Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-27 Thread Pierre Quentel
Yes, there is a clear winner : python zope = 3.950.000 Pierre -- http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-25 Thread UrsusMaximus
On December 15, Alex Martelli wrote: Alternatively, counting Google hits: rails python django 112,000 rails python subway 81,600 rails python turbogears 32,000 This isn't exactly buzz, of course, but it's SOME measure of critical mass -- and with django about equal to

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-25 Thread UrsusMaximus
One last comment: This will work, I think, if and only if the Consolidating framework, the one to be used to absorb the other(s) best aspects, makes immediate and up-front, highly visible concession(s) so as to clearly communicate a win-win scenario. --

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-23 Thread Paul Rubin
Robert Kern [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: RMS has said precisely the opposite, in fact. http://lists.debian.org/debian-legal/2002/11/msg00217.html I guess you mean: [RMS:] As for the more general question, we think that a program that uses Emacs facilities needs to be GPL-covered, but a program

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-22 Thread Richie Hindle
[Paul] The web app gets run by Karrigell like a CGI script is run by Apache, like a Linux app is run by the Linux kernel. Paul, you keep making comparisons between Python web frameworks and the Linux kernel. Are you aware that there is a special note attached to the Linux GPL[1] explaining

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-22 Thread Paul Rubin
Richie Hindle [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Paul, you keep making comparisons between Python web frameworks and the Linux kernel. Are you aware that there is a special note attached to the Linux GPL[1] explaining that user-space code is not considered a derived work of the Linux kernel? Without

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-22 Thread A.M. Kuchling
On 20 Dec 2005 15:05:15 -0800, Michael Tobis [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Python people don't really think that way. As a community we really seem to inherit the open source dysfunction of trying harder to impress each other than to reach out to the rest of the world. The problem is Yes;

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-22 Thread Ed Singleton
On 22/12/05, A.M. Kuchling [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On 20 Dec 2005 15:05:15 -0800, Michael Tobis [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Python people don't really think that way. As a community we really seem to inherit the open source dysfunction of trying harder to impress each other than to

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-22 Thread A.M. Kuchling
On Thu, 22 Dec 2005 14:05:08 +, Ed Singleton [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Yes; I've long worried about this, but have no idea how to fix the problem. Python users largely talk to other Python users, not to the world at large. A good start would be for there to be a way for newbies

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-22 Thread Ed Singleton
On 22/12/05, A.M. Kuchling [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Thu, 22 Dec 2005 14:05:08 +, Ed Singleton [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Yes; I've long worried about this, but have no idea how to fix the problem. Python users largely talk to other Python users, not to the world at large.

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-22 Thread Kent Johnson
A.M. Kuchling wrote: On 20 Dec 2005 15:05:15 -0800, Michael Tobis [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Python people don't really think that way. As a community we really seem to inherit the open source dysfunction of trying harder to impress each other than to reach out to the rest of the world.

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-22 Thread Jean-Paul Calderone
On 21 Dec 2005 13:53:55 -0800, Pierre Quentel [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Just to add some more confusion to the discussion, here is what I've found about other web frameworks : CherryPy : BSD Django : BSD Jonpy : Python licence Quixote : CNRI Skunkweb : GPL or BSD Snakelets : MIT Subway : ? +

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-22 Thread Jeff Rush
Kent Johnson wrote: Luis M. Gonzalez wrote: The only problem with KARRIGELL, I guess, is that its creator is very humble and doesn't like to advertise his creature. He is not very fond of marketing ... From my point of view the biggest problem with Karrigell is that it is released

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-22 Thread Paul Rubin
Jeff Rush [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Your only solution would be a proprietary license that states you purchased this program and don't have the right to pass it on to others, similar to ActiveState or somesuch. It sounds like that's what Kent wants to do with the apps that he's building.

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-22 Thread Robert Kern
Paul Rubin wrote: Jeff Rush [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Your only solution would be a proprietary license that states you purchased this program and don't have the right to pass it on to others, similar to ActiveState or somesuch. It sounds like that's what Kent wants to do with the apps that

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-22 Thread Robert Kern
Paul Rubin wrote: Hmmm. I seem to remember RMS saying that the GPL didn't extend to Emacs Lisp functions that the user writes, even though those call various built-in Emacs functions, as long as they use the documented API. Those certainly run in the same address space as Emacs. This is

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Steve Holden
Kent Johnson wrote: Luis M. Gonzalez wrote: I don't think Pierre (Karrigell's creator) is awared of licenses and legal issues. Perhaps you can tell us what's the problem with GPL and, if possible, propose an alternative... OK I'll try. First let me say I have no interest in a licensing

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Paul Rubin
Steve Holden [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: However the work I do is commercial and proprietary and I doubt I could get approval to release it under GPL. I see the GPL is a problem in this environment, and you are clearly aware of the issues it raises. Do be aware, though, that not all GPL

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Pierre Quentel
Hello all, I am Karrigell's author. I have chosen the GPL licence almost at random (I saw that the Python licence was GPL-compatible), so I don't mind switching to another Open Source licence if the GPL is liable to cause problems. Which one would you advice : BSD ? Python licence ? another ?

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Paul Rubin
Pierre Quentel [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I am Karrigell's author. I have chosen the GPL licence almost at random (I saw that the Python licence was GPL-compatible), so I don't mind switching to another Open Source licence if the GPL is liable to cause problems. Which one would you advice : BSD

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Steve Holden
Paul Rubin wrote: Steve Holden [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: However the work I do is commercial and proprietary and I doubt I could get approval to release it under GPL. I see the GPL is a problem in this environment, and you are clearly aware of the issues it raises. Do be aware, though, that

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Paul Rubin
Steve Holden [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Indeed. But most software authors aren't lawyers and aren't likely to trust their own judgment about these matters unless the situation is pretty unambiguous. I suspect this may be evidence that Microsoft's viral propaganda has had some effect. Hmm,

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Pierre Quentel
I definitely don't want to invent another licence, there are enough of them already ! Pierre -- http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Ben Sizer
Paul Rubin wrote: Pierre Quentel [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I am Karrigell's author. I have chosen the GPL licence almost at random (I saw that the Python licence was GPL-compatible), so I don't mind switching to another Open Source licence if the GPL is liable to cause problems. Which one

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Paul Rubin
Ben Sizer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Unfortunately, that doesn't really satisfy the GPL's concerns. The work arguably contains or is derived from Karrigell, I don't see that. The web app gets run by Karrigell like a CGI script is run by Apache, like a Linux app is run by the Linux kernel. The

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Richie Hindle
[Pierre] I am Karrigell's author. I have chosen the GPL licence almost at random (I saw that the Python licence was GPL-compatible), so I don't mind switching to another Open Source licence if the GPL is liable to cause problems. Which one would you advice : BSD ? Python licence ? another ?

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Paul Rubin
Richie Hindle [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: A good solution would be multiple-licensing. You state that the code is (for example) triple-licensed under the GPL, LGPL and BSD licenses. The user of your code decides which license to obey. It's no more work for you, and you can please almost

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Kent Johnson
Steve Holden wrote: Paul Rubin wrote: I'm trying to avoid flame wars too, but my take on this is that Kent's reading is a little too restrictive and the GPL isn't really a problem in this situation unless he's actually modifying Karrigell itself, rather than writing applications that run

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Raffaele Salmaso
Pierre Quentel ha scritto: Hello all, I am Karrigell's author. I have chosen the GPL licence almost at random (I saw that the Python licence was GPL-compatible), so I don't mind switching to another Open Source licence if the GPL is liable to cause problems. Which one would you advice : BSD

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Arthur Clune
Kent Johnson wrote: OK I'll try. First let me say I have no interest in a licensing flame war, there are valid reasons why an author might prefer one license over another and certainly there are good reasons to choose GPL. However the work I do is commercial and proprietary and I

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Fuzzyman
BSD license is good. It requires that your copyright notice be included with any derivative works - but otherwise lets users create and distribute derivatives how they see fit. The version I use is at http://www.voidspace.org.uk/python/license.shtml (which links to the version at the OSI). The

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Kent Johnson
Paul Rubin wrote: Kent Johnson [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: You've lost me here. The server certainly would contain Karrigell code, it wouldn't function without it. I don't understand the analogy to GCC, the web site is not something that is compiled with Karrigell. Karrigell is a library or

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Ben Sizer
Paul Rubin wrote: Ben Sizer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Unfortunately, that doesn't really satisfy the GPL's concerns. The work arguably contains or is derived from Karrigell, I don't see that. The web app gets run by Karrigell like a CGI script is run by Apache, like a Linux app is run by

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Scott David Daniels
Richie Hindle wrote: You will hear valid arguments for GPL, LGPL, BSD and other licenses (though the Python license is unsuitable for anything other than Python - see http://wiki.python.org/moin/PythonSoftwareFoundationLicenseFaq) A good solution would be multiple-licensing. You state that

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Pierre Quentel
In Karrigell the scripts are executed in a namespace prepared by the framework, with HTTP environment, form data, the functions and exceptions for authentication, session management, redirection etc. I suppose that this falls into the first category above, modules (that) are designed to run linked

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Martin Christensen
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Kent == Kent Johnson [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Kent [Karrigell is GPL'ed] Unfortunately this makes it impossible for Kent me to consider using Karrigell in my work. I recently needed a Kent stand-alone web server for a small in-house project that

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Martin Christensen
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Ben == Ben Sizer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Ben Unfortunately, that doesn't really satisfy the GPL's concerns. Ben The work arguably contains or is derived from Karrigell, which Ben is explicitly covered in section 2b of the GPL. If you start Ben

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Kent Johnson
Martin Christensen wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Kent == Kent Johnson [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Kent [Karrigell is GPL'ed] Unfortunately this makes it impossible for Kent me to consider using Karrigell in my work. I recently needed a Kent stand-alone web server

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Robert Kern
Martin Christensen wrote: Kent == Kent Johnson [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Kent [Karrigell is GPL'ed] Unfortunately this makes it impossible for Kent me to consider using Karrigell in my work. I recently needed a Kent stand-alone web server for a small in-house project that might Kent

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Alex Martelli
Paul Rubin http://[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Richie Hindle [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: A good solution would be multiple-licensing. You state that the code is (for example) triple-licensed under the GPL, LGPL and BSD licenses. The user of your code decides which license to obey. It's no

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Ben Sizer
Martin Christensen wrote: Ben == Ben Sizer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Ben Unfortunately, that doesn't really satisfy the GPL's concerns. Ben The work arguably contains or is derived from Karrigell, which Ben is explicitly covered in section 2b of the GPL. If you start Ben excluding key

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Fredrik Lundh
Pierre Quentel wrote: I am Karrigell's author. I have chosen the GPL licence almost at random (I saw that the Python licence was GPL-compatible), so I don't mind switching to another Open Source licence if the GPL is liable to cause problems. Which one would you advice : BSD ? Python licence

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Robert Kern
Alex Martelli wrote: Paul Rubin http://[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Richie Hindle [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: A good solution would be multiple-licensing. You state that the code is (for example) triple-licensed under the GPL, LGPL and BSD licenses. The user of your code decides which license to

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Martin Christensen
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Kent == Kent Johnson [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Kent In the text you quoted I said, a small in-house project that Kent might possibly be distributed to business partners or become a Kent product some day. Sounds like distribution to me. My bad. I

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Paul Rubin
(Responding to several posts) Ben Sizer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I don't see that. The web app gets run by Karrigell like a CGI script is run by Apache, like a Linux app is run by the Linux kernel. The web app uses parts of Karrigell though - things like the QUERY variable or or Session

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Pierre Quentel
Just to add some more confusion to the discussion, here is what I've found about other web frameworks : CherryPy : BSD Django : BSD Jonpy : Python licence Quixote : CNRI Skunkweb : GPL or BSD Snakelets : MIT Subway : ? + licence of the components PythonWeb : LGPL (will consider BSD-Style or Python

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-21 Thread Kent Johnson
Paul Rubin wrote: [Kent Johnson] Where would you draw the line? Suppose I want to use a GPLed library in my Python code, does that mean I have to distribute my code under the GPL if I distribute them together? Yes, that's the point of using the GPL on a library instead of

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Ben Sizer
Paul Rubin wrote: Russell E. Owen [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I disagree. Once you've picked a database (not trivial in itself, of course), you typically only have a few options for talking to in in Python. Also, typically either: - One stands out (because others have been abandoned or

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Paul Boddie
Paul Rubin wrote: It's been a long-time source of puzzlement to me why so many web sites are so slow, and RDBMS overhead is an obvious candidate. So the rant seems appropriate even in the case of web apps where clients can cause db updates. Indeed. Large portions of a lot of Web sites could

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread paron
Wow! You´re right, at least at first reading. It looks REALLY simple, and almost anything you can dream up will work. Python scripts, python-in-html, html-in-python, and karrigell services ( based on CherryPy). Seems to support smart urls, sessions, authentication, and internationalization

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread paron
Oops! Second line on the home page: snipWith Karrigell you have . . . * a pure-Python database engine : KirbyBase Karrigell can also work with . . . all the databases for which a Python API exists (sqlite, mySql, PostGreSQL, ZODB, etc). /snip Well, off to reread and work the tut! My

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Luis M. Gonzalez
Karrigell can also work with . . . all the databases for which a Python API exists (sqlite, mySql, PostGreSQL, ZODB, etc). /snip Well, that's exactly what makes KARRIGELL so especial. It is very flexible and lets you use whatever database or component you want. It doesn't force you to use an

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Mike Meyer
Paul Boddie [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Paul Rubin wrote: It's been a long-time source of puzzlement to me why so many web sites are so slow, and RDBMS overhead is an obvious candidate. So the rant seems appropriate even in the case of web apps where clients can cause db updates. Indeed.

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Steve Holden
Mike Meyer wrote: Paul Boddie [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Paul Rubin wrote: It's been a long-time source of puzzlement to me why so many web sites are so slow, and RDBMS overhead is an obvious candidate. So the rant seems appropriate even in the case of web apps where clients can cause db

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Kent Johnson
Luis M. Gonzalez wrote: The only problem with KARRIGELL, I guess, is that its creator is very humble and doesn't like to advertise his creature. He is not very fond of marketing ... From my point of view the biggest problem with Karrigell is that it is released under the GPL. Most of my

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Russell E. Owen
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Benji York [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Russell E. Owen wrote: I disagree. Once you've picked a database (not trivial in itself, of course), you typically only have a few options for talking to in in Python. Perhaps it's off-topic for this thread, but I think

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Luis M. Gonzalez
I don't think Pierre (Karrigell's creator) is awared of licenses and legal issues. Perhaps you can tell us what's the problem with GPL and, if possible, propose an alternative... -- http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Luis M. Gonzalez
From my point of view the biggest problem with Karrigell is that it is released under the GPL. Most of my projects at least have the potential of being distributed to customers and GPL is not an option. I don't think Pierre (Karrigell's creator) is awared of licenses and legal issues.

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Paul Rubin
Luis M. Gonzalez [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Perhaps you can tell us what's the problem with GPL and, if possible, propose an alternative... See: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/pragmatic.html -- http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Michael Tobis
Clearly the Ruby/Rails folks are making an effort to place themselves as an easy-to-learn first language for people who might otherwise drift into the rather awkward template-first way of thinking that is PHP. I note that the Rails people are closely affiliated with the 37signals people who in

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Kent Johnson
Luis M. Gonzalez wrote: I don't think Pierre (Karrigell's creator) is awared of licenses and legal issues. Perhaps you can tell us what's the problem with GPL and, if possible, propose an alternative... OK I'll try. First let me say I have no interest in a licensing flame war, there are

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Paul Rubin
Kent Johnson [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I chose CherryPy in part because its license allows this. I would have considered Karrigell if it had a different license. Have you had to modify CherryPy in some substantive way that you needed to keep proprietary, as opposed to simply developing content

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Kent Johnson
Paul Rubin wrote: Kent Johnson [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I chose CherryPy in part because its license allows this. I would have considered Karrigell if it had a different license. Have you had to modify CherryPy in some substantive way that you needed to keep proprietary, I did make

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Paul Rubin
Kent Johnson [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I did make some changes to CherryPy. I wouldn't mind sharing those changes back with the CherryPy community. But the product was the server itself, not the web site. As I understand the GPL the server software would be a work based on the [GPL-licensed]

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Mike Meyer
Paul Rubin http://[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: IANAL but that is not my understanding of the GPL. GPL version 2 section 2.b) reads, You must cause any work that you distribute or publish, that in whole or in part contains or is derived from the Program or any part thereof, to be licensed as a

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Kent Johnson
Paul Rubin wrote: Kent Johnson [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Remember that the GPL only applies to the code of Karrigell itself, not to stuff that you write using it. IANAL but that is not my understanding of the GPL. GPL version 2 section 2.b) reads, You must cause any work that you distribute or

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-20 Thread Paul Rubin
Kent Johnson [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: You've lost me here. The server certainly would contain Karrigell code, it wouldn't function without it. I don't understand the analogy to GCC, the web site is not something that is compiled with Karrigell. Karrigell is a library or framework that is an

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-19 Thread Luis M. Gonzalez
Sorry for the interruption, but... Has anyone tried KARRIGELL?? I find hard to believe there is any easier python framework than this one. It's incredibly flexible, very fun, very powerful and with an almost flat learning curve. Go check it out (NOW!) http://karrigell.sourceforge.net/ --

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-19 Thread Russell E. Owen
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Paul Rubin http://[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Alex Martelli) writes: To put it another way: one reason I love Python is that I strongly subscribe to the idea that there should preferably be only one obvious way to do something. Unfortunately,

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-19 Thread Russell E. Owen
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Mike Meyer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Ben Sizer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I see what you mean, but unfortunately I think there is a lot more fuzziness than that. If the separate parts were clearly delineated things would be a lot better. I look to the Database API

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-19 Thread Paul Rubin
Russell E. Owen [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I disagree. Once you've picked a database (not trivial in itself, of course), you typically only have a few options for talking to in in Python. Also, typically either: - One stands out (because others have been abandoned or whatever), so there's

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-19 Thread Benji York
Russell E. Owen wrote: I disagree. Once you've picked a database (not trivial in itself, of course), you typically only have a few options for talking to in in Python. Perhaps it's off-topic for this thread, but I think picking a database is the first mistake most people make. It's a form

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-19 Thread Mike Meyer
Benji York [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Russell E. Owen wrote: I disagree. Once you've picked a database (not trivial in itself, of course), you typically only have a few options for talking to in in Python. Perhaps it's off-topic for this thread, but I think picking a database is the first

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-19 Thread Paul Rubin
Mike Meyer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: What makes me think I need a database is a requirement that says multiple simultaneous writers. I'd go a little further and say multiple simultaneous writers doing multi-step transactions with steps that can have high latency, e.g. transactions that have to

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-19 Thread Paul Rubin
Paul Rubin http://[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: If the transactions are simple and low-latency, then it can be enough to have a single process own the whole database, and have every client send all its requests to the db process. Meant to say: it can be enough to let the clients lock the database,

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-19 Thread Dave Benjamin
On Mon, 19 Dec 2005, Paul Rubin wrote: Russell E. Owen [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I disagree. Once you've picked a database (not trivial in itself, of course), you typically only have a few options for talking to in in Python. Also, typically either: - One stands out (because others have been

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-19 Thread Alex Martelli
Scott David Daniels [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Mike Meyer wrote: Benji York [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Perhaps it's off-topic for this thread, but I think picking a database is the first mistake most people make. It's a form of premature optimization. For lots of problems, that's

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-19 Thread Scott David Daniels
Alex Martelli wrote: Scott David Daniels [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If the data you store and update is sufficiently valuable to your enterprise, picking a database may be vital. Transactions guarantee every update either happens or not, and infrastructure is provided for you to be able to

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-17 Thread Mike Meyer
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Mike Meyer wrote: It's conceivable that a change might make Python more popular and also detract from the language in some way. For a ridiculous example, making Python interpret Perl 6 would certainly make it more popular, but I would argue that would seiously

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-17 Thread floydophone
I'm the founder and lead developer of Subway. I am all for it. TG would have to change a couple of things IMHO, but I think it would be a great idea. If we were to merge projects, we would have to get a serious TurbowaySubgears blogging hype train going. - Peter Hunt --

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-16 Thread chuck
I did a fairly thorough investigation of web frameworks that let us write Python (we didn't care what the framework was written in; merely that it interfaced with Python) for one of the systems I've built this year. I wouldn't call the evaluation of web frameworks a problem - we met our

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-16 Thread A.M. Kuchling
On Thu, 15 Dec 2005 20:15:17 -0800, Alex Martelli [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If you claim there's a web project that's unfeasible to do in Ruby, you'd better come up with a strong example. If you're making no such claim, which would be counter to the claims of the Ruby community, then

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-16 Thread Ben Sizer
Mike Meyer wrote: Ben Sizer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Flexibility is good, but personally I think the problem is that instead of useful variety, we have redundant overlap. How many different templating systems, sql--object mappings, and URL dispatch schemes do we need? And what exactly is

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-16 Thread Alia Khouri
In http://subway.python-hosting.com/ticket/216 Peter Mere writes: Subway has a lot of ideas TurboGears lacks. Everything from the @client ajax-in-python to CherryFlow. On technical merits, Subway should eat TurboGears' dinner. But we all know market outcomes are not based on technical merit.

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-16 Thread gene tani
Alia Khouri wrote: In http://subway.python-hosting.com/ticket/216 Peter Mere writes: Conquest is a method of union. ... unstoppable juggernaut of chaos will continue in python web app land, and ruby will become ascendant. This is more than a critical issue - don't dismiss it without

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-16 Thread Mike Meyer
chuck [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: As I read through this thread I can't say that I disagree that having more choices is a 'good thing'. However in your example here - I suspect that you are a bit sharper and have a bit more guts than your average code slinger since you appear to be an

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-16 Thread Mike Meyer
Ben Sizer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I see what you mean, but unfortunately I think there is a lot more fuzziness than that. If the separate parts were clearly delineated things would be a lot better. I look to the Database API Specification as a great example of how this could (should?) be

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-16 Thread chuck
Let's just note that sturgeon's law applies to all programmers, and let it go at that. I'll get back to this. fine And thank you. you are welcome I'm not a big fan of popularity for the sake of popularity. neither am I it would make Python more popular isn't an adequate justification

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-16 Thread Mike Meyer
Alia Khouri [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: If Subway does not unite, chaos will continue in python web app land, and ruby will become ascendant. This is more than a critical issue - don't dismiss it without understanding that doing so will have severe repercussions for subway (and by a process of

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-16 Thread Mike Meyer
chuck [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: it would make Python more popular isn't an adequate justification for a change I disagree. The world desperately needs programming languages, frameworks, etc. that allow for the more efficient creation and maintenance of software application - web or

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-16 Thread bonono
Mike Meyer wrote: It's conceivable that a change might make Python more popular and also detract from the language in some way. For a ridiculous example, making Python interpret Perl 6 would certainly make it more popular, but I would argue that would seiously detract from the language. why

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-15 Thread Ben Sizer
Mike Meyer wrote: [Not sure if this attribution is correct.] Alex Martelli wrote: Because of course if other languages have 1 or two frameworks, python needs a dozen. People keep talking about Python's wealth of web frameworks as if it were a bad thing. I just don't see it. Just like I

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-15 Thread gene tani
Ben Sizer wrote: Mike Meyer wrote: [Not sure if this attribution is correct.] Alex Martelli wrote: Because of course if other languages have 1 or two frameworks, python needs a dozen. woops, that attribution is absolutely *wrong*, DH said that, sorry Alex --

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-15 Thread gene tani
Ben Sizer wrote: Mike Meyer wrote: [Not sure if this attribution is correct.] Alex Martelli wrote: Because of course if other languages have 1 or two frameworks, python needs a dozen. People keep talking about Python's wealth of web frameworks as if it were a bad thing. I just

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-15 Thread Alex Martelli
gene tani [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Ben Sizer wrote: Mike Meyer wrote: [Not sure if this attribution is correct.] Alex Martelli wrote: Because of course if other languages have 1 or two frameworks, python needs a dozen. woops, that attribution is absolutely *wrong*, DH said

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-15 Thread Mike Meyer
Ben Sizer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Mike Meyer wrote: [Not sure if this attribution is correct.] And it was apparently wrong. Apologies to both DH and AM. Alex Martelli wrote: Because of course if other languages have 1 or two frameworks, python needs a dozen. People keep talking about

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-15 Thread chuck
People keep talking about Python's wealth of web frameworks as if it were a bad thing. I disagree somewhat. While variety and choice are nice, sometimes having too many choices may inhibit people from trying the language because they don't know where to start in terms of framworks. Maybe I'm

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-15 Thread Alex Martelli
chuck [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: People keep talking about Python's wealth of web frameworks as if it were a bad thing. I disagree somewhat. While variety and choice are nice, sometimes having too many choices may inhibit people from trying the language because they don't know where to

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-15 Thread Robert Kern
Alex Martelli wrote: I agree with chuck. I've seen excellent programmers explain why for some urgent problem they chose Ruby on Rails rather than Java or Python: Ruby has ONE web framework (that matters), so the choice was finished there; to evaluate properly 50 frameworks for Java or 20 for

Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?

2005-12-15 Thread Alex Martelli
Robert Kern [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ... Picking RoR because you want to do the project in Ruby makes sense. Picking Ruby because it only has one web framework is as silly as picking one Python web framework at random. Just because RoR is the only Ruby web framework around doesn't mean it's

  1   2   >