It doesn't have to be in the PD in order for it to qualify for replacement
copying under Section 108, Jessica: 108 can be invoked as soon as the
library or archives has, after a reasonable effort, determined that an
unused replacement cannot be obtained at a fair price.
Recent discussions with
Hi James
The Mellon project I'm working on has to do with preservation of
out-of-distribution works. All this talk about 108 is, of course, a
central issue for this project. The project is initially focused on
identifying such stuff in three collections (NYU/Avery Fisher, Berkeley,
and Loyola,
I think that this is what happens when the professionals most closely
involved and aligned with content selection and management are not
consulted or involved. This is the root of the UCLA issue, as well, in my
view.
The LCA/ARL opinions are, in my opinion and only my opinion, abstracted,
I don't think there IS a difference...that's what drives me crazy about
the licensing models now in place: where we could, in the past, buy once
and show many, now we're forced into paying repeatedly for the same
privilege. SOMETHING has got to change.
On the other hand, I think what this
uh...well OK...This is part of ARL's response to the UCLA case. I think
the jury is still definitely out, despite what ARL thinks. The thing
that's frustrating about this pronouncement is the fact that it was
shepherded thru without any participation whatsoever from media
librarians--in other
The bottom line is, Hannah, it's gonna take test cases to solve this.
There are no existing legal realities in this area--only informed
opinion and speculation.
Colleagues and I have been advocating and generally working our brains out
on these issues for years...
Gary
By the way: the original
Hi Scott
The Volume 58, Number 3, Winter 2010 of Library Trends is Devoted to media
and media collections.
Introduction: Current Trends in Academic Media Collections and Services
Ciara Healy
pp. 321-323
License to Look: Evolving Models for Library Video Acquisition and Access
Gary Handman
pp.
Hi all
I'm back from NY--great meeting re the Mellon funded video preservation
project I've talked about earlier. (The single most horrifying plane ride
in my 40 years of plane travel...2 huge lightening strikes on the wing and
enormous wind shear...I take the train next time)
Some really
It's not in DVD distribution. Make a DVD replacement copy under Section
108 of the copyright law. The law requires initial attempts to purchase a
legit replacement at fair market, but I am certain that it can be
demonstrated that $300 is not fair market.
The one catch is that 108 mandates that
Nope...one of thousands of missing in action casualties in the vhs to dvd
swing. Just imagine what's gonna transpire if Blu-ray takes over the
universe.
gary
Has Sam Shepard's True West ever been released on DVD??
Thanks!
__
Chris
Hi all
The Artificial Eye Complete Jean Vigo is available from various sellers
via amazon uk...a beautiful set, but in non-US code (also a bit costy)
Gary Handman
Director
Media Resources Center
Moffitt Library
UC Berkeley
510-643-8566
ghand...@library.berkeley.edu
Hi Rue
We do not have a defined program in Genocide Studies, although there is
obviously a great interest in various other disciplines/programs (Jewish
Studies. African Studies, Slavic and Eastern European Studies, etc. etc.
I buy heavily in this area: see, for eg:
Hi Dylan
I'd say the FTF exemption COULD apply if there were no fees involved and
if the class were held in a place of regular instruction--i.e. in an
institutional classroom or meeting space, not i someone's living room. The
video shown must also be a part of instruction (i.e. I don't think
Ding ding ding ding
why this should not happen is currently being hotly contested: see the
UCLA case:
http://newsroom.ucla.edu/portal/ucla/campus-to-re-start-streaming-of-154601.aspx
gary handman
Hi all,
I hate to raise this issue again, but apparently the computer geeks on
campus are
Arg!
Let's stop and breath. There are two issues going on here: The DMCA
issues have (or had) to do with the proscription against breaking
encryption on DVDs to extract clips. The law was recently amended to
allow faculty in all disciplines an exemption to break extract DVD/digital
clips for
Hey deg
I think an update would be groovy...on the other hand, putting this list
together initially turned out to be nearly impossible...for one thing, the
issue of whose core list? keeps popping up: public libraries, school
libraries, higher ed...the list would be totally unmanageable if it
I'm with you on all counts, Dennis
I am informally enjoined (more like a friendly request) by UC counsel from
offering too many opinions in this matter, but I'm with you.
gary
Gary, to be fair, I did bring UCLA up in my first email and suggested this
is all up in the air. And also to be
Hi Pat
I'd say you need to acquire a license; others may not. I personally would
find it very difficult claiming fair use or TEACH exemptions in such a
case.
gary handman
Hi all,
Let me clarify-the films streamed are documentaries produced for
educational use-not feature films. The
Hi Reno and welcome to the list
Unfortunately, I don't think your project would have any legal--i.e. fair
use--leg to stand on whatsoever, snippit or not... It's one thing to
extract a limited number of short clips for use in educational or
scholarly contexts; it's another thing altogether to
Hi Pat
As you know, most of the 50s capitalist propaganda films were works for
hire, made to support similar agendas by commercial firms, or cranked out
by government sponsored programs (e.g., United States Information Agency).
Since these were commercial or educational films intended for highly
We just did a review of our international feature films on tape (about
3,500 titles); we found that about 1,400 are not currently available in
any format (most have never been released on DVD).
gary
When I pulled stats for our top circulating VHS tapes (looked at overall
circs limited to
Hi...your making my brain hurt, Susan
A lot of this kind of stuff boils down to risk assessment. If it were me,
I'd show the damn thing and be done with it. It seems to me that your
good-faith efforts are good enough for your particular situation (Save
your paper trail, though)
Gary
Looks
Hi all
I am currently serving as an advisor on a planning grant funded by the
NEH, awarded to the Tribeca Film Institute for a project entitled From
Bluegrass to Broadway, a film history of popular music in America. (I've
attached a summary of the project.) Tim Gunn, the project director, is
Hi Jay
I'm afraid you're advertising again. As I mentioned to you earlier,
replies to member queries regarding specific titles or specific areas of
interest are fine on this list; the type of unsolicited or generically
commercial post you just sent is not.
Let me know if you have questions.
It's too general for my taste, Jana. There are lots of OP distributors
out there.
Responses to the following types of queries are appropriate for videolib:
1. I'm looking for videos about topic X
2. I'm looking for videos by director X
3. I'm trying to see if film X was ever released on DVD
Hey Jacki
I'm very familiar with your work (we own a copy in the Media Center)...it
definitely fits. Not sure whether my friend is just interested in
mainstream features, but if not, I'll definitely recommend your film.
gary
Hi Gary,
At the risk of seeming self serving, my film LETTERS NOT
Hi all
An ex-Berkeley faculty friend has posed a very cool reference question...I
can use your help:
I'm looking for examples of films that do interesting
things with words, either written or spoken, or (at the other extreme) try
to do without words. I've got lots of silent films with title
No. Basically you're talking about international copyright, which applies
to all equally.
Gary Handman
Hi there -
This is a PAL permissions question.
Are there differences in permission requirements for libraries versus
campus foreign language tech centers
for PAL DVD conversion to
Thanks, Nancy. It was difficult to pick. Your choices are among my
absolute faves, too! This was sort of an interesting exercise: made me
realize what a basically old fashioned cinema guy I really am (at least
apropos to horror)...slashers, torture porn, and even Bava and Argento
don't
The form is at:
https://calmail.berkeley.edu/manage/list/options/videolib@lists.berkeley.edu
Unfortunately, you'll have to request your password (FORGET YOUR PASSWORD?)
It's a stupid mail system, but I have no control.
gary
Gary,
I am on my way out of the office to go to NMM - can you remind
Or, alternatively, Jessica and I can continue to snipe at each other in
the void...pretty much the same thing we always do, but with fewer people
to annoy.
Gary
Since many of us will be at NMM, maybe we can declare a quiet week? I'll
be armed with an IPAD to keep up with email but would
Hi
In my experience, studio and network sites (such as Warners, HBO, etc.)
are little more than dumb, automated fulfillment machines. Unlikely
you're gonna get past the tax exempt issue.
Re amazon and paying more...may be they charge a bit more, but you always
need to factor in the
Question 1: This is totally counter-intuitive (and just plain stupid), but,
Section 108 of the copyright law sez that if the title in hand is no
longer in distribution or obtainable at fair-market elsewhere (in the same
or other formats) you can make a copy. The copy (not the original!!!) is
to
Hy deg
VHS to VHS...sorta like copying 8 track to 4 track, no?
gary
The restriction to use in the library only pertains to the digital copy
(DVD).
So if you were to copy a VHS to VHS (tho unlikely) the copy can leave the
premises
Also, it's important to note that the section permit
No
gary
New but related question, if a professor needs to screen a video that's
only on VHS (no DVD version is available for purchase), but the classroom
they're in doesn't have a VCR, could a DVD copy be made for use in the
classroom?
Matt
__
Matt Ball
VHS degradation hasn't been a major issue for us, particularly since the
circulation of vhs has been declining for the past 10 years.
gary
One advantage of working for a vendor rather than a library is that I
never have to weed or worry about storage space. However, in my personal
Unfortunately, Mike, storage at UC can't be negotiated. We have a huge
remote storage facility (about 6 miles from here). Individual unit quotas
for sending stuff out are strictly governed by dollars and space
availability. Negotiation is pretty much out of the question.
Again, the prospect of
Hi all
Remember months back when I floated an offer to give away (for the price
of postage) the 39 BBC Shakespeare plays on vhs? Well, we're getting
ready to do a massive Fall cleaning of MRC and I'm making the offer again.
The vhs copies are in serviceable condition--they've been struck from
Hi all
I think I need input and/or moral support: for various reasons having to
do with space and projected library renovation plans here at UCB, I'm
taking a hard and fairly ruthless look at the collection.
We currently have somewhere around 5K international cinema titles, about
96% of which
Hi Chuck
What kinds of stuff? Commercially produced? What?
Specifics, pls (you can email me off the list, if you wish)
gary
Thanks Gary,
These are U-matic tapes, total of 5. Tech requirements would be high bit
rate MPEG-2 (exact specs could be discusssed if needed) ... so it would be
and you really want to spend time and money digitizing this stuff? h
gary
It's stuff we, the University, has the intellectual rights on ... old
University (our University) marketing/promotional videos produced by
Florida
State.
Chuck
On Sat, Oct 16, 2010 at 12:29 PM,
Hi David
This is an interesting and perennial question...
After having worked in this business for close to 30 years, it's clear to
me that one major qualification for being a media librarian is the
willingness to work in other areas before getting a gig as a media
librarian. At the risk of
Hi Patty
You should contact Peter Asaro at http://www.peterasaro.org/
Gary Handman
Thank you Jay, it's not the correct movie, here's more information from
IMDB:
http://www.imdb.com/media/rm798593792/tt1028550
Love Machine Poster
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 8.5/10 X
Users: 8.5/10
I'm probably a grumpy minority voice, but I find all things twittery
profoundly annoying...like a fly on a hot day constantly buzzing in the
ear. You got something to say, say it in sufficient length and depth as
to be useful.
gary handman
Dear All,
A question for the collective: have you
I TOLD you I was probably a minority voice.
Twitter (and most blogs) always remind me of my hero, Neil Postman,
talking about the death of effective public discourse (killed under a
crush of buzz, shallow banter, tweet, and endless electronic noise). But
then again, I also lament the death of
Hi Elizabeth
Well, although I haven't seen the film yet (I will--I'm a HUGE AG fan), I
doubt that it (or ANY feature film) can be said to be effective literary
criticism. The narrative and cinematic structure of features and their
ultimate goal (box office receipts, always) generally put these
Thanks, E.
Listening to Zizek always makes me feel as if I've been through a couple
of rounds of electroshock therapy.
I was a Gitanes smoker also, for a short period, until all my friends
abandoned me (although I do still have a proclivity for hipster black)
Sartre never rattled my existential
Yow! I meant my last ramble for Elizabeth only, not the list at large.
Sory folks.
g
Gary Handman
Director
Media Resources Center
Moffitt Library
UC Berkeley
510-643-8566
ghand...@library.berkeley.edu
http://www.lib.berkeley.edu/MRC
I have always preferred the reflection of life to
Reserve books are inventoriable...they presumably get cataloged and become
part of the library's collection, no?
gary
Hi Kim,
I guess I disagree with Gary. Short term access to resources for classes
is something we've provided for forever in Reserve Services here at the
University of
There is no such thing.
At risk of shamelessly flacking my work, my Greenwood book has stuff in it
that still holds true: http://www.greenwood.com/catalog/GR1658.aspx
There are a handful of Guidelines out there
Kris Brancolini's Audiovisual policies in ARL libraries is looking a bit
shaggy
Hey Kim
As you know, this is one of the many things that gets me seeing crimson.
I am categorically NOT one of those librarian types that refuses to let go
of traditional function or to embrace new...but: I can see no
justification whatsoever for libraries getting into the business of
picking
Hi Amanda
Let me toy with your question a bit.
First of all, let's dispense with the whole issue of image quality.
Unless an institution is going to be storing and pumping huge chunks of
uncompressed video over the the wires (thus almost certainly bringing down
the network), there are limits to
Hi all
Just came across something sort of odd. I notice that Films Media is
selling streaming licenses for a number of public domain films that are
available absolutely free on the Internet Moving Image Archive. This
doesn't seem right to me.
Maybe our friends at Films.com can elaborate?
Gary
Hi all
With almost no exception, DVD enhancements, supplements, add-ons, bonuses,
and the Special Features are almost completely ignored here. There are a
few interesting exceptions. Last year, we bought the TV series Young
Indiana Jones, which includes (I kid you not) over 20 hours of
Hi Joe
There are two lists: videolib--a commercial-free discussion forum, and
videonews--a new product and service bulletin board. You are not
subscribed to the latter, so it's not that direction from which this stuff
is coming at you.
Video marketers have a large number of ways in which they
Ach Doktor Freud!
I wrote suck things in the last post instead of such. Depending on your
viewpoint (like Joe's), the former may be more accurate.
Gary Handman
Director
Media Resources Center
Moffitt Library
UC Berkeley
510-643-8566
ghand...@library.berkeley.edu
I've taken you off the list, Fred. Adios!
gary handman
I've tried the procedure to unsubscribe on the mailman website but it
hasn't worked. How do i unsubsribe?
Fred Sandner
Head, Circulation/Media Services
Finkelstein Memorial Library
24 Chestnut Street
Spring Valley, NY 10977
Check out
http://films.com/id/17839/Prelinger_Archives_American_Thrift_Part_I_1962.htm
I have a note into Rick Prelinger, who may or may not be aware of this. I
have huge respect for Rick, so I hope it's not
gary
Can you forward some examples. J.
Op 29-09-10 17:07,
Totally agree, Brigid.
I've been trying to extract and publicize (at least videographically
speaking) interesting extras (see, for e.g. our Warner Brothers and MGM
Animated Shorts videography
http://www.lib.berkeley.edu/MRC/warnertoons.html) and Newsreel
supplements
First Sale
Digital licenses generally have nothing to do with First Sale...they're
binding commercial contracts which supersede both Fair Use and First Sale
rights
gary handman
Hi Dennis,
This is very informatvie, thanks for taking the time to explain things
from the disrtibutor
That's OK, Matt
I've been at this gig close to 27 years and I still haven't gotten it
figured out
gary
Thanks Jessica (and Gary). It's my goal this semester to get copyright
figured out so until them I'm sure I'll misuse its different components a
lot. Including Fair Use, which does
Check back with me in five years, Dennis...
Bluray = BetaMax
gary
Not to piss Gary or anyone off, but as I've mentioned before, DVD sales
are
way down and the journalists are much more interested in covering bluray.
Add to that my films usually start with $10,000 to $50, film
Hi Lyn
If you acquired the 16mm prints legally, you're mostly likely covered for
transfer to DVD (or other formats)under Section 108 of the copyright law.
The issue remains: 108 stipulates that the duplicated/transferred copy be
used within the library building...my personal approach to this
Technically, no one really owns a purchased copy of a piece of media,
ever. You acquire the piece with certain rights and/or stipulations (right
to screen or view it in certain contexts, etc. etc.) Most purchase
transactions are implicitly or explicitly contractual and for the life of
the
No court in the land that wouldn't accept 108 as applicable, Jessica.
Let's face it, 16mm, if not obsolete, is increasingly arcane and unusable
in most teaching contexts. I'm totally with you on knee-jerk conversions
from vhs to DVD), but this ain't a matter of convenience, at all.
Gary
All good points, Dennis...I adore 16mm (and 35 and 70...)
However:
Consider this: UC Berkeley, one of the premiere educational institutions
in the world, does not have a single, working 16mm projector on campus
(the PFA doesn't count...they're a world unto their own).
I'm sure I'm not alone.
Hi Ben...you ARE a curious guy
At UCB I'm the primary selector for video across disciplines. I have my
own budget, which serves all disciplines.
Occasionally, other subject selectors will request a title (generally
something requested of them by their faculty)...often they pay and we
house it
First Sale has to do with commercial property transfer exclusively, I
think. In other words, it has to do with the rights of legal buyers. The
NetFlix transaction is a rental--a temporary lease?--and is, I would
imagine, a different can o' worms. But then again, I'm in no way
positive.
gary
The Coens work on the same movie...think the question was re brothers
involved in separate movies.
gary
In a message dated 9/20/10 9:25:18 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time,
sarah.e.mccles...@hofstra.edu writes:
A trivia note: Both Ben and Casey Affleck (brothers) have directed films
that are in
oh for god's sake...you'd think you were in Berkeley
gary
Something to chew on:
Would your library consider switching to USDA certified organic-popcorn
in light of the fact that non-organic popcorn is on the FDA's list of the
top ten foods most contaminated with toxic pesticides and
Hi
Well, if they'll sell it to you at home video prices, take it.
Copyright law allows the use of copyrighted materials in valid,
face-to-face teaching. In other words, anything in the home video market
(stuff sold via amazon, etc.) can be used in the service of teaching
without having to pop
Thanks, Jen
I'll let my colleagues know of this exciting development.
Thanks from all of us for moving forward on this project!
Gary
Gary:
Thank you for reaching out to Variety. I am the general manager who
oversees Variety's digital properties, including the archive.
We are
Yeah
performance or display of a work by instructors or pupils in the course of
face-to-face teaching activities of a nonprofit educational institution,
See http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html#110
gary handman
Hello all,
Does the fact that my school is for-profit rule out all
Hi all
I was just doing some maintenance on the VIDEOLIB list and noticed (again)
the fairly large number of subscribers who are not also subscribed to
VIDEONEWS. 'Tis a pity...
VIDEONEWS is a relatively low-volume list that has been established as a
way for distributors and filmmakers to post
1) For the [theoretically] short-term, one time use: Does Kastenmeier
apply to online content?
2) For the long-term archival use: What should the role of the library
(or
other campus unit) be in facilitating long-term access to online video
content not available for sale?
Both
In which case, I nominate Der Untergang
gary
I didn't realize you could choose BAD leadership! Definitely LORD OF THE
FLIES.
Best,
Dennis
On Thu, Sep 9, 2010 at 12:52 PM, Jana Atkins jatki...@uco.edu wrote:
And with that example, We Are Marshall is another good mention for the
same
Not true. Off-air copies made by individuals are perfectly legal (that's
what the the Sony Betamax case was all about...it's called time shifting,
Jessica). The use of off-air material in the classroom is not covered by
Title 117 at all, but the Kastenmeier Guidelines are generally considered
a
Right... Remember that these are simply guidelines, not law. I think,
however, that long-term retention and use puts one on pretty thin ice.
Gary
Gary, the Kastenmeier guidelines for using material taped off-air (by
institutions) involve showing it once and erasing the program after 45
Read the Kastenmeier Guidelines, Jessica. These frame time limits for
retention, but the use of whole off-air works is perfectly legal
otherwise.
gary
Home copies are for individuals Gary. If they were legal copies you
could
sell and rent them but you can not. There is a BIG difference.
Smoke a Gaulois and watch a Renoir film
Gary
What Would Henri Langlois Do?
I don't ask myself
Judy
VIDEOLIB is intended to encourage the broad and lively discussion of
issues relating to the selection, evaluation, acquisition,bibliographic
control, preservation, and use of current
Hi Benjamin
Berkeley's answers:
Does your library still order DVD's primarily, or have you
switched to online collections?
Berkeley collects video materials based on the short- and long-term value
of these resources to teaching and scholarship. We license materials for
online delivery where
QR? nah...
BUT, you wanna make us happy: include ISBN on your containers!
Gary
Dear wise(r) ones
We know nothing about QR Codes, but are putting our virtual toe in the ...
So, may I ask a coupla' more questions please:
A) do any of you use QR codes for anything?
B) if so, what?
C)
Hi
Unless you plan on very large numbers of concurrent users (which tends to
be rare in most institutions), most hosted streamed collections are fairly
easy on bandwidth (at least in my experience).
Gary Handman
I am investigating the Films Media Group streaming collections and also
looking
Here's the cataloging for our copy:
http://169.229.32.116:80/record=b16214898~S34
Bought from Edition Filmmuseum. I'm almost 100% it has never been
released in the US.
It's PAL, Region 0 with subtitles. Definitely worth getting!
Gary
Dear CW,
Is Robert Reinert's Nerves/Nerven (1919)
Hi Vicky
The short answer is--NO, she cannot legally transfer a WHOLE film to DVD.
The longer answer is--YES, she can extract clips from the vhs and use them
in teaching.
Clipping from VHS to DVD is more than a bit cumbersome, however. It involves:
1. An analog/digital capture device--a
Depends on the newsreel. Universal Newsreels (which can be bought on DVD
from lots of places) are in the PD.
March of Time is, I believe, still held by Time, Inc. (or whoever the hell
owns Time now)
The Hearst Metronome and Pathe newsreels are still owned, I think.
I'd go with the Universal
We got ours directly from Thom
gary handman
Hi,
I've tried for years to get a copy of this film, but always heard it was
held up in copyright Hell, and so I stopped trying. Yet, I see that many
of you have a copy - How did you do that? Did you contact Thom Andersen
at Cal Arts directly,
You want me to name names, Jon? Well, I am not nor have I ever been...
I will venture my opinion that the model adopted by Alexander Street Press
might be on the right track (up front buy-in (too high, I feel, in the
case of ASP) and a yearly (low-ish) maintenance fee. The issue I have
with ASP
Hey there
The Woody riff on Sergei is in Bananas
gary
OK, I have a question. When I saw this list, I expected to see Woody
Allen's Take the Money and Run. I went to Youtube and found this
delightful compilation which has most of the films Gary mentions:
Well...
The Internet Moving Image Archive (and others) have some cool stuff in
them...but...what are the chances of these sources having the titles that
faculty want/need. Pretty slim. The IA is largely PD/Open Source/Orphan
stuff... I quake in my boots thinking about the (increasingly common)
Videolib folks:
A query for the collective wisdom: how do you all stay on top of current
releases? I would very much like to collect these as automatically as
possible, and free my time for hand-selecting the more obscure art,
independent, and educational films. I am sure I'm not the only
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Battleship_Potemkin
gh
Speaking of the National Media Market. Have you looked at Gary¹s
testimonial? The movie clip that is playing in the background looks
familiar, but I can¹t place it. http://www.nmm.net/market_about_us.shtml
Ursula Schwarz
Save the
Not to mention
Parodies/homages to the Odessa Steps scene in Sergei Eisenstein's
Battleship Potemkin:
Bananas (Woody Allen, 1971) Features a parody of the Odessa Steps
scene from S. Eisenstein's film Battleship Potemkin.
Brazil (Terry Gilliam, 1985)[The] big Odessa moment comes near the
ganz richtig!
g
A very small number of the titles enumerated in the list may no longer
be available as individual dvds but can be purchased as part of larger
sets---for example, *Watch on the Rhine* comes as part of of The
Bette Davis Collection, Part 3 ; likewise, one can secure *A Member
u kill me, Rick
I was too lazy to yank Maria off the list during her seemingly endless
vacation and in light of the attending vacation message glut.
Hope the vacation was lovely, Maria.
gary
On 8/13/10 1:20 PM, Maria Soares maria.soa...@humber.ca sent this:
I will be on vacation as of July
Well, there are other performances of Rite out there, but I do believe the
Joffrey is no longer available on DVD or tape. It appears to be on
YouTube (of course)
gary
Does anyone have ideas of where I might be able to find a copy of the film
mentioned below? One of my professors is
Edison was a notoriously cut-throat business guy and notoriously
aggressive defender of his patent rights. I'm sure he'd have something to
say about all of this...
gary
Nothing to add - but just think - all this over one of Thomas Edison's
inventions - wonder what he'd think!
Becky Tatar
Really...cool, I'll take a look. Thanks, D.
g
I believe the 1931 Berlin Alexanderplatz is a bonus feature on Criterion's
DVD release.
DD
Sent from my iPhone
On Aug 11, 2010, at 12:21 PM, ghand...@library.berkeley.edu wrote:
ah what would I do without my daily Jessica annoyance.
The
We're talking about keeping stuff alive for use in working collections,
Jessica. Not David Shepard territory.
g.
Well re section 108. If you have that deteriorating VHS you can't replace
and do a transfer, it can't leave the library My argument was with the
preservation' of said
I don't know how I can make this any simpler, Jessica.
If we own a tape and the the tape is no longer commercially distributed in
either DVD or vhs (in the US or abroad or legally in the OP marketplace),
then I'm gonna try to save it from the flames...it's what librarians do:
we preserve the
401 - 500 of 596 matches
Mail list logo