Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-05 Thread Mauro M.
A first step would be someone gathering a list of people committed to working on it, and going through the opensolaris project creation process to get yourself a mailing list and source repository setup. I am not an X11 expert but you can count me in, with some guidance I can do some work.

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Jensen Lee
Jensen Lee wrote: Certainly I want to keep using my Sun Blade. Will Sun next commercial release of Solaris at least support the legacy 3D Labs cards? Because like every other computer company in the world, including Sun for the past 25 years, hardware is not supported forever and at some

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread John Martin
Jensen Lee wrote: 1) open the 3D Labs drivers in Europe where software patents even if existing are not enforceable, someone in Europe could pick up the work Software patents have nothing to do with this discussion. There are legal agreements in place which restrict disclosure and derived

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Mattieu Baptiste
On Wed, Nov 4, 2009 at 3:30 PM, Jensen Lee hayd...@haydude.org wrote: Jensen Lee wrote: Certainly I want to keep using my Sun Blade. Will Sun next commercial release of Solaris at least support the legacy 3D Labs cards? Because like every other computer company in the world, including Sun

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Octave Orgeron
From: Jensen Lee hayd...@haydude.org To: opensolaris-discuss@opensolaris.org Sent: Wed, November 4, 2009 8:30:33 AM Subject: Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards Jensen Lee wrote: Certainly I want to keep using my Sun Blade. Will Sun next commercial

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Alan Coopersmith
Jensen Lee wrote: Let me understand Alan, why in 25 years of computing I never had this problem before. Windoze supports old hardware, Windows 7: Requires at least 1Ghz CPU, 1 GB RAM, Video card capable of DirectX 9 MacOS Snow Leopard: only supports Intel Macs - no longer supports their

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Alan Coopersmith
Octave Orgeron wrote: Here's a fun test that shouldn't cost millions for Sun to do today. How about get Nvidia or ATI to build a PCI and PCI-E 3D video card that will work with OpenSolaris Xorg on SPARC. Make it work on UltraSPARC III/IIIi workstations and sell it for under $300. I'm

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Jensen Lee
Windows 7: Requires at least 1Ghz CPU, 1 GB RAM, MacOS Snow Leopard: only supports Intel Macs - no WinXP? That is hardly the latest Windows - I doubt that machine runs Vista or Windows 7. You'll be able to run Solaris 10 for many years to come on your workstation - that would be

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Jensen Lee
Who said anything about software patents? Copyright contract law are enforceable in Europe, but frankly, European law is irrelevant, since the contract is between two US-based companies, and is thus governed by US law, and would result in lawsuits in US court if we decided to break it.

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Erik Trimble
Jensen Lee wrote: Windows 7: Requires at least 1Ghz CPU, 1 GB RAM, MacOS Snow Leopard: only supports Intel Macs - no WinXP? That is hardly the latest Windows - I doubt that machine runs Vista or Windows 7. You'll be able to run Solaris 10 for many years to come on your

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Erik Trimble
Jensen Lee wrote: Who said anything about software patents? Copyright contract law are enforceable in Europe, but frankly, European law is irrelevant, since the contract is between two US-based companies, and is thus governed by US law, and would result in lawsuits in US court if we decided to

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread John Martin
Mattieu Baptiste wrote: 3) obtain the chips documentation from 3D Labs and give that to the community. Like Sun already did for his own chips. It can be understood that 3D Labs don't want to provide documentation for advanced 3D features. But not publishing the basics to use the chip is utterly

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Jensen Lee
Sun's been selling ATI cards for SPARC workstations for a while, the XVR-100 (PCI) and XVR-300 (PCI-E) - both of which are supported under OpenSolaris Xorg - sales are not exciting in the least. Is this perhaps because they are 2D and too expensive for what they offer? Developing new

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Alan Coopersmith
Jensen Lee wrote: Who said anything about software patents? Copyright contract law are enforceable in Europe, but frankly, European law is irrelevant, since the contract is between two US-based companies, and is thus governed by US law, and would result in lawsuits in US court if we

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Martin Bochnig
OBP *is* open src since 2007. And there have always been guides and books describing how to write fcode drivers. One I know costs 60$ and includes many sample fcode / forth sample drivers, including basic graphics. if you are that expert who will write us all this fancy stuff, then you can

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Martin Bochnig
On Wed, Nov 4, 2009 at 7:28 PM, Martin Bochnig mar...@martux.org wrote: OBP *is* open src since 2007. And there have always been guides and books describing how to write fcode drivers. One I know costs 60$ and includes many sample fcode / forth sample drivers, including basic graphics. if

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Jensen Lee
Frankly, it's a better idea to see if we (or some other helpful soul) can implement support for the various cards into Xorg (which comes with t's own challenges, but is a more sure bet). Thank you, we are beginning to be constructive here, better than a NO NO So what it the plan? Who is

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Jensen Lee
I doubt you'll find any vendor who'll promise the video card you buy today will be supported in new OS versions coming out ten years from now. True, but as a consumer I have a choice to buy the video card that has open drivers, at least for x86. -- This message posted from opensolaris.org

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Martin Bochnig
On Wed, Nov 4, 2009 at 7:44 PM, Jensen Lee hayd...@haydude.org wrote: I doubt you'll find any vendor who'll promise the video card you buy today will be supported in new OS versions coming out ten years from now. True, but as a consumer I have a choice to buy the video card that has open

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread ken mays
Hi Jensen, A few things: 1. There was some work I did a few years ago in that we didn't need SPARC-specific video cards - you could use commercially available video cards that were compatible to Xorg and SPARC motherboards. 2. I submitted a bunch of RFEs to update Sun OpenGL to OpenGL 1.5-2.1

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Tomas Bodzar
You can run Solaris apps in compat mode under OpenBSD ;-) zfs - no , but you can try real competitor from BSD world in this area - DragonflyBSD zones - chroot of course, not same, but no one says that OpenBSD is good for everything virtualization - no until developers correct their buggy

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Mauro M.
If they do how can they have an interest into non disclosing information on old and no longer commercially exploited technology? That's their right to determine, not ours or yours. This is arguable. As a consumer I have the right to use the hardware I purchase in whatever way I see fit

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Mauro M.
either install Xsun from SXCE on OS200yy.mm, or buy one of the officially Sun-Xorg supported cards, or one of the community supported ones (#0). What packages have to be installed on OpenSolaris (from SXCE or Solaris 10) to make Xsun work with a Sun FB? Is there a guide? -- This message

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Alan Coopersmith
Mauro M. wrote: If they do how can they have an interest into non disclosing information on old and no longer commercially exploited technology? That's their right to determine, not ours or yours. This is arguable. As a consumer I have the right to use the hardware I purchase in

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Erik Trimble
Mauro M. wrote: If they do how can they have an interest into non disclosing information on old and no longer commercially exploited technology? That's their right to determine, not ours or yours. This is arguable. As a consumer I have the right to use the hardware I purchase

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-04 Thread Alan Coopersmith
Mauro M. wrote: either install Xsun from SXCE on OS200yy.mm, or buy one of the officially Sun-Xorg supported cards, or one of the community supported ones (#0). What packages have to be installed on OpenSolaris (from SXCE or Solaris 10) to make Xsun work with a Sun FB? Is there a guide?

[osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread Jensen Lee
It is a shame that Sun does not support XVR-500, XVR-1000, Expert 3D and several other graphic cards on OpenSolaris because of copyright/NDA/patent issues. I think that Sun should make an effort to liase with 3D Labs to open their drivers source to allow for implementation into OpenSolaris.

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread ken mays
--- On Mon, 11/2/09, Jensen Lee hayd...@haydude.org wrote: From: Jensen Lee hayd...@haydude.org Subject: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards To: opensolaris-discuss@opensolaris.org Date: Monday, November 2, 2009, 5:21 AM It is a shame that Sun does

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread Jensen Lee
Has anybody (Sun) actually asked 3D Labs to open their graphic cards drivers source? Because 3D Labs are no longer in the business of producing graphic cards, and I do not see why they would not do that if asked. If they did it would only make good publicity to their name. -- This message

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread Mattieu Baptiste
On Mon, Nov 2, 2009 at 12:29 PM, Jensen Lee hayd...@haydude.org wrote: Has anybody (Sun) actually asked 3D Labs to open their graphic cards drivers source? Because 3D Labs are no longer in the business of producing graphic cards, and I do not see why they would not do that if asked. Check :

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread Martin Bochnig
On Mon, Nov 2, 2009 at 3:33 PM, Mattieu Baptiste mattie...@gmail.com wrote: On Mon, Nov 2, 2009 at 12:29 PM, Jensen Lee hayd...@haydude.org wrote: Has anybody (Sun) actually asked 3D Labs to open their graphic cards drivers source? Because 3D Labs are no longer in the business of producing

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread Mattieu Baptiste
On Mon, Nov 2, 2009 at 3:00 PM, Martin Bochnig mar...@martux.org wrote: hi, with unaccelerated frame buffer mode drivers derived from wsfb   ... %mab Yeah, with that unaccelerated frame buffer mode drivers derived from wsfb my *workstation* is actually more useful than a serial console. --

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread Rainer Orth
Jensen Lee hayd...@haydude.org writes: It is a shame that Sun does not support XVR-500, XVR-1000, Expert 3D and several other graphic cards on OpenSolaris because of copyright/NDA/patent issues. I think that Sun should make an effort to liase with 3D Labs to open their drivers source

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread Alan Coopersmith
Rainer Orth wrote: Jensen Lee hayd...@haydude.org writes: It is a shame that Sun does not support XVR-500, XVR-1000, Expert 3D and several other graphic cards on OpenSolaris because of copyright/NDA/patent issues. I think that Sun should make an effort to liase with 3D Labs to open

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread Jensen Lee
I understand that even though Sun posted binary drivers for OpenSolaris, Xorg will not work with them and Xsun is not bundled with it. To reply to those who suggested OpenBSD, that is out of topic, I have Sun because I want to run Solaris, if I wanted openBSD I would have had a cheap intel

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread Jensen Lee
I posted a message to ziiLabs' customer support which is the new company formed from 3DLabs. Please join me in inondating ziiLabs with requests to open the drivers for Sun frambuffer cards following this link: http://www.ziilabs.com/aboutus/contactgeneral.aspx The power of the Internet

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread Alan Coopersmith
Jensen Lee wrote: Certainly I want to keep using my Sun Blade. Will Sun next commercial release of Solaris at least support the legacy 3D Labs cards? Solaris 10 is the last release of Solaris planned to support those cards. And by the way, due to this mess with OpenSolaris, I do not think I

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread Rainer Orth
Alan Coopersmith writes: The SMF support for selecting an X server should stay - I have no plans to remove it since it is useful for selecting between the remaining X servers (Xorg, Xvnc, Xvfb), but Xsun will probably disappear from the list in the Xserver script at some point. That's great

Re: [osol-discuss] Sun UltraSparc: XVR-500, Expert 3D, legacy graphic cards

2009-11-02 Thread John Martin
Jensen Lee wrote: And by the way, due to this mess with OpenSolaris, I do not think I will ever buy Sun hardware in the future. But most importantly, being a professional, I will refrein from advising anyone to buy Sun hardware. I used to recommend it as an investment ... what a shame! No