Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-24 Thread denstar
On Tue, Jul 20, 2010 at 5:34 PM, Medic wrote: ... > Vizzini: You only think I guessed wrong! That's what's so funny! I switched > glasses when your back was turned! Ha ha! You fool! You fell victim to one > of the classic blunders - The most famous of which is "never get involved in > a land war i

RE: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-23 Thread Eric Roberts
Pretty much ;-) Red Foreman had it right hehehe. -Original Message- From: Scott Stroz [mailto:boyz...@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, July 22, 2010 10:20 PM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth. Yea, I realize

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Scott Stroz
Original Message- > From: Scott Stroz [mailto:boyz...@gmail.com] > Sent: Thursday, July 22, 2010 10:42 AM > To: cf-community > Subject: Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA > Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth. > > > Here is a novel idea. How about if the

RE: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Eric Roberts
It may have been before the phrase was coined, but he sure sounds like one... -Original Message- From: Maureen [mailto:mamamaur...@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, July 22, 2010 3:09 PM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In

RE: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Eric Roberts
: Thursday, July 22, 2010 11:11 AM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth. If what you said was applicable on a Nationwide level, the realities of the figures for employment, poverty, discrimination,leadership in the corporate

RE: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Eric Roberts
radical in any direction. Your final statement (starting with "I know two types of white people") doesn't even make sense. -Original Message- From: Vivec [mailto:gel21...@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, July 22, 2010 11:11 AM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Oops! Did I say that on tap

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Maureen
Assumption made on facts not in evidence. There has been no increase in discrimination in programs where affirmative action is not enforced. On Thu, Jul 22, 2010 at 12:58 PM, Eric Roberts wrote: > > You can't just do that because without something to enforce > non-discrimination, people will d

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Maureen
Nope. The Dixiecrats were active in the election of 1948. A few Democrats, notably Strom Thurmond and Jesse Helms left the Democratic party for the Republican party in the 60s, but that had nothing to do with the Dixiecrats, and neither did Woodrow Wilson, who was dead long before anyone even co

RE: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Eric Roberts
You can't just do that because without something to enforce non-discrimination, people will discriminate. -Original Message- From: Scott Stroz [mailto:boyz...@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, July 22, 2010 10:42 AM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherr

RE: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Eric Roberts
: Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth. "A list of successful blacks is actually indicative that the problems caused by prejudice and racism have not been solved to the point where they can now be ignored." In your eyes it may show

RE: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Eric Roberts
-Original Message- From: Jerry Barnes [mailto:critic...@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, July 22, 2010 6:30 AM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth. "How do you determine your ethnicity? When the census

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Jerry Barnes
"Prejudice still exists (hell, the shit I hear come out of my brother-in-law's mouth embarrasses and frightens me sometimes), but, admittedly as a white male, would like to think it is better than it was 20-30 years ago." No doubt. Look at King Samir Shabbaz. "Dude.." Dude "If out of a

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Scott Stroz
I think it may be more accurate to say prejudice is not as big of a barrier as it used to be. Prejudice still exists (hell, the shit I hear come out of my brother-in-law's mouth embarrasses and frightens me sometimes), but, admittedly as a white male, would like to think it is better than it was

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Sam
Sam: It's too bad you're such a hater. You could be an asset to the list. Larry: Sam I just hate your ignorance, intolerance, your style of argument (ie., if someone disagrees and you cannot adequately respond launch personal attacks). Too funny ;) ~

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Sam
We were having a nice discussion until you had to make it personal and accused everyone that didn't hold your viewpoint as angry attack dogs. I'm just saying when you stop seeing us as enemies and realize we're allowed to hold different views the discussions stay civil. On Thu, Jul 22, 2010 at

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Scott Stroz
sed >>> oppression of minorities in our collective face constantly. If there were >>> any truth to that idea we would be following news about Hillary Clinton's >>> presidency. >>> >>> -Original Message- >>> From: trish simon [mailto:

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Sam
Did you just say being black was a handicap? As I've stated before, remove the negatives like parents attitude towards education and they there are no differences in achievements. That's not say prejudice doesn't exist, it just isn't a barrier to success like it used to be. On Thu, Jul 22, 2010

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Vivec
If what you said was applicable on a Nationwide level, the realities of the figures for employment, poverty, discrimination,leadership in the corporate sector, business ownership etc. would be very different. It is very easy to use anecdotes to attempt to portray those Blacks who do not achieve a

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Zaphod Beeblebrox
ollective face constantly. If there were >> any truth to that idea we would be following news about Hillary Clinton's >> presidency. >> >> -Original Message- >> From: trish simon [mailto:trishsimo...@gmail.com] >> Sent: Thursday, July 22, 2010 9:56 AM &g

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Larry C. Lyons
Sam I just hate your ignorance, intolerance, your style of argument (ie., if someone disagrees and you cannot adequately respond launch personal attacks). Its amazing how someone like you can be so intelligent and so stupid at the same time. Tell me does your head explode on a regular basis from

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Scott Stroz
ession of minorities in our collective face constantly. If there were any > truth to that idea we would be following news about Hillary Clinton's > presidency. > > -Original Message----- > From: trish simon [mailto:trishsimo...@gmail.com] > Sent: Thursday, July

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Maureen
I remember as a child having a discussion about skin color with the children of several of the musicians in my Dad's band. We decided they were darker cause God left them in the oven longer. Kids are wonderfully unbiased until taught otherwise. On Thu, Jul 22, 2010 at 9:00 AM, Zaphod Beeblebrox

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Larry C. Lyons
My five year old daughter just says my friends. I never knew the ethnicity of any of the kids until I met them. Funny thing is that she's the only blonde blue-eyed kid in the lot. On Thu, Jul 22, 2010 at 12:00 PM, Zaphod Beeblebrox wrote: > > My daughters refer to their friends as "..the one wit

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Vivec
Dude.. If out of a population of 10,000 you have 100 wheel-chair bound men who excel... can you argue that men in wheel-chairs have it easy now and there is no need for special handicap treatment? The facts show that it is MUCH HARDER to achieve even mediocrity, far less excel as a black person

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Sam
Wow, that's sad. Categorizing people based on color? Don't they have names? On Thu, Jul 22, 2010 at 12:00 PM, Zaphod Beeblebrox wrote: > > My daughters refer to their friends as "..the one with blond hair, the > one with brown skin, the one with tan skin, the one with black hair, > the one with

RE: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Sisk, Kris
ency. -Original Message- From: trish simon [mailto:trishsimo...@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, July 22, 2010 9:56 AM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth. Racism...LOL...how many emails on this one subjec

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Judah McAuley
Word. My daughter, thus far, just refers to everyone by name. I assume that ethnicity will come up at some point since there are several different ethnicities on our block but at this point it is all Jeff, Tamara, Zeomara, Simon, Linda, etc. I like that. Judah On Thu, Jul 22, 2010 at 9:00 AM, Za

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Scott Stroz
On Thu, Jul 22, 2010 at 11:49 AM, Jerry Barnes wrote: > > How about Sumo Wrestling. That might tend to favor big guys like myself. :D -- Scott Stroz --- You can make things happen, you can watch things happen or you can wonder what the f*&k happened. - Cpt. Phil Harris http://xkc

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Sam
It's too bad you're such a hater. You could be an asset to the list. On Thu, Jul 22, 2010 at 11:40 AM, Larry C. Lyons wrote: > > Unfortunately trish all the right wingers on the list now have you in > their sights. > > Generally I agree with you, but that said, I have no problems > discussing my

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Sam
So what's Sharrod after? Another huge lawsuit payout? "I think they should but they won't. They intended exactly what they did. "They were looking for the result they got yesterday," Sherrod said of Fox. "I am just a pawn. I was just here. They are after a bigger thing, they would love to take us

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Zaphod Beeblebrox
My daughters refer to their friends as "..the one with blond hair, the one with brown skin, the one with tan skin, the one with black hair, the one with the green eyes"...as if skin color were nothing more or less different that hair color or eye color. They're not Black, Asian, Mexican or any of

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Judah McAuley
On Thu, Jul 22, 2010 at 4:29 AM, Jerry Barnes wrote: > > "How do you determine your ethnicity? When the census form comes to you, how > do you go about figuring out what to put down?" > > Exactly. You make my point for me.  Poverty is much easier to define and > check. That is rather disingenuou

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Jerry Barnes
"It is just as wrong to deny someone a job, college admission, etc based on how wealthy or poor they may be as it is to deny someone a job based on their skin color." Bravo. I'd better clarify or people will get the wrong idea. Remember that I have said if you have to have affirmative action,

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Jerry Barnes
"Here is a novel idea. How about if the job, college admission, etc go to the most qualified candidates - PERIOD." Bravo "It is just as wrong to deny someone a job, college admission, etc based on how wealthy or poor they may be as it is to deny someone a job based on their skin color." Bravo.

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Jerry Barnes
" Things have become so partisan and politically motivated that we don't care what the facts are. " Yep. On the other story you mention, why would anyone threaten to withdraw money from a charity over politics. It is ridiculous. "The administration seems that it was trying to cut losses asa

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Scott Stroz
Here is a novel idea. How about if the job, college admission, etc go to the most qualified candidates - PERIOD. It is just as wrong to deny someone a job, college admission, etc based on how wealthy or poor they may be as it is to deny someone a job based on their skin color. I think that if al

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Larry C. Lyons
Unfortunately trish all the right wingers on the list now have you in their sights. Generally I agree with you, but that said, I have no problems discussing my views on the topic with any black person, or other minority for that matter. When I was in BC for my cousin's funeral last June, I did ha

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Jerry Barnes
"A list of successful blacks is actually indicative that the problems caused by prejudice and racism have not been solved to the point where they can now be ignored." In your eyes it may show that. To me, it points out the hypocrisy of saying someone is going to be poor or not successful because

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Sam
Remember when real numbers meant nothing and percentages meant everything? Blacks make up 12% of the population. That's 37 million out of 300 million. Do you realize how hard it is for anyone to live in Chris Rock's neighborhood? Look at the workplace, I usually see at least 12% of my co-workers

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Zaphod Beeblebrox
This is actually the thing I'm most disgusted with. Things have become so partisan and politically motivated that we don't care what the facts are. The administration seems that it was trying to cut losses asap. Fox News seems that it was trying to pander to it's readership. Breitbart seems to

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Sam
What are you trying to say? NAACP did no wrong? The White House has a black leader and they forced her to retire. The NAACP had the full video all along and still condemned her. Why do they have to try so hard to make us look racist? Is it because the real issues they're forcing on is suck and the

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Scott Stroz
1. Chris Rock is a comedian, not comedienne (its like actor and actress) 2. I am not sure Chris Rock is one of the best in the world. I would say he is above average, but far from one of the best in the world. :D On Thu, Jul 22, 2010 at 11:06 AM, Vivec wrote: > > How would a white person unders

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Jerry Barnes
"I dare you to have this discussion with a "real" person of color...reality is not as pretty." I have this conversation or variation of it frequently. My best friend at work is Black. My wife's best friend is white but her husband is Black. We talk about this stuff all of the time. J - The

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Vivec
How would a white person understand a non-white's day to day reality? A list of successful blacks is actually indicative that the problems caused by prejudice and racism have not been solved to the point where they can now be ignored. As Chris Rock says, the guy living next to him is a Doctor. N

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread trish simon
Racism...LOL...how many emails on this one subject, and the target being "Blacks" (one of many minorities in America)? How many poster who responded to the original subject has apologized for jumping on the bandwagon to criticize and attack this woman, and the NAACP? How many posters are outraged

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Sam
Race is a real issue and the Obama admin will make sure of that. In this day and age when blacks have achieved so much this admin spends so much time calling whites racists. That's bringing us back to a 60's mentality. You call someone an evil name often enough they might end up not liking you. Th

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Sam
Not sure I'm getting your point. I think your saying it's a factor because it's there. My point is the study states very clearly if you remove the negative factors all races are exactly equal. That tells me it has nothing to do with race. On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 3:48 PM, Larry C. Lyons wrote: >

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Jerry Barnes
"I imagine that if you're a constitutional originalist race has to be counted - weren't black slaves counted as 2/3d's a person." The 3/5 rule never said that a slave was 3/5 of a person. It only said that 3/5 of the population could be counted for representation. While that in itself still su

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Jerry Barnes
"How do you determine your ethnicity? When the census form comes to you, how do you go about figuring out what to put down?" Exactly. You make my point for me. Poverty is much easier to define and check. "The reasons that programs like affirmative action were put into place originally aren't g

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Jerry Barnes
"I leave it blank. Frankly, my race, sex, gender, color, sexual preference and a wide variety of other attributes are none of the government's business. The quickest way to resolve the major issues regarding race or other forms of discrimination would be for everyone to refuse to answer those qu

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-22 Thread Jerry Barnes
Back to the original story, it seems like Shirley has been apologized to by several organizations and been offered her job back. The White House still claims that it had nothing to do with the firing, but some are disputing this. J - The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from t

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Judah McAuley
It doesn't actually even say slaves. It details who is counted as a person, who is excluded (Indians not subject to taxation) and then everyone else is 3/5ths. I found it interesting that those who were indentured servants were counted as whole persons. Judah On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 9:58 PM, Ma

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Maureen
Slaves were counted as 3/5 - nowhere does it say black slaves. On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 7:56 PM, Larry C. Lyons wrote: > > I imagine that if you're a constitutional originalist race has to be > counted - weren't black slaves counted as 2/3d's a person. ~~~

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Judah McAuley
Both close, it was 3/5ths. >From Article 1, Section 2: Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers, which shall be determined by adding to the whole Number of free Persons, including

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Scott Stroz
I thought it was 2/5's? On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 10:56 PM, Larry C. Lyons wrote: > > I imagine that if you're a constitutional originalist race has to be > counted - weren't black slaves counted as 2/3d's a person. > > On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 10:27 PM, Maureen wrote: >> >> I leave it blank.  Fra

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Larry C. Lyons
I imagine that if you're a constitutional originalist race has to be counted - weren't black slaves counted as 2/3d's a person. On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 10:27 PM, Maureen wrote: > > I leave it blank.  Frankly, my race, sex, gender, color, sexual > preference and a wide variety of other attributes

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Maureen
I leave it blank. Frankly, my race, sex, gender, color, sexual preference and a wide variety of other attributes are none of the government's business. The quickest way to resolve the major issues regarding race or other forms of discrimination would be for everyone to refuse to answer those que

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Larry C. Lyons
+100 On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 7:31 PM, Judah McAuley wrote: > > On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 4:10 PM, Jerry Barnes wrote: >> >> "Race is a tricky thing to even define in America considering the amount of >> intermarrying." >> >> Exactly.  That is why it race shouldn't be a determining factor in the >

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Judah McAuley
On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 4:10 PM, Jerry Barnes wrote: > > "Race is a tricky thing to even define in America considering the amount of > intermarrying." > > Exactly.  That is why it race shouldn't be a determining factor in the > fields we a discussing.  Hell, Barrack is called black, but he's half

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Jerry Barnes
"But considering that you chastised me for saying that "class" isn't a useful enough distinction, I find it hard to accept 'I just know' as a distinction either." How about this: In my humble opinion, I think the time has passed. "Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson are all about attention seeking.

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Medic
I blame rap music. On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 6:15 PM, Judah McAuley wrote: > > On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 2:00 PM, Jerry Barnes wrote: > > > > "Fair enough. What do you think is the tipping point then where race > isn't a > > predictor of poverty?" > > > > All I can say is that the point has passe

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Judah McAuley
On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 2:00 PM, Jerry Barnes wrote: > > "Fair enough. What do you think is the tipping point then where race isn't a > predictor of poverty?" > > All I can say is that the point has passed.  Race is used these days as > political currency.  By declaring one race poorer than anoth

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Jerry Barnes
"Fair enough. What do you think is the tipping point then where race isn't a predictor of poverty?" All I can say is that the point has passed. Race is used these days as political currency. By declaring one race poorer than another and promising rectification of the problem, a politician is tr

RE: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Sisk, Kris
amily tree. -Original Message- From: Jerry Barnes [mailto:critic...@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, July 21, 2010 2:25 PM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth. "The culture of poverty can be found anywhere. It ce

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Larry C. Lyons
Not arguing with you about that, what you're saying is very standard. The data across the literature shows similar results. The problem is that race is so intertwined with SES in the United States that any causal model has to use race as a correlated predictor when including socio-economic status

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Judah McAuley
On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 12:24 PM, Jerry Barnes wrote: > I never said that race at some point in history was not a predictor of > poverty.   You are deluding yourself if you think I said that.   I have said > race is no longer a predictor of poverty; instead, poverty  is the leading > indicator of

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Jerry Barnes
"The culture of poverty can be found anywhere. It certainly happens amongst whites, I grew up in the middle of it. But I think that you are deluding yourself if you don't think that there is a historic component to it and that historic component, in the US, is largely racial." I never said that r

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Sam
Not sure why you keep saying poverty is increasing. It was 22% in '59 and it's 13.2% now. I used percentages because you don't like real numbers :) (40mil vs 40mil) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States As for race when you break it down it's no longer 3 to 1: Among marr

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Judah McAuley
On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 11:07 AM, Jerry Barnes wrote: > > "So it's not being a minority that causes poverty, it's the culture of being > poor." > > Exactly.  I couldn't have said it better myself. Which is what I've been talking about distinguishing class versus race and current economic situati

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Jerry Barnes
"So it's not being a minority that causes poverty, it's the culture of being poor." Exactly. I couldn't have said it better myself. J - Empty pockets never held anyone back. Only empty heads and empty hearts can do that. - Norman Vincent Peale ~~~

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Sam
The report seems to be saying race itself does not cause drop outs. In these cases chances of dropping out increased significantly: Being poor, low SES. Raised by a single parent. Move around a lot. PTA involvement Parental education achievement expectations Behavior including smoking. So it's n

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Scott Stroz
Even in this study, it seems as if different people were being surveyed during the different follow-ups. For example, those who were identified in the base year, but did not reply, were allowed to repli in the first follow up. Again, it seems as if subsequent follow ups are adding in new people as

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Scott Stroz
This reply is based on the data from this link, http://cloud9.norc.uchicago.edu/faqs/nels.htm not the PDF. I hit 'reply' on the last message. On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 12:16 PM, Scott Stroz wrote: > Sorry, maybe I am just dumb, but I do not see how that makes any > sense. Here is what does not com

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Scott Stroz
Sorry, maybe I am just dumb, but I do not see how that makes any sense. Here is what does not compute with me (not saying its wrong, just does not make sense) 1. None of the followups include the same people. For example, the first follow up does not include data from parents. 2. Beyond the first

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Larry C. Lyons
OK Scott last thing. This is the 4th follow up technical report on the methodology: http://nces.ed.gov/pubs95/95426.pdf On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 11:47 AM, Larry C. Lyons wrote: > Also I found some more detail explanation of the followups for the > survey which ended in the late 80's. From what I

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Larry C. Lyons
Also I found some more detail explanation of the followups for the survey which ended in the late 80's. From what I understand the same methodology was used. http://cloud9.norc.uchicago.edu/faqs/nels.htm On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 11:40 AM, Larry C. Lyons wrote: > Here Scott, this is a very brief e

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Vivec
The USDA is going to reconsider ousting the official based on more complete information that they now have at hand. http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=128659806&sc=fb&cc=fp ~| Order the Adobe Coldfusion Antholo

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Larry C. Lyons
Here Scott, this is a very brief explanation of longitudinal research: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Longitudinal_study To get how the researchers did the actual assessments, you'll need to troll the NORC site's methodology sections for how they handled attrition etc. On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 8:3

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Jerry Barnes
"I don't see why I ought to provide freebies when I charge a consulting fee for doing such." Thank God. I don't think we could stand any more free analysis. J - The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not. I think my

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Sam
Wow, I can't believe you have such a hatred for real news. Fox didn't even cover the story until after she resigned. But go and blame them anyway. As for Breitbart, he states his point was the NAACP called the tea party movement racist yet while Sherrod was telling them how she was racist agains

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Scott Stroz
On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 8:34 AM, Larry C. Lyons wrote: > > Not. But to give a real answer that addresses your concerns would take > a fair amount of work, the sort of stuff I do consulting. Besides, > being stuck on a commuter train right now makes it rather difficult in > the first place. > > Gh

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Larry C. Lyons
Not. But to give a real answer that addresses your concerns would take a fair amount of work, the sort of stuff I do consulting. Besides, being stuck on a commuter train right now makes it rather difficult in the first place. Ghads I hate commuting. On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 8:31 AM, Scott Stroz

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Larry C. Lyons
You and Judah have it wrong the real answer is both. On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 7:52 AM, Jerry Barnes wrote: > > "Both. One does not choose between the two nubile women when you can > realistically have both. Mostly you have to worry about that sneaky > Professor. He may have to be bumped off." > >

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Scott Stroz
Why do you seem to be taking that personally? I am just curious how following some kids for 1 year and some for 14 years can yield consistent data. As I said, a lot can happen to people in 14 years. In 14 years you can go from 2nd grade to college graduate. Or from 6th grade to being a doctor. I

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Larry C. Lyons
Not sure about that. With correlated predictors you cannot reliably ascertain on whether the effects on a dependent variable are the result of one correlated predictor or another. In this case to what degree is school achievement due to SES or racial factors. The actual analyses we did was lookin

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Larry C. Lyons
Its still legitimate. The longitudinal sampling techniques took such into account. Go to the site and look at how they do that sort of research. I'm pretty satisfied with their methodology, as is the entire field. You need to do your own research about it. I don't see why I ought to provide freebi

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-21 Thread Jerry Barnes
"Both. One does not choose between the two nubile women when you can realistically have both. Mostly you have to worry about that sneaky Professor. He may have to be bumped off." We differ there. It would have to be Mary Ann. I am into substance over appearance. Though yours wasn't a bad choic

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Judah McAuley
For those that may be curious, here is the full video and a little write up of her speech: http://tpmmuckraker.talkingpointsmemo.com/2010/07/watch_full_video_of_sherrods_speech.php?ref=fpa It is really an excellent speech. Given the way she has been treated, I suggest that we get rid of Vilsack

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Judah McAuley
On Tue, Jul 20, 2010 at 6:08 PM, Jerry Barnes wrote: > > Wow.  The day keeps getting weirder.  I have a BA and MA in Mathematics. > Though most of our posts wouldn't show it, we seem to have quite a few > things in common.  Next question:  Ginger or Mary Ann? Both. One does not choose between th

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Jerry Barnes
"I kept telling my Profs that in college. I ended up majoring in it so as to learn how to fight the man. Take it down from the inside so to speak." "Fight the Power!" Wow. The day keeps getting weirder. I have a BA and MA in Mathematics. Though most of our posts wouldn't show it, we seem to h

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Scott Stroz
I see your point, I do not agree with it, but I see it. If everything else is equal, I would be more inclined to think flipping a coin would be a better, and more fair, determination on who gets a job or slot in a college than using race. In my mind, it is never good for someone to get any kind

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Jerry Barnes
You are confusing fact with correlation. On statistics, if you torture the numbers long enough, they'll tell you exactly what you want. On your correlation, I contend that you can disregard race altogether. I say that the number one indicator of poverty is poverty. That is, someone from a poor

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Judah McAuley
You and I are talking about two different situations. You are talking about a situation where one candidate is less qualified and elevated above another. I am talking about a situation where both candidates are qualified. If you are talking about two candidates who are qualified for a position yo

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Medic
Hahaha. Oh wow. That's awesome. I would've wee'd in my pants. On Tue, Jul 20, 2010 at 7:39 PM, Judah McAuley wrote: > > Yes, I thought of that scene exactly. > > Never go in against a Sicilian when death is on the line. > > Judah > > As an aside, I once got to perform a wedding ceremony where t

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Judah McAuley
Yes, I thought of that scene exactly. Never go in against a Sicilian when death is on the line. Judah As an aside, I once got to perform a wedding ceremony where the couple let me start it off with "Love, true love, is what brings us together today". I did not use the Peter Cooke voice, but the

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Scott Stroz
To me the Affirmative Action rationale says 'choose the non-white'. There have been many times where a less qualified non-caucasian has gotten a job, admission to college, etc, over a more qualified caucasian. (I have seen it first hand in previous jobs) Granted there have been a lot more times i

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Medic
> > However, in your example, if it is wrong to NOT chose the minority > candidate because they are a minority, it is equally wrong, regardless > of the rationale, to NOT choose the white candidate because they are > NOT a minority. > Does this paragraph remind anyone else of this: Man in Black

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Judah McAuley
On Tue, Jul 20, 2010 at 2:18 PM, Scott Stroz wrote: > > To be fair, I think 'discriminatory' might be a better word. To me, > 'racist' would infer some sort of hatred or dislike of one person or > group because of their race. Clearly, in your example, there is no > hatred or dislike (at least tha

Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Sam
I said this: > I'm confused. Why do failed farmers get to blame racism for not getting > loans? And you said this: > When I was doing research with data for large scale studies (with > sample sizes in the tens, and in several cases hundreds of thousands) > in any causal model we developed we h

RE: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth.

2010-07-20 Thread Sisk, Kris
dotter.com] Sent: Tuesday, July 20, 2010 4:12 PM To: cf-community Subject: Re: Oops! Did I say that on tape? Shirley Sherrod of the USDA Sticks Her Foot In Her Mouth. On Tue, Jul 20, 2010 at 1:56 PM, Scott Stroz wrote: > > On Tue, Jul 20, 2010 at 2:54 PM, Judah McAuley wrote: >> >&g

  1   2   >