Rich-
Most manufacturers don't shop test the pump with the driver that's being
shipped, especially if it's a diesel.
Most have various electric shop drives that they use to simulate the
selected or specified driver.
Note that when a order says "factory choice" on a driver, you could get a
1775 motor for a 1750 pump and potentially have problems.  I'm not saying
factories are deceiving you or anything but they have a certain window to
design a pump, it's impeller, cast them and make them work.  The shop curve
in some cases will not match the acceptance curve in the field.  Nameplate
rpm is supposed to be at 150% but actual rpm is per the driver, whether
electric or diesel and how close the driver is matched to the pump and 10%
is tolerated by code.  This can get hairy when you have specific
requirements like a 110% churn  to keep pressures below 175 psi, just for
example.

Your design is what the pump is supposed to do, you ordered it that way. But
if you ordered 115% churn and got a shop curve that made 120% and you
accepted it, well .....  Not saying you did this, just saying it happens.
Tom


I guess it depends on what you're calling guaranteed performance. I would
say guaranteed "minimum" performance. The pump curves are corrected back to
rated speed so to degree that's theoretical unless your real-world driver
can maintain exactly rated speed across all flow rates. The real-world curve
should be the same at 150% and then will rise as you move back to churn. At
least with the better fire pump suppliers I've worked with, when you
indicate a very specific need to control churn pressure, they recommend
adjusting for no-load driver RPM, particularly with a diesel. Although most
diesels are in the 4-5% droop range that I'm aware of, I don't think there
is anything in the approval standards or 20 that would prevent a new unit
from meeting rated RPM at 150% and running at 10% greater RPM at churn. That
could be a significant excess churn pressure and if the engineer/designer
isn't paying attention to it, I don't think the finger can be pointed back
at the manufacturer.

Rich

Richard Malek
[EMAIL PROTECTED]



I am aware of all that.

The 10% engine speed allowance is reflected in 20% pressure range.

I get a pump package from a supplier.

Is the name plate data means min. guarantied performance or is it
meaningless?

Dan

Dan,

NFPA 20-2007 paragraph 11.2.4.1.1:
"Engines shall be provided with a governor capable of regulating
engine speed within a range of 10 percent between shutoff and maximum
load condition of the pump."

Does this help: paragraph 11.2.4.1.2
"The governor shall be field adjustable and set and secured to
maintain rated pump speed at maximum pump load." ?

The pump in concern should have a pressure relief valve installed per
paragraph 5.18.1.1:
"Where a diesel engine fire pump is installed and where a total of
121 percent of the net rated shutoff (churn) pressure plus the
maximum static suction pressure, adjusted for elevation, exceeds the
pressure for which the system components are rated, a pressure relief
valve shall be installed."

If the water supply has its own storage tank(s), you may be able to
solve the problem by piping the discharge side of this relief valve
back to the water storage tank.

Although, note that paragraph 5.7.4.2 does not allow to use the
relief valve for this purpose:
"Pressure relief valves shall not be used as a means to meet the
requirements of 5.7.4.1."

You may also find other useful text in section 5.7.4* Maximum
Pressure for Centrifugal Pumps.
like paragraph 5.7.4.1:
"The net pump shutoff (churn) pressure plus the maximum static
suction pressure, adjusted for elevation, shall not exceed the
pressure for which the system components are rated."

It says "net pressure" , no 5% allowance mentioned.

Frans Stoop
TOS architecture & fire protection
Netherlands


At 10:20 30-10-2007 +0200, you wrote:

>Dear All,
>
>I have got a problem with a fire pump.
>
>The pump performance does not match the name plant data.
>
>The cause is the Diesel Engine.
>
>The engine RPM deviation from "No Load" to 150% nominal is 90 rpm, just
over
>5% of the nominal (1760 rpm).
>
>The result is too high pressure (5% excess) at churning causing operation
of
>the 175psi relief valves of the sprinkler systems,
>
>At the other end, 150% flow, the pressure is 5% below the name plant data.
>
>The question: To what extent the pump supplier is bound by the name plant
>performance data.
>
>The supplier Rep. argues that 5% deviation is within the normal.
>
>
>Dan Arbel
>Tel: 972-4-8243337
>Fax: 972-4-8243278
>M: 972-52-2810593


_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum

To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)

Reply via email to