On Tue, May 16, 2017 at 7:19 AM, Peter Gutmann <[email protected]> wrote:
> Ryan Sleevi <[email protected]> writes: > > >Mozilla updates every six to eight weeks. And that works. That's all that > >matters for this discussion. > > Do all the world's CAs know this? Does that matter, if all participants in Mozilla's Root Program _could_ know this? I can't help but feel you're raising concerns that aren't relevant. Perhaps I didn't explain sufficiently why even if a client takes a single copy of the Mozilla root store and *never updates after that*, things could still work for 20+ years for those clients, and with reduced risk for Mozilla users. I feel like if that point had been clearer, perhaps you would understand why it could fly. Perhaps you're confused and think the roots themselves have 5 year validity (e.g. notBefore to notAfter). That's also not what I said - I said bound the time for inclusion of that root in Mozilla products. They're very different things, you see, and the latter doesn't prescribe the validity period of the root - precisely so it can support such broken 'legacy' cases without requiring too much of the world to adopt modern security practices. That said, Mozilla's mission to ensure the Internet is a global public resource that is safe would, among other things, entitle them to push this particular vision, since it would help make users safe. However, I merely proposed a smaller step in that. Perhaps you could re-read the proposal with a fresh perspective, as I hope it might become clearer how it could address many of these issues. As it relates to the topic at hand, by limiting the lifetime of the roots themselves, it reduces the risk/need to impose additional contraints - there are fewer legacy roots, they're bounded in validity period, and things move onward towards distrust much easier. That does seem a net-positive for the ecosystem. _______________________________________________ dev-security-policy mailing list [email protected] https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-security-policy

