Re: Recovered memory

2005-02-09 Thread Annette Taylor, Ph. D.
Quoting David Hogberg <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > Is it because she's "only" a psychologist? Just wondering. > Or only a woman??? annette Annette Kujawski Taylor, Ph. D. Department of Psychology University of San Diego 5998 Alcala Park San Diego, CA 92110 [EMAIL PROTECTED] --- You are currentl

Re: student question: Broca's & Wernicke's Areas

2005-02-09 Thread Rikikoenig
In a message dated 2/9/05 11:15:18 AM Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: A side question: a few years ago I read about research that suggestedthat there are some fundamental differences between ASL and "ordinary"languages, such that people who grow up speaking ASL exclus

Re: Recovered memory

2005-02-09 Thread David Hogberg
Tim: I agree w/ your contention that there are some holes in the arguments supporting the defendant's jury-decided guilt. What bothers me about the whole controversy, though, is the way that the term "repression" was tossed about with abandon and that people "all over the place" seem to be uncriti

RE: student question: Broca's & Wernicke's Areas

2005-02-09 Thread Frigo, Lenore
Marc Carter asked "A side question: .[snip] that people who grow up speaking ASL exclusively tend not to read at the usual (age, peer, etc.) level. ASL is far more spatial than spoken (or written) language, and something about that spatial character generates differences in the way language

Re: graduating senior Tests

2005-02-09 Thread Dr . Bob Wildblood
Deb, From Doug's response to your post, it would appear that there are a lot of us out here that are interested in something that does what we want it to do in testing our graduating seniors. Maybe his idea has some merit. We have been using the ETS test and have been looking at other commerc

Re: Recovered memory

2005-02-09 Thread Beth Benoit
This case took place in our "neighborhood" - everything is pretty close if you live in New England, so it's all your neighborhood...   There were other accusers in the Shanley case, but they decided against testifying at the last minute.  The one who stood his ground did, indeed claim that h

Oops!

2005-02-09 Thread Peterson, Douglas \(USD\)
Obviously my typing and proof-reading skills give out after 2 posts - sorry! My last e-mail (#3) Should have read "NOTHING from me for months." Doug --- You are currently subscribed to tips as: archive@jab.org To unsubscribe send a blank email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

RE: graduating senior Tests

2005-02-09 Thread Peterson, Douglas \(USD\)
Noting from me for months and then three in one day - something strange is happening. I have been on our departmental assessment committee for 3 years and we have struggled to come up with a solution for a variety of reasons, but I'll pose one question and one money making scheme Question - if an

Re: Fwd: Brain game

2005-02-09 Thread Patrick O. Dolan
Well I knew what was coming (though I thought it was going to ask about a vegetable and an animal) and I still picked hammer and red! Patrick __ Patrick O. Dolan, Ph.D. Assistant Professor Department of Psychology Drew University Madison, NJ 07940 973-408-3558 [EMAIL PROTECTED] - Original M

graduating senior Tests

2005-02-09 Thread Deb Briihl
Sorry for the cross posting. For those of you who use a test that you have created for graduating seniors, could you send me a copy of what yours looks like? We are putting together one here and I would like some samples if possible. I know that there are tests created out there that we could

RE: Recovered memory

2005-02-09 Thread Shearon, Tim
Tipsters- Not a reply to anyone in particular but I'm sure there will be an A&E treatment of this case and how the memories were recovered, etc.  within the next 3 or 4 days (sorry for the cynicism- they just seem to get these sensationalistic cases on American Justice or such very quickly).

Re: Recovered memory

2005-02-09 Thread Tom Allaway
I, too, am curious what the facts of the Shandley conviction are.  I heard (on NPR, I think) that the defense  claimed that the alleged victim's "recovered memory" only happened after he had discussed the court case with other alleged victims.  This would certainly make it suspect.  My understand

RE: Fwd: Brain game

2005-02-09 Thread Shearon, Tim
Has anyone tried just asking people to name a color and a tool. I wonder what percent would say "RED HAMMER" without the math prompts. :) Tim -Original Message- From: Paul Smith [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, February 09, 2005 6:59 AM To: Teaching in the Psychological Science

RE: Fwd: Brain game

2005-02-09 Thread Shearon, Tim
Rick- I'll confirm your reactant hypothesis- I said Blue Hammer too!. Tim :) -Original Message- From: Rick Froman [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, February 09, 2005 11:01 AM To: Teaching in the Psychological Sciences Subject: RE: Fwd: Brain game Here's another hypothesis to ad

RE: student question: Broca's & Wernicke's Areas

2005-02-09 Thread Miguel Roig
I have had that opportunity ... unfortunately. Over 25 years ago while in college, a Cuban friend who was already quite fluent in English either developed an aneurysm which eventually burst or had a stroke of some sort (I forget the details). Anyhow, he became aphasic and could only articulat

RE: student question: Broca's & Wernicke's Areas

2005-02-09 Thread DeVolder Carol L
Something I and my students find interesting is the rare case of aphasia in polyglots (people who are multilingual). I have gone back to some of the earlier writings on aphasia as cited in Hecaen and Albert (1976), and find it fascinating that someone who is multilingual may lose their "mother t

RE: Fwd: Brain game

2005-02-09 Thread Rick Froman
Here's another hypothesis to add to Doug's: Psychologists, the contrary (and possibly psychologically reactant) lot that we are, are more likely to send a response to TIPS if we didn't say red hammer (I, for example, said blue hammer) than if we did while the average person is more likely to forwar

Recovered memory

2005-02-09 Thread Claudia Stanny
I was surprised to learn that the primary witness in the recently adjudicated Shanley case involved a victim with a recovered memory of abuse. Until I heard that Elizabeth Loftus was involved with the trial, I had assumed that the victims in this case had continuous recollections of their abuse. Ho

Re: TIPS archive time warp

2005-02-09 Thread Bill Southerly
Stephen, Yes, there is something screwy going on - incompatibility of two different software packages. I have been told by those in charge that it can not be resolved and no more attempts will be made to try to resolve it. So if you retrieve something from the archives, be sure to look at the

Re: Fwd: Brain game

2005-02-09 Thread David Campbell
This could work for a class demonstration. First, put the sequence of questions in PowerPoint format. Have some of the class watch and record answers while others look down. Then reverse this for the next "group." Easy to run 3 "groups" this way in a large lecture class with 3 slightly dif

TIPS archive time warp

2005-02-09 Thread Stephen Black
I've just spend a fair bit of time in the TIPS archive, trying to locate a post from long long ago for which I only had the date. Supposedly, TIPS allows searches on the date. But I discovered that to TIPS, all posts were on 2004/09/23. OK, I'm exaggerating. But there's something very peculiar

RE: Fwd: Brain game

2005-02-09 Thread Peterson, Douglas \(USD\)
Several of my students last semester in PSYC 101 asked me if I knew why the number 5 was related to the color red. They even asked me what color came to mind with I thought of the number 5 (I even said red) and then they proceeded to ask why. My answer then was similar to those on this list - Red

Re: student question: Broca's & Wernicke's Areas

2005-02-09 Thread Annette Taylor, Ph. D.
Yes, this fits with what I know; namely, that there is no type of language, other than just a compilation of haphazard pieces of language--the organizational structure of language is disrupted. This applies both to receptive and productive language. However, when there is a conduction deficit,

RE: Fwd: Brain game

2005-02-09 Thread Annette Taylor, Ph. D.
Well I picked a red screwdriver, so there! But that aside, I had seen a similar discussion where yellow was considered to be the most common color to be picked. I just make take Paul up on his research design below and toss it to some of my students Unfortunately, I deleted the original post. C

grad school program advice

2005-02-09 Thread swansomr
Hi all, I am a senior in college and plan on graduating in December of 2005. I am planning on attending graduate school (preferably a PhD program) in Fall of 2006. My problem is that I am having a hard time determining what type of program I want to attend. If any of you have any advice on how to c

RE: student question: Broca's & Wernicke's Areas

2005-02-09 Thread Marc Carter
Exactly right. Too often we confuse communication with language. Language has other characteristics, but syntax is essential to the definition. (Too often this is taken as a way to denigrate other forms of communication; I always tell students that it differentiates, but does not denigrate.) A

Re: student question: Broca's & Wernicke's Areas

2005-02-09 Thread Tom Allaway
    I thought it had been pretty well established that the key ingredient for real language was syntax.  ASL has it, and is a true language.  The symboling chimps appear not to have it (although there is still a minority who believe they do).  Pidgins don't have it, creoles do.  Bickerton suggest

RE: student question: Broca's & Wernicke's Areas

2005-02-09 Thread Rick Adams
Marc: And I might not be able to read or write or speak, but might be able to use symbols to communicate (I think here of chimps and other non-human primates). Rick: Wow! I didn't know politicians knew how to use symbols to communicate! -- Rick Adams. Capella University Grand Canyon University

RE: student question: Broca's & Wernicke's Areas

2005-02-09 Thread Marc Carter
Hey, All -- Seems that we should be careful to distinguish language, communication, and speech. Damage to some areas affects speech, but might not necessarily affect language; that is, I might not be able to speak, but I could read and write and communicate other ways. Other damage might legiti

RE: student question: Broca's & Wernicke's Areas

2005-02-09 Thread tarner
Rick, What you are explaining is exactly what the students were saying. What do we define as language? This is where I became unclear as to what the damage actually meant. I couldn't find a clear answer anywhere. Nina > Wouldn't that depend on our interpretation of "language" however? > > For

RE: student question: Broca's & Wernicke's Areas

2005-02-09 Thread Rick Adams
Wouldn't that depend on our interpretation of "language" however? For example, damage to Wernike's and Broca's areas won't prevent a person from being able to draw a picture of a scene. Nor will it affect his or her understanding of the concepts of "future," "past," or such verbal concepts as "to

RE: student question

2005-02-09 Thread Peterson, Douglas \(USD\)
Completely anecdotal, but our campus ASL interpreter has taught stroke victims with language impairments to use a limited set of signs, and she stressed that, at best, some have been able to learn about 100-150 signs but do not use ASL as a language only as symbolic representation. The funny thing

Re: student question: Broca's & Wernicke's Areas

2005-02-09 Thread Tom Allaway
I think your student doesn't understand how central to language these areas are. Someone with damage to Broca's area would not be making up their own language, because they haven't just lost their original language, they've lost the processing areas necessary for any language. Similarly, if s

student question

2005-02-09 Thread tarner
We were discussing Broca's and Wernicke's areas last night in Intro. and how damage to Broca's area means the person has trouble with speaking a language and damage to Wernicke's area means the person has trouble understanding spoken language. I was under the impression that with "language" we are

RE: Fwd: Brain game

2005-02-09 Thread Paul Smith
Being yet another of that reported 2% (orange hammer, in my case), I'm a bit disinclined to explain a phenomenon that so far doesn't seem to exist. However, I can imagine a mechanism by which the math would make a difference. "Red" and "hammer" seem fairly prototypical of their respective categ