RE: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-07 Thread Eric Roberts
I just remember reading about that being a big factor in why it should be required. -Original Message- From: Scott Stroz [mailto:boyz...@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, July 06, 2011 9:56 PM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Dawrin Award Winner I guess I do not know enough about how insurance

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-07 Thread Maureen
Both my mother and my partner's mother have dementia, which requires a much higher level of care than someone in a vegetative state. His mother, who is California, costs about 7 grand a month. My mother, who is in Georgia, costs roughly half that, although her condition is worse. Dan's mother

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-07 Thread Chris Stoner
This topic seems like an opportunity for a new tax! You don't want to wear a helmet, fantastic, just pay the yearly I-don't-want-to-wear-a-helmet tax when you register your bike. And don't forget the I-don't-want-to-wear-a-helmet insurance that is required too. Sorry, the rates are so high but

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-07 Thread Jerry Barnes
At some point it just seems like it's not the government's business and if we decide it is, where's the line? Helmet laws were usually pushed into place by the huge insurance industry lobby. The governments didn't give a damn about personal safety. J - Ninety percent of politicians give the

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-07 Thread Larry Lyons
nice bit of propaganda but typically data and evidence free. citations please. Helmet laws were usually pushed into place by the huge insurance industry lobby. The governments didn't give a damn about personal safety. ~|

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-07 Thread Jerry Barnes
nice bit of propaganda but typically data and evidence free. Propaganda? You don't think a lobbyist group can't influence legislation? citations please.

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Scott Stroz
Here is what I do nto understand about the helmet laws for those who ride motorcycles. In those states that have these laws, you can hop on your motorcycle in a pair of shorts and a t-shirt, but as long as you are wearing a helmet, you are 'safer' - even though the rest of your body has no

RE: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Eric Roberts
can imagine that it is pretty common). -Original Message- From: Maureen [mailto:mamamaur...@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2011 11:43 PM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Dawrin Award Winner Moot. If the law is correct, even once is too many times. On Tue, Jul 5, 2011 at 9:40 PM, Eric

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread G Money
On Wed, Jul 6, 2011 at 7:56 AM, Eric Roberts ow...@threeravensconsulting.com wrote: No..The point is that the costs of all the bashed skulls would be a drain. The one instance of butt/private bits scraping would not be enough to be considered a drain because it was a one off whereas the are

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Sam
The problem used to be that the plastic helmet would wear down a bit, if dragged against pavement, until a certain point and then stop short snapping the users neck. I'm sure technology has fixed that problem by now. . On Wed, Jul 6, 2011 at 9:29 AM, G Money gm0n3...@gmail.com wrote: On Wed,

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Larry Lyons
The most expensive insurance claim related to a motorcycle accident involves a woman who fell from the back of the cycle and was dragged down the road because her jeans got caught on the kickstand. She spent months in the hospital having multiple operations to reconstruct her pelvic region, and

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Larry Lyons
Here's some data from a study by NHTSA that's very revealing. I'm reproducing the Exec summary here: (http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/Pubs/811208.PDF) The combined data set contains information on 104,472 motorcyclists involved in crashes in these 18 States during the years 2003, 2004, and 2005.

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Cameron Childress
On Wed, Jul 6, 2011 at 3:26 PM, Larry Lyons larrycly...@gmail.com wrote: So motorcycles riders who don't wear helmets cost the rest of us a lot. Its not a matter o free choice, rather its a matter of public health and safety. Those who object maybe should also be objecting to the Typhoid

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread G Money
That's interesting stuff. Question: How much would I be willing to pay for particular freedoms, including paying for other people's freedom? Just because not having a law may cost me a few extra cents in tax dollars as an American citizen, doesn't necessarily mean I should support the law.

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Larry Lyons
So motorcycles riders who don't wear helmets cost the rest of us a lot. Its not a matter o free choice, rather its a matter of public health and safety. Those who object maybe should also be objecting to the Typhoid Mary laws that exist for public health. After all its your personal

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Larry Lyons
The first study I mentioned noted that following Pennsylvania's repeal non helmet related head injuries went up over 42 percent. Here's the rest of the quote: The number of head-injured, hospitalized motorcyclists requiring further care at facilities specializing in rehabilitation and

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Maureen
It is if you divide the amount spent by the number of taxpayers. Probably more like a few cents. Personally, I think anyone who rides a motorcycle without a helmet is already brain dead, but I don't think it is my place to require them to wear one. On Wed, Jul 6, 2011 at 1:18 PM, Larry Lyons

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Scott Stroz
Unless all of these motorcyclists were under Medicare or Medicaid, I am not sure I see how this costs 'us' any more money than any other disease/injury. On Wed, Jul 6, 2011 at 4:18 PM, Larry Lyons larrycly...@gmail.com wrote: The first study I mentioned noted that following Pennsylvania's

RE: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Eric Roberts
It increases insurance rates. -Original Message- From: Scott Stroz [mailto:boyz...@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, July 06, 2011 8:07 PM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Dawrin Award Winner Unless all of these motorcyclists were under Medicare or Medicaid, I am not sure I see how this costs

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Larry Lyons
Unless all of these motorcyclists were under Medicare or Medicaid, I am not sure I see how this costs 'us' any more money than any other disease/injury. You want to know how fast you can burn through a million? Just look at how much it costs to maintain someone in a persistent vegitative

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Scott Stroz
. -Original Message- From: Scott Stroz [mailto:boyz...@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, July 06, 2011 8:07 PM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Dawrin Award Winner Unless all of these motorcyclists were under Medicare or Medicaid, I am not sure I see how this costs 'us' any more money than any other

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-06 Thread Gruss Gott
G Money gm0n3...@gmail.com wrote: That's interesting stuff. I know drinking causes umpteen millions, and maybe billions, in health spending every year.but damnit, I want to be able to drink, so i'm willing to pay the bill for a little freedom. VERY interesting point - I never thought

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-05 Thread Jerry Barnes
Probably was a real downer for the rest of the rally. And as a blast from the past: Gary Busey Urges States to Pass Helmet Laws December 14, 1991 Actor Gary Busey, who was not wearing a helmet when he was nearly killed in a motorcycle crash three years ago, on Friday urged all state

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-05 Thread Gruss Gott
Jerry Barnes critic...@gmail.com wrote: Actor Gary Busey, who was not wearing a helmet when he was nearly killed in a motorcycle crash three years ago, on Friday urged all state legislatures to pass mandatory helmet laws. I'm not a biker and if I was I'd definitely wear a helmet, but a big

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-05 Thread Dana
I want to agree. On the other hand, when a motorcyclist comes in to the ER with massive head injuries, it's not going to get shrugged off as a consequence of a bad choice, too bad. So there's a social interest. On the *third* hand, if you extrapolate from that logic, the government should

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-05 Thread Maureen
The most expensive insurance claim related to a motorcycle accident involves a woman who fell from the back of the cycle and was dragged down the road because her jeans got caught on the kickstand. She spent months in the hospital having multiple operations to reconstruct her pelvic region, and

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-05 Thread Dana
I understand the issue. But then why require seat belt use? I am not really comfortable arguing either side of this debate. One of the things I don't like about Canada is the mentality that personal health choices can be politically incorrect because they affect the collective public health.

RE: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-05 Thread Eric Roberts
Award Winner The most expensive insurance claim related to a motorcycle accident involves a woman who fell from the back of the cycle and was dragged down the road because her jeans got caught on the kickstand. She spent months in the hospital having multiple operations to reconstruct her pelvic

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-05 Thread Maureen
. -Original Message- From: Maureen [mailto:mamamaur...@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2011 11:15 PM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Dawrin Award Winner The most expensive insurance claim related to a motorcycle accident involves a woman who fell from the back of the cycle and was dragged

Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-04 Thread Larry Lyons
Darwin Award Winner of the Day: A man taking part in a protest against mandatory helmet laws died after losing control of his motorcycle and striking his helmet-less head on the pavement. Parish-resident Philip A. Contos was riding his 1983 Harley Davidson along Route 11 in Onondaga, New

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-04 Thread Vivec
Yeah I saw this. Kinda sad. Yeah. I see the humor though...^_^ On 4 July 2011 09:36, Larry Lyons larrycly...@gmail.com wrote: Darwin Award Winner of the Day: A man taking part in a protest against mandatory helmet laws died after losing control of his motorcycle and striking his helmet-less

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-04 Thread Justin Scott
Darwin Award Winner of the Day: A man taking part in a protest against mandatory helmet laws died after losing control of his motorcycle and striking his helmet-less head on the pavement. That's one of the great and terrible things about living in a mostly free society. You have the right

Re: Dawrin Award Winner

2011-07-04 Thread Casey Dougall
On Mon, Jul 4, 2011 at 1:46 PM, Justin Scott leviat...@darktech.org wrote: Darwin Award Winner of the Day: A man taking part in a protest against mandatory helmet laws died after losing control of his motorcycle and striking his helmet-less head on the pavement. That's one of the