[AsburyPark] Re: http://www.the-esperanza.com

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
It must have been a cookie because at home I get to the site. I think it is a beautiful building BUT I think one picture on thes ite tells it all. I think it is the one when you try to go to Virtual Tour. It's an illustration looking to the shoreline from the ocean. The esperanza sticks out

[AsburyPark] Land in Limbo

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
This is an excerpt from today's APP story about Springwood Avenue. My comments follow. One reason Springwood was not developed is that Philip Konvitz, the Long Branch millionaire and political power broker who died last year, controlled about four blocks of land from Memorial Drive to Atkins

[AsburyPark] ~Try To Keep It~

2006-02-24 Thread Jim
We should try to keep it on what going on Present.With the City of Asbury Park we are getting away from that feeding in to some of these Developers hands.Some Developers are taking the time to do the right way.Some are putting long days doing it don't have to.Can sit Home do it on a Computer

[AsburyPark] Re: ~Try To Keep It~

2006-02-24 Thread Jim
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, Jim [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: We should try to keep it on what going on Present.With the City of Asbury Park we are getting away from that feeding in to some of these Developers hands.Some Developers are taking the time to do the right way.Some are

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo

2006-02-24 Thread oakdorf
Since I've been amrketing the Railroad Plaza at the opposite corner, I've spoken to easily over 500 investors. Easily. Block of 902 Springwood as well. You have 2 problems here - as is now. Crime and Drugs. There is no reason that section can not, and has not, been developed. Time is

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread bluebishop82
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, dfsavgny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: All one needed to do was to get the waterfront out of litgation. A master developer was not needed. Carabetta owed the City over $12 million in taxes (about half of one year's budget at the time). Carabetta's creditors

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, bluebishop82 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Carabetta owed the City over $12 million in taxes (about half of one year's budget at the time). Carabetta's creditors were owed a fortune. If I recall correctly the price tag the Bankruptcy Judge put on it to

[AsburyPark] Incentives for affordable housing, not luxury housing. Only in AP

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
New York Daily News - http://www.nydailynews.com Mike sees 20,000 middle-class homes BY LISA L. COLANGELO DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITER Friday, February 24th, 2006 Mayor Bloomberg unveiled plans yesterday for a city version of the historic Mitchell-Lama housing program that would provide more than

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread Fred
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, bluebishop82 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: --- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, dfsavgny dfsavgny@ wrote: Don't forhet that it was a Conn. Judge not a NJ Judge. Which makes a big difference. That would still be in court. Carabretta held all the cards except

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread wernerapnj
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, bluebishop82 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Such luminaries as the State of New Jersey, Hovnanian, Westminster Realty Corp., The Applied Cos.,Berman Development Co. and Kushner Companies each looked into it and took a pass. Can you be more specific about

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread wernerapnj
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, Fred [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Don't forhet that it was a Conn. Judge not a NJ Judge. Which makes a big difference. That would still be in court. Carabretta held all the cards except for the tax liens, that's the only card the city had and they sold

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, wernerapnj [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The ASSUMPTION that the development rights were properly protected under the bankruptcy is where the problem is. The City had always maintained that Carrabetta had defaulted and thus no longer had those rights. A

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread bluebishop82
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, dfsavgny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: For instance, I am uncertain whether the city could have simply condemned the development rights or was that trumped by the Bankruptcy Court. I don't think it was tried. The second part of your answer is correct. The

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread wernerapnj
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, dfsavgny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ... They don't have to make money. That's not their purpose. We could have purely civic buildings that cost tens of millions to rehabiliatate. That's the REAL purchase price Partners was supposed to pay in order to have the

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread bluebishop82
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, wernerapnj [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The ASSUMPTION that the development rights were properly protected under the bankruptcy is where the problem is. The City had always maintained that Carrabetta had defaulted and thus no longer had those rights. A

[AsburyPark] Re: Fred's Truth - he’s such a pooch

2006-02-24 Thread Skip Bernstein
Last kick at the rabid dog. When you bring it to her ask her why should lied to you. I thougkt she didn't plea guilty to anything. And Tommy other than a lawyer, ask any layperson if a person pleaded guilty of Foodstamp Fraud are they a felon or a disorderly person 90percent would say the

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, bluebishop82 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The City wasn't weak, it's argument was. Do your really think the Bankruptcy Judge would let one creditor (Asbury Park) take back the whole asset without Carabetta's other creditors getting something? It doesn't

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread bluebishop82
Werner the next time I'm involved in litigation with a Brnkruptcy I'm going to use your laws. The laws the Bankruptcy Court makes me use are much tougher. ;-) --- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, wernerapnj [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: --- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, bluebishop82

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread oakdorf
1. On the Cab deal, one may say there were some back room deals. Many professionals walked out of various meetings, muttering to themselves they couldn't beleive it or they would take what they were told to their graves. End of an old story. Now what? 2. The city, over the years, had enough

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread oakdorf
Interesting to watch in Fed bankruptcy court in trenton, 2 bidders, their 2 attorneys. One attorney picks up his/her phone. The other attorney's phone rings. There you sit, millions in real estate up for bid, 2 offers. Any other offers? Nope. Then you leave wondering. A wink, a blink.

[AsburyPark] Re: Fred's Truth - he’s such a pooch

2006-02-24 Thread Fred
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, Skip Bernstein [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I wasn't Jerry. It was Rita and Terry not Jerry read the post. Last kick at the rabid dog. When you bring it to her ask her why should lied to you. I thougkt she didn't plea guilty to anything. And Tommy

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread wernerapnj
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, dfsavgny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: --- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, bluebishop82 bluebishop82@ wrote: This is incorrect. Not only does the Bankruptcy Judge have jurisdiction, once the Petition in Bankruptcy is filed, jurisdiction is exclusive to

[AsburyPark] The weldon saga - 2006

2006-02-24 Thread oakdorf
NEWARK — A Monmouth County developer has been indicted on charges that he paid former Ocean Township Mayor Terrance D. Weldon about $50,000 in bribes in order to help clear the way for a zoning approval. Moshe G. Gohar, 55, surrendered to the FBI Friday morning. He has been indicted on charges

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, oakdorf [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: 3. Looking back, it all looks like a great deal - but at that point in time they did what they did. I assume you meant to say DOESN'T look like a great deal or that it was a great deal for Partners. Yahoo! Groups

[AsburyPark] Re: The weldon saga - 2006

2006-02-24 Thread wernerapnj
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, oakdorf [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: NEWARK — A Monmouth County developer has been indicted on charges that he paid former Ocean Township Mayor Terrance D. Weldon about $50,000 in bribes in order to help clear the way for a zoning approval. But nothing

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread oakdorf
It was a deal for SASS. Yahoo! Groups Links * To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/AsburyPark/ * To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] * Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, wernerapnj [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On these two issues the following questions pop out. Why were the taxes never requiered to be up to date by the trustee, Why did the City never foreclosed for non-payment, Why was a paper contract for which no money

[AsburyPark] Re: The weldon saga - 2006

2006-02-24 Thread oakdorf
Let the singing begin. Yahoo! Groups Links * To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/AsburyPark/ * To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] * Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, oakdorf [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: It was a deal for SASS. So much so that Marty Sass couldn't beleive he got the entire waterfront so cheap and said so in a magazine article. I loved giving that article to the Council. Sass crows that even his own real estate

[AsburyPark] Re: The weldon saga - 2006

2006-02-24 Thread oakdorf
did weldon's prosecutor ever return from China or wherever he went to when Weldon was to be sentenced. Someone should go find him. Yahoo! Groups Links * To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/AsburyPark/ * To unsubscribe from this group, send an email

[AsburyPark] Asbury Partner's EDA Loan

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
I finally got resolution to this matter. Someone raised the question about what happened to the $1.5 million loan that NJ EDA approved. Asbury Partners was supposed to use it to acquire 1100 Ocean Ave and begin resoration on the pavillions. Mark Saldutti from EDA just confirmed to me that

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread oakdorf
I Keep asserting that the bankruptcy court had no jurisdiction over local land use and no one seems to be realizing the significance of that. ??? Today, after all is said on done, it doesn't matter. That is, unless there were some other law that enabled this to get done. Yahoo! Groups

[AsburyPark] Re: Asbury Partner's EDA Loan

2006-02-24 Thread oakdorf
Nice work, Dan. Interesting the comment: that they did a $2 billion bond float on cigarette tax revenue for the state in order to balance the budget... That is where the state has a conflict to STOP SMOKING. They lose revenue. Follows a great story last week where China has stopped new

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, wernerapnj [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: It's only an asset if it's in force, which goes back to the dysfunction of the City not forcing the claim of default. (which was pretty obvious when reading the contract). There were no rights to be held in

Re: [AsburyPark] Asbury Partner's EDA Loan

2006-02-24 Thread Lighty
On 2/24/06 3:48 PM, dfsavgny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I finally got resolution to this matter. Someone raised the question about what happened to the $1.5 million loan that NJ EDA approved. Asbury Partners was supposed to use it to acquire 1100 Ocean Ave and begin resoration on the

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread bluebishop82
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, wernerapnj [EMAIL PROTECTED] On these two issues the following questions pop out. Why were the taxes never requiered to be up to date by the trustee, Why did the City never foreclosed for non-payment, Werner, When the new council was sworn in 2001, one

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread wernerapnj
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, oakdorf [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I Keep asserting that the bankruptcy court had no jurisdiction over local land use and no one seems to be realizing the significance of that. ??? Today, after all is said on done, it doesn't matter. That is, unless there

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread oakdorf
what matters now is to get this headache moving or out - not renegotiating at the 23rd hour. Yahoo! Groups Links * To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/AsburyPark/ * To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] * Your use

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread wernerapnj
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, dfsavgny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I think that is a separate issue and I don't think that anyone, including the Bankruptcy Court, suggests that it could dictate local land use. But that's exactly what happened. Fishman walked away from the bankruptcy

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, wernerapnj [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: But that's exactly what happened. Fishman walked away from the bankruptcy with the right to build condos in places where, by zoning, Carrabetta only had the right to build commercial/retail/entertainment. Fishman

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, oakdorf [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Interesting to watch in Fed bankruptcy court in trenton, 2 bidders, their 2 attorneys. One attorney picks up his/her phone. The other attorney's phone rings. There you sit, millions in real estate up for bid, 2 offers.

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, Skip Bernstein [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Even if a promise to perform, in this case reneged on, satisfies consideration, my understanding is that unpaid taxes, trump all other claims; if these points weren't made I can't help wonder what fishy lawyer acted

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread wernerapnj
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, bluebishop82 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The Bankruptcy Turstee, with the approval of the Judge, gets to dispose of the contract. Local land use law is irrelevant. What do you think, a Federal Judge as to appear before the Asbury Park Planning Board

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in.... :CORRECTION:

2006-02-24 Thread Skip Bernstein
That is why you, Tom, myself and others suggest to the current council that they shoudl have claimed default already. Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me. There's an old saying in Tennessee — I know it's in Texas, probably in Tennessee — that says, fool me once, shame on —

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, oakdorf [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: what matters now is to get this headache moving or out - not renegotiating at the 23rd hour. Exactly. What are they negotiating? What you want is restoration fo the waterfront (they way you want it) within a certain time

[AsburyPark] How do I stack up?

2006-02-24 Thread bluebishop82
Here is two articles in a local Howell area newspaper about me versus the Mayor in the Freeholder race. Hoping you folks could critique me on how I'm stacking up on the issues. The election is tomorrow morning and the most important speech is the one right before the whole 775 member

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, wernerapnj [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Woah, now there's a stretch, that local land use law is irrelevent. Local land use law and zoning are the defacto regulations for land development and cannot be changed except by appropriate process of the

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread wernerapnj
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, dfsavgny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Nothing trumps federal jurisdiction. Land use is a unique situation and set of laws the reserve those rights to the local units. Werner Yahoo! Groups Links * To visit your group on the web, go to:

[AsburyPark] From rev. Kevin Brown

2006-02-24 Thread jerseykev
The Halper's got a 90 day stay... There will be no need to go to the prayer vigil for God has pre empted the eviction Today. However: Let us not slow down. We are gaining momemtum... The Legislators will have to listen to us and change the laws quickly to protect us. We all need to send

[AsburyPark] Re: How do I stack up?

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, bluebishop82 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Here is two articles in a local Howell area newspaper about me versus the Mayor in the Freeholder race. Hoping you folks could critique me on how I'm stacking up on the issues. The election is tomorrow morning and

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, wernerapnj [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Land use is a unique situation and set of laws the reserve those rights to the local units. You're missing the big picture here. The Court did not intrude on the city's right to set its own land use. Yahoo!

[AsburyPark] A year after Kelo

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
A year after Kelo By Linda Chavez Feb 22, 2006 As anniversaries go, this one might not be up there on your list of memorable dates, but it should be. One year ago this week, the Supreme Court heard arguments in a case that someday may affect your life in a devastating way: Kelo v. City of

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread wernerapnj
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, dfsavgny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: You are failing to see the essence here. Local land use is irrelevant in that it is immaterial to the Court. It does not and will not try to affect local land use. Dan, The MOU dictating land use in Asbury Park came

[AsburyPark] Re: A year after Kelo

2006-02-24 Thread bluebishop82
I spent this afternoon in a meeting with Township Officials and a client whose property the town wants to take by eminant domain and give to a developer. It's all around us and getting worse. --- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, dfsavgny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: A year after Kelo By Linda

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, wernerapnj [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Dan, The MOU dictating land use in Asbury Park came directly from the bankrupcty proceedings and rubber stamped by the Conn Judge. Yes, in the end run the City is responsible, but the City has always pointed back to

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread wernerapnj
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, dfsavgny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: That is what the City agreed to, not what the Court dictated. See, the Court allowed the City to determine what the land use should be. Of course the court did not dictate the land use, but the City used the cover of the

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread bluebishop82
That's absolutely expected Werner. Dan is right about this. The Trustee is trying to sell off an asset for the benefit of the creditors. Remember - the Trustee OWNS the redevelopment rights at the point in time you are referencing, not Carabetta or the City. If the MOU induces the sale so

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread Fred
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, bluebishop82 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Would of, could of, should of didn't, so what's your advice now? We know Dans. That's absolutely expected Werner. Dan is right about this. The Trustee is trying to sell off an asset for the benefit of the

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread wernerapnj
I thinks it's you guys that are not understanding this, and keep lumping the CONRACT (redevelopers agreement) together with the PLAN (zoning). I understand and agree that the trustee can hold/sell the CONTRACT and get the best price. The trustee has no juresdiction over the PLAN (zoning), nor

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, wernerapnj [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The trustee has no juresdiction over the PLAN (zoning), nor can the trustee modify the cintract in violation of the PLAN (zoning). Agreed. It was the city that allegedly acted illegal by letting land use be dictated by

[AsburyPark] Re: Land in Limbo - Question

2006-02-24 Thread bluebishop82
No Warner, the Trustee agrees to the sale with parties agreeing to the MOU. It later went to the Planning Board and the Council, etc., and a new Redevelopment Agreement completely replaced the MOU, so the integrity of Land Use Law was protected. If the Developer and the City never agreed to a

[AsburyPark] Partners tells city to stuff it

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
On a different subject, I heard a rumour that Partners is not negotiating with the city and in fact, has refused to meet except for the initial meeting. The rumoured position of Partners is that it gave the budget, plans and schedules (stretching to 2013) to the city and that is all it is

[AsburyPark] Re: Partners tells city to stuff it

2006-02-24 Thread bluebishop82
If all that happends, do you know what will happen to AP? I'll be able to buy Pat Fasano's $1.3 million house for $150K again. --- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, dfsavgny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On a different subject, I heard a rumour that Partners is not negotiating with the city and

[AsburyPark] Re: Partners tells city to stuff it

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, bluebishop82 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If all that happends, do you know what will happen to AP? I'll be able to buy Pat Fasano's $1.3 million house for $150K again. Explain please. Are you saying if Partners won't negotiate or having the 1991 plan, or

[AsburyPark] Re: Partners tells city to stuff it

2006-02-24 Thread bluebishop82
The opinion maker, unfortunately, is the Abury Park Press. They couldn't wrap their heads around the idea that the default in this limited situation was good not bad. You think they'll take the time to sort out the nuances of what you point out below? Once they hear the 2002 plan is no

[AsburyPark] Re: Partners tells city to stuff it

2006-02-24 Thread dfsavgny
--- In AsburyPark@yahoogroups.com, bluebishop82 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The opinion maker, unfortunately, is the Abury Park Press. They couldn't wrap their heads around the idea that the default in this limited situation was good not bad. You think they'll take the time to sort out the

[AsburyPark] Re: Partners tells city to stuff it - a vote of no confidence

2006-02-24 Thread Skip Bernstein
I heard a rumour that Partners is not negotiating with the city and in fact, has refused to meet except for the initial meeting. The rumoured position of Partners is that it gave the budget, plans and schedules (stretching to 2013) to the city and that is all it is doing. It allegedly has no

[AsburyPark] Re: Partners tells city to stuff it - it’ll be a cold day in hell

2006-02-24 Thread Skip Bernstein
I'll be able to buy Pat Fasano's $1.3 million house for $150K again. Tom, (note no mention of blind) I nearly complimented you on one of your more sensitive, profound and informative replies to Werner; perhaps running for office has awoken a `kinder/gentler' bishop. However, let me disabuse

[AsburyPark] Re: Partners tells city to stuff it

2006-02-24 Thread Skip Bernstein
The opinion maker, unfortunately, is the Abury Park Press. They'll treat it like a nuke went of in the middle of Asbury and every bank and investor will run for cover. Ah, once again the suggestion of visual disorder, you make a curmudgeon proud, who'd a thunk it the justly right, though rarely