Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-06 Thread Dana Tierney
> Never happen. The tobacco and alcohol lobbies (drugs that they are) want to have > the market all to themselves. Even if there was a law allowing certain narcotics > and controlling their use, it may not solve much of the crime. > I believe it would reduce the murder rate in DC by at LEAST half.

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-06 Thread Dana Tierney
::blinks:: Bill was in Lorton? Evil place. Dana Haggerty, Mike writes: > Too bad they didn't have this in place when you did that stint in > Lorton, Bill. > > Are you still walking crooked? > > M > > > -Original Message- > > From: Bill Wheatley [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > Sent: Fri

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread S . Isaac Dealey
Yea, I noticed the tongue-in-cheekness of it... I realize I'm an idealist ... I just think that the only reason people commit crime is because there's incentive to ... I'm sure similar thoughts go through the mind of corporate executives committing fraud as through petty burgalars and car theives.

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Doug White
nt: Friday, September 05, 2003 2:22 PM Subject: Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act | Amnesty International (not sure about American Amnesty) has a standing | argument with Texas (along with other states and the federal government) | for its use of the death penalty. | | - Jim | | Angel Stewart

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Jim Campbell
That overwhelming evidence, even, can be less than clear-cut. What was overwhelming evidence a handful of years ago is blown away by DNA testing, resulting in a surprising number of people released from jail after tests are done, sometimes more than 10-15 years after that person was found guil

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Michael Dinowitz
> 1. Make drugs legal. This would deal with the vast majority of the > "non-violent" offenders we have in prisons, it would also lessen the > violence associated with the drug trade. It's time to end this ridiculous > prohibition like we did the one in the 20s. Never happen. The tobacco and alco

RE: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Heald, Tim
Airborne -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, September 05, 2003 3:45 PM To: CF-Community Subject: Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act Let me restate myself. Death is a proper punishment for those where the case is clear cut. There are

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Michael Dinowitz
Let me restate myself. Death is a proper punishment for those where the case is clear cut. There are many cases where the case has overwhelming evidence. Make sure it's rock solid and then use that rope. > In the cases you mentioned, I see no problem with hanging. There are some crimes > which sh

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Michael Dinowitz
In the cases you mentioned, I see no problem with hanging. There are some crimes which should result in death. The two you mentioned fall well within my definitions of who deserves it. Some crimes deserve death and some crimes deserve rehabilitation. The trick is to know which crimes deserve which

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Jim Campbell
Amnesty International (not sure about American Amnesty) has a standing argument with Texas (along with other states and the federal government) for its use of the death penalty. - Jim Angel Stewart wrote: >They hang people in Trinidad. > >But we have come under continuous attack by Amnesty Int

RE: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Angel Stewart
They hang people in Trinidad. But we have come under continuous attack by Amnesty International And American Amnesty I believe, that tis become nearly impossible to carry out our own laws :( We hung 6 people all at once in one year for a heinous drug related crime, one of them was a multimilliona

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Larry C. Lyons
Jerry Look up the book Panopticon by Jeremy Bentham. He was an 18th century philosopher who came up with the concept of modern prisons. The basic promise has always been rehabilitation. >At 02:30 PM 9/5/2003, you wrote: >What promises of rehabilitation? Who made that promise? > >I don't buy it

RE: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Heald, Tim
Reload the ammo :) Tim -Original Message- From: Larry C. Lyons [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, September 05, 2003 3:04 PM To: CF-Community Subject: Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act At 02:22 PM 9/5/2003, you wrote: >Rehabilitation is a thing of the past. > >Prison

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Kevin Graeme
> I can't find the statistics right now (you know, when they would be useful), but I remember that 98 percent of crime is committed by someone who has already been through the "justice" system for previous crimes. I'm no statistician, but that strikes me as odd. In order for someone to commit a se

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Larry C. Lyons
At 02:22 PM 9/5/2003, you wrote: >Rehabilitation is a thing of the past. > >Prisons are purely warehousing operations now, and impose rudimentary >"treatment" programs for drug offenders once paroled, but not much else. > >The old days of getting a free high school /GED and college educations >whi

RE: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Haggerty, Mike
mber 05, 2003 12:46 PM > To: CF-Community > Subject: Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act > > > I don't think I support this law. One of the great deterrents > against people going back out and committing crimes again is > prison rape. In addition, because it'

RE: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Jim Davis
a more complex issue than the discussion seems to be painting it. Jim Davis > -Original Message- > From: Michael Dinowitz [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: Friday, September 05, 2003 12:46 PM > To: CF-Community > Subject: Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act > > I

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Jerry Johnson
What promises of rehabilitation? Who made that promise? I don't buy it. My personal view is that _most_ people in prison are there from personal choices, and are not going to change their ways. Recidavism is something like 85 percent. That means that 85 percent of people getting out of jail are

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Michael Dinowitz
If the punishment fit the crime then murderers would be killed and rapists castrated. The US system is a representative one where a crime is translated into jail time. Supposable, this is to rehabilitate the criminal, but its really just to put them away from society for a period. If our jails were

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Michael Dinowitz
That's because of a few things. They learn better crime techniques and if they're caught, they know they have free room, board, training, medical, etc. There was a criminal in California who got a heart transplant because he was 'entitled' to it by prison medical. Our prison system is just warehous

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Doug White
done! - Original Message - From: "S.Isaac Dealey" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "CF-Community" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Friday, September 05, 2003 12:29 PM Subject: Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act | I've heard that statistically people who've

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Kevin Graeme
Now if only guilty people that deserved to be raped were sent to prison. -Kevin - Original Message - From: "Michael Dinowitz" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "CF-Community" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Friday, September 05, 2003 11:46 AM Subject: Re: PREA - PRison

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread jon hall
I see where you are coming from, but the punishment should fit the crime as well. I don't think as a society we should be scarring a person for life for shoplifting either. -- jon mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Friday, September 5, 2003, 12:46:23 PM, you wrote: MD> I don't think I support this law.

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread S . Isaac Dealey
I've heard that statistically people who've been to prison are more likely to commit crime rather than being less likely after having the experience of being in prison... Personally -- if this is true -- I'd rather see some effort toward making the prison system live up to promises of rehabilitatio

Re: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Michael Dinowitz
I don't think I support this law. One of the great deterrents against people going back out and committing crimes again is prison rape. In addition, because it's so widely known, it's even a deterrent before someone commits a crime in the first place. If you knew that you'd be the sex toy of some 4

RE: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination Act

2003-09-05 Thread Haggerty, Mike
Too bad they didn't have this in place when you did that stint in Lorton, Bill. Are you still walking crooked? M > -Original Message- > From: Bill Wheatley [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: Friday, September 05, 2003 10:21 AM > To: CF-Community > Subject: PREA - PRison Rape Elimination