Re: [Hardhats-members] Estimating project cost and schedule

2005-08-11 Thread smcphelan
How do you accomplish this and still keep goodwill with the customer? 4. It's better to take MORE time in the design stage to get it right, then having to go back and re-engineer the entire product. 5. All aspects of the design and code have to be traced to requirements, if it isn't in a requireme

Re: [Hardhats-members] Structured Computer Organization

2005-08-11 Thread Mike Lieman
On 8/10/05, Greg Woodhouse <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I notice that there is a new edition out (the 5th) of Andrew > Tanenbaum's excellent book "Structured Computer Organization". Does > anyone know what has changed in the new edition? WOO HOO! Damn, I am a dork. http://vig.prenhall.com/catal

Re: [Hardhats-members] Muchas gracias

2005-08-11 Thread Mike Lieman
On 8/10/05, Gregory Woodhouse <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > The first law of software is that nothing is ever released when "it > was supposed to [be]". > > The second law of software is that people who consistently release on > time cut corners to do it. > > The caveat to the first law is that so

Re: [Hardhats-members] Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread Mike Lieman
On 8/10/05, Maury Pepper <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > With either, it depends on variables, some known, some not. I Generally, I divide the market into "Broadband" and "Everything Else". Within the broadband, it's all pretty much the same, once it's in and stable. At that point, the biggest dif

[Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread Kevin Toppenberg
On 8/10/05, smcphelan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > ... We cannot share the import functionality with > anyone as that would be a violation of our IA with VistA Imaging. I don't understand. If one has an IA with VistA imaging, then one is not allowed to share code? Kevin ---

[Hardhats-members] Re: Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread Kevin Toppenberg
If you are talking about netwoking for CPRS, then latency is the big issue, far outweighing bandwidth issues. CPRS chatters back and forth to the server, so latency times are multiplied many times over, leading to sluggish responce. Kevin On 8/11/05, Mike Lieman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On 8

Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread smcphelan
We all know how protective the VistA Imaging people are. I cannot share anything I obtained because of the IA. Maybe legally I can. But I cannot jeopardize our relationship with Silver Springs. So we take the most conservative approach. The import API was released as a patch to the MAG package

Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread Gregory Woodhouse
I think a bigger issue is VPN. These may not be the specific protocols, but consider running IMAP and LDAP over a VPN (TCP or UDP). For Internet mail, I use a combination of POP (at least right now) and IMAP without using LDAP. But I do need to be able to connect to Exchange, and I'm guessi

[Hardhats-members] Re: Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread Kevin Toppenberg
Greg, I think you confuse me with one who understands... :-) I got lost in the initial-rrhea again. What advantages would one have using "IMAP" over a VPN. Just for the record, I do know what VPN,TCP,UDP,POP,FTP,HTTP mean. But I'm fuzzy on IMAP,LDAP. :-) Kevin On 8/11/05, Gregory Woodhous

[Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread Kevin Toppenberg
I understand the need to protect one's business investments. But it was my understanding that the entire VI package was FOIA -- its just that one would need to be careful not to cross the FDA in implementations. So the "import API" should be open source, and the "VI background processor" should

[Hardhats-members] Re: Re: [Hardhats-members] Estimating project cost and schedule

2005-08-11 Thread info
All of this was very well documented in the Chaos Report. If interested, check out http://dimsboiv.uqac.ca/~sboivin/C2005/8INF814_Ete05/raw/CHAOS_1994.pdf. smcphelan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote on 08/11/2005, 02:01:22 PM: > How do you accomplish this and still keep goodwill with the customer? >

Re: [Hardhats-members] Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread Dan
One other thing. I believe that the majority of cable companies ban the user from running any type of server on their residential accounts. If you get a non-Bell DSL provider, most allow servers and even provide static IPs on residential accounts. At 10:24 PM 8/10/2005, Greg wrote: Does

RE: [Hardhats-members] Estimating project cost and schedule

2005-08-11 Thread Richard . Sowinski
Steve, I must say my experience mirrors yours at least in the medical software business. I think the domain of medicine is so broad, and so complex, and still so reliant on the skills and knowledge of clinicians, that it remains very non-deterministic, and will always be that way. Plus, medicine c

Re: [Hardhats-members] Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread Mike Lieman
On 8/11/05, Dan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > One other thing. > > I believe that the majority of cable companies ban the user from running > any type of server on their residential accounts. > > If you get a non-Bell DSL provider, most allow servers and even provide > static IPs on residential ac

Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread Mike Lieman
On 8/11/05, Kevin Toppenberg <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Greg, > > I think you confuse me with one who understands... :-) I got lost in > the initial-rrhea again. What advantages would one have using "IMAP" > over a VPN. > IMAP. Email protocol, where the mailboxes reside on the server, ( vs.

VistA Imaging FDA and NonCommercial Use Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread Joseph Dal Molin
There was a recent post on the OSIRIX list that asked the question why is OSIRIX not subject to FDA regs. The answer apparently is "if you sell it installed" it is FDA regulated if you give it away it is not. I have asked the people responsible for OSIRIX (BTW it is an open source medical

RE: [Hardhats-members] Estimating project cost and schedule

2005-08-11 Thread A. Forrey
Rich: Your comments hit the nail on the head and indicate how the VistA Community MUST organize if it is to truly succeed. The essentail overll perspective is Enterprise View Life Cycle Principles. THe MDC was set up to articulate the overall Life Cycle Principles into M environment realted la

Re: [Hardhats-members] Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread Dan
Even residential users may want to run their own SMTP or personal web or FTP server, etc.. Even these servers are a violation of most Cable TOS, as well as the bells. Also most block port 25. At 10:42 AM 8/11/2005, Mike wrote: Why would you use a residential account for a business? The R

Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread Greg Woodhouse
IMAP = Internet Message Access Protocol. It's a more sophisticated alternative to POP supporting features like multiple mailboxes, notification of events such as the arrival of a message, message disposition notifications, the ability to flag messages and more. If you're familiar with Microsoft Exc

Re: [Hardhats-members] Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread Greg Woodhouse
I remember helping my mother install DSL years ago. It didn't work. I spent some time on the phone, getting bumped up the support chain. Finally, I got impatient and ran traceroute (actually tracert under Windows), and gave the IP address of the failed router to the engineer I was speaking to. I wa

Re: VistA Imaging FDA and NonCommercial Use Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread Greg Woodhouse
That's interesting. Frankly, I find it a bit disconcerting to think that medical applications might be unregulated just because they are open source. --- Joseph Dal Molin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > There was a recent post on the OSIRIX list that asked the question > why > is OSIRIX not subject

Re: [Hardhats-members] Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread James Gray
I am a little puzzled by the reference to "ethical stand". What does that mean? - Original Message - From: "Dan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Thursday, August 11, 2005 9:10 AM Subject: Re: [Hardhats-members] Cable vs. DSL Even residential users may want to run their own SMTP or pe

[Hardhats-members] Re: VistA Imaging FDA and NonCommercial Use Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread Joseph Dal Molin
Actually this has nothing to do with open source it is how it is distributed ie. sold vs. given away. One of the best medical imaging systems in the market actually started out as a freebiethe name escapes me now not sure what the FDA history of that solution is but it spread far

RE: [Hardhats-members] Re: VistA Imaging FDA and NonCommercial Use Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread Cameron Schlehuber
I think "purpose" is being confused with "price". Whether something that is FDA regulated is paid for, free or even given to someone to use along with a cash incentive, it's the PURPOSE TO WHICH IT IS PUT OR LLKELY TO BE PUT that is going to determine whether the item is regulated or not. Of cour

Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: VistA Imaging FDA and NonCommercial Use Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread Michael D. Weisner
From: "Joseph Dal Molin" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Actually this has nothing to do with open source it is how it is > distributed ie. sold vs. given away. > Actually it appears to have nothing to do with the method of distribution as explained in http://www.fda.gov/cdrh/ode/guidance/337.pdf "This

[Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread jae kim
Another newbie q's: Has anybody installed openVistA unto Mac OS X and attempted to set it up as server with SMB for a Windows client with CPRS? Will OSIRIX work in this setting (from Windows)? Jae. --- SF.Net email is Sponsored by the Bett

Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: VistA Imaging FDA and NonCommercial Use Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread A. Forrey
The FDA has repeated said that the difference of a device from other non-regulated software is whether its control capability has the inclusion of an open cognitive loop that precedes the control of a device. In any particular situation the can be consulted to determine whether this control cri

RE: [Hardhats-members] Estimating project cost and schedule

2005-08-11 Thread Richard . Sowinski
Arden, we collaborate with Regenstrief quite a bit, because we are affiliated with them. And "yes" I have much interest in the "adapt-for-adoption" activities associated with VOE. Frankly, my prediction is a slightly different pace of adoption than some of the hype here (and other places) suggest

Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: VistA Imaging FDA and NonCommercial Use Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread Maury Pepper
Unless the law has changed in the last 10 years or so, the FDA's ability to regulate a medical device is based on "marketing" that device. They claim that they have the right to regulate based on use, but that's not what the letter of the law says. When pressed, they refuse to answer (or so I'

RE: VistA Imaging FDA and NonCommercial Use Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread Thurman Pedigo
They may be still safer than some chemicals promoted in health food stores - or more important, consider the safety of paper records - where is FDA there? ...thx/t > -Original Message- > From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:hardhats- > [EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Greg Woodhouse > Sent: Thurs

[Hardhats-members] VistA sites that currently do not exchange records but do exchange patients?

2005-08-11 Thread Ignacio Valdes
Hi, There is a researcher that is looking for a testbed of two clinic sites running VistA that currently do not exchange e-records but DO exchange patients often enough to examine staff workload patterns. Please let me know if you have knowledge of such a place. -- IV

RE: VistA Imaging FDA and NonCommercial Use Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread Greg Woodhouse
Fair enough. It is just disconcerting to see all this talk about how to find "loopholes" in FDA regulations (e.g., the use vs. marketing discussion). I realize not everyone lives in the U.S. and not everyone is subject to the same laws, but I'd think VistA developers would want to embrace regulatio

[Hardhats-members] Problem when i try to dispence a patient

2005-08-11 Thread Carlos sosa sosa
adivien que paso, guess what :) i have a patient and this patien some have a problem , and his converted a INPATIENT and after some days the dorcto says this patien it's ok now can leave the hospital and y use "adt manager---Bed Control Menudischarge a Patient" select my patien and after t

RE: [Hardhats-members] Problem when i try to dispence a patient

2005-08-11 Thread Cameron Schlehuber
You did very well explaining your problem! At the Select TEAM NAME: prompt it appears there are no teams to select from. I don't know if this will solve the CPRS problem, but you can create new Primary Care Teams by following the documentation in the Primary Care Management Module. See http://ww

Re: [Hardhats-members] Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread Mike Lieman
On 8/11/05, James Gray <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I am a little puzzled by the reference to "ethical stand". What does that > mean? > The orignal post to which I replied was about terms of service for residential cable restricting your rights to run a server on your ip address. I pointed out

Re: [Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread Mike Lieman
On 8/11/05, jae kim <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Another newbie q's: > > Has anybody installed openVistA unto Mac OS X > and attempted to set it up as server with SMB > for a Windows client with CPRS? > Will OSIRIX work in this setting (from Windows)? SMB is about sharing disk directories and

Re: [Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread Tyrus Maynard
Jae, My response is to ask you questions and others might have answers. I suppose others who have answers would also be interested in your sketch of the type of clinical setting you where you would be setting up these services including Osirix. 1. Vista is a server/client architecture with bui

Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: VistA Imaging FDA and NonCommercial Use Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread Mike Lieman
On 8/11/05, Michael D. Weisner <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > One might then be > forced to look at the issue of SOUP (Software of Unknown Pedigree) in the > software device. I wonder if all OS software must be treated as SOUP, since > there are few if any formal controls on design, let alone V&V. >

Re: [Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread Joseph Dal Molin
OSIRIX only runs on a MAC. Joseph jae kim wrote: Another newbie q's: Has anybody installed openVistA unto Mac OS X and attempted to set it up as server with SMB for a Windows client with CPRS? Will OSIRIX work in this setting (from Windows)? Jae.

Re: [Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread Greg Woodhouse
Right. You'd need SMB if, for example, you wanted to mount a shared drive from a Windows system, but it has nothing to do with the Broker or standard Internet protocols. I've never tried to do anything with SMB under OS X. In fact, I never bothered to ask whether was even supported. (As an aside, o

RE: [Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread David Sommers
Samba's built into MAC so it'll have no problems accessing or serving up files. I'm accessing mine via XP and no problems with linux-to-MAC either (or FreeBSD for that matter since I run that at home). You'll need SMB to access the images but the real question is CPRS since it is Windows. What t

RE: [Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread Greg Woodhouse
There is a commercial productr called VirtualPC, but I don't know how well it will run CPRS. Since it's a true virtual machine and not an emulation library like Wine, I think it should be okay. --- David Sommers <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Samba's built into MAC so it'll have no problems accessi

RE: [Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread Aylesworth Marc A Ctr AFRL/IFSE
SMB is for file sharing so long as you just want to be able to access the program from a windows machine you should be fine. 3.0 has some interesting features that let it act as a domain controller so you can have common passwords between you *nix box and windows machines. Mac OSX is just BSD with

Re: [Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread jae kim
I am still learning Vista and CPRS and not familar with server/client setting for those either. I asked the question because Mac OS X is basically FreeBSD at the core (Mach core, descendant of NextStep), and OSIRIX only runs on a Mac. Theoretically openVista could be ported to Mac. I am dreaming o

Re: [Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread jae kim
Medical Practice Setting I'm thinking: Community Clinic with * 1 doctor + 1-2 NP/PA + 1-2 RNs + 1-2 Office staff * waiting room with computer terminal for self-registration of patients (with a volunteer helping them) * a few exam rooms, each with CPRS terminal * lab room for drawing specim

Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: VistA Imaging FDA and NonCommercial Use Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread Tyrus Maynard
This was discussed on a long thread in May 2004 at the topica.com site in which I cited some of the FDA links after struggling to put them in a context. http://lists.topica.com/lists/hardhats/read/message.html?mid=910130973 In the use of language about *closed* or *open*, do you mean Title 21 Pa

[Hardhats-members] Fw: mpsEdit - IDE for MUMPS GT.M programmers.

2005-08-11 Thread Maury Pepper
I saw this on comp.lang.mumps and thought it might interest some on this list. It's an IDE for MUMPS but primarily meant for GT.M. - Original Message - From: "jerzyrog" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Newsgroups: comp.lang.mumps Sent: Thursday, August 11, 2005 3:38 PM Subject: mpsEdit - IDE for MU

Re: [Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread Tyrus Maynard
Jae, I don't know anything about VirtualPC or MacOS10, but when I think of a small clinic with lots of terminal locations being used intermittently I have to ask if multiple XTerminals can run instances of a single VirtualPC application called on OS10 server. would that be legal with th

Re: [Hardhats-members] CPRS Error Message

2005-08-11 Thread Pkale Robinson
Well,, I can telnet to the server (linux), from my client (winbloze),,, I get the GTM prompt, so this tells me that my firewall is allowing the negotiation. Are there any parameters with the CPRS interface that I need to specify,,, other than the ip address, and port ? On 8/11/05, Nancy Anthracite

Re: [Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread jae kim
Rusty, Even with VirtualPC licenses, the overhead will be too heavy. Maybe having all Mac network (Mac in each office) and build a complete Mac-VistA system managed by NetInfo. New GUI could be created with Mac's Interface Builder for Macintosh graphics. That means no need for Windows, yes! Jae.

Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: VistA Imaging FDA and NonCommercial Use Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: TIU Interface for Document Scanning

2005-08-11 Thread smcphelan
Sure viewing a scanned paper document should not be under the FDA regs. But if the device is used for clinical interpretation, wouldn't a practicing clinician want to use a FDA approved device? Camera taking pictures of things probably doesn't need FDA approval for example in anatomic pathology o

Re: [Hardhats-members] CPRS Error Message

2005-08-11 Thread Nancy Anthracite
What port are you telnetting to? On Thursday 11 August 2005 09:08 pm, Pkale Robinson wrote: > Well,, I can telnet to the server (linux), from my client > (winbloze),,, I get the GTM prompt, so this tells me that my firewall > is allowing the negotiation. Are there any parameters with the CPRS >

Re: [Hardhats-members] CPRS Error Message

2005-08-11 Thread Pkale Robinson
9200 I DO get the GTM prompt On 8/11/05, Nancy Anthracite <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > What port are you telnetting to? > > On Thursday 11 August 2005 09:08 pm, Pkale Robinson wrote: > > Well,, I can telnet to the server (linux), from my client > > (winbloze),,, I get the GTM prompt, so this tel

Re: [Hardhats-members] CPRS Error Message

2005-08-11 Thread Nancy Anthracite
If you are telnetting to 9200 and the Broker is listening on that port, you should not be getting the GTM prompt. The connection should close as soon as you type just a few characters. On Thursday 11 August 2005 10:50 pm, Pkale Robinson wrote: > 9200 > > I DO get the GTM prompt > > On 8/11/05,

[Hardhats-members] RE: VistA Imaging FDA...

2005-08-11 Thread Jim Self
Gregory Woodhouse <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >Fair enough. It is just disconcerting to see all this talk about how to >find "loopholes" in FDA regulations (e.g., the use vs. marketing >discussion). Gregory, I think you misinterpret. Past discussion was not centered on findling loopholes but on f

RE: [Hardhats-members] CPRS Error Message

2005-08-11 Thread Roy Gaber
I have to ask. On you GT.M box are you dropping into programmer mode and typing D STRT^XWBTCP(9200), or starting the broker from the RPB BROKER MANAGEMENT menu? If you type at a shell prompt on the Linux box lsof | grep 9200 you should see that a process has that port open it should me named mu

RE: [Hardhats-members] RE: VistA Imaging FDA...

2005-08-11 Thread Roy Gaber
Exactly, diagnostic imaging (interpreting a chest x-ray or an MRI) is regulated by the FDA, clinical imaging (viewing an image of an EKG or even looking at the same chest x-ray as the Radiologist but not for diagnostic reasons) is not regulated by the FDA. Software used for diagnostic purposes is

Re: [Hardhats-members] Re: Cable vs. DSL

2005-08-11 Thread Suchi Pande
On 8/11/05, Kevin Toppenberg <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: initial-rrhea again. What advantages would one have using "IMAP" over a VPN. Mike Lieman wrote: IMAP. Email protocol, where the mailboxes reside on the server, ( vs. POP, where it's all downloaded to the client.) Just to give Kevin

Re: [Hardhats-members] RE: VistA Imaging FDA...

2005-08-11 Thread Nancy Anthracite
The FDA was mentioned in my initial post because the routines we could use that connect the TIU and the image have FDA notices on them, and I did not want to run afoul of the FDA if parts of the code were used, hence the reason I called them again. On Friday 12 August 2005 12:20 am, Roy Gabe

Re: [Hardhats-members] CPRS Error Message

2005-08-11 Thread Gregory Woodhouse
If you're getting the GTM> prompt, it's because you're not running the right command to handle connections. You don't want to start an interactive GT.M session. Instead, you want to run a specific M program (which may need to be written) to process Broker requests on GT.M. === Gregory Woo

RE: [Hardhats-members] RE: VistA Imaging FDA...

2005-08-11 Thread Roy Gaber
I see your point, but I think that this would not be an issue because the whole "device" is not being employed in a different environment, only the parts that aid in the indexing of images. -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Nancy Anthracite

RE: [Hardhats-members] Server Message Block (SMB)

2005-08-11 Thread David Sommers
Remember, GTM doesn't run on Mac - only Cache. And there's no CPRS replacement, yet, so don't count on somebody writing a Cocoa/Carbon app on Mac instead of Mono/Mozilla for *nix (to be used everywhere else). I write with XCode (Mac) and that's not nearly as RAD and cross-platform as Mono or Mozi

[Hardhats-members] VistA Community Conference Call

2005-08-11 Thread Maury Pepper
VistA Community Call Friday at NOON EDT. TOPICS: - VistA Office Update -- 10 minutes - General VistA topics - your choice DATE: Friday, August 12 TIME: 12:00 Noon EDT DURATION: 1 hour. CONFERENCE CALL DIAL IN NUMBERS USA 866-483-4159 Outside USA 706-634-0093 Conference ID Number: