Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-29 Thread kh6ty
Hi Rick, The numbers for the models seem very optimistic. Normal gain for J-pole (theoretical) can not be more than a dipole, since the antennas is an end fed dipole with the Q section for matching. This means at most 2.14 dBi, but maybe you are experiencing some ground gain which you can

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-29 Thread Rick W
Judy and I did further testing of 1/4 wave and 5/8 wave antennas for 2 meters on her vehicle using the ICOM IC-7000 at 50 watts out. The base station continued to be the 30 foot high homebrew J-pole and now has 100 watts out from the ICOM 746 Pro. The mobile antennas were only mag mounts, but

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-28 Thread Rick W
Skip, Realistically, the 5/8 wave will be maybe around the gain of a dipole. I would use 2 dBi, maybe 3 dBi at the most. I don't think there are any 5/8 wave verticals that can do much better than that and some antenna gurus point out that they can perform worse than half wave antennas. I

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-28 Thread kh6ty
Rick, Skip, Realistically, the 5/8 wave will be maybe around the gain of a dipole. I would use 2 dBi, maybe 3 dBi at the most. I don't think there are any 5/8 wave verticals that can do much better than that and some antenna gurus point out that they can perform worse than half wave

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-28 Thread Rick W
Hi Skip, The numbers for the models seem very optimistic. Normal gain for J-pole (theoretical) can not be more than a dipole, since the antennas is an end fed dipole with the Q section for matching. This means at most 2.14 dBi, but maybe you are experiencing some ground gain which you can get

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-27 Thread kh6ty
Hi Rick, Have you found that DominoEX is the best overall digital mode for FM? I know that PSK modes can have doppler errors from aircraft, but otherwise seem pretty good for weak signal. Yes, definitely! DominoEx is a frequency shift keying mode, not a phase shift mode, but doppler problems

[digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-27 Thread Mel
Regarding horizontal antennas... they also have a big advantage in rejecting intermod due to being cross-polarized with most commercial services... --- In digitalradio@yahoogroups.com, Rick W [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Skip, Have you found that DominoEX is the best overall digital mode for

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-27 Thread Rick W
Very good information, Skip, If the signals are in the marginal range, how do you do the coordinating between the stations? How do you calculate the error rate (such as the 6% mentioned)? If I understand this correctly, the test was between a 5/8 vertical to quad for vertical polarization vs.

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-27 Thread kh6ty
If the signals are in the marginal range, how do you do the coordinating between the stations? To date, we have been able to use a cell phone. How do you calculate the error rate (such as the 6% mentioned)? We send 50eroids.(..). Anything that is

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-27 Thread kh6ty
27, 2008 8:19 PM Subject: Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field? If the signals are in the marginal range, how do you do the coordinating between the stations? To date, we have been able to use a cell phone. How do you calculate the error rate (such as the 6

[digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-26 Thread Howard Z.
@yahoogroups.com Sent: Tuesday, November 25, 2008 6:58 PM Subject: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field? Is the volunteer out of VHF range? If the base station has a 100 watt VHF radio like the 746pro - you might be able to still reach the volunteer, but he may

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-26 Thread Rick W
Hi Howard, If you respond to someone's response to a question, with asking questions of your own, then it might be reasonable for some to respond as Skip did. It seems reasonable to me considering you asked Is the volunteer out of VHF range? You also asked about setting up something in the

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-26 Thread kh6ty
] To: digitalradio@yahoogroups.com Sent: Wednesday, November 26, 2008 1:42 PM Subject: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field? SKIP SKIP SKIP READ READ READ I, HOWARD, AM not not NOT NOT not THE PERSON WITH THE QUESTION NOR THE PROBLEM. GEEZ, I TRY TO ANSWER SOMEONE'S QUESTION

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-26 Thread kh6ty
: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field? Hi Howard, If you respond to someone's response to a question, with asking questions of your own, then it might be reasonable for some to respond as Skip did. It seems reasonable to me considering you asked

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-26 Thread John Becker, WØJAB
In this county you can sum up the biggest problem in one word manpower. Within my zip code there is 3 hams living in town. One is up in the years and has not been on the air in years as well as to weak to do much. As far as the other 2, one is chief of police. The other is #2 in command on

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-26 Thread Charles Brabham
typing, my vision is not good today and I'm a hunt 'n peck typist. 73 DE Charles Brabham, N5PVL - Original Message - From: John Becker, WØJAB To: digitalradio@yahoogroups.com Sent: Wednesday, November 26, 2008 4:41 PM Subject: Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm

[digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-26 Thread Howard Z.
I deleted that posting soon after I made it. However, I suppose those who get emails still got it. My posting was not appropriate. I appologize. Howard

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-26 Thread kh6ty
Message - From: Howard Z. [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: digitalradio@yahoogroups.com Sent: Wednesday, November 26, 2008 6:32 PM Subject: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field? I deleted that posting soon after I made it. However, I suppose those who get emails still got

[digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-26 Thread Howard Z.
I deleted the posting a few minutes after I made it. I realized it was inappropriate. I somehow felt I was being challenged to a debate, All I did was give someone my 2 cents, and dozens of others would also likely give their opinions. I don't know why, but I reacted badly to the post directed

[digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-26 Thread Howard Z.
Yes indeed - I have found that nothing on HF is reliable 24/7. One can not reliably reach another country at will regardless of equipment. Local NVIS operation also has problems. In my MARS group before DST ended, conditions were pretty bad because we started before sunrise - and then

RE: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-26 Thread Fred VE3FAL
-Original Message- From: digitalradio@yahoogroups.com [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Charles Brabham Sent: Wednesday, November 26, 2008 6:22 PM To: digitalradio@yahoogroups.com Subject: Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field? One obvious choice

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-26 Thread Rick W
Skip, Have you found that DominoEX is the best overall digital mode for FM? I know that PSK modes can have doppler errors from aircraft, but otherwise seem pretty good for weak signal. Your point is well taken that many of the hams who participate in public service activities, may tend to be

[digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-25 Thread Howard Z.
Is the volunteer out of VHF range? If the base station has a 100 watt VHF radio like the 746pro - you might be able to still reach the volunteer, but he may not have enough power to get back to you. Or he may be out of VHF range. HF is the way to go - but both ends of the conversation need

RE: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-25 Thread Bob Donnell
. It'll be interesting to see how they do. 73, Bob, KD7NM -Original Message- From: digitalradio@yahoogroups.com [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Howard Z. Sent: Tuesday, November 25, 2008 3:59 PM To: digitalradio@yahoogroups.com Subject: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-25 Thread kh6ty
@yahoogroups.com Sent: Tuesday, November 25, 2008 6:58 PM Subject: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field? Is the volunteer out of VHF range? If the base station has a 100 watt VHF radio like the 746pro - you might be able to still reach the volunteer, but he may not have enough

RE: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-25 Thread David Little
Subject: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field? Is the volunteer out of VHF range? If the base station has a 100 watt VHF radio like the 746pro - you might be able to still reach the volunteer, but he may not have enough power to get back to you. Or he may be out

RE: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-25 Thread Cortland Richmond
planning are not yet all known, either. Cortland KA5S AAR5UT [Original Message] From: Howard Z. [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: digitalradio@yahoogroups.com Date: 11/25/2008 6:59:21 PM Subject: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field? Is the volunteer out of VHF range

RE: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-25 Thread John Becker, WØJAB
The last time I got into something like this I was called (all be it direct reply) a fool. What works for you in the large city may not work for me in the rural area with hills all around. In the floods this spring I at times had the only HF mobile rig in the county.

RE: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-25 Thread David Little
PM To: digitalradio@yahoogroups.com Subject: RE: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field? And further, this thought should be considered as VHF FM, or VHF SSB? In a base/mobile or mobile/mobile environment, SSB on VHF works over much greater distances. With voice

Re: [digitalradio] Re: How Can We Push HF Emcomm Messages to the Field?

2008-11-25 Thread Rick W
This is something that would likely be more at home at the HFDEC yahoogroup that discusses disaster and emergency communications but lets look at some of the practical aspects. Distance was not specified, but it would be rare to send someone out at night, under dangerous conditions, in