classroom exercise

2004-03-28 Thread joanna bujes
Zizek has a life-long sinecure and subminimal teaching duties. If the story is true, there is no excuse. On the other hand, if such is his character, perhaps it is best that students get to know him through his books rather than in person. Joanna paul phillips wrote: While Michael is undoubtedly

Re: Computer outsourcing to Russia.

2004-03-28 Thread Chris Doss
Well, yeah. There's no comparing Moscow and say Yakutia. They're different worlds. It's like comparing New York and Appalachia. Worse. -Original Message- From: joanna bujes [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Sun, 28 Mar 2004 09:26:59 -0800 Subject: Re: [PEN-L] Computer