Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-15 Thread Jim Bronson
-Original Message- From: rbw-owne...@googlegroups.com [mailto:rbw-owne...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of Steve Palincsar Sent: Friday, December 12, 2014 1:08 PM To: rbw-owne...@googlegroups.com Subject: Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again On 12/12/2014 03:57 PM, Doug Williams

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-15 Thread Patrick Moore
My gofast has a 15 t small and a 17 t big (both fixed) with a single 46 t ring (and 24 1/2 actual diameter 650C wheels). My ultimate top speed (at least on 2 occasions) was 37.5 mph; my typical downhill top speed is 30 mph; and my typical downhill cruising speed is 25 mph. ~168, 136, 112 crank rpm

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-14 Thread Clayton.sf
One thing to note - recent xt model derailers (at least mine) no longer have the floating upper pulley. So flipping pulleys will have no effect. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-14 Thread Doug Williams
Hmmm...interesting. If true, this could save me some hassle. Thanks for the tip, when I get my new bike, I'll definitely check before I start messing with the pulleys. Doug Williams On Sunday, December 14, 2014 9:03:19 AM UTC-8, Clayton.sf wrote: One thing to note - recent xt model derailers

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-12 Thread ascpgh
The side play in the upper pulley goes with Shimano's indexing. The shifter has a very crisp break when going to the next gear and the abrupt pull of cable and the tiny bit of over shift caused by this is moderated in movement of the chain by that rear derailleur's bit of slop in that upper

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-12 Thread Shoji Takahashi
Hi Doug, I have a similar set up to what you're building up: - 56cm AHH with Suntour friction down tube shifters (Noodle hbar) - Sugino triple and HG41 8 speed rear. - Shimano XT front and rear derailers (bit-o-bling, but works nicely) It works great. For the terrain I ride, the

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-12 Thread Doug Williams
Well I do get hills where I live, and especially when I head north. My knees (and the rest of my body) are not getting any younger. So I like a full range of gears. I had decided to go with 8 gears for better friction shifting, and I think I should stick with that because most people report

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-12 Thread Steve Palincsar
On 12/12/2014 03:57 PM, Doug Williams wrote: Well I do get hills where I live, and especially when I head north. My knees (and the rest of my body) are not getting any younger. So I like a full range of gears. I had decided to go with 8 gears for better friction shifting, and I think I should

RE: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-12 Thread Doug Williams
, December 12, 2014 1:08 PM To: rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com Subject: Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again On 12/12/2014 03:57 PM, Doug Williams wrote: Well I do get hills where I live, and especially when I head north. My knees (and the rest of my body) are not getting any

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-12 Thread Bill Lindsay
:08 PM To: rbw-owne...@googlegroups.com javascript: Subject: Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again On 12/12/2014 03:57 PM, Doug Williams wrote: Well I do get hills where I live, and especially when I head north. My knees (and the rest of my body) are not getting any younger

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-12 Thread Deacon Patrick
...@googlegroups.com Subject: Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again On 12/12/2014 03:57 PM, Doug Williams wrote: Well I do get hills where I live, and especially when I head north. My knees (and the rest of my body) are not getting any younger. So I like a full range of gears. I had decided

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-12 Thread Steve Palincsar
On 12/12/2014 04:38 PM, Doug Williams wrote: Steve, I suppose you could do that, but then 13 and 14 are awfully close together. I couldn't even tell the difference as I lack your finesse. :-) I have no difficulty at all telling the difference between 13-14-15, the three 1-tooth gaps on my

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-12 Thread Patrick Moore
Just to toss more grit into the gears, Miche makes Shimano-compatible outers (perhaps Campy ones too) up to 16. I run a 16-26 9 speed on my ram (with compact 52/38 rings) (very nicely shifted with Silver dt levers pulling a 7400 DA rd. I've several times crammed a non-outer-position-specific 14

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-12 Thread Doug Williams
Steve, Maybe I'm reading Sheldon's Gear Calculator incorrectly, but I get 108.7 gear inches with 46x11 and 650b wheels. So yes...a little high, but not anything close to 125 (which I admit would be silly). Also, the 14 gives me 85.4 gear inches, so the gap between 11 and 14 would be 23.3 gear

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-12 Thread Patrick Moore
Gearing is almost as fun to calculate and talk about as to ride. The jump between an 11 and a 14 (46 t ring -- I assume few on this list are using 53s with any normal cassette) is 24. PDB. EDB would be the 28 between them using the 53. I love gear fiddling. Even though I ride mostly fixed on

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-12 Thread Patrick Moore
I meant to specify a nominally 27 700C wheel. On Fri, Dec 12, 2014 at 5:32 PM, Patrick Moore bertin...@gmail.com wrote: Gearing is almost as fun to calculate and talk about as to ride. The jump between an 11 and a 14 (46 t ring -- I assume few on this list are using 53s with any normal

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-11 Thread Bill Lindsay
I think your component choices all sound lovely. Go ahead and think about trying an Altus rear derailer. I haven't done that yet, but I have absolutely gotten to the opinion that when you are friction shifting, expensive derailers are really overrated. Cheap works great! Flopping the

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-11 Thread dougP
Agree with Bill on all points. Rivendell' recommended components work'n'play well together. To your concern about using the 34 cog only with the 24 ring, you may be favorably impressed with how well the 8 tooth jump from the 26 to 34 works. A 36 middle ring with a 34 cog will get you up a

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-11 Thread Deacon Patrick
For me, swapping the pulleys made a world of difference. I'm on the 9-speed though. I'd have to look up the numbers, but the range I have is the same as your's in the rear and in the front is Riv's standard triple set up. I love the 34 in the rear, as I can stay in the middle front ring for 90%

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-11 Thread lungimsam
Bizarre that a derailer company would design the pulleys that don't function optimally in their original orientation. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-11 Thread Deacon Patrick
They do operate optimally for index shifting, where some wiggle helps apparently. It doesn't help with friction shifting though. With abandon, Patrick On Thursday, December 11, 2014 5:22:18 PM UTC-7, lungimsam wrote: Bizarre that a derailer company would design the pulleys that don't

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-11 Thread Doug Williams
The derailer company designed the derailer to work properly with indexed shifting systems. That's what more than 90% of their customers use...so no mystery there. Wobbly upper pulleys work best with indexed shifters. It is only the small, deeply disturbed minority using friction shifters who

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting and pulleys again

2014-12-11 Thread lungimsam
deeply disturbed..ha! That's funny. 1. *I use Silver bar ends on my Blue 2013 Sam* with the stock RBW build of the time Deore front derailer and Deore rear derailer, both, with a non-stock 8-speed Hyperglide cassette, that I got from the RBW site and everything works great. I do get some auto

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction Brifter?

2013-08-11 Thread Lee Legrand
I am surprise the Goats have not found this post yet. I do not have them but would love to hear randonneurs review on these since they may block the use of the front bag. Other than that, they look like solid shifters for riders who ride the hood. These shifters are for cyclocross users and

[RBW] Re: Friction Brifter?

2013-08-10 Thread Chris Andress
Coincidentally, saw a review for the Retroshift shifters on Urban Velo: http://urbanvelo.org/retroshift-cx2-brakeshift-levers/ -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it,

[RBW] Re: Friction Brifter?

2013-08-09 Thread Chris Andress
Couldn't you also put the thumb shifters on the top bar, like on a mountain bike? Seems easier than a stem shifter. I like the retroshift idea myself. I may have to give those a try! Chris On Sunday, August 4, 2013 10:35:10 PM UTC-7, Michael wrote: Is there one in existence? I love my

[RBW] Re: Friction Brifter?

2013-08-08 Thread IanA
Have to agree that stem shifters are super convenient and can be had for small sums of money. Old Suntour or Shimano with long levers work well and you can change gear for front or rear with either hand. This is a low cost and excellent option, if the Kelly's or Retroshift weren't more your

[RBW] Re: Friction Brifter?

2013-08-06 Thread Joe Bernard
+1 for stem shifters. I have Simplex Retrofriction mounted on Riv's mounts, and it's pretty awesome. I use them with V-O Porteur bars so not a direct comparison, but I would think reaching back in the same plane from the hoods on drops would be better for you than the downward move to bar-cons.

[RBW] Re: Friction Brifter?

2013-08-05 Thread IanA
Retroshift shifters http://retroshift.com/ will come pretty close to what you are describing. On Sunday, August 4, 2013 11:35:10 PM UTC-6, Michael wrote: Is there one in existence? I love my Silver shifters, but would like a more convenient reach to a shifter on drops. I have to keep

[RBW] Re: Friction Brifter?

2013-08-05 Thread Johnny Alien
Those are a good suggestion. Cheaper would maybe be mount them to the stem. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to

[RBW] Re: Friction Brifter?

2013-08-05 Thread Shoji Takahashi
Another possibility: Kelly Take Offs. IIRC, these were featured many moons ago in a RR. http://kellybike.com/2nd_xtra_takeoff.html On Monday, August 5, 2013 6:13:41 AM UTC-4, Johnny Alien wrote: Those are a good suggestion. Cheaper would maybe be mount them to the stem. -- You received

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-05-15 Thread Michael Hechmer
Ouch, Zach. I'm not sure how that can happen. Did you hit it with your tones pointed in? You might want to think about a simple toe clip. I use the Bruce Gordon with the White pedal on my town - errand - touring bike; and like them a lot because they pretty much keep my foot settled while

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-05-15 Thread Zack
Nope, it was my heel. i hopped up onto the pedal, my heel kind of missed the target (pedal) and found a new target (front derailer). -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To view this discussion on the web visit

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-05-14 Thread Zack
I find this to be relatively amusing: One of the tips in here was to switch to a compact double. Well, last week, I was in traffic in our downtown and pushed down with a ton of force to get up to speed really quickly at a green light. I am a big dude, and I ended up driving my sneaker down

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-05-05 Thread Zack
just finished Just Ride, and there is a bunch of good stuff in the book. if you come across this thread and are looking for more tips/insight, pick up the book! -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To view this discussion on the

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-05-05 Thread Michael Hechmer
OK, I probably shouldn't post this, but I can't resist. There's a common topic on the tandem list about people yelling, Hey fella, she's not pedaling. label this, she's not shifting. Two years ago we bought a tandem, and my wife fell in love with it; so much so that, until today, she hadn't

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifters issue

2012-05-01 Thread William
The stop thingy is only used when that shifter is mounted on the downtube. You were right to re-use the round one without the stop thingy on your bar-con pod. On Monday, April 30, 2012 9:54:57 AM UTC-7, Lynne Fitz wrote: looseness of the bolt isn't the issue. I thought it was, but I'd

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction Shifters issue

2012-04-30 Thread PATRICK MOORE
A little blue Loctite on the bolt's threads will fix this problem. On Sun, Apr 29, 2012 at 7:22 PM, pam pamelamurra...@gmail.com wrote: This happens occasionally on mine too. I just tighten it and it's fine. I thought that's the way they work. I'll be taking it in for a tuneup and have

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifters issue

2012-04-30 Thread Lynne Fitz
looseness of the bolt isn't the issue. I thought it was, but I'd really reef it down, and a few miles later, the shifter would just lose it. This has been an intermittent problem since I originally took delivery of the bike in July 2010. In any case, the original vendor was Velo Orange, so I

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifters issue

2012-04-29 Thread pam
This happens occasionally on mine too. I just tighten it and it's fine. I thought that's the way they work. I'll be taking it in for a tuneup and have them looked at. It only happens once every few months and I just tighten a slight bit. I thought they just worked themselves loose over time.

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifters issue

2012-04-24 Thread Bob Cooper
I too suspect a thicker washer is the solution. Counterintuitively, sometimes when mechanical things slip, the solution is to apply a thin layer of oil or grease to every metal-to- metal interface including both sides of all washers and to all threads. This enables you to tighten them more. It

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-19 Thread Frank Brose
Joes' advice is great. It's simple stuff. It's like learning to ride a bikeonce you figure it out (and that's not to tough) you just get better. I prefer it but it's what I learned on and still think it's as good as it gets. You have to dance on the pedals so to speak. In fact, given my

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-18 Thread RJM
Hey, Bicycling Magazine every so often is good for something. I kid, I kid. On Tuesday, April 17, 2012 10:02:56 PM UTC-5, Joe Bernard wrote: What may seem intuitive to me today came from reading exactly the way you're doing now. It may be possible to teach oneself all the shifting

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-18 Thread pam
Which one is the shifter bolt? If I ask the LBS will they know which one it is? I do have the Silver shifters. It is a 8 speed. It only skips occasionally - twice in 14 miles. It's more an annoyance since there are no squeaks or rattles otherwise. Thanks, Pam On Apr 17, 8:07 pm, Jim Thill -

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-18 Thread Jim Thill - Hiawatha Cyclery
It's the little loop bolt that attaches the shifter to the frame or to the bar-end pod. You can tighten it with your fingers. Your LBS will know exactly what to do, if you ask. On Wednesday, April 18, 2012 11:03:25 AM UTC-5, pam wrote: Which one is the shifter bolt? If I ask the LBS will

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-18 Thread Ryan Ray
I'm a friction noob too but some things that helped me: - Move to a compact double. Seriously. I have one less gear I didn't need anyway and I fiddle with my shifters 90% less. Anyone who says a triple in front is just as easy as a double hash been riding bikes for a very long

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-18 Thread Jim
I have this 25 year hole in my riding history, stopped around 1987, just restarted last year. So i've never NOT shifted friction. Before my Hilsen, I was grinding gears through an old (and miserable) schwinn-approved Huret. That will get upgraded if i ever bring that bike back on line...

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-18 Thread Michael Hechmer
Right on happycamper! I couldn't agree more. I run both a double and triples in 9 speed mode and am happy with both, but anyone who says a triple is just as easy to use as a double is probably in denial. My favorite setup is on my Ram, 44/30 rings on a White Ind Crank mated to an 11/28 9

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-17 Thread Joe Bernard
The remedies for throwing chains I've used is careful adjustment of the front derailer, and making those front shifts gently. One rule of them which will contribute to shifting this way is shift before you need to. If you're approaching an incline that will require the granny ring, go ahead

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-17 Thread Michael Hechmer
I'm not quite sure what you mean by throwing chains on the big granny gear, but assume you mean the chain overshifts and falls to the outside of the ring. If so there are three possible causes. The limit screws in the F dr may need to be tightened just a bit. You can also buy a chain

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-17 Thread Zack
I have thrown the chain off the outside ring (i.e. the chain goes too far outside) and off the inside ring (i.e. it goes too far inside). I have fiddled with the limit screws and followed the riv install a derailer video, by my eye things look right. Setup questions: I have the Alpina FD 8

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-17 Thread Michael Hechmer
I'm not familiar with that derailler. Make sure the derailler is only a couple of mm above the big ring. Some deraillers, including the popular 105, have such a long cage that they cannot be lowered down to a 46 ring without hitting the chain stay. I use the Campy, which has a pretty short

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-17 Thread Eric Norris
From the Master (Sheldon Brown): Everything you need to know about chain wear, skipping, etc.: http://sheldonbrown.com/chains.html --Eric N On Apr 17, 2012, at 4:34 PM, Michael Hechmer mhech...@gmail.com wrote: I'm not familiar with that derailler. Make sure the derailler is only a

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-17 Thread Zack
FD was from Riv, I had them do the setup last year when I got the bike. It would surprise me if I had already worn out either a chainring or a casette, only rode the Sam for the end of the summer until now, less than 1,000 miles I would imagine. slipping on the cogs, not the rings. have

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-17 Thread Jim Thill - Hiawatha Cyclery
If it's skipping around the rear cluster with Silver shifters, I'd suggest making sure the shifter bolt is tight. Also, I find that these shifters are at their best with 7/8sp cassettes or freewheels. With 9sp, the ratcheting is too imprecise for my tastes, but others report apparently

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-17 Thread Joe Bernard
Zack, I live in a hilly area so I use all three rings pretty often..this may not apply to your terrain. Like you, I ride flattish roads in the middle ring, but when approaching an incline I'll usually shift to the small ring up front before bottoming out the gears in back. So my conditions are

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-17 Thread Zack
Joe - Thank you for the response - perfect description, and also the exact opposite of what I have been doing. To some of you guys may just be intuitive or obvious, but it takes me a little bit to catch on to things. I will also tighten the silvers up again. It does seem like I have to *

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-17 Thread Horace
On Tue, Apr 17, 2012 at 7:46 PM, Zack zack...@gmail.com wrote: I will also tighten the silvers up again. It does seem like I have to * really* have them tight in order for them not to slip on the Sam. I had a Salsa Casseroll that had silvers which was not nearly as finnicky. I had this

[RBW] Re: Friction Shifting and Riding Tips?

2012-04-17 Thread Joe Bernard
What may seem intuitive to me today came from reading exactly the way you're doing now. It may be possible to teach oneself all the shifting tricks strictly from riding and doing, but I prefer to ask someone who already knows them. My front shifting approach was derived from a Bicycling

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-15 Thread stevep33
Recently switched to 9sp 7700 Dura Ace downtube indexed shifters after a long time using Silver friction dt shifters. Maybe I'm getting lazy, but I'm pretty happy with the result particularly when off-road. The indexed shifters shift perfectly every time. It turns out that you can also use

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-15 Thread Jim Cloud
I have friction shifters on one of my bikes, and indexed shifters (the old SunTour Accushift) on my Rivendell Road Standard. I actually prefer the indexed shifters, just a quick click and the bike is in the gear with no need to trim or adjust the shift. Maybe I'm lazy, but the ease of shifting

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-15 Thread islaysteve
This thread is 30 posts long, so WTH, I'll weigh in with my 2 cents. STI brake-shift levers pretty much (hard to find the right words) brought back my cycling life in 1995. Been riding them ever since, mostly the very same components (105-8), now installed on my new-to-me Riv. I won't give

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-14 Thread Patrick in VT
On Sep 13, 6:16 pm, Thomas Lynn Skean thomaslynnsk...@comcast.net wrote: Does anybody here use other modern index arrangements, like STI or higher numbers of cogs or other brifters? If so, are those systems more finicky? Like, do they require regular re-alignment? miss gears? seem hard to

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-14 Thread EricP
Funny. Because of this discussion, decided to move the little lever on my Shimano 8 speed clickers to friction for the commute into work this morning. As before, it works fine. No problems with it. In fact, could argue it operates a bit smoother than the Silver shifters on my Sam Hillborne.

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-14 Thread Horace
On Wed, Sep 14, 2011 at 6:25 AM, Patrick in VT swing4...@gmail.com wrote: Still, I love 9spd dura ace indexing downtube shifters - just some about the click/pop super positive engagement on those. These are excellent. I put them on my Romulus years back and I swore if they gave me the least

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting, moral and intellectual virtue, and a very, very Rivendellian book.

2011-09-13 Thread Pondero
Title - Shop Class as Soulcraft Author - Matthew B. Crawford Fantastic book. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To post to this group, send email to rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com. To unsubscribe from this group, send email

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-13 Thread Steve D.
I first saw the rackaleur at the LBS (Counterbalance Bicycles) on the B-G a few months ago. It had one of VO's boxy bags attached to it. I thought it was an inexpensive alternative to decaleurs, and I didn't want to put a front rack on my Atlantis. And I was really fixated on getting a boxy-style

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting, moral and intellectual virtue, and a very, very Rivendellian book.

2011-09-13 Thread Steve D.
The other day I was doing my morning ride with a friend who has STI shifting. So we're riding along, and we both shift for a hill. His clicked into gear, mine to a bit of feel. At that point, I think I realized why I like friction shifting: it's like shifting a manual transmission as opposed to an

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-13 Thread Thomas Lynn Skean
Hi, all. My general experience is that indexing works very, very well. But my experience has been almost entirely with SL-BS64 (Ultegra) 8-speed shifters (the bar-con, sometimes bar-end but sometimes on thumbies) with a 7-speed IRD freewheel. I've also used SL-BS64 shifters with

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-13 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Tue, 2011-09-13 at 15:16 -0700, Thomas Lynn Skean wrote: Does anybody here use other modern index arrangements, like STI or higher numbers of cogs or other brifters? If so, are those systems more finicky? Like, do they require regular re-alignment? miss gears? seem hard to control? shift

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-13 Thread James Warren
Ditto! Pretty much my favorite all-time shifting system. On Sep 13, 2011, at 3:40 PM, Steve Palincsar wrote: I have several - lots - of bikes that have 9 speed indexed drive trains with Shimano indexed bar end shifters. They aren't finicky at all, and do not require regular

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-13 Thread dougP
Thomas: One of my touring buds (with decades of experience) has 9 speed STI on both his go-fast (a 20 year old, lugged steel custom Lighthouse) and his REI Randonnee touring bike, both with triples. Both function perfectly. He recently fitted the Lighthouse with a wide(r) range cassette to get

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-13 Thread rob markwardt
I think you get used to what you use. I use silvers on a couple bikes...bikes I ride all the time...8 and 9 speed, and I can move the levers into a specific gear without a thought. No fussing, no figiting. I honestly can't imagine index being any more precise or quicker...could be though. I

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Michael Hechmer
I don't think I'd ever actually get to the point where the chain simply lands in alignment with the cog 98+% of the time, which is how I'd characterize my Shimano-shifter indexing experience. You may be surprised at how accurate you can be with some practice. One of the things that I like

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Garth
Thomas .. your first ride with friction shifters and you're already saying you'll never be accurate shifting with them? Give yourself some time with them. They require some conscious effort at first, but they'll get easier. Stop comparing them with indexed shifters . 'cause that they

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Thomas Lynn Skean
I should point out... this was my first decent-length ride with Silver shifters, not friction. I rode with friction shifting for most of a decade as a teenager. Rode a lot, actually, compared to normal kid riding. While shifting then was never a big problem, it was something that I always to be

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread PATRICK MOORE
One place where I'd be inclined to choose indexing is for off road riding where rough terrain makes smooth friction shifting hard to do. As it is, my terrain is mostly flat, so I don't bother, but for terrain that called for a lot more shifting, I'd be inclined to choose it. But only 7 speed

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Mon, 2011-09-12 at 05:01 -0700, Thomas Lynn Skean wrote: I should point out... this was my first decent-length ride with Silver shifters, not friction. I rode with friction shifting for most of a decade as a teenager. Rode a lot, actually, compared to normal kid riding. While shifting

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Mon, 2011-09-12 at 04:04 -0700, Michael Hechmer wrote: You may be surprised at how accurate you can be with some practice. One of the things that I like about the Silver shifters is that I can leap across most of the cassette in a single move, which is nice when or if you ride a lot of

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread SamuelJames
I tried friction for awhile with the Silver shifter and I got to the point where I could shift perfectly about 98% of the time. I switched to Shimano bar-cons for a test and to be honest can not see myself going back to friction. They work really well and when they are get out of whack I can

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread jimD
I guess I should confess to being an 'imperfect' shifter. I've got silvers on the Saluki and bar end indexers on the custom and like em both. Never thought about high 90% shifting accuracy. Don't really notice probably cause I've got poor powers of shifter discrimination. Or...I've just got

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Garth
The truth is it really doesn't matter what kind of shifting one does. If I had a choice of indexed or or not riding at all indexed it'd be :) We have a choice though and we have good ones. Life is a celebration of being doing . . . . when my days as Garth are over . . . . I

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Thomas Lynn Skean
On Monday, September 12, 2011 9:37:24 AM UTC-5, Garth wrote: The truth is it really doesn't matter what kind of shifting one does. If I had a choice of indexed or or not riding at all indexed it'd be :) We have a choice though and we have good ones. Life is a celebration of

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Thomas Lynn Skean
On Monday, September 12, 2011 7:04:21 AM UTC-5, Patrick Moore wrote: One place where I'd be inclined to choose indexing is for off road riding where rough terrain makes smooth friction shifting hard to do. As it is, my terrain is mostly flat, so I don't bother, but for terrain that called

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Steve D.
http://db.tt/Y01RjLd - Rackaleur, Baggins, and Irish I like that rackaleur solution for you Hobo bag. It's very elegant. I've been using hemp tied between my Hobo bag's D-rings and brake hoods to suspend it from the h'bars. I need to order one from VO. -Steve DeMont Seattle On Sep 12, 3:07 am,

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Eric Norris
FWIW, I rode PBP this year with friction-shifting downtube levers. There's plenty of varying terrain, and I found the setup (7-speed freewheel) to work just fine. I never really missed index shifting. I also took comfort in the fact that there's very little to go wrong with friction

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Montclair BobbyB
Out of practicality I ride indexed 9-speed derailleurs for off-road, and can't imagine getting by without them; (in particular I like SRAM XO gripshifters and derailleurs, as they offer fast, precise, flawless shifting when you need it in situations where you can ill-afford to be crunching in

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Thomas Lynn Skean
On Monday, September 12, 2011 10:34:05 AM UTC-5, Steve D. wrote: http://db.tt/Y01RjLd - Rackaleur, Baggins, and Irish I like that rackaleur solution for you Hobo bag. It's very elegant. Higher praise than it deserves. But appreciated. It does work, though, exactly as you might hope; the

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting, moral and intellectual virtue, and a very, very Rivendellian book.

2011-09-12 Thread dougP
Patrick: I also have read that book, and thoroughly enjoyed the author's points. It was pointed out to me by someone else who'd read the book that he uses two styles, one quite academic (passages I had to re- read) and the other more workingman. It's not obtrusive and I didn't notice the shifts

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Re: 7 speed: no, I was being facetious. Good luck on the bracket; let's see the result. On Mon, Sep 12, 2011 at 9:30 AM, Thomas Lynn Skean thomaslynnsk...@comcast.net wrote: On Monday, September 12, 2011 7:04:21 AM UTC-5, Patrick Moore wrote: But only 7 speed cassettes. Is that because

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Minh
Funny how this came up, i was riding this weekend (on the quickbeam so maybe it was more noticeable) and was thinking about how loud index shifting was on the go-fast riders around me. As i don't have any bikes with index shifting anymore i had forgetten how loud it is when you shift down. As

[RBW] Re: Friction

2011-09-12 Thread Ryan J
I use Silver downtube on my Jamis Aurora and Silver barend on my Sam Hillborne and I got to say if I was being honest with myself, I don't know if I will ever really go back to index shifters. Maybe on a mountainbike because the quick precise shifting may be more helpful with the quickness of

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting with Dia Compe bar e nd “Silver Shifters”

2010-08-19 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Wed, 2010-08-18 at 11:46 -0700, JLa wrote: I read from Paul's web site that the Thumbies have 26mm clamp size and fit standard stem-clamp sleeves. But in the picture at rivbike.com they are mounted on Nitto bars that should be 24mm diameter:

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting with Dia Compe bar e nd “Silver Shifters”

2010-08-19 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Wed, 2010-08-18 at 11:36 -0700, JLa wrote: By the way, is it possible to convert Dia Compe bar end shifters to down tube shifters? The Dia Compe bar end shifter is in fact the shifter Sun Tour sold as the Sprint downtube lever mounted on Shimano pattern bar end shifter pods. However, if

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting with Dia Compe bar end “Silver Shifters”

2010-08-18 Thread JLa
Thanks for all the replys. My bike is quite new and the shifting is fine other than the largest cogs. If the problem was with derailleur hanger, would it affect all the gears? If forgot to say that the cassette is 9 speed (11-34). Grant Petersen's advice on the Shifting page on rivbike.com

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting with Dia Compe bar e nd ³Silver Shifters²

2010-08-18 Thread CycloFiend
on 8/18/10 8:17 AM, JLa at juhani.lait...@gmail.com wrote: Is there anyone else using the ³Silver Shifters² with Shimano 9 speed 11-34. I¹m wondering if it¹s really so that they don¹t work together well - or is it just about the technique? The main challanges with 9 speed gearing and friction

[RBW] Re: Friction shifting with Dia Compe bar end “Silver Shifters”

2010-08-18 Thread William
I use 8-speed on all the Rivendells. Silver shifters with an 8speed SRAM 11-32 cassette. I use a normal rise rear derailleur, and I can absolutely shove it from the second-largest to the largest cog under load silently. Shifting to a smaller cog is already lightly loaded, because I'm shifting

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting with Dia Compe bar e nd “Silver Shifters”

2010-08-18 Thread Brian Hanson
I would also recommend going 8 cog on the back. I found 9 too touchy with my Silvers. 8's easy. Brian On Wed, Aug 18, 2010 at 9:34 AM, William tapebu...@gmail.com wrote: I use 8-speed on all the Rivendells. Silver shifters with an 8speed SRAM 11-32 cassette. I use a normal rise rear

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting with Dia Compe bar e nd “Silver Shifters”

2010-08-18 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Wed, 2010-08-18 at 09:48 -0700, Brian Hanson wrote: I would also recommend going 8 cog on the back. I found 9 too touchy with my Silvers. 8's easy. I wasn't successful with 8, but found 7 easy. Actually, I can't see the point of 8. In the first place, the selection of available

Re: [RBW] Re: Friction shifting with Dia Compe bar e nd “Silver Shifters”

2010-08-18 Thread Seth Vidal
On Wed, Aug 18, 2010 at 12:56 PM, Steve Palincsar palin...@his.com wrote: I wasn't successful with 8, but found 7 easy. Actually, I can't see the point of 8.  In the first place, the selection of available cassettes in 8 has dwindled to the point there isn't one I'd be interested in, other

<    1   2   3   >